This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Mr. Speaker, Greeting · 21 wordsI wish you would be as generous with your time as the Liberal government is with taxpayer money in this budget.GreetingPositioning · 63 wordsMy goodness, this is a government that talks about being a new government, but it is amazing how much we see the old ways of spending.Actually, that is not fair.Justin Trudeau, believe it or not, looks like a fiscal conservative stacked up against the Liberal government’s budget now.This is a budget that could be termed “the young and the reckless”.PositioningClaims · 13 wordsIt is forecasting deficits of nearly $300 billion over the next five years.1Procedure · 17 wordsThis is not an abstract number when we realize what the real implications are of these deficits.ProcedureClaims · 14 wordsEvery dollar the government spends has to come from the taxpayer in some way.Procedure · 3 wordsWe know that.ProcedureUnearned certaintyClaims · 43 wordsWe all, as Canadians, accept that there is a balance.We pay a little in tax, and we get a little in services.Sometimes that balance is a lot more lopsided.Canadians now are paying more and more but getting less and less.Reasoning · 41 wordsWhen government chooses to spend outside of its means, as this government is, when governments choose to spend more than they are taxing Canadians, we end up with deficits that require the government to incur greater and greater levels of debt.Claims · 34 wordsThat is what we are seeing here.Anyone who has ever taken out a mortgage or made a purchase on a credit card, things that ordinary Canadians are doing, knows debt is not free.Reasoning · 28 wordsOftentimes, depending on a number of calculations, people end up spending more on interest than they did on the thing itself that required them to incur the debt.Claims · 58 wordsI would be remiss not to point out that the Liberal government’s reckless budget is resulting in more and more money being spent each year on nothing, on debt payments and interest.In this particular budget, the interest payments are $58 billion.2That is more than one-tenth of the overall amount the government is spending, more than 10%.3An hon. member: Billions, billions.Andrew Lawton: Positioning · 39 wordsMr. Speaker, it is interesting that I am being heckled by a former cabinet minister to Kathleen Wynne’s government in Ontario, who should really stay quiet right now when we are talking about debt and deficits and government spending.PositioningAside · 5 wordsWhat could that $58 million— AsideAn hon. member: We were the only government to ever balance a budget.Aside · 6 wordsThe former Conservatives never did that.Aside