This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Mr. Speaker, Claims · 75 wordsthat $58.7 billion could buy 50 new hospitals every single year.1That money could double the entire federal health transfer, money the federal government gives to provinces to fund health care services.That amount could cut income taxes in this country by 25%.That money could eliminate the GST.These are all decisions a government could make if it had this money back in its coffers, or it could simply return the money to Canadians.Positioning · 12 wordsThis is why we have to talk about the recklessness of it.PositioningClaims · 52 wordsEvery dollar spent in debt interest is a dollar spent enriching bankers and bondholders.It does not go to government services.It does not go to middle-class families.It does not go back into the pockets of Canadians who were taxed in the first place for the government to take that money.Reasoning · 70 wordsThis is why when governments try to make big, flashy promises and pay for things they cannot afford, they end up loading more and more debt and more taxes onto future generations.The government claims this budget is called “Masters of our destiny”, 2but what it has mastered is indebtedness for future generations.It has mastered the illusion that governments can spend money recklessly, with abandon, and bear no consequences.Procedure · 9 wordsIt is not just the spending that is reckless.ProcedureClaims · 94 wordsIn this budget, the government has also put forward the most massive increase to immigration by way of increasing the number of permanent residents this country has ever seen.While housing is out of reach, health care resources are overstrained and unemployment is at record levels, the Liberals are planning to add 654,000 permanent residents in a single year, despite claiming that they are taking seriously the immigration crisis they have created.3This number is 35% higher than the previous all-time record, 4which was set by Justin Trudeau.5Yes, it is a new government, Positioning · 6 wordsbut new does not mean improved.PositioningClaims · 75 wordsThere are new levels of debt, new levels of deficits, the same member for Winnipeg North and new levels of immigration, all of which continue to make life less affordable for Canadians, to make government less responsible and to aggravate and exacerbate the problems that Canadians have been grappling with and demanding that the government act on.This is a reckless budget that is putting reckless debt and deficits onto Canadians, which they cannot afford.The ask · 19 wordsThe Liberal government would do well to acknowledge the harms this is going to cause for generations to come.