Analysis · beta

Sandra Cobena

Not analysed yet

A requested analysis is usually ready within half an hour; come back to this page or reload it.

moved that Bill C-270, An Act to amend the Criminal Code (defence of person), be read the second time and referred to a committee. She said: Mr. Speaker, since I was elected to the House, I have had the privilege of speaking with so many Canadians. They speak about the cost of living, about their children and about the future of this country, but they consistently speak about something more fundamental. They speak about the fear that the place they have always considered their safe place may no longer be as secure. That place is their home. There are certain things in life that should not require explanation. A family should be able to sleep peacefully at night. A person should be able to close the door of their home and know that within those walls, they have a right to protect the people they love. However, across our country, Canadians have seen enough cases where a homeowner is dragged through the justice system only to prove that they had been protecting their family from a criminal breaking into their home. Canadians are reasonably asking whether our laws adequately protect them in the place where they should feel the safest. That is why I introduced my private member’s bill, the stand on guard act. It would give special legal recognition to something Canadians have always understood: Our home is our safe place. It is, after all, what we teach our children, that there is nowhere else in the world where they are safer than at home in the arms of mom and dad. This same home deserves special protection under our laws. The legislation before us would strengthen protection for law-abiding Canadians who are forced to defend themselves or their family during a home invasion. Consider a mother asleep in her home. It is 2 a.m., and her children are sleeping down the hall. Suddenly she hears glass breaking. She hears footsteps. Someone is inside her home. She does not know who he is. She does not know if he is armed. She does not know what he intends to do. She knows only one thing: Her children are in danger. She has seconds, not minutes and not hours, to decide what to do. In those seconds, she must act. Now consider what happens afterwards. It is bed time again. What does she say to a child who wants to know why locking the door will keep them safe tonight when it did not last night? The legal process rolls. Statements are taken, and the police reports are submitted. In York region, 43 home invasions took place in 2025 alone. Under our current laws, whether the force the mother used was reasonable may be judged against a long list of circumstances: the size and physical ability of the people involved, the presence of weapons, the nature of the threat and the alternatives that may have been available. These considerations have their place in the law, but there is something profoundly unreasonable about asking a frightened mother, awakened in the darkness, to make judgements that lawyers and judges may spend hours examining in the calm of the light of day. The criminal had the luxury of choosing his actions. The mother had no choice but to defend her children. That difference matters, and our laws should recognize it. We want to change the law so Canadians can act with certainty when their loved ones are put in danger. Our amendment to the Criminal Code would protect the innocent in three ways. First, if a violent intruder breaks into somebody’s home and threatens their family, the law would finally be on their side, not on the intruder’s side. Second, it would presume reasonableness. The force used to stop a home invader who poses a threat would be deemed reasonable. There would be no more second-guessing after the fact. Third, it would end legal limbo. Canadians defending themselves should not spend years in court, while criminals walk free. This proposed law would give clarity to citizens, police and prosecutors. The stand on guard act recognizes the difference and would establish two important legal presumptions. First, when someone knowingly and unlawfully enters an occupied home, the law should presume that the intruder intends to use force against the people inside unless the evidence establishes otherwise. Second, when a person uses force to defend themselves or their loved one in those circumstances, the force would be presumed reasonable unless the evidence establishes otherwise. This would extend to lethal force as it may be needed in self-defence. It is important to understand what this means. It is not a licence for violence. It is not an unlimited right to use force. The presumption can be rebutted. Evidence still matters. Courts retain the responsibility to examine the facts, but the law would begin by recognizing a fundamental difference: One person chose to violate the security of another’s home. The other was forced to respond. The law should stand with those forced to defend themselves or a loved one in those circumstances. That force should be presumed reasonable unless the evidence shows otherwise. This is about restoring common sense to our justice system. A person’s home is their safe place and deserves special legal protection under Canadian law. The bill would send an unequivocal message to police, prosecutors and judges that our homes benefit from unique legal standing. A home invasion terrorizes not only the victims but also the entire community, who also feel less safe. Equally, it would send a message to criminals that the law stands with the person who is forced to defend themselves and their family. Canadians want the natural truth set out clearly in our Criminal Code. If someone knowingly and unlawfully enters my home, the force used to protect me or my family is presumed to be reasonable, full stop. This bill is simply in recognition of the truth we already know. A person’s home is not a sidewalk. It is not a bar. It is not a workplace. A home is something altogether different. It is where people build a life, where children take their first steps, where families gather around the dinner table, where parents sit at the edge of a child’s bed and whisper good night. It is where we are the most vulnerable. We trust that the walls around us mean something and that the door we close at night marks a boundary the law will respect. When someone knowingly and unlawfully crosses that boundary, the law should recognize the gravity of what has happened. That is the principle at the heart of the bill. A person’s home is their safe place, and it deserves special protection under Canadian law. Right now, a person’s home does not have special legal protection under our laws. The stand on guard act would change that and enshrine it in the Criminal Code. Yes, we know this deep inside. A home is special. It is our human right to defend it. It is our place. Until recently, Canadians never had to even think about home invasions, but after a decade of bad Liberal policies, now we do. We need to enshrine rights that are so deeply human that they are written in our conscience and our laws. We need our Criminal Code to actually say clearly what we all know is true. When I introduced this bill on March 12, I was overwhelmed by the attention it received. Five days later, there was a home invasion in Vaughan. What was the headline? “No charges against Ontario resident who shot and injured alleged home invader: police”. It was almost like a sigh of relief that this time, the homeowner was not charged. It was also a reflection that Canadians are particularly interested and concerned with self-defence in the context of a home invasion. That article went on to state that, “Ari Goldkind, a criminal defence lawyer, said he finds it ‘refreshing’ that the police did not charge the homeowner.” The article also recounts, “Last month, prosecutors withdrew charges against a man in Lindsay, Ont., who had been accused of assaulting an alleged home intruder in August 2025.” In this case, the home intruder came into his home with a crossbow, and the victim needed to defend himself with a knife. Canadians have had enough of laws that leave them uncertain of their rights when they are most vulnerable. They want to know that when a criminal violates the safety of their home, the law recognizes the difference between the person who created the danger and the family forced to confront it. That is why I am bringing forward the stand on guard act. It is to give a family defending their home a clear legal presumption of reasonableness, while preserving the ability of courts to consider evidence to the contrary. Someone’s home is their safe place and it deserves special legal protection under our laws. This legislation would not create a blanket immunity and would not import U.S.-style “stand your ground” laws. It would be a targeted Canadian clarification anchored in the existing section 34 reasonableness standard. The stand on guard principle would affirm the home is a unique protected space; make it clear in the law that when a violent intruder breaks into someone’s home and threatens their family, the law is on their side, not the intruder’s side; if someone uses force to stop a home invader who poses a threat, that force will be presumed reasonable; it would be an unequivocal message to police, prosecutors and judges that a home benefits from a unique legal standing; it would signal legal certainty that protects families and discourages offenders; it would preserve safeguards or proportionality and individualized assessment; and it would improve transparency and public understanding of self-defence in the home, reinforcing confidence in the administration of justice. Canadians are calling for stronger self-defence laws in a home. Conservatives have heard that and know that our self-defence laws need to treat a home differently and uniquely. The stand on guard act is not about right or left. It is about whether we hear the call from Canadians to strengthen self-defence laws in the unique context of a home invasion. The question confronting us is simple: Do we believe that a home is a safe place that deserves special legal protection under our laws, yes or no? I hope the answer from every member of this House is yes. A vote for yes means this bill goes to committee to be studied and refined. A vote no means the government does not even hear the call of Canadians to strengthen self-defence laws. Someone’s home should be their safe place, not the place where the law turns against them for protecting the people they love.