Analysis · beta

Sandra Cobena

Replying to Alexis Deschênes (Bloc Québécois)
“Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for her contribution to the debate. In her speech, she mentioned the case in Ontario. An individual is the victim of a home invasion, grabs a gun, shoots the intruder, and seriously injures them. That person pleads self-defence and is acquitted. This example demonstrates that the Criminal Code currently provides people with the necessary certainty and security to defend their property. Has my colleague looked into the impact of what she is proposing? This type of law was implemented in Florida, and it was found to have increased the rate of gun-related homicides, because the argument is that as soon as someone enters without permission, the homeowner can shoot them in the head and be cleared of any wrongdoing.”

Not analysed yet

A requested analysis is usually ready within half an hour; come back to this page or reload it.

Mr. Speaker, the case in the example the member cited ignores one fact. When a person is charged, even if the charges are eventually dropped, they are dragged through the justice system. There are cases where someone had been in jail for six months but the charges were not dropped until two years later. They lost their job, and, of course, they had to spend thousands of dollars in legal fees only to prove that they had been defending themselves. That is what this law would prevent. It would prevent lawful Canadians from having to be dragged through the justice system only to prove that they had been defending themselves and their family.