Analysis · beta
Pierre Poilievre
Not analysed yet
A requested analysis is usually ready within half an hour; come back to this page or reload it.
Mr. Speaker, it was a night like any other for the Morton family, sound asleep in their beds, assuming they were safe. Then, shortly after 4 a.m., the door smashed open. Masked and armed criminals jolted them awake by forcing themselves in with a hammer. They shot the father, David Morton, and his two daughters. They attacked everyone in the house with hammers. In mere minutes, the place where the family should have felt most at home, quite literally, and most safe turned into a crime scene. No family should have to wake up to this kind of horrifying nightmare, but this is the reality after 11 years of Liberal laws and the resulting chaos. Since 2015, violent crime is up in Canada by 57%, sexual assault by 77%, human trafficking by 119%, and extortion, which, by the way, is a home invasion-related offence, by 297%. Canadians deserve to be safe in their homes and on the streets. Instead, they worry about the sound of breaking glass in the middle of the night. How did we get here? Law after law after law that Liberals have passed siding with criminals and turning them loose on our streets have awakened a monster. Bill C-75, regarding Liberal bail, which requires judges to release repeat offenders at the earliest opportunity under the least onerous conditions, which is quoted right out of the act, often allows the same offender to be released hundreds of times and rearrested in between those releases, punctuating our society with endless crime. Bill C-5 removed mandatory jail time for serious offences and allowed serious criminals to serve their sentences in their living room. The present Prime Minister put forward Bill C-16, allowing judges to ignore almost all mandatory prison sentences in the Criminal Code, including those for extortion, firearms, human trafficking and aggravated sexual assault with a gun. Even the Liberals’ so-called bail reform, Bill C-14, continues to allow repeat offenders to be released onto our streets again and again. The law is not on our side. Let us be clear. The law is not defending the Canadian people, and it does not let them defend themselves. The current laws related to self-defence and home defence are too vague, leave too much discretion and risk dragging law-abiding people through a devastating and expensive legal process and potentially sending them to jail for the mere offence of protecting themselves and their property. Courts will decide if self-defence was justified, whether the person acted on “reasonable grounds”, but, of course, no one has time to think about the legal definition of reasonable grounds when someone has smashed through a window and crawled with a weapon into their children’s bedroom. Their priority in that circumstance is to protect themselves and their family. However, when we raised the issue, the Liberal justice minister said we were trying to create what he called the Wild West. He should tell that to the family in Vaughan who watched as their father and husband was taken from them. In August of last year, three armed robbers forced their way into the family’s home, the place where they celebrate birthdays and where they sit around the dinner table, where they are supposed to feel safe. One intruder held the daughter at gunpoint. The father did what any parent would do. He stepped in between the gunman and his daughter, and for that, he was shot and killed. His daughter watched as he was murdered. They saw him lose his life. The primary suspect was there because he was out on bail. Of course he was out on bail. Who is not out on bail that is committing crimes? In fact, he had been released on bail not once, but four times. After 11 years, Minister, this is the Wild West. The Wild West is everywhere in our streets. Just this month, at a grocery store in Prince George, British Columbia, three criminals tried to leave the store with $2,000 of unpaid groceries. An ordinary workday quickly turned violent. When employees stood up to them, they were attacked. One employee and a 20-year-old manager were attacked. That young manager showed up to work to do his job and earn a paycheque. Instead, he went to the hospital with multiple injuries. One of the men charged was a repeat offender, again released under the Liberal catch-and-release system. That is why Conservatives have put forward concrete solutions to keep people safe in their homes and on the streets. I am so proud of the hon. member for Newmarket—Aurora for putting forward this castle law so that people can stand their ground and keep their families safe. Her proposed bill would change subsection 34(2) of the Criminal Code regarding the use of force, including lethal force. If it is used against someone who has illegally and knowingly entered one’s home, it is presumed that someone is acting lawfully in applying a counterforce, including a lethal counterforce. Simply put, if someone knowingly and unlawfully enters someone’s home, they should be allowed to use any force that they deem necessary to protect their family. Liberals and others in the House might say, “Does that not put someone’s life in danger, if the homeowner potentially overreacts?” I have a solution for that. If someone does not want to be harmed by someone in their house, they should not break in. It is that simple. We want to ensure that, if somebody stands up in the middle of the night and makes the split-second judgment that is potentially necessary to protect their home against someone who has invaded it, they will not face the grind of our legal system and potentially jail time. I should also point out that this bill would add to the stand-alone Criminal Code offence that the safe at home act would add to. That is another Conservative bill that would make more penalties apply to people who invade homes. We have a double approach to protecting homes. One approach is to give people the power to defend themselves. The second is to make sure that anyone who invades faces a minimum sentence of five years and a maximum sentence of life in prison with a reverse onus bail provision. We call on Liberals and all members of Parliament to support these bills in addition to the jail not bail act, which the Liberals voted against. We asked them to revive that bill. It would crack down on repeat violent offenders and strengthen bail laws. It would repeal Liberal bail. This is the so-called “principle of restraint” that requires judges to release accused “at the earliest opportunity under the least onerous conditions”. We should repeal that and allow judges to put public safety first when assessing whether the accused is a danger to society. We also ask the government to revive the bill it defeated, the one law for all bill. It would ensure that judges could no longer give a discount sentence to someone on the basis that they are visiting Canada and applying for immigration. Right now, judges are lowering sentences for visiting foreign nationals who are not permanent residents or citizens so that they will not jeopardize their immigration application or, in other words, to keep them in Canada. If a foreign national visiting our country commits a serious crime, they should do the full sentence and be immediately deported from our country. Foreign nationals who commit crimes should not get lollipop sentences just because they are not Canadian citizens or permanent residents. While Conservatives continue to put law-abiding Canadians first, the Liberals are putting criminals first, and enough is enough. Canadians deserve an end to the revolving door. They deserve to know that criminals will go behind bars. The law-abiding, decent, honourable people who work hard, pay their taxes and play by the rules should expect to live in safety and tranquility. If, God forbid that moment ever comes, someone invades their most sacred place for their family, they should also know that they can defend themselves using any force necessary. We would empower Canadians to defend themselves, their families and their homes, using any force they deem necessary to stop criminals, because it is time for the government and the country to stand on the side of law-abiding, innocent Canadians, especially in their homes.