Analysis · beta

Maggie Chi

Replying to Helena Konanz (Conservative)
“Mr. Speaker, for Canadians, access to health care should never depend on where they live, how old they are or how long they are willing to wait, yet across this country, more Canadians are struggling to access even basic medical care. I hear from constituents frustrated by the difficulty of finding a family doctor, lengthy delays for specialist appointments, and uncertainty about whether essential services will be available in their communities. The numbers reflect these concerns. A 2025 comparative study by the Fraser Institute found that Canada ranked third in health care spending as a share of its economy among 31 high-income countries with universal health care, yet Canada ranked 27th for doctor availability, 25th for hospital beds, 27th for MRI machines and 28th for CAT scans. Governments are spending more, but that spending is not translating into timely access to care. In 2023, more than one in four Canadians aged 18 to 34 did not have a regular health care provider, and among those aged 35 to 49, nearly one in five were in the same position. For those who do not have a family doctor, accessing specialists and diagnostic testing can mean waiting months. A 2025 analysis by the C.D. Howe Institute found that Canada ranked last among 10 comparable countries for timely access to care, with 47% of Canadians waiting at least two months for a specialist appointment. These delays have real consequences. For someone living with chronic pain or waiting for surgery, months without treatment can mean lost income, reduced mobility and a lower quality of life. These challenges are particularly pronounced in rural communities, including many in my riding, Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay. Anyone from my riding who is watching me speak tonight is not surprised. We have received letters from numerous citizens about this. Penticton Regional Hospital has recently lost its entire team of neurologists, leaving patients with fewer local options for specialized care. Seniors and others requiring ongoing neurological assessments may now have to travel outside their communities to receive treatment. In Oliver, the hospital’s emergency department experienced more than 40 unexpected closures in a single year. This leaves residents uncertain about whether emergency care will be available when they need it most. We cannot continue to accept a high-cost health care system where Canadians still go without a family doctor, wait months without essential treatment or are left wondering whether their local emergency department will be open. The Liberal government’s role in health care recruitment has left too many on the sidelines. With still no sign of promised action, how can the Liberal government justify its federal role in our system, which far too often is leaving Canadians without the care they need when they need it most?”

Not analysed yet

A requested analysis is usually ready within half an hour; come back to this page or reload it.

Mr. Speaker, first, I want to thank my fellow HESA member for her question. I always appreciate our collaboration on committee and her thoughtful input on various topics on behalf of her constituents. I really appreciate our work together. We have had good discussions, especially during this fall session, and have had helpful testimonies on the pressures on systems across our provinces and territories. I appreciate her question because it is important. We are seeing pressures on our system. The Asian population has a complexity of diseases, and access is generally an issue. My friend across the way sees it in her own community. I see it in Ontario as well, where I represent as a member. In budget 2025, we made a generational investment for building health care infrastructure, with $5 billion committed to work with the provinces and territories. We are having great conversations to see where some of the gaps are. We are working with them collaboratively to see where investment should happen. In this budget, we have also extended mental health services and home care support with the provinces and territories, with $1.2 billion, as we examine the system as a whole. We have also had discussions in committee on foreign credentialing. We have seen good results from the provinces and different regions. We have heard from the Medical Council of Canada about its efforts in physician registry, on how it is trying to have a good line of sight on physicians across Canada, and how we can have those workforce planning pieces, which are very important. I also want to mention that, last week, students from the Canadian Federation of Medical Students were on the Hill advocating for issues that matter to them. We heard unique perspectives from students in training, residents in training, on where they see improvements could happen, where they are seeing the access points and the policies we should have non-partisan collaboration on. One of the pieces they advocated for was having connected health data. Bill S-5, which is going through the House now, and the member opposite spoke very thoughtfully to the bill, would enable a lot of the data connectivity piece for the visibility of our health data and make sure people have the autonomy to access it. It would unlock innovation. Having automated, good-quality data would enable researchers to conduct research that would benefit our population. It would attract companies to invest in Canada. It would also give a boost to our modernization effort in the system. To support provinces and territories in this effort, we are in constant discussion with them, and there are different pressures. Different provinces experience different complexities and pressure points. As with the member’s community, Ontario and a number of provinces, there are different experiences. There are also efforts to make sure we have a good health care work force with the investments in TMU and York University to build out the medical schools with a focus on providing primary care at a community level.