Analysis · beta

Dan Muys

Following a speech by Eric Melillo (Conservative)
“Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to be able to rise today and speak to Bill C-42. Obviously, it is an important discussion. This bill aims to address issues of affordability and the housing crisis. I am sure all members in this place would agree that these issues are of the utmost importance. I will start by saying that while I believe it is positive to see the government acknowledging that we are indeed in an affordability crisis and a housing crisis, it is unfortunate that, overall, we see the Liberals continuing to advance the same policies that have led us to these issues in the first place. Canadians have held up their end of the bargain, so to speak. Canadians work hard, they follow the rules, and they love their country, and truly, that should be enough to afford them a basic, affordable life. Unfortunately, under the Liberal government, that simply is not the case. Everything has become more expensive since the Prime Minister took office, and his decisions at home have only made things worse. He is hiking taxes on fuel and driving up the cost of everything. He is adding $765 billion in new debt, meaning taxpayers will actually pay more on debt servicing than on health care under the plan. The Prime Minister also promised to spend less, but in fact, he is spending more, adding $331 billion in new spending, which will lead to higher inflation and higher interest rates for Canadians. As a result of this, as we have heard from far too many people, Canadians are struggling to get by and are turning to food banks or even eating less simply to try to save some money. We can look at it from a national perspective. According to the CBC, yes, the CBC, recent reports indicate that nearly 10 million Canadians are experiencing food insecurity, a staggeringly high number. A further survey, from The Salvation Army, shows that 31% of Canadians are skipping or reducing their meals to save money on groceries. For me, one of the most shocking statistics is that 776,000 food bank visits this year alone were made by children. These statistics are as shocking as they are heartbreaking to read. The situation in Canada is so dire that, according to the CEO of Food Banks Canada, many people who used to donate to food banks are now the ones lining up, finding themselves in need of visiting the food bank. This truly is a failure of government. These kinds of numbers tell stories, and these stories of people struggling are simply unacceptable, and we should never concede that this is normal in Canada. The Liberals boast about the programs they have created to try to help Canadians afford groceries, but a decade ago Canadians did not need the government to pay for their groceries. The very need for such programs indicates a failure of the Liberal government. Despite this reality, despite the numbers and despite the constant stories filling all of our inboxes, the Prime Minister has said that affordability is the best it has been in a decade. With 10 million Canadians experiencing food insecurity and 31% of Canadians skipping meals, the Prime Minister could not be more out of touch in that respect. Those national numbers show the big picture, but I believe these issues are impacting every corner of this country. That is true in northwestern Ontario. I can look to Kenora, where more than 10% of Kenora’s population turned to the Salvation Army food bank during the first six months of this year. The food bank served over 1,500 unique individuals, which is an increase of more than 100% compared with the same period in 2025. I will remind members that this is a small city of some 15,000 folks or so. The more recent numbers are even more staggering. In August 2025, the food bank served 60 people. In August of this year, it served a record 437 people. That is a 700% increase in food bank usage in Kenora. These numbers are shocking enough on their own, but 40% of people relying on the food bank also have a job. Of course, that means wage growth is not keeping up with rising costs. This is particularly concerning because a job used to be and should be enough to afford a good life, certainly a basic life, and that is clearly no longer the case in Canada after more than a decade of Liberal policies. I also want to note that this is a somewhat timely discussion. Coincidentally, today is the 36th annual Miracle Marathon in Kenora to support The Salvation Army and its work in making the holiday season brighter for those in need. I am looking forward to calling in to the radio show later today as part of the event. This is an incredible opportunity each year where folks can donate cash, non-perishable food items and unwrapped toys to The Salvation Army’s Christmas hamper program. Clearly, I am in Ottawa today and not able to be there in person this year, but I want to thank everyone who is involved in making the event a reality and all in our community who support it. Of course, I want to encourage everyone who can to stop by or go to the link online to support this very important cause, which is badly needed around the holiday season. I will come back to Bill C-42. This is not a bill that is focused only on groceries and affordability. It also aims to address housing concerns. We are no doubt in a housing crisis. All Canadians should have an opportunity to afford their own home and have access to safe, affordable housing. In fact, the Prime Minister promised he would double housing starts, but homebuilding is down 3% from last year. That is just another one of the Prime Minister’s broken promises. That is what happens when the Liberals build bureaucracy instead of homes. More programs, more spending and more government have not delivered the housing supply that Canadians were promised. Instead, families are paying a hefty price through higher housing costs. I can cite local examples in northwestern Ontario. I can look to Kenora again, which is a community of 15,000 people. There is an identified housing shortage of 1,620 units, and that is expected to grow to nearly 2,500 units by 2031. This is a shockingly high number in such a small community. When I am travelling my district, in places like Sioux Lookout, I often hear from young professionals about how they are moving away because they cannot find a place to live. There are many young professionals who cannot move to the community. They would love to take a job, move to northern Ontario and enjoy our way of life, but they are unable to do so because of the lack of housing. I look to other regions like Red Lake, Deer Falls and Ignace, which are all poised for growth with natural resource development opportunities. All of those communities are in desperate need of housing to be able to capitalize on that growth and ensure that it can be of the utmost benefit for their communities. I hear similar concerns from the housing standpoint across all corners of northwestern Ontario, and it paints a picture of just how urgent this issue is. Let us make no mistake. This is a Liberal-created housing crisis. Young people have given up completely on their dream of home ownership. Sellers are struggling to sell their homes. Builders are unable to build the homes we need. This is the reality. The Conservatives have a plan to fix this crisis. We would stop the inflationary spending that is driving up inflation and interest rates, eliminate the GST on new homes under $1.3 million and clear away needless red tape so builders can build more homes faster and at lower costs for Canadians. Overall, Conservatives will continue fighting to restore the promise of Canada that hard work and playing by the rules will lead to a good job and a good, affordable life. We are working to save Canadians money and jobs while bringing down the deficit so everyone can afford to put food on the table and afford a safe place to call home.”

Not analysed yet

A requested analysis is usually ready within half an hour; come back to this page or reload it.

Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for his speech and, at the end, for talking about the promise of Canada. Twelve years ago, we had the richest, most prosperous middle class in the world, according to The New York Times. We had the strongest-performing economy in the G7. The private sector was building pipelines and projects. Canada was prospering, and the middle class was successful. How did we get to the point, after 11 years of the Liberals, where we have such an unaffordable life in Canada and the middle class is shrinking?