Analysis · beta
Xavier Barsalou-Duval
Bloc Québécois / on Grocery and Housing Affordability Act /
Following a speech by Yves Perron (Bloc Québécois)
“Mr. Speaker, I believe my esteemed colleague from Pierre-Boucher—Les Patriotes—Verchères raised an issue of paramount importance just now. Today, everyone is patting themselves on the back, puffed up with pride at having come together to advance a bill that serves the public interest. It is true that we were able to work together, and I am happy about that. However, I have to say that this does not happen very often anymore. Since the government got its fake majority thanks to floor crossers, its attitude has gradually shifted. We see examples every day. As the chief whip of the Bloc Québécois, I work with my team to oversee all of the work of the House of Commons standing committees. If there is anyone who is well placed to observe the government’s changing attitude toward collaboration and openness, it is us. I have seen some unfortunate things, and it is even worse when the committees meet in camera. Unfortunately, I am not allowed to talk about what happened in those meetings, but it seems much easier for the government to get away with things when committees meet in camera. The government is completely rejecting arguments put forward by French-speaking members, members from Quebec. I am trying to choose my words carefully, but I find this alarming. I was glad that my colleague raised that point, and that is why I began my speech by talking about this. The Bloc Québécois has not changed its DNA since the Liberal government manufactured its majority. Because we were elected by the people in our ridings, we have a duty to represent their collective interests. An election campaign lasts a month and a half. Mr. Speaker, I can hear people talking in the chamber. I would appreciate it if they would take their conversations outside, since it does take some concentration to deliver a speech. I was saying that our DNA has not changed. We are always prepared to work constructively for the good of our constituents. Unfortunately, that is not always the case on the government side. We are getting steamrolled. I am referring to the Legislative Committee on Bill C‑39. It is practically sitting around the clock. We are exhausting our resources, our people, who are careful, conscientious workers. This is demanding work. At times like these, the work we do here becomes a bit surreal. We talk past each other for hours or weeks on end, and then suddenly, a certain bill needs to be passed, so we hunker down, sit until midnight every day, vote without a debate and are forced to insist on voting clause by clause in order to keep the attention on the bill and try to work on its content in, again, an intelligent and constructive way. I am very proud of the Bloc Québécois team. I think we are doing an outstanding job. I think we often rise above the fray in the House, and for that, I congratulate my team. Nevertheless, it seems a shame. Mr. Speaker, if people want to have conversations, they should do it in the lobby. I would appreciate it if they could step outside. What a tough morning. It is true that it is Friday and we are tired. It must be because of the Legislative Committee on Bill C-39, which will be sitting until midnight. Those people are more tired, but their voices carry. I say this to my friends: Their voices carry. Let us come back to Bill C-42. It is a fine example of collaboration. We are happy to vote in favour of this bill, because it fulfills one of our budget requests. Lord knows it is not often that a budget request from the Bloc Québécois is granted. When it does happen, we are always happy and we make a point of saying so. However, the last budget was not very impressive. Our decision to support this bill may also head off cheap shots from members on the other side. Whenever we ask questions in the House of Commons, they stand up and say that we voted against increasing the Canada groceries and essentials benefit, which was in the budget. However, they hand us a budget full of things that are unpalatable, unacceptable, and even outrageous to a certain extent, including giving oil companies up to $25 billion more over the next five years. If we consider what is going to be sent through the pipelines without no environmental assessment and no oversight, it is even worse. It is only natural that we would vote against a hodgepodge of a bill that is like a dish containing ingredients that are going bad and that would make us sick if we ate them. However, we are pleased that we are getting to vote on one specific thing. The key feature of this measure is that it is targeted. We have been making this point for a long time. Handing out money to people before an election is easy. Just think back to the carbon tax rebate, which was issued before the provinces of Canada had even paid the tax. It did not apply in Quebec, because of our carbon exchange, which is still in place, but the government sent rebates to people in other provinces for a tax that had not been paid. That money was a gift sent to people right before an election. Doing that is easy. Those kinds of measures are not very smart, not very well thought out, since everyone will get the money, even though some people do not need it. This is being done at a time when inflation is skyrocketing, people are struggling to put food on the table, and lineups at food banks are getting longer and longer. I hope every single person in the House is aware of that. Anyone who is not aware must not be visiting their riding very much. We all have food banks in our ridings. As everyone knows, they are facing enormous demand. It is becoming a very big problem. At the same time, we cannot help but wonder why it is that, in a G7 country, working people have to go to a food bank. It makes no sense. It is just as absurd as having to sit until midnight when we could have been working more efficiently beforehand. The Canada groceries and essentials benefit supplement is a poetic rebrand of the old GST credit. Governments do that sometimes. They change the memo line on the cheque to make it look like they created something, when in fact it is an old credit that already existed but has been enhanced. We welcomed that. The benefit had already been increased by 25%. Last year, the government sent out a cheque for a 50% increase. In our budget requests, we asked that it be done again this year, and it has been done. We welcome that. We are pleased. My colleagues already know that. I am happy, but I do want to call for collaboration. I am asking the Liberals to be objective, to take a step back, take in what is happening and realize that the opposition members are not stupid. We are capable of working constructively. We sometimes get the sense that there is a bit of contempt and that no consideration is given to what the opposition can contribute under this fake majority government. That is important. That is key. Another measure in the bill is the extension of the ban on foreign purchases of residential property. The ban was set to expire on January 1, 2027, but it has been extended to January 1, 2029. We welcome this measure because the housing affordability crisis has not been resolved. It is still a very serious issue, and we must continue to work on it despite all the new construction going on. We cannot simply say that we are going to build, build, build, because we are starting to see buildings with exorbitant rents sitting half empty. I am beginning to see this in my own region. If rents are set at $1,600 a month in a rural area where people simply cannot afford that, those units will remain vacant for quite some time. The government needs to look at incorporating social housing into the mix. It should also consider transferring the money to Quebec and the provinces, which are best placed to address this issue. It is fine for the government to send people a cheque to help pay for groceries, but we have to consider the long term. Can we be constructive and look at the studies that have already been done? I wasw a member of the Standing Committee on Agriculture and Agri-Food for a long time, and we did studies on that issue. When five companies control more than 80% of the grocery retail market, it comes as no surprise that they always deny any collusion and say it is not an oligopoly. However, they keep an eye on each other, and if they notice that one of them is increasing its prices, they all follow suit. The same goes for gasoline. The joke is on us. Everyone is laughing at us. Some sensible solutions have been suggested, such as an agency to oversee grocery pricing practices. How is it possible that a farmer can sell a head of lettuce for 35¢ only to see it selling for $2 at the grocery store three days later? Where is the money going? Did the driver who drove it from one location to the other pocket the difference? That is not where the money should be going. It should be going to the producer, but that is a different matter altogether. I may not be the agriculture critic anymore, but I still care about our farmers. We need to look after them and make sure they stay in business. That requires respect. We need to understand what they do and focus on the heart of the matter. On the whole, we support the bill. I would be pleased to answer any questions.”
Not analysed yet
A requested analysis is usually ready within half an hour; come back to this page or reload it.
Mr. Speaker, I want to pick up on the last point made by my colleague from Berthier—Maskinongé on the notion of collaboration. This is very important on both sides of the House. Although the government has a majority, working together can only improve legislation and increase the chances of coming up with ideas that were not thought of at the outset. We have the impression that the government opposite is constantly steamrolling Parliament to push its priorities forward. How does that create a difficult dynamic in terms of collaboration? I imagine that when one side is acting in good faith and the other is not, it gets harder to keep reaching out.