Analysis · beta

Kevin Lamoureux

Following a speech by Jenny Kwan (NDP)
“Mr. Speaker, the government says budget 2026 is about making life more affordable for Canadians, but when we take a closer look at the two key measures, the groceries and essentials benefit and the proposed changes to the foreign homebuyer ban, some very important questions emerge. Are these measures actually going to make life more affordable for ordinary Canadians, or are they designed to create the appearance of action while leaving the underlying problems largely untouched? Let us start with groceries. The government is proposing a $4.1-billion one-time supplement to the GST credit through the new groceries and essentials benefit. For eligible individuals, the payment will range from $329 to $679 for a couple with two children, depending on household circumstances and income. Combined with other increases to the benefit, total support could reach $1,290 for a single individual and $2,570 for a couple with two children. Let us be clear: people need this money. Families are making difficult choices among groceries, rent, utilities and other basic necessities. Any additional support that helps put food on the table is welcome. For a single person, the additional supplement amounts to roughly $20 a month over a year. Grocery prices do not stop rising after the government issues cheques. The bills do not stop arriving. Families do not get a break from the cost of living just because the government has announced a one-time payment. There is also an important eligibility consideration. People will need to have filed their 2025 income tax return to qualify. What about the people who are struggling but have not filed their taxes? What outreach will the government undertake to ensure that eligible people actually receive the benefit? Why should Canadians have to wait until 2027 to receive this support when they are struggling with grocery bills today? The government is spending $36 billion over five years on its corporate mega deduction, yet when it comes to helping people afford groceries, it is offering a one-time temporary relief. That tells us something about the Prime Minister’s priorities. The NDP has been clear that we need to address the underlying causes of food inflation and the concentration of power in Canada’s grocery sector and its oligopolies. Why will the government not take meaningful action to increase competition in the grocery sector? Why will it not move forward with a network of public grocery stores that could provide affordable food and put competitive pressure on the major grocery chains? Why will it not ban surveillance pricing, where corporations use personal data and algorithms to charge consumers different prices? Canadians need more than a one-time cheque. They need a grocery system that works in the public interest. On the second issue, which is about housing, the government has proposed changes to the Prohibition on the Purchase of Residential Property by Non-Canadians Act. The bill does not say that newly constructed residential properties and rural properties will be exempted from the ban. However, that is the government’s intention, and that is what it is going to do. That will, of course, be left to regulations. The government’s apparent rationale is that allowing foreign investment in new housing construction will help increase supply, but there is no guarantee that the homes being built will be affordable for Canadians, because, of course, they will not be. In fact, the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives calls this a “big loophole” designed primarily to bail out property developers rather than help regular homebuyers. Economist Mark Lee indicated that carving out new residential properties fundamentally undermines the ban. The truth is that relying on private investor-driven preconstruction fails to produce genuinely affordable housing. A luxury condominium purchased by an overseas investor does not solve the housing crisis facing a young family trying to get into the market. CBC Massey lecturer Leilani Farha’s work on the financialization of housing has proven that point. There is also a mismatch with family housing. Foreign buyers typically target preconstruction condos rather than the ground-oriented detached or townhomes most families struggle to afford. The government has chosen not to be transparent about its intentions, and in this legislation, the foreign-owned housing ban does not say newbuilds will be exempt. That policy decision will be made by the government behind closed doors. Since we will not know what is going to be in the regulations, I want to ask the government the following. What safeguards will be in place? Will there be limits on the number of newly built homes or residential units that a foreign buyer can purchase? Can one foreign investor purchase an entire condominium development? Can a foreign investment fund acquire hundreds of units in a single building or multiple developments across the country? Will there be restrictions on bulk purchases by corporations, investment funds or other entities acting on behalf of foreign interests? Will the government allow foreign investors to accumulate large portfolios of residential properties simply because those properties are newly constructed? These are not hypothetical concerns. They go directly to the question of whether this policy would create another avenue for financial speculation. Second, what exactly qualifies as a newbuild? Does it include preconstruction purchases? What about assignment sales? What about completed but previously unoccupied units? None of this information is outlined in the bill, and Canadians deserve to know. Third, what about rural Canada? The government has referenced rural properties in its proposed changes, but what exactly is the rationale for these exemptions? The existing prohibition already applies only within designated census metropolitan areas and census agglomerations. Many rural communities are outside of those boundaries. Will the government expand the exemptions? Will it change the geographic rules? What evidence does it have that foreign investment is needed to address housing supply in rural communities? Rural communities are not immune to housing pressures. In many places, local workers, young families and seniors are struggling to find affordable housing. What protections will be in place to ensure that foreign investment does not further drive up prices or reduce the availability of homes for local residents? These two measures tell us something about the government’s overall approach. On groceries, the government offers a one-time payment rather than taking on the concentrated market power that contributes to high food prices. On housing, the government is opening new avenues for foreign investment without yet providing Canadians with sufficient clarity about the limits and safeguards. Across the broader budget, we see $36 billion in corporate tax deductions alongside major increases in military spending and a continued absence of meaningful new measures to make the wealthiest Canadians pay their fair share. The government is asking Canadians to trust that if corporations and investors do well, everyone else will eventually benefit, but Canadians cannot pay their rent with promises of future economic growth, they cannot put food on the table with corporate tax deductions, and they cannot build a future if housing and agricultural land continue to be treated primarily as financial assets. The NDP believes the public policy must start with the needs of the people, and that means addressing grocery prices and inflation, tackling corporate concentration, investing in affordable and non-market housing, protecting agricultural land and ensuring that Canada’s resources serve the public interest. Canadians are not asking for miracles. They’re asking for affordable groceries, homes they can afford and a government that understands the difference between helping people and helping wealthy investors. The groceries benefit may provide some temporary relief, but it is not a substitute for structural action, and the proposed changes to the foreign homebuyer ban raise serious questions about who will benefit from Canada’s housing market and what protections will remain for ordinary Canadians. The test of this budget should not be how money is delivered to corporations and investors. It should be how it makes life better for everyday people.”

Not analysed yet

A requested analysis is usually ready within half an hour; come back to this page or reload it.

Mr. Speaker, when I look at Bill C-42, I see that it addresses in good part the issue of affordability. It would be nice to hear whether the New Democratic Party will support it. I might have missed the member’s comments indicating whether those members actually support the principle of the legislation, of providing assistance to Canadians at a time when affordability is an issue. It would be nice to see virtual unanimous support for legislation such as the bill on the floor today.