Discussion · Government Orders

Garnett Genuis Conservative

“I oppose this bill. It lets someone else decide if a person is suffering too much based on a paper signed years ago, without asking that person how they feel right now. It would allow someone to be killed without even telling them what is about to happen.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, earlier today the justice minister was talking about people facing intolerable suffering. The problem with this advance request structure is that it would involve somebody else, a third party, determining what is intolerable to them without even a requirement that the person be asked or consulted in the moment about the state of their suffering. It would involve an external third party assessment, according to a document that was signed potentially years or decades before, about what is intolerable to an individual who is not being consulted. That is obviously absurd. We cannot assess what is intolerable to a person without at least asking them about their own present subjective experience, yet Bill C-41 would allow someone to be killed without them even being told what is about to happen to them. I want to thank the member for highlighting the concerns he has about this framework and just ask if he has anything else he wants to add.

No comments yet.

Comment rules