Discussion · Government Orders
Garnett Genuis Conservative
“I worry this bill lets people sign up for assisted dying in advance when they are scared and being pressured by officials. Later on, they could be killed based on that paper without anyone asking them again. I want the member to share his thoughts on this danger.”
“Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my colleague both for an excellent speech and for his kind words about my bill, Bill C-260. The bill is aimed at addressing the issue of MAID coercion, when people are trying to access support from authority figures and are pressured or pushed to consider MAID, oftentimes by professionals who are not even supposed to be involved in MAID, like bureaucrats at Veterans Affairs, social workers and other such people, even outside of the medical system. With Bill C-41, I see a potential toxic combination of advance requests with coercion, where a person gets a diagnosis and is not very familiar with what the implications are. They feel a lot of pressure and fear, because they do not have any lived experience with what that is actually going to be like. They then sign a piece of paper and effectively sign away their future autonomy. Bill C-41 would allow someone to be killed at a future point without even being asked, based on a piece of paper they signed in the past. Can the member comment on how this combination of factors could impact people?”
Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my colleague both for an excellent speech and for his kind words about my bill, Bill C-260. The bill is aimed at addressing the issue of MAID coercion, when people are trying to access support from authority figures and are pressured or pushed to consider MAID, oftentimes by professionals who are not even supposed to be involved in MAID, like bureaucrats at Veterans Affairs, social workers and other such people, even outside of the medical system. With Bill C-41, I see a potential toxic combination of advance requests with coercion, where a person gets a diagnosis and is not very familiar with what the implications are. They feel a lot of pressure and fear, because they do not have any lived experience with what that is actually going to be like. They then sign a piece of paper and effectively sign away their future autonomy. Bill C-41 would allow someone to be killed at a future point without even being asked, based on a piece of paper they signed in the past. Can the member comment on how this combination of factors could impact people?