Discussion · Adjournment Proceedings
Jacob Mantle Conservative
“The Liberals blame foreign conflicts and other leaders instead of taking responsibility for their spending. The government controls how much money it spends and borrows. Adding more debt is not fiscal discipline. The government is also using confusing budgeting tricks that the Parliamentary Budget Officer says are contradictory, break accounting standards, and are not used by any other G7 country.”
“Mr. Speaker, I have to admit, I am getting tired of this line from the Liberals. Nothing is their fault. The world is a dangerous place. In a divided and dangerous world, nothing could possibly be their fault anymore. It is all someone else’s fault. It is all the fault of the war in Iran. It is all the fault of Donald Trump. It is all the fault of anyone else. It is never the Liberals’ fault. They are just the government. They just control the country’s finances. The member asked what we can control. We can control how much money the government spends and how much debt it incurs. Is it fiscal discipline to increase debt? Is it fiscal discipline to increase our debt charges? No, it is not. Let us dispel this nonsense about day-to-day spending. Nobody understands the government’s new, crafty budgeting between day-to-day and operating spending. The Parliamentary Budget Officer does not understand it. No other G7 country or modern democracy does this. In fact, the Parliamentary Budget Officer looked at it and said, “Attributions of certain tax or spending initiatives as operating versus capital appear contradictory”. Moreover, the PBO said none of those definitions apply or conform to the Public Sector Accounting Board. Is that fiscal discipline—”
-
Question or comment in debate
Signal 37 of 100
Much of this statement went to praise, blame, greetings, routine procedure or general stories rather than reasons, requests or specific points.
See full analysis
Mr. Speaker, I have to admit, I am getting tired of this line from the Liberals. Nothing is their fault. The world is a dangerous place. In a divided and dangerous world, nothing could possibly be their fault anymore. It is all someone else’s fault. It is all the fault of the war in Iran. It is all the fault of Donald Trump. It is all the fault of anyone else. It is never the Liberals’ fault. They are just the government. They just control the country’s finances. The member asked what we can control. We can control how much money the government spends and how much debt it incurs. Is it fiscal discipline to increase debt? Is it fiscal discipline to increase our debt charges? No, it is not. Let us dispel this nonsense about day-to-day spending. Nobody understands the government’s new, crafty budgeting between day-to-day and operating spending. The Parliamentary Budget Officer does not understand it. No other G7 country or modern democracy does this. In fact, the Parliamentary Budget Officer looked at it and said, “Attributions of certain tax or spending initiatives as operating versus capital appear contradictory”. Moreover, the PBO said none of those definitions apply or conform to the Public Sector Accounting Board. Is that fiscal discipline—