Discussion · Government Orders
Raquel Dancho Conservative
“I will vote against the budget. It spends 600 billion dollars and adds huge debt, but it does nothing to fix our broken health care system. Canada spends a lot on health care, but we rank near the bottom among wealthy countries for doctors, hospital beds, and scanners. People are waiting months for care and dying on wait-lists. This budget does not offer any new plans to fix these problems or work with the provinces.”
“Mr. Speaker, two weeks ago, the federal Liberal government dropped a $600-billion federal budget. In fact, it was the largest budget in Canadian history. It is an extraordinary amount of money. It is difficult to even wrap one’s head around the magnitude of $600 billion. It is also an extraordinary amount of debt for this year and the years to come. I am the official opposition health critic for Canada, so I was looking at it through a health care lens. Everybody knows that our health care system is facing significant issues. In fact, there is quite a large deterioration in the quality of care that many Canadians are experiencing in this country, so I was eager to see the budget and this unprecedented level of spending. I assumed there would be commitments to work with provinces to modernize our health care system and an acknowledgement of what Canadians are facing: dying waiting for care, having their well-being severely compromised while waiting for care, and the lack of access to hospital beds, doctors and care homes. We can go on and on about all the problems in health care, yet none of them were acknowledged, and certainly they are not a priority of the federal government. My hon. colleague from Thornhill mentioned this quite well: The budget document is a reflection of the values and the priorities of any given government on any given day, so it is fair to say, from my read of the budget, that ensuring that Canadians have quality access to timely, efficient and effective health care is not a priority at all. Working with the provinces, working with health authorities or working with education institutes are not a priority on health care for the Liberal government. I was quite disappointed to see that. However, the Liberals are making a lot of promises. They are promising that there will be jobs, investment and opportunity for this generation and many to come, and that this budget will be the solution to dealing with the tariff issues we are facing and the changing geopolitical international scene we are experiencing. I feel we have heard a lot of these promises before. In 2015, Canada had one of the richest middle classes in the world. We were doing very well. Then, the Liberal government came in, with Justin Trudeau’s leadership, and it spent half a trillion dollars of debt, which was more debt than all the other governments that came before it, combined. The Liberals doubled the national debt in that time. In every single budget, they promised that this was going to deliver prosperity. I believe “real change for the middle class” was one of their campaign slogans. However, 10 years after inheriting the richest middle class in the world, we saw quite the opposite from what they were promising for a decade. In fact, the price of the average home and the price of the average rental doubled in the 10 years they were governed under Justin Trudeau. We have over two million people going to food banks now. Despite all that so-called investment in the Canadian economy, our productivity has flatlined over the last decade. That really impacts the quality of life for everyday people, which is predicted to decline in the coming years. I feel that we have heard this story before, but I will say that I do wish them the best of luck. I hope they succeed and that their promises and the commitments in this budget do bear fruit. Again, the challenges we are facing in health care were nowhere acknowledged, let alone addressed, in this budget. We are spending a lot on health care. Canada spends about $433 billion annually on health care. That is roughly $10,000 per man, woman and child in Canada. It is the 13th-highest spending per capita in the developed world, according to the OECD, which is an international think tank that compares peer nations on how they are doing economically on health care and education. We are the 13th-highest spender, spending $10,000 per person annually, so I think it is fair to ask what Canadians are getting for that money. If we look at the OECD, we are ranking fairly poorly on major indicators in health care. For example, on MRIs, CTs and PET scanners, the major diagnostic machinery in this country, we rank 28th out of 31 OECD countries. We have 26 of those diagnostic imaging scanners per million people. The average is 51 per million. We are at almost half of the average in the developed world for these diagnostic imaging machines. If it is taking someone a year to get an MRI, that is why. We rank 31st out of 37 for practising doctors per 1,000 people. On hospital beds per 1,000 people, we rank 29th out of 38. This is why we have hallway medicine, for example. This is why people cannot get a general practitioner. This is why people are struggling for six months to get a specialist referral. We do not have the doctors, we do not have the beds, and we do not have the MRI and CT machines, and it is having real impacts. Let us say that someone feels that something is off. Maybe they feel a lump, and something is going on. Their general practitioner refers them to a specialist. Then, that specialist figures out what is going on, and they get a treatment plan and a surgery. The average time from the first referral to the surgical procedure or treatment is over 30 weeks. That is seven months from when a person realizes something is wrong to when they can actually get help for it. That is the average, so some people are experiencing much worse wait times than that. It is so bad, in fact, that about 23,000 people on wait-lists are estimated to have died last year, according to SecondStreet.org. Since 2018, the cumulative death count for people on wait-lists was 133,000. We do not know why they passed away. It may not have been because they were waiting. They may have just passed away, and that happens, but I think it is fair to say that what we have all seen or heard from our community or our family and from what we read in the news or the data we are seeing is that many of those deaths may have been preventable if people had had timely and efficient access to high-quality medical care. The stakes are quite high in Canada. Forty per cent of Canadians, two out of five, will get cancer during their life. Let us say that if there were 20 people in this room right now, eight of us would get cancer in our life. It could be me, God forbid. Everyone knows someone who has had cancer. It is one of the top killers in this country. For example, one in eight women will get breast cancer. I do not know anyone who has not been touched by this disease. If we talk to the top breast cancer experts in Canada, we learn that the benchmark for the first mammogram is seven weeks. Do members want to know how many jurisdictions in Canada are meeting the benchmark for the number one cancer for women? It is zero. Zero Canadian jurisdictions, zero health authorities and zero provinces are meeting the benchmark for the initial mammogram to diagnose breast cancer in Canada, and it is the most common cancer. I recently met a young woman whose name is Crystal. She has two young daughters. She waited so long to get treatment that her breast cancer progressed from stage 2 to stage 3. As many people know, if a person gets beyond stage 2 in breast cancer, it is a real fight. It is the fight of their life. Now Crystal is in remission, thank God, but she will be on $4,000-per-week medication for the foreseeable future, and her life expectancy is predicted to be shorter because her cancer got so serious. Crystal started an advocacy group called Too Young to Wait, to raise the alarm and advocate for young women to get screened, which is all great, but we need access to mammograms. We need the technicians to do those mammograms. We need the radiologists to read them. We need to have GPs to refer us. We need hospital beds when we get sick. We need treatment rooms. We need surgery. We are just not getting those things, relative to peer nations, despite spending more than they are in many cases. It is not just cancer. It is also visits to the ER. Members may have seen the very alarming headline I read a few weeks ago. A young woman died from a broken ankle. The surgery to fix her broken ankle right after the accident was delayed, and she got a blood clot from her broken ankle and died. There was a father of three, right before Christmas last year, who had serious chest pain. He waited in an ER for eight hours and died in the ER before he was able to get care. An emergency room doctor who was reported about in Toronto CityNews is raising the alarm on the issue in the ER. He is saying that the number of patients is “insane, out-of-control, explosive, never seen before, [and] record-breaking.” This is in our country’s biggest city. He is an ER doctor. He works at three hospitals. It is time to break the glass. We are in an emergency situation in our health care system, and it is only going to get worse unless something serious changes. The federal government, the Liberals, has committed to bringing in 380,000 new permanent residents every single year, which is the population of a small city. To my knowledge, no consultation was done with provincial health authorities to determine whether we can withstand that level of influx of people. In addition, the largest demographic in history, the baby boomers, is aging into health care. This means that our population is a little lopsided. When the Canada Health Act came in during the 1980s, a then modern health care system was initiated, and there were seven working people for every one retiree. Now there are three working people for every retiree. We pay some of the highest taxes in the world, and we have some of the highest health care expenses. Is money the only option to fix this? Maybe we need more money. That is probably part of the solution, but I do not think it is the only one. What I do know is that nothing is being offered despite the largest budget in history. There is no new initiative for health care. There is no commitment to modernize it. There is nothing saying that we are going to work with provinces to get to the bottom of this and fix it or that we are going to look at other countries to see what they are doing with their universal health care systems that we are not. It is not a priority of the government to support provinces to ensure that Canadians are not dying in ERs or dying waiting for surgical care. This is not something the Liberals are taking seriously, which was the biggest disappointment for me in this budget, and it is the top reason that I will be voting against it.”
Mr. Speaker, two weeks ago, the federal Liberal government dropped a $600-billion federal budget. In fact, it was the largest budget in Canadian history. It is an extraordinary amount of money. It is difficult to even wrap one’s head around the magnitude of $600 billion. It is also an extraordinary amount of debt for this year and the years to come. I am the official opposition health critic for Canada, so I was looking at it through a health care lens. Everybody knows that our health care system is facing significant issues. In fact, there is quite a large deterioration in the quality of care that many Canadians are experiencing in this country, so I was eager to see the budget and this unprecedented level of spending. I assumed there would be commitments to work with provinces to modernize our health care system and an acknowledgement of what Canadians are facing: dying waiting for care, having their well-being severely compromised while waiting for care, and the lack of access to hospital beds, doctors and care homes. We can go on and on about all the problems in health care, yet none of them were acknowledged, and certainly they are not a priority of the federal government. My hon. colleague from Thornhill mentioned this quite well: The budget document is a reflection of the values and the priorities of any given government on any given day, so it is fair to say, from my read of the budget, that ensuring that Canadians have quality access to timely, efficient and effective health care is not a priority at all. Working with the provinces, working with health authorities or working with education institutes are not a priority on health care for the Liberal government. I was quite disappointed to see that. However, the Liberals are making a lot of promises. They are promising that there will be jobs, investment and opportunity for this generation and many to come, and that this budget will be the solution to dealing with the tariff issues we are facing and the changing geopolitical international scene we are experiencing. I feel we have heard a lot of these promises before. In 2015, Canada had one of the richest middle classes in the world. We were doing very well. Then, the Liberal government came in, with Justin Trudeau’s leadership, and it spent half a trillion dollars of debt, which was more debt than all the other governments that came before it, combined. The Liberals doubled the national debt in that time. In every single budget, they promised that this was going to deliver prosperity. I believe “real change for the middle class” was one of their campaign slogans. However, 10 years after inheriting the richest middle class in the world, we saw quite the opposite from what they were promising for a decade. In fact, the price of the average home and the price of the average rental doubled in the 10 years they were governed under Justin Trudeau. We have over two million people going to food banks now. Despite all that so-called investment in the Canadian economy, our productivity has flatlined over the last decade. That really impacts the quality of life for everyday people, which is predicted to decline in the coming years. I feel that we have heard this story before, but I will say that I do wish them the best of luck. I hope they succeed and that their promises and the commitments in this budget do bear fruit. Again, the challenges we are facing in health care were nowhere acknowledged, let alone addressed, in this budget. We are spending a lot on health care. Canada spends about $433 billion annually on health care. That is roughly $10,000 per man, woman and child in Canada. It is the 13th-highest spending per capita in the developed world, according to the OECD, which is an international think tank that compares peer nations on how they are doing economically on health care and education. We are the 13th-highest spender, spending $10,000 per person annually, so I think it is fair to ask what Canadians are getting for that money. If we look at the OECD, we are ranking fairly poorly on major indicators in health care. For example, on MRIs, CTs and PET scanners, the major diagnostic machinery in this country, we rank 28th out of 31 OECD countries. We have 26 of those diagnostic imaging scanners per million people. The average is 51 per million. We are at almost half of the average in the developed world for these diagnostic imaging machines. If it is taking someone a year to get an MRI, that is why. We rank 31st out of 37 for practising doctors per 1,000 people. On hospital beds per 1,000 people, we rank 29th out of 38. This is why we have hallway medicine, for example. This is why people cannot get a general practitioner. This is why people are struggling for six months to get a specialist referral. We do not have the doctors, we do not have the beds, and we do not have the MRI and CT machines, and it is having real impacts. Let us say that someone feels that something is off. Maybe they feel a lump, and something is going on. Their general practitioner refers them to a specialist. Then, that specialist figures out what is going on, and they get a treatment plan and a surgery. The average time from the first referral to the surgical procedure or treatment is over 30 weeks. That is seven months from when a person realizes something is wrong to when they can actually get help for it. That is the average, so some people are experiencing much worse wait times than that. It is so bad, in fact, that about 23,000 people on wait-lists are estimated to have died last year, according to SecondStreet.org. Since 2018, the cumulative death count for people on wait-lists was 133,000. We do not know why they passed away. It may not have been because they were waiting. They may have just passed away, and that happens, but I think it is fair to say that what we have all seen or heard from our community or our family and from what we read in the news or the data we are seeing is that many of those deaths may have been preventable if people had had timely and efficient access to high-quality medical care. The stakes are quite high in Canada. Forty per cent of Canadians, two out of five, will get cancer during their life. Let us say that if there were 20 people in this room right now, eight of us would get cancer in our life. It could be me, God forbid. Everyone knows someone who has had cancer. It is one of the top killers in this country. For example, one in eight women will get breast cancer. I do not know anyone who has not been touched by this disease. If we talk to the top breast cancer experts in Canada, we learn that the benchmark for the first mammogram is seven weeks. Do members want to know how many jurisdictions in Canada are meeting the benchmark for the number one cancer for women? It is zero. Zero Canadian jurisdictions, zero health authorities and zero provinces are meeting the benchmark for the initial mammogram to diagnose breast cancer in Canada, and it is the most common cancer. I recently met a young woman whose name is Crystal. She has two young daughters. She waited so long to get treatment that her breast cancer progressed from stage 2 to stage 3. As many people know, if a person gets beyond stage 2 in breast cancer, it is a real fight. It is the fight of their life. Now Crystal is in remission, thank God, but she will be on $4,000-per-week medication for the foreseeable future, and her life expectancy is predicted to be shorter because her cancer got so serious. Crystal started an advocacy group called Too Young to Wait, to raise the alarm and advocate for young women to get screened, which is all great, but we need access to mammograms. We need the technicians to do those mammograms. We need the radiologists to read them. We need to have GPs to refer us. We need hospital beds when we get sick. We need treatment rooms. We need surgery. We are just not getting those things, relative to peer nations, despite spending more than they are in many cases. It is not just cancer. It is also visits to the ER. Members may have seen the very alarming headline I read a few weeks ago. A young woman died from a broken ankle. The surgery to fix her broken ankle right after the accident was delayed, and she got a blood clot from her broken ankle and died. There was a father of three, right before Christmas last year, who had serious chest pain. He waited in an ER for eight hours and died in the ER before he was able to get care. An emergency room doctor who was reported about in Toronto CityNews is raising the alarm on the issue in the ER. He is saying that the number of patients is “insane, out-of-control, explosive, never seen before, [and] record-breaking.” This is in our country’s biggest city. He is an ER doctor. He works at three hospitals. It is time to break the glass. We are in an emergency situation in our health care system, and it is only going to get worse unless something serious changes. The federal government, the Liberals, has committed to bringing in 380,000 new permanent residents every single year, which is the population of a small city. To my knowledge, no consultation was done with provincial health authorities to determine whether we can withstand that level of influx of people. In addition, the largest demographic in history, the baby boomers, is aging into health care. This means that our population is a little lopsided. When the Canada Health Act came in during the 1980s, a then modern health care system was initiated, and there were seven working people for every one retiree. Now there are three working people for every retiree. We pay some of the highest taxes in the world, and we have some of the highest health care expenses. Is money the only option to fix this? Maybe we need more money. That is probably part of the solution, but I do not think it is the only one. What I do know is that nothing is being offered despite the largest budget in history. There is no new initiative for health care. There is no commitment to modernize it. There is nothing saying that we are going to work with provinces to get to the bottom of this and fix it or that we are going to look at other countries to see what they are doing with their universal health care systems that we are not. It is not a priority of the government to support provinces to ensure that Canadians are not dying in ERs or dying waiting for surgical care. This is not something the Liberals are taking seriously, which was the biggest disappointment for me in this budget, and it is the top reason that I will be voting against it.