Discussion · Oral Questions
Sandra Cobena Conservative
“The finance minister used strange accounting tricks to make the budget look balanced. He moved $136 billion from expenses to investments. He says he did it to be open with the public, but people cannot check his numbers. Does he think Canadians will believe this scheme?”
“Mr. Speaker, the member clearly dodged the question, but let me say this: The finance minister, in fact, said that he did this for transparency. He invented definitions not used anywhere else in the world for transparency, and then used them inconsistently for transparency. Then, the numbers cannot be independently replicated with public information for transparency, but conveniently, this accounting scheme moves $136 billion of expenses to investments and causes the operating budget to be balanced. Does he really think that Canadians are foolish enough to believe his scheme, or does he think that telling the truth does not matter anymore?”
-
Opposition question in Question Period
Respect 83 of 100
This statement targeted a person rather than their actions or views: “does he think that telling the truth does not matter anymore”.
See full analysis
Mr. Speaker, the member clearly dodged the question, but let me say this: The finance minister, in fact, said that he did this for transparency. He invented definitions not used anywhere else in the world for transparency, and then used them inconsistently for transparency. Then, the numbers cannot be independently replicated with public information for transparency, but conveniently, this accounting scheme moves $136 billion of expenses to investments and causes the operating budget to be balanced. Does he really think that Canadians are foolish enough to believe his scheme, or does he think that telling the truth does not matter anymore?