Discussion · Government Orders
Pat Kelly Conservative
“The Alto rail project makes no financial sense. Even if it costs $90 billion, the interest alone would be $300 per ticket, before counting running costs or paying back the original money. This project will waste money.”
“Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for drawing a straight line from the Rivard affair of the Pearson era through to present Liberal corruption and the culture within that party. However, I do want to focus in my question on the Alto rail project. The member said that the PBO says it will cost probably $113 billion. I am just doing a quick bit of math. I know the project even said $90 billion. I am sure it will be much more than that, but even $90 billion at 4% interest, divided by 12 million passengers, is $300 per ticket. That is from a study from the University of Montreal. If the interest alone is $300 one way, without operating costs and without recouping capital, how could this program ever make any sense whatsoever, when it is so clearly and obviously going to be a financial boondoggle?”
Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for drawing a straight line from the Rivard affair of the Pearson era through to present Liberal corruption and the culture within that party. However, I do want to focus in my question on the Alto rail project. The member said that the PBO says it will cost probably $113 billion. I am just doing a quick bit of math. I know the project even said $90 billion. I am sure it will be much more than that, but even $90 billion at 4% interest, divided by 12 million passengers, is $300 per ticket. That is from a study from the University of Montreal. If the interest alone is $300 one way, without operating costs and without recouping capital, how could this program ever make any sense whatsoever, when it is so clearly and obviously going to be a financial boondoggle?