Discussion · Private Members' Business

Alexis Deschênes Bloc Québécois

“Our laws already allow people to defend themselves and their homes. An Ontario person recently shot an intruder and was found not guilty. Laws like this one in Florida led to more gun deaths. Has the member looked into the real impact of this bill?”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for her contribution to the debate. In her speech, she mentioned the case in Ontario. An individual is the victim of a home invasion, grabs a gun, shoots the intruder, and seriously injures them. That person pleads self-defence and is acquitted. This example demonstrates that the Criminal Code currently provides people with the necessary certainty and security to defend their property. Has my colleague looked into the impact of what she is proposing? This type of law was implemented in Florida, and it was found to have increased the rate of gun-related homicides, because the argument is that as soon as someone enters without permission, the homeowner can shoot them in the head and be cleared of any wrongdoing.

No comments yet.

Comment rules