Discussion · Statements by Members
Scott Reid Conservative
“The new fast train project from Montreal to Toronto will make rail service worse for Kingston. Stopping in Kingston adds 20 minutes to the trip. To save time, fewer trains will stop there, and the station will likely move 30 minutes out of town. Kingston does not want this project.”
“Mr. Speaker, the case for Alto is based on a 180-minute travel time from Montreal to Toronto. Adding a stop at the Kingston Via station would slow this by 20 minutes, making Alto uncompetitive with air travel. Two factors are responsible. First, for a TGV-style train, every intermediate stop adds 10 minutes. Second, diverting the planned route to Kingston would add 50 kilometres and, therefore, a further 10 minutes to every trip. If Kingston’s promised Alto stop is actually delivered, it is probably going to look like this. First, the 10-minute deficit caused by extra stops will be addressed by ending Via’s practice of stopping every train in Kingston. Take a look at Port Hope’s intermittent train service to see what this looks like. Second, the deficit caused by the 50-kilometre detour would be addressed by moving the station, not the track. Kingston’s train station would likely be 30 minutes away in Verona or Sydenham. Alto service will be far worse and far slower for Kingston than Via is. It is no wonder Kingston does not want Alto.”
Mr. Speaker, the case for Alto is based on a 180-minute travel time from Montreal to Toronto. Adding a stop at the Kingston Via station would slow this by 20 minutes, making Alto uncompetitive with air travel. Two factors are responsible. First, for a TGV-style train, every intermediate stop adds 10 minutes. Second, diverting the planned route to Kingston would add 50 kilometres and, therefore, a further 10 minutes to every trip. If Kingston’s promised Alto stop is actually delivered, it is probably going to look like this. First, the 10-minute deficit caused by extra stops will be addressed by ending Via’s practice of stopping every train in Kingston. Take a look at Port Hope’s intermittent train service to see what this looks like. Second, the deficit caused by the 50-kilometre detour would be addressed by moving the station, not the track. Kingston’s train station would likely be 30 minutes away in Verona or Sydenham. Alto service will be far worse and far slower for Kingston than Via is. It is no wonder Kingston does not want Alto.