Discussion · Private Members' Business
Tamara Kronis Conservative
“Abandoned boats are a big problem on our coast, and I support this bill. But new laws will not fix the issue if the government does not enforce the rules we already have. Current laws already allow the government to remove these boats and fine the owners. We need the government to use its existing powers, give workers the tools they need, and clean up these wrecks.”
“Mr. Speaker, I represent Nanaimo—Ladysmith, where abandoned and derelict boats are a constant problem. They sit in our harbours, sink in our bays, threaten navigation and damage marine habitats. Like my predecessors, I have spent an extraordinary amount of time dealing with these vessels. Because those who came before me sought legislative change, I too initially thought what was required here was more legislation. However, the more I consulted, the more I came to understand that what we really need is enforcement. More laws will not fix the federal government’s failure to clean up the derelict boats on our coast. Enforcement will do that. On the derelict vessels file, the claim that we need more legislation has become an all-too-convenient excuse for not doing what the law already allows. I supported sending this bill to committee. I agree that we have a problem with people transferring deteriorating vessels to buyers who cannot afford to maintain them. What has come back from committee? The bill would now require the seller to provide written information about the boat’s condition and obtain a written statement from the buyer saying that they have the resources and intention to maintain and eventually dispose of it responsibly. That is it. There would be no requirement for a marine survey, no independent verification of the buyer’s resources, no proof that the buyer can actually afford disposal and no requirement to file the required declarations with Transport Canada. The bill claims it would stop people from transferring worthless boats to people who cannot maintain them by asking them to sign a piece of paper saying they can. I am sure the people who abandon boats are terrified. Here is what actually troubles me. Section 130 of the existing Wrecked, Abandoned or Hazardous Vessels Act already gives the federal government authority to make regulations establishing conditions for selling or acquiring vessels. The government could have regulated the sale and acquisition conditions. No law is required. Section 32 of the existing law makes abandoning a vessel illegal and provides for a process by which it can be designated, abandoned and removed. Section 33 of the existing law prohibits owners from allowing their vessel to become wrecks through inadequate maintenance. Section 30 of the existing law restricts stranding a dilapidated vessel in one location for more than 60 days without consent. The act already authorizes federal authorities to direct owners to act, move or remove vessels, dismantle and dispose of wrecks, impose penalties and recover costs in many cases. These powers have existed since 2019. When I see an uninhabited, derelict or dangerous vessel sitting in my riding, my first question is not whether Parliament needs to pass another law. It is why the federal government has not used the law we already have to remove it. I can tell the House from experience that asking that question repeatedly works. I particularly want to thank the good people of Ladysmith, Gabriola Island and the other coastal communities in my riding, as well as the organizations, many of which were named by the hon. member in his remarks, for the photographs, locations, histories of vessels and evidence of deterioration they have sent me. They have made calls, written emails, followed up with authorities and joined me in refusing to accept that these boats are somebody else’s problem. They have kept after me, and I have kept after Transport Canada and the minister’s office. We have pressed for removal timelines, challenged decisions and insisted on follow through. The boats are starting to move. Transport Canada has arranged for the removal of a number of vessels in Degnen Bay and Silva Bay, and has started enforcement proceedings against several others. At least three left after receiving notices and at least 14 abandoned or dilapidated vessels were removed. Unauthorized floating rafts were also cleared. This was all done under the laws we already have. I was out last weekend surveying the progress so far. I was delighted to see an unprecedented number of unoccupied moorings. That is what enforcement looks like. We have also seen what happens when enforcement fails. Near Ladysmith’s Transfer Beach, residents documented a vessel that sank and an apparent fuel sheen on the water. Advocacy with Transport Canada saw the vessel moved, but only to the Dogpatch, where it promptly started to sink again. That is not a solution. However, at the time of this speech, I am waiting for a list from Transport Canada of vessels to be removed from the Dogpatch. I was supposed to get that list yesterday and have been in touch with an official from the Minister of Transport’s office who knows that I am making this speech today. To his credit, he got back to me immediately, and I take him at his word that I will have the list early next week. The work is far from finished. There is important work to be done, with compassion and with help from the province and other agencies, with those living aboard derelict boats that are not theirs. Still, in these past 18 months, with careful file management, persistence, community advocacy and a good deal of elbow grease, we have accomplished more in parts of my riding than years of legislative proposals have done. Fines do not remove derelict boats; people do. I want to thank the Transport Canada and Coast Guard employees who are doing their jobs. I want them to have the resources to do more of it, and I am working directly with Transport Canada officials to get it. A member of Parliament should not have to chase individual boats through a maze of federal departments before somebody acts, but if that is what is necessary, that is what we will do. Bill C-244 would not build the ship-wrecking and ship-breaking facility we need on the west coast, provide new cleanup funding, establish removal deadlines or give local organizations a clear, user-friendly path to report and remove abandoned and derelict vessels. I would add that removing derelict vessels must not create more pollution in the process. These boats often contain diesel, oil and other contaminants that can escape during salvage. North Vancouver’s Aqua-Guard won a national competition with Canadian-made technology capable of recovering oil sheens previously considered impossible to collect. The technology is now commercially available, but Transport Canada has yet to adopt it. Surely, we should be requiring coastal authorities to have appropriate spill-recovery equipment on hand wherever they operate in Canada. The fisheries committee recommended vessel turn-in programs, better owner identification, disposal and recycling incentives and fewer barriers for people willing to remove and remediate derelict boats. Where are those measures in the bill? I am not opposed to improving the law. I support it, but what I am opposed to is pretending that every enforcement failure can be fixed by passing another law. The people of Nanaimo—Ladysmith do not want another legislative promise to protect their coastline. They want the wrecks removed in a way that deals compassionately with those living aboard dilapidated or abandoned vessels they do not have the right to be on. In Nanaimo—Ladysmith, we have shown that when people organize, when government is pressed to act and when someone actually manages the file, boats get removed. I have no objections to Bill C-244, but new laws are no substitute for enforcing the ones we already have. I thank everyone who has been assisting in this very important project. We will continue until all the boats that are supposed to be gone are gone.”
Mr. Speaker, I represent Nanaimo—Ladysmith, where abandoned and derelict boats are a constant problem. They sit in our harbours, sink in our bays, threaten navigation and damage marine habitats. Like my predecessors, I have spent an extraordinary amount of time dealing with these vessels. Because those who came before me sought legislative change, I too initially thought what was required here was more legislation. However, the more I consulted, the more I came to understand that what we really need is enforcement. More laws will not fix the federal government’s failure to clean up the derelict boats on our coast. Enforcement will do that. On the derelict vessels file, the claim that we need more legislation has become an all-too-convenient excuse for not doing what the law already allows. I supported sending this bill to committee. I agree that we have a problem with people transferring deteriorating vessels to buyers who cannot afford to maintain them. What has come back from committee? The bill would now require the seller to provide written information about the boat’s condition and obtain a written statement from the buyer saying that they have the resources and intention to maintain and eventually dispose of it responsibly. That is it. There would be no requirement for a marine survey, no independent verification of the buyer’s resources, no proof that the buyer can actually afford disposal and no requirement to file the required declarations with Transport Canada. The bill claims it would stop people from transferring worthless boats to people who cannot maintain them by asking them to sign a piece of paper saying they can. I am sure the people who abandon boats are terrified. Here is what actually troubles me. Section 130 of the existing Wrecked, Abandoned or Hazardous Vessels Act already gives the federal government authority to make regulations establishing conditions for selling or acquiring vessels. The government could have regulated the sale and acquisition conditions. No law is required. Section 32 of the existing law makes abandoning a vessel illegal and provides for a process by which it can be designated, abandoned and removed. Section 33 of the existing law prohibits owners from allowing their vessel to become wrecks through inadequate maintenance. Section 30 of the existing law restricts stranding a dilapidated vessel in one location for more than 60 days without consent. The act already authorizes federal authorities to direct owners to act, move or remove vessels, dismantle and dispose of wrecks, impose penalties and recover costs in many cases. These powers have existed since 2019. When I see an uninhabited, derelict or dangerous vessel sitting in my riding, my first question is not whether Parliament needs to pass another law. It is why the federal government has not used the law we already have to remove it. I can tell the House from experience that asking that question repeatedly works. I particularly want to thank the good people of Ladysmith, Gabriola Island and the other coastal communities in my riding, as well as the organizations, many of which were named by the hon. member in his remarks, for the photographs, locations, histories of vessels and evidence of deterioration they have sent me. They have made calls, written emails, followed up with authorities and joined me in refusing to accept that these boats are somebody else’s problem. They have kept after me, and I have kept after Transport Canada and the minister’s office. We have pressed for removal timelines, challenged decisions and insisted on follow through. The boats are starting to move. Transport Canada has arranged for the removal of a number of vessels in Degnen Bay and Silva Bay, and has started enforcement proceedings against several others. At least three left after receiving notices and at least 14 abandoned or dilapidated vessels were removed. Unauthorized floating rafts were also cleared. This was all done under the laws we already have. I was out last weekend surveying the progress so far. I was delighted to see an unprecedented number of unoccupied moorings. That is what enforcement looks like. We have also seen what happens when enforcement fails. Near Ladysmith’s Transfer Beach, residents documented a vessel that sank and an apparent fuel sheen on the water. Advocacy with Transport Canada saw the vessel moved, but only to the Dogpatch, where it promptly started to sink again. That is not a solution. However, at the time of this speech, I am waiting for a list from Transport Canada of vessels to be removed from the Dogpatch. I was supposed to get that list yesterday and have been in touch with an official from the Minister of Transport’s office who knows that I am making this speech today. To his credit, he got back to me immediately, and I take him at his word that I will have the list early next week. The work is far from finished. There is important work to be done, with compassion and with help from the province and other agencies, with those living aboard derelict boats that are not theirs. Still, in these past 18 months, with careful file management, persistence, community advocacy and a good deal of elbow grease, we have accomplished more in parts of my riding than years of legislative proposals have done. Fines do not remove derelict boats; people do. I want to thank the Transport Canada and Coast Guard employees who are doing their jobs. I want them to have the resources to do more of it, and I am working directly with Transport Canada officials to get it. A member of Parliament should not have to chase individual boats through a maze of federal departments before somebody acts, but if that is what is necessary, that is what we will do. Bill C-244 would not build the ship-wrecking and ship-breaking facility we need on the west coast, provide new cleanup funding, establish removal deadlines or give local organizations a clear, user-friendly path to report and remove abandoned and derelict vessels. I would add that removing derelict vessels must not create more pollution in the process. These boats often contain diesel, oil and other contaminants that can escape during salvage. North Vancouver’s Aqua-Guard won a national competition with Canadian-made technology capable of recovering oil sheens previously considered impossible to collect. The technology is now commercially available, but Transport Canada has yet to adopt it. Surely, we should be requiring coastal authorities to have appropriate spill-recovery equipment on hand wherever they operate in Canada. The fisheries committee recommended vessel turn-in programs, better owner identification, disposal and recycling incentives and fewer barriers for people willing to remove and remediate derelict boats. Where are those measures in the bill? I am not opposed to improving the law. I support it, but what I am opposed to is pretending that every enforcement failure can be fixed by passing another law. The people of Nanaimo—Ladysmith do not want another legislative promise to protect their coastline. They want the wrecks removed in a way that deals compassionately with those living aboard dilapidated or abandoned vessels they do not have the right to be on. In Nanaimo—Ladysmith, we have shown that when people organize, when government is pressed to act and when someone actually manages the file, boats get removed. I have no objections to Bill C-244, but new laws are no substitute for enforcing the ones we already have. I thank everyone who has been assisting in this very important project. We will continue until all the boats that are supposed to be gone are gone.