Discussion · Private Members' Business

Kevin Lamoureux Liberal

“I want the House to pass this bill. Abandoned boats pollute the water, harm sea life, and get in the way of other ships. Boat owners should pay to clean up the damage and dispose of old boats, instead of leaving taxpayers with the bill.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to hear a member from the Bloc indicate that the bill is a step forward, because there is no doubt that it is a step forward. I must say that I was a little disappointed to hear the Conservative speaker not recognize the intrinsic value of seeing the legislation pass. I want to just take a moment, looking at the sponsor of the legislation, to express my appreciation in recognizing a very important issue. We do not have to live on the coastlines in order to appreciate the coast. I live in the middle of Canada, in Manitoba. The closest that we have to that is Lake Winnipeg and the feed into Churchill. There are concerns about abandonment even in our lakes and the impact that it has. I want to compliment the sponsor. I love the riding name. I think it is a reflection of the member himself, West Vancouver—Sunshine Coast—Sea to Sky Country. What a beautiful name that is. When we think about British Columbia and the area that the member represents, I am not surprised that he is genuinely concerned about an issue that affects the province of B.C. specifically, especially along the coast. It also affects Atlantic Canada. I would suggest to members that all of us have a vested interest in the issue that the member has brought forward. I did a quick try to find out what kinds of numbers we are talking about in Pacific Canada. We are talking about an estimated 900 abandonments. In Atlantic Canada, it is nowhere near as high but still well over 100. These vessels are causing a great deal of concern and a great deal of potential damage, many of them damaging today in a number of ways. I think it is important that we recognize the responsibility for the federal government, provincial governments and even municipalities and indigenous communities. When we talk about the federal government, it is Transport Canada and our Coast Guard that lead the way on this issue, but there is also a lot of responsibility for provinces, municipalities and indigenous communities, all of which have expressed the sort of interest that is necessary to deal with the issue of wrecked and abandoned vessels. When I think of the types of vessels we are talking about, whether it is the fishing boats, commercial ships and, in some situations, even recreational boats. I can tell members, even from an inland perspective, the number of abandoned vessels that we see is very real. I like the bill that is before us today because it really attempts to achieve two primary objectives. I asked my colleague and friend about the issue of liability, using an example. We do need to ensure that there is a classification of a strict liability offence. The example that was shared with me was when we have a vessel that is in our waters that discharges oil. There are situations in which this occurred, where that vessel was not held accountable because there was no demonstration of it being intentional. For the vast majority of Canadians, whether a discharge is intentional or not, it should not be the taxpayer who pays the bill. The responsibility is for the vessel owners, not the taxpayers, ultimately. This is one of the reasons I like the bill that is before us today. There is a responsibility that is there. It is real. It is tangible, and if it is not maintained, then the issue of a strict liability offence being put into legislation, I think, is a wonderful thing to see. One of the loopholes that we know are there and that this bill actually resolves in good part is the issue of the seller or owner, if I can put it that way, and the purchaser. As it was pointed out earlier in debate, when a vessel is sold for one dollar, one wants to make sure the person who has purchased that vessel has a responsibility that goes beyond handing over a loonie. This bill advances that thought. It is saying to that owner or seller that in order to discharge that responsibility, they have to get a purchaser who is going to take on the responsibility of ultimately ensuring that the boat is not causing harm, that there is a plan to dispose of the boat or the vessel. I think it is a very important aspect, and I like the fact that Bill C-244 attempts to deal with it in a very real and tangible way, whether it is through a written disclosure or whether the purchaser has to demonstrate that they have the resources to be able to fix or dispose of the vessel. Today, when we look at it, what often happens is that we will get owners who will completely disappear. We will get owners who will claim bankruptcy, and then we will get owners who just abandon the vessels. Therefore, I do believe there needs to be more work in this area. With Bill C-244, we are seeing that issue at least being addressed in good part. When we think in terms of the types of vessels that are out there, which I made reference to, whether it is fishing, commercial or recreational, the impact of abandoning or leaving a wrecked ship or letting a vessel deteriorate to a certain point is that it causes a great deal of damage, both short-term and long-term. One could talk, for example, about water pollution. There are all forms of things that we will find that are on an abandoned vessel that are not healthy for water, which will lead to contamination that all of us should be concerned about. We can talk about the damage to marine life. These abandoned vessels have a negative impact in many ways on the viability of our marine life, not only in the immediate area in which the vessel has been abandoned, but also in the surrounding area and quite a bit more than just the surrounding environment. We can talk about the destruction of habitats. That, too, can cause a significant impact. We can talk about navigational hazards when we have a partially submerged vessel and there are others who are trying to navigate in and around it. We can talk about the high cleanup costs that are there. This is why it is so important that we ensure there is accountability and responsibility. There is economic damage and environmental damage that can be very long-term. There are over 1,000 abandoned and derelict vessels when we combine both of our coasts. I suspect we might even have some in the Arctic, but we know there are vessels on the Pacific and Atlantic coasts. These are all reasons I would ultimately argue that Bill C-244 should be supported.

No comments yet.

Comment rules