Translate Politics: Parliament in plain language.

Recent debates 8 latest debates

The Budget

Debate on Budget 2026 in Government Orders, covering government spending, deficits and debt, immigration, health transfers, and tax measures. Conservative members said the budget is too expensive, that borrowing figures were understated, that high immigration is contributing to youth unemployment in their regions, and that taxes and regulations are driving businesses away. Liberal members defended the budget as investing in affordability, housing, groceries, and key industries, said health transfers are growing and will stay at a 5% increase through 2027-28, and challenged the Conservatives’ link between immigration and youth unemployment, noting youth unemployment was higher when the Conservatives were in government. Bloc Québécois members raised federal compensation to Quebec for asylum seekers and the planned slowdown of health transfer increases from 5% to 3% after 2028, asking for commitments on both; one exchange also covered how the budget’s capital gains measures affect farm transfers between generations.Written by AI from the debate. Updated .

Official text (opens in a new tab)

7 statements

Andrew Lawton, Elgin—St. Thomas—London South

Conservative
“I will vote against this budget. It spends too much, adds to our debt, and sets immigration numbers too high. In my area, young people cannot find work because of these policies. This budget leaves ordinary Canadians and future generations behind.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I spoke earlier in my remarks about the recklessness that is ingrained in the entirety of this budget, not just in the debt and deficits, which is money that has to be repaid one way or another and compounds over time, which adds more to future generations. I also acknowledged the recklessness of the immigration number: 654,000 new permanent residents in Canada in a single year, at a time when all Canadians and newcomers to this country are seeing the consequences of reckless Liberal immigration. I cannot stress enough that the issue is not one for which the immigrants are to blame. I do not blame anyone for wanting to live in this wonderful, bountiful country. I blame the Liberal government, which holds the keys to the country, the government that has the right and obligation to set the number of immigrants who can come to this country. Let us look at the consequences of this. I want to point out that I live in and represent a region that has among the highest unemployment rates in Canada right now. The London area, which includes London, St. Thomas and Elgin county, has frequently had the highest over the last year. A large part of that is because of the disruption to the manufacturing sector, another area where, in this budget, we do not see something that will solve the problem and truly protect jobs. Youth unemployment has reached nearly 20%. It was 19.9% in the month of October. This is a rate that we can see as very heavily influenced by Liberal immigration policy, particularly when it comes to temporary residents. The proliferation of temporary foreign workers in the service sector is notably displacing jobs that would normally be taken by youth. Now, one in five youth in my region who are looking for work cannot find it, and that number does not take into consideration the number who have given up hope on looking for employment, which is a larger and larger share, as I learn when I speak to people, especially high school students. I will bring this back to a common thread. The recklessness of the Liberal budget, reckless spending, reckless debt, reckless deficits and reckless immigration, all hurt ordinary Canadians, the very people we are sent here to represent and serve. When someone all of a sudden cannot find a job, and if they do, they are paying more in their taxes for a greater share of that to go toward paying down debt, they as an individual and we collectively as a country are only getting further and further behind. We hear in question period time and time again that the Liberal government measures its success by the number of government programs it has and by the number of people using those programs. We should all be measuring success by the number of people who do not need to rely on government, especially for the basics, things such as groceries and food. We should not have a society in which government must be the answer to these fundamental questions. I will be voting against this budget. We have put forward and will continue to put forward concrete suggestions on the way to fix the fiscal recklessness the Liberals have caused and the fiscal problems they are putting on this country. I want to close by pointing out that it is not and should not be a question of politics; it is a question of safeguarding this country. A sovereign nation cannot be a nation that is indebted to itself and to others over and over. A sovereign nation is one that must stand on its own two feet in terms of security, liberty, prosperity and the economy. That is not what this budget does. This budget mortgages the future of the next generation, and we cannot stand for it.

Andrew Lawton, Elgin—St. Thomas—London South

Conservative
“Youth unemployment in my region is nearly 20 percent. High immigration is one cause of this, but it is not the only one. Liberal taxes, regulations, and high spending also make it harder for businesses to hire young people.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, the member actually understated the severity of the problem. In my region, youth unemployment is actually 19.9%. Also, I did not say that immigration is the only cause. I said that it is a cause. At the tail end of the Harper government, temporary residency in Canada was at 2.2%. It is, I believe, two and a half times that right now. Therefore, the immigration problem is a problem created by the Liberal government, and absolutely it is displacing jobs, but that is not the only reason for the youth unemployment rate. I can give the laundry list of other Liberal policies that are making it harder for businesses to get by, from taxes to regulation and inflation, which goes back to rising debt and deficit. The Liberals have caused this problem not only by immigration. They have screwed up a number of other things too.

Andrew Lawton, Elgin—St. Thomas—London South

Conservative
“The national debt hurts all Canadians because it forces the government to get bigger. Over a tenth of what the federal government spends now just pays interest on that debt. That money goes to bankers and bondholders instead of public services.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I am happy to look into the specific numbers, but I will say that the problem I was raising with the debt is one that affects Quebeckers and all Canadians because it forces the government to become larger and larger. I will reiterate the point I raised earlier, which is that now, more than one-tenth of all federal expenditures is just paying interest on debt. That is money that cannot go towards anything of value or towards any service. It is just enriching the bankers and bondholders on the backs of Canadians.

Pat Kelly, Calgary Crowfoot

Conservative
“The government says the deficit is $62.3 billion, but it is actually borrowing $149.5 billion this year and $765 billion over the budget plan. I want the member to talk about how this debt will hurt us in the future.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I wonder if the member can comment further on the role that debt is increasingly playing across government. We have a nominal deficit of, I think, $62.3 billion, which is double the amount that Chrystia Freeland resigned over, yet it grossly understates the scale of borrowing. The true fiscal borrowing requirement for this year alone is $149.5 billion, and over the budget horizon, it is going to be $765 billion. Can the member comment on the impacts this may have in years to come?

Andrew Lawton, Elgin—St. Thomas—London South

Conservative
“The government is using misleading accounting to hide the real state of its finances. Interest rates just went up, and the government is adding three-quarters of a trillion dollars in new debt over five years. This spending will hurt Canadians for generations.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, it is crazy. Just recently, there was an interest rate increase. We do not know what the future holds, but we know that the creative accounting the Prime Minister and his finance minister are employing is meant to present and project an image that is fundamentally not true. My colleague from Calgary very eloquently laid out the issue, which is that we are always going to be dealing with the consequences of this spending. We are talking about three-quarters of a trillion dollars in new debt over the next five years. Nobody can say that this will not have consequences that will last for generations.

Andrew Lawton, Elgin—St. Thomas—London South

Conservative
“We should not compare Canada to other countries. Canadian taxes, costs, and rules are driving businesses away, and the government has no plan to fix this.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, it would take a lot more time to answer that properly. First, I do not care about benchmarking to some countries around the world when we can look at Canadian standards, Canadian costs, Canadian taxes and Canadian regulations, all of which are driving businesses out, and the government is not providing a plan to fix that.

Greg McLean, Calgary Centre

Conservative
“The government is going to borrow $765 billion from foreign banks over the next four and a half years. The member seems to support this huge debt just to get a skating rink for his riding.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I listened to my new colleague’s speech and would like to welcome him to the House of Commons. That said, I heard something in his remarks suggesting that he supports the expansion of Canada’s debt. We are not just talking about debt. We are talking about borrowing $765 billion from foreign banks over the next four and a half years, yet he seems to support that because his riding will get skating rink. Did I hear that right?

Discussion

No comments yet

See the full discussion

Comment rules