Translate Politics: Parliament in plain language.

Recent debates 8 latest debates

The Budget

The debate over the Budget centered on concerns regarding the government’s management of national debt, which opposition members noted reached $1.37 trillion, and overall spending. Members argued that government investments lacked productive value, citing the high cost of the Alto high-speed rail project, and claimed that current policies were unaffordable for Canadians facing rising costs for groceries and fuel. In response, the government defended the budget, stating that global economic conditions and the need to invest in the economy while maintaining a strong credit rating justified the expenditures. Opposition members also raised issues concerning agricultural funding, the accessibility of the dental plan, and the appropriateness of releasing the budget late in the fiscal year.Written by AI from the debate. Updated .

Official text (opens in a new tab)

3 statements

Kevin Lamoureux, Parliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Liberal
“Our dental program helps seniors on fixed incomes pay for dental work. The Conservatives oppose it. Will the member support this program for the seniors in her area who use it?”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I have not had the time to go through all the history of former Conservative prime ministers, but I do happen to have one of the booklets, which is “Harper, Serial Abuser of Power: The Evidence Compiled.” There are a lot of pages to it. The one I thought was the biggest, of course, was the contempt of Parliament. However, that is not the reason I stood up to ask a question. The member made reference to seniors and the issue of affordability. I just want to remind the member opposite about one question I brought up in the past, and that is about the dental program, which is there to support seniors on fixed incomes who need to get dental work done. Unfortunately, her colleagues in her party are in opposition to that program. I am wondering if, for the sake of the seniors on fixed incomes who have used the program in her constituency, she would say she supports it?

Ruby Sahota, Secretary of State (Combatting Crime)

Liberal
“Immigrants are not to blame for crowded hospitals. Since 2016, new immigrants have made up only 3% to 4% of Canada's population. It is false to blame our health care problems on them.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I keep hearing this notion of hospitals being overburdened and filled with immigrants, all due to immigrants coming to this country. If we were to look at the numbers from 2016 to approximately the present, we would see that new immigrants to this country make up about 3% to 4% of the whole population. Are we to believe that somehow this percentage of the entire Canadian population is to blame for overburdening our hospitals? That is completely false, and it is putting the blame for a system that, sure, maybe needs some work and over which the provinces need to take control, on the backs on new immigrants. We cannot do that.

Carlos Leitão, Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Industry

Liberal
“I want the House to pass this budget. The world economy has faced big shocks from the pandemic, unstable trade, and wars. Higher oil prices brought Canada billions in extra revenue. We are choosing to invest that money back into our economy and into supporting families. Our credit rating is strong, borrowing costs are low, and our deficit is small compared to the size of our economy.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I want to begin by saying that I will be sharing my time with the member for Vancouver Granville. It is my turn to share my thoughts on the budget. In the 10 minutes that I have, I will try to structure my remarks into three parts. First, I will talk a little bit about the situation that we are currently in and that the budget seeks to address. Second, I will talk about the numbers and ratios that are found in the budget. Third, I will close by explaining why we are doing what we are doing and why we are taking this approach. The context we are in is extremely important because it presents very serious challenges for Canada. We are witnessing a direct assault on the global trading system, a system that has served both Canada and our U.S. neighbours well for the past 30 or 40 years. During that period of accelerated globalization, Canada and the United States became more economically integrated. Now, in 2025-26, our economy is far more closely intertwined with that of the United States than it was 20 or 30 years ago. What is more, the rules governing trade and integration used to be understood, predictable and stable. Those rules have been upended in ways that are unpredictable, unstable and highly chaotic. This is where we find ourselves. As if that were not enough, since 2020, the world has been hit by a series of shocks that have caused profound disruptions to the global economy. Of course, the pandemic springs to mind. Yes, I am going back to that again. Its effects on the global economy were enormous. The post-pandemic recovery in 2021-22, plus the major supply chain disruptions, triggered a powerful global surge in inflation, and it has proven difficult to bring it back within a more reasonable range. As if that were not enough, we then witnessed the start of the war in Ukraine in 2022. This war has been ongoing for almost five years now. Who would have thought that in late 2026 and soon 2027 we would still be talking about the war in Ukraine or, rather, Russia’s attack on Ukraine? It also triggered increases in the cost of raw materials, energy and more, which have further fuelled this much harder to control inflationary episode. As if all that were not enough, we then witnessed the start of another war this year, in late February of 2026. The war against Iran also disrupted the production and supply of crude oil. The cost of gasoline very quickly increased, and crude oil soon passed the $100-a-barrel mark. In Canada, or at least in Quebec, in my riding of Marc-Aurèle-Fortin, the price of gas went just over $2 a litre for a time. It has been quite an oil shock. That was the backdrop against which our budget was drafted and tabled in early November. The budget promotes and provides the means to transform Canada’s economy, diversify our markets and truly become masters of our destiny, as the title says. The goal is to make sure we fully understand that, even if the political landscape among our neighbours changes, as we all saw in the mid-term elections, the protectionist stance of the current administration will persist. That is not going to change. We have to be ready for it. We have to keep diversifying. We have to do whatever we can to protect our jobs and businesses. That is the context in which we found ourselves, and that is how we acted. Now, back to the budget itself. Because of the sharp rise in energy prices, the Government of Canada brought in revenue that was much higher than projected. At this point in time and for years to come, that will create fiscal room in excess of $20 billion a year. Additional annual revenue may even reach $30 billion or $35 billion thanks to higher energy prices and the revenue they generate for the Canadian government. We chose to reinvest this additional revenue in the Canadian economy on a massive scale. As a rough estimate, I would say that about two-thirds of that additional revenue has been invested in the economy and one-third has gone toward measures to support Canadians, families and individuals. Naturally, our Conservative friends described these actions as catastrophic, an unmitigated disaster. Canada’s economy was the biggest basket case in the world. The thing is, we still have a AAA credit rating. That is not bad for a basket case, for a collapsing economy. Our borrowing costs remain among the lowest in the world. They are certainly lower than those of our American neighbours and are not far off from those of Germany and other developed G7 countries, for example. Canada continues to enjoy a AAA credit rating, and our borrowing costs are under control and highly favourable. That said, there is a deficit. There is no point pretending otherwise. The budget clearly projects deficits of $62 billion in 2026-2027, $62.5 billion the following year, and $57 billion the year after, and so on. That is less than 2% of GDP. When we talk about deficits and debt, it is essential to consider them in relation to the size of the economy. The size of the economy determines the government’s ability to carry that debt and manage these deficits. Deficits of less than 2% of GDP are entirely and completely manageable. It is not a disaster. A public debt burden of roughly 45% of GDP is entirely manageable. What our friends often neglect to mention is that Canada’s economy, Canada’s GDP, is growing as well. Canada’s economy will be worth $4 trillion by 2030-31. When we talk about debt and deficits, it always has to be in relation to that size. We are doing what we are doing because we chose to do it, because we can do it, because we have the fiscal space to do it and because we must do it. It is now that we have to address these issues, not five years from now, maybe waiting and doing nothing. No, it is now that we have to act, and it is now that we have chosen to act.

Discussion

No comments yet

See the full discussion

Comment rules