Xavier Barsalou-Duval, Pierre-Boucher—Les Patriotes—Verchères
“I support this bill. It is good to make boat owners take responsibility for their vessels. But laws are not enough on their own. The federal government often neglects its duties, leaving dangerous shipwrecks in our waters and letting wharves fall apart. I want this bill to lead to real action from the government to clean up our waterways.”
“Mr. Speaker, today we are debating Bill C-244, the clean coasts act. First of all, I want to say that I am thrilled to see a bill like this one being debated in the House, not that I necessarily consider it groundbreaking. I think my colleague who spoke earlier on the matter made the point quite effectively. Indeed, laws alone do not always solve problems. Sometimes what is needed is simply the political will to act and get things done. That is an important point that all of us in this House would do well to keep in mind whenever we are faced with a problem. Nonetheless, I must say that it is refreshing, and I will explain why. Essentially, when private members’ bills are introduced by opposition members, they are often powerful, impactful, with a clear vision. They are designed to make a difference, to really tackle specific issues. Unfortunately, when private members’ bills come from the government benches—and I am not talking about bills introduced by ministers, since ministers are not allowed to introduce private bills—what we usually get are trivial bills that change absolutely nothing. It is as though those members are practically tossing out whatever bill they can come up with, because they lucked out in the draw and have to introduce a bill just for the sake of introducing something. I suspect the whip’s office or the House leader’s office ends up scribbling something on the back of a napkin and telling the member to turn it into a bill. In the case before us today, I do want to acknowledge my colleague’s work, because there is at least a genuine effort here to tackle a real problem, which is a refreshing change. I think it is a shame when Parliament’s time is wasted on completely insignificant issues that are not really issues at all. I commend my colleague opposite. I do not know whether he had to stand up to his party to be able to introduce this common-sense legislation, but I want to commend him for his initiative. We know that, in Canada, there are at least 2,000 abandoned derelict vessels in our waters. I say “at least” because they have not all been documented. Obviously, they can be found up and down our coasts, but some places in Quebec are especially known for their shipwrecks, particularly Charlevoix and the north shore. These wrecks are pretty easy to spot if one is paying attention. In some cases, they have even become a sort of tourist attraction. However, I would not say that every shipwreck is a tourist attraction or that we want more of them in our lakes, rivers and waterways. Quite the contrary, I think that is far from desirable. That reminds me of a specific case. I have been a member of the House since 2015, and I had the opportunity to witness repeated interventions by some of my colleagues who represented the riding that is now known as Vallée‑du‑Haut-Saint-Laurent. They regularly brought up a local wreck known as the Kathryn Spirit. If I am not mistaken, the ship was abandoned around 2011 and was not removed from the water until 2018. It took seven years to finally get the pieces of the wreck out of the St. Lawrence River. I am the member for Montérégie, so it happened in my region. I must say that I was quite upset to see the government sitting on its hands and doing nothing week after week, month after month, year after year. Would Bill C-244 have resolved the Kathryn Spirit case? I cannot say for sure. I would tend to say no. Nevertheless, this is a striking example of a federal government that too often neglects its responsibilities and displays a troubling degree of complacency. I must say that these abandoned ships often leave behind all kinds of debris and damage. We know that the metals they contain gradually leach into the surrounding environment. Rust is an obvious example. They can also become hazards to navigation. On the St. Lawrence River, in my region, we do not really have a choice but to remove them quickly when they are in the middle of the channel because, if we do not, boats can no longer reach Montreal. On the other hand, when they are a little farther out, it seems less urgent because they sometimes stay there longer. These wrecks can have a wide range of impacts. The chemicals they contain can end up in the water we drink and in the food chain. There are also plastic particles to consider. In some cases, we are talking about lead, mercury, cadmium, chromium, oil, grease, and so on. Everything on a boat eventually breaks down and ends up scattered everywhere. That is not exactly pleasant for the people who live nearby, and it clearly does nothing to enhance the scenery. If I had paid a lot of money for a beautiful waterfront property, I would certainly not want to end up with a shipwreck nearby. We do not know what is on these vessels and parents might be worried that their children will go and play there and get hurt. I have young children, but I do not have a waterfront home. However, if I did, I would not want my children playing around a shipwreck and getting hurt. My riding is home to the Verchères wharf, which the federal government has abandoned, since it considers it to be a surplus asset. The federal government has not taken care of this infrastructure for 20 years. I am bringing up the Verchères wharf in the context of Bill C-244 and abandoned vessels because there is a response team based there. The team has boats so that it can respond to any spills in the river. Unfortunately, this is the only facility between Montreal and Sorel, or between Montreal and Lake Saint-Pierre, that can intervene if there is a spill in the river. Unfortunately, we know that wrecks can lead to spills. Once again, unfortunately, we have been fighting for years to tell the federal government that it is responsible for the wharf, that essential activities take place there and that the wharf will be needed if there is a spill. In time, once the wharf becomes completely unusable, these boats will no longer be able to dock there. They will have to go somewhere else. Where will they go? We do not know. If there is a spill in the future and they are not able to respond, it will be Ottawa’s fault because it neglected its infrastructure. Consider the state of the Verchères wharf in my riding. Located in the heart of the village, it is meant to be a source of pride and a gathering place. It is, in many ways, the village’s postcard image. For those unfamiliar with Verchères, it is a historic rural community, with homes that are hundreds of years old and built of stone and timber. However, all this beautiful character is ruined by the eyesore left there by the federal government. It is completely neglected, and the local council is constantly raising the matter with Ottawa. Unfortunately, a solution has yet to be found. Every time the matter is brought forward, we are told that the wharf is on the priority list and that perhaps they will get in touch when there is funding available. We have been hearing the same thing for 20 years. We feel as though we are being strung along. We are talking about abandoned boats. I mentioned the Kathryn Spirit. I talked about what is happening back home with the Verchères wharf. What these cases illustrate is a broader pattern of federal neglect in areas that fall squarely within its own jurisdiction. Unfortunately, the federal government should be taking responsibility for these problems. They are its responsibility. It is always quick to lecture the provinces, however. I could also talk about the broader impacts of shipping. Shipping has many benefits, particularly when it comes to trade and economic activity. We would not want ships to stop delivering goods from around the world, nor would we want to lose the ability to export our own products to markets abroad. This has consequences. People sometimes abandon vessels when they reach the end of their useful life. There can be other kinds of consequences, too. People live along the shorelines. Another example from my riding that we have been complaining about to Ottawa for more than 20 years is the impact of shipping on shoreline erosion along the St. Lawrence River. People live alongside these ships, which generate significant economic benefits, but their land is being eroded year after year. The shorelines are receding. Some people are losing several metres every year. There used to be retaining walls and protective structures built by Ottawa, but once again, Ottawa has completely abandoned them. Ottawa is not paying attention to the reality facing the people in my riding. This was clearly illustrated in a story on the Radio-Canada show La facture on November 10. While serving on the Standing Committee on Transport, Infrastructure and Communities, I had the opportunity to table a study calling for this issue to be addressed. The report was debated in the House and ultimately adopted. Among its recommendations was the reinstatement of a shoreline protection program. Despite that, and despite the many petitions submitted by residents of my riding, Ottawa’s response has been a deafening silence. Nothing has been done. People feel that they are not being taken seriously. Nevertheless, I hope that this bill will finally lead to concrete solutions and meaningful action. There are some positive aspects to Bill C-244. For example, it would require a person acquiring ownership of a vessel to formally assume responsibility for it. I believe that is a worthwhile measure and a step in the right direction. However, will it resolve every case of vessel abandonment? I can raise my hand and swear that I will deal with the vessel down the line, but will I actually do it? That remains to be seen. At least this is a starting point, because it does create a moral obligation and require an extra effort to avoid this kind of abandonment. I think the initiative is commendable, but what I would like to see is more concrete action and a real political will to address problems with things that are the federal government’s responsibility. Unfortunately, most of the time, what we see from Ottawa is arrogance and a readiness to steamroll over the constructive work that we are trying to accomplish in this place. I hope that, this time, we will see—”
Mr. Speaker, today we are debating Bill C-244, the clean coasts act. First of all, I want to say that I am thrilled to see a bill like this one being debated in the House, not that I necessarily consider it groundbreaking. I think my colleague who spoke earlier on the matter made the point quite effectively. Indeed, laws alone do not always solve problems. Sometimes what is needed is simply the political will to act and get things done. That is an important point that all of us in this House would do well to keep in mind whenever we are faced with a problem. Nonetheless, I must say that it is refreshing, and I will explain why. Essentially, when private members’ bills are introduced by opposition members, they are often powerful, impactful, with a clear vision. They are designed to make a difference, to really tackle specific issues. Unfortunately, when private members’ bills come from the government benches—and I am not talking about bills introduced by ministers, since ministers are not allowed to introduce private bills—what we usually get are trivial bills that change absolutely nothing. It is as though those members are practically tossing out whatever bill they can come up with, because they lucked out in the draw and have to introduce a bill just for the sake of introducing something. I suspect the whip’s office or the House leader’s office ends up scribbling something on the back of a napkin and telling the member to turn it into a bill. In the case before us today, I do want to acknowledge my colleague’s work, because there is at least a genuine effort here to tackle a real problem, which is a refreshing change. I think it is a shame when Parliament’s time is wasted on completely insignificant issues that are not really issues at all. I commend my colleague opposite. I do not know whether he had to stand up to his party to be able to introduce this common-sense legislation, but I want to commend him for his initiative. We know that, in Canada, there are at least 2,000 abandoned derelict vessels in our waters. I say “at least” because they have not all been documented. Obviously, they can be found up and down our coasts, but some places in Quebec are especially known for their shipwrecks, particularly Charlevoix and the north shore. These wrecks are pretty easy to spot if one is paying attention. In some cases, they have even become a sort of tourist attraction. However, I would not say that every shipwreck is a tourist attraction or that we want more of them in our lakes, rivers and waterways. Quite the contrary, I think that is far from desirable. That reminds me of a specific case. I have been a member of the House since 2015, and I had the opportunity to witness repeated interventions by some of my colleagues who represented the riding that is now known as Vallée‑du‑Haut-Saint-Laurent. They regularly brought up a local wreck known as the Kathryn Spirit. If I am not mistaken, the ship was abandoned around 2011 and was not removed from the water until 2018. It took seven years to finally get the pieces of the wreck out of the St. Lawrence River. I am the member for Montérégie, so it happened in my region. I must say that I was quite upset to see the government sitting on its hands and doing nothing week after week, month after month, year after year. Would Bill C-244 have resolved the Kathryn Spirit case? I cannot say for sure. I would tend to say no. Nevertheless, this is a striking example of a federal government that too often neglects its responsibilities and displays a troubling degree of complacency. I must say that these abandoned ships often leave behind all kinds of debris and damage. We know that the metals they contain gradually leach into the surrounding environment. Rust is an obvious example. They can also become hazards to navigation. On the St. Lawrence River, in my region, we do not really have a choice but to remove them quickly when they are in the middle of the channel because, if we do not, boats can no longer reach Montreal. On the other hand, when they are a little farther out, it seems less urgent because they sometimes stay there longer. These wrecks can have a wide range of impacts. The chemicals they contain can end up in the water we drink and in the food chain. There are also plastic particles to consider. In some cases, we are talking about lead, mercury, cadmium, chromium, oil, grease, and so on. Everything on a boat eventually breaks down and ends up scattered everywhere. That is not exactly pleasant for the people who live nearby, and it clearly does nothing to enhance the scenery. If I had paid a lot of money for a beautiful waterfront property, I would certainly not want to end up with a shipwreck nearby. We do not know what is on these vessels and parents might be worried that their children will go and play there and get hurt. I have young children, but I do not have a waterfront home. However, if I did, I would not want my children playing around a shipwreck and getting hurt. My riding is home to the Verchères wharf, which the federal government has abandoned, since it considers it to be a surplus asset. The federal government has not taken care of this infrastructure for 20 years. I am bringing up the Verchères wharf in the context of Bill C-244 and abandoned vessels because there is a response team based there. The team has boats so that it can respond to any spills in the river. Unfortunately, this is the only facility between Montreal and Sorel, or between Montreal and Lake Saint-Pierre, that can intervene if there is a spill in the river. Unfortunately, we know that wrecks can lead to spills. Once again, unfortunately, we have been fighting for years to tell the federal government that it is responsible for the wharf, that essential activities take place there and that the wharf will be needed if there is a spill. In time, once the wharf becomes completely unusable, these boats will no longer be able to dock there. They will have to go somewhere else. Where will they go? We do not know. If there is a spill in the future and they are not able to respond, it will be Ottawa’s fault because it neglected its infrastructure. Consider the state of the Verchères wharf in my riding. Located in the heart of the village, it is meant to be a source of pride and a gathering place. It is, in many ways, the village’s postcard image. For those unfamiliar with Verchères, it is a historic rural community, with homes that are hundreds of years old and built of stone and timber. However, all this beautiful character is ruined by the eyesore left there by the federal government. It is completely neglected, and the local council is constantly raising the matter with Ottawa. Unfortunately, a solution has yet to be found. Every time the matter is brought forward, we are told that the wharf is on the priority list and that perhaps they will get in touch when there is funding available. We have been hearing the same thing for 20 years. We feel as though we are being strung along. We are talking about abandoned boats. I mentioned the Kathryn Spirit. I talked about what is happening back home with the Verchères wharf. What these cases illustrate is a broader pattern of federal neglect in areas that fall squarely within its own jurisdiction. Unfortunately, the federal government should be taking responsibility for these problems. They are its responsibility. It is always quick to lecture the provinces, however. I could also talk about the broader impacts of shipping. Shipping has many benefits, particularly when it comes to trade and economic activity. We would not want ships to stop delivering goods from around the world, nor would we want to lose the ability to export our own products to markets abroad. This has consequences. People sometimes abandon vessels when they reach the end of their useful life. There can be other kinds of consequences, too. People live along the shorelines. Another example from my riding that we have been complaining about to Ottawa for more than 20 years is the impact of shipping on shoreline erosion along the St. Lawrence River. People live alongside these ships, which generate significant economic benefits, but their land is being eroded year after year. The shorelines are receding. Some people are losing several metres every year. There used to be retaining walls and protective structures built by Ottawa, but once again, Ottawa has completely abandoned them. Ottawa is not paying attention to the reality facing the people in my riding. This was clearly illustrated in a story on the Radio-Canada show La facture on November 10. While serving on the Standing Committee on Transport, Infrastructure and Communities, I had the opportunity to table a study calling for this issue to be addressed. The report was debated in the House and ultimately adopted. Among its recommendations was the reinstatement of a shoreline protection program. Despite that, and despite the many petitions submitted by residents of my riding, Ottawa’s response has been a deafening silence. Nothing has been done. People feel that they are not being taken seriously. Nevertheless, I hope that this bill will finally lead to concrete solutions and meaningful action. There are some positive aspects to Bill C-244. For example, it would require a person acquiring ownership of a vessel to formally assume responsibility for it. I believe that is a worthwhile measure and a step in the right direction. However, will it resolve every case of vessel abandonment? I can raise my hand and swear that I will deal with the vessel down the line, but will I actually do it? That remains to be seen. At least this is a starting point, because it does create a moral obligation and require an extra effort to avoid this kind of abandonment. I think the initiative is commendable, but what I would like to see is more concrete action and a real political will to address problems with things that are the federal government’s responsibility. Unfortunately, most of the time, what we see from Ottawa is arrogance and a readiness to steamroll over the constructive work that we are trying to accomplish in this place. I hope that, this time, we will see—