Translate Politics: Parliament in plain language.

Recent debates 8 latest debates

Natural Resources

During oral questions on natural resources, the Conservatives asked about a $100 million federal loan to Millar Western Forest Products, an American-owned forestry company. Todd Doherty said hundreds of jobs in Quesnel were cut roughly 100 days after the loan was approved, despite the loan agreement requiring an employment plan, and asked whether the finance minister knew the site would close when approving the loan. The Liberal parliamentary secretary said U.S. duties and tariffs have hit the forestry sector hard, pointed to $2.9 billion in announced support plus $6.5 billion in the budget, offered to discuss the specifics with the member later, and said the government would stand with forestry workers.Written by AI from the debate. Updated .

Official text (opens in a new tab)

4 statements

Todd Doherty, Cariboo—Prince George—Omineca

Conservative
“The finance minister gave $100 million to an American-owned forestry company to protect Canadian jobs. Just 100 days later, hundreds of workers in Quesnel lost their jobs anyway. I want a yes or no answer: did the minister know the company was going to close that site when he approved the loan?”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, Millar Western Forest Products is owned by Atlas Holdings, an American private equity firm. In July, the Liberal finance minister gave this company $100 million of taxpayer money to protect Canadian jobs, and just 100 days later, hundreds of jobs were lost in my community of Quesnel. Did the finance minister know that Millar Western was going to shut down its Quesnel operation when he approved the $100 million loan, yes or no?

Corey Hogan, Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Energy and Natural Resources

Liberal
“Unfair American taxes on our wood hurt Canada's forestry industry. We announced $2.9 billion to support the sector last summer and added another $6.5 billion in our budget. I am happy to talk to the member about his specific concerns later.”
  • Government answer in Question Period

    Relevance 45 of 100

    None of this answer addressed the specific question that was asked.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, of course we know the forest sector has been hit very hard by unjustified duties and tariffs from the United States. That is why we have programs that have supported the sector to get through these moments and also transition and pivot to a more prosperous future. There were $2.9 billion in supports announced last summer and we are very happy that the budget brings an additional $6.5 billion to move forward. I am happy to talk to the member about his specific concerns later.

Todd Doherty, Cariboo—Prince George—Omineca

Conservative
“Millar Western got a 100-million-dollar loan with a promise to protect jobs, but it is shutting down just 100 days later. Either the company lied to get the money, or the minister knew it would cost hundreds of jobs in my community. I want the minister to tell us which one happened.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, under the terms of the contract, Millar Western must provide an employment plan, laying out the employment expectations over 24 months, and it is required to adhere to that plan as a condition of the loan agreement. Millar Western is shutting down its operations 100 days after receiving the funds. Someone is not telling the truth. Either Millar Western lied on its application or the minister knew it would kill hundreds of jobs in my community of Quesnel and still gave it the $100 million. Which is it?

Corey Hogan, Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Energy and Natural Resources

Liberal
“We will always support forestry workers in Quesnel and across Canada. I am happy to discuss the details with the member later.”
  • Government answer in Question Period

    Relevance 48 of 100

    None of this answer addressed the specific question that was asked.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, we will stand with the workers in Quesnel as we will stand with forestry workers across the country. As mentioned, I am happy to bring up the specifics with the member at a later date, but we will always fight for the forestry sector and forestry workers in Canada.

Discussion

No comments yet

See the full discussion

Comment rules