“Madam Chair, yes I am, with the member for St. Albert—Sturgeon River. I will just go through the list, because I think the finance minister may not be aware of some of the commitments that he made to Canadians that have since fallen through. At Stellantis in Brampton, the plant laid off 3,000 workers. In fact it took those jobs, sent them to the U.S. and promised 5,000 jobs in the U.S. and $13 billion of U.S. investment, despite hundreds of millions of dollars flowing from the taxpayers through the Liberal government to retool Stellantis’s facility in Brampton. Northvolt in Quebec went bankrupt despite up to $3 billion of commitments from the taxpayer through the Liberal government. Ford in Oakville, despite millions of taxpayer dollars spent, cancelled its project and is now making gas-powered trucks. With Umicore for EV batteries in Loyalist Township, Ontario, millions of taxpayer dollars were spent, and the project was delayed indefinitely. GM POSCO in Quebec is an EV battery plant. Phase 2 is now delayed despite well over $126 million from the taxpayer being spent. GM’s CAMI facility is in Oshawa with $244 million from the taxpayer. Their BrightDrop EV project was shelved. Of course, Honda just recently suspended indefinitely a $15-billion electric vehicle project in Ontario, citing issues with global EV demand. The Liberals’ cornerstone, the NextStar Energy facility that was supposed to build and be a world leader in electric car batteries, is no longer making EV batteries. In fact, the auto company involved with that, Stellantis, has pulled out altogether. I will just ask the minister again if he feels his promises are being delivered on an electric vehicle supply chain in Canada?”
Statement grade
B–
The average of Signal, Relevance, Respect and Clarity is 85. The grade is held to 70, 30 above Signal.
70 / 100, held down by Signal
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Positioning 46%Claims 45%Thanks 9%
This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Madam Chair, Positioning · 28 wordsI am so happy to have that line of questioning.I almost hope that time would stop for a minute, because honestly, I could go on and on.PositioningClaims · 57 wordsLet us talk about Volkswagen, one of the largest automakers when we landed the gigafactory.It is the largest gigafactory outside of Europe of Volkswagen.1In which country did they decide to put it?It was in Canada.2It is amazing that, for the first time in Canada’s history, we have attracted a European automaker to Canada.3Positioning · 31 wordsI see in her smile that the member knows in her heart that we have done good things for the workers and that we have done good things for the industry.PositioningThanks · 12 wordsShe is a good member.She is experienced.She will appreciate that—Thanks