Yves Perron

Mr. Speaker, Positioning · 13 wordsI would like to say that we are rather disappointed with Bill C-31.Positioning Claims · 92 wordsWe are disappointed because neither the implementation bill nor the economic update really take into account the current tariff crisis. This serious crisis is affecting businesses in general, but, once again, it has been particularly hard on businesses in Quebec, where these tariffs apply to one-quarter of exports.⁷ Smaller businesses have been particularly hard hit. That is something else that makes Quebec unique.Partly on point When I say that the country of Quebec already exists, I mean that there are already structural differences between Quebec and Canada.Off point Quebec’s economy is made up of SMEs, Reasoning · 35 wordsand they need support. They need a government that is there for them and that tells them that we are going through a tough time because our neighbours to the south have an unpredictable president. Claims · 9 wordsNo one here knows what he will do next. Reasoning · 21 wordsThere is nothing worse for the economy and for our businesses than uncertainty, so we have to be there for them, Claims · 16 wordsbut the government is not taking serious action. Then, the Bloc Québécois put forward 11 requests. Reasoning · 6 wordsThat may seem like a lot, Positioning · 5 wordsbut they are reasonable requests.Positioning Claims · 8 wordsWe wanted to put them up for discussion. Positioning · 63 wordsEver since I arrived here in 2019, the Bloc Québécois has been an intelligent and constructive opposition. In fact, it is in the Bloc Québécois’s DNA to work that way. We are not here to obstruct everything, despite what some may think or say. We are here to move things forward for the common good, at least for the time being, of course, PositioningPartly on pointClaims · 8 wordsbecause our ultimate goal remains achieving Quebec’s independence. Positioning · 23 wordsIn our day-to-day work here, we are well aware that time is of the essence and that our goal is far from unrealistic.Positioning Reasoning · 22 wordsIt is essential to the full and comprehensive development of our society, in accordance with its values and, above all, its priorities. Positioning · 22 wordsIt is not that Canada is not a beautiful country. That is not the issue, and this is not directed against Canada.Positioning Reasoning · 14 wordsIt is really about our own development according to our own choices and priorities. Claims · 59 wordsThis will certainly be done in partnership with Canada, since Canada will always be an important neighbour.Off point However, we are in Parliament and we have made proposals. We asked our colleagues to look at them and we have not even received a call. There has not even been 12 seconds of consultation. Things were different a few months ago.Partly on point Procedure · 1 wordsHowever, ProcedureClaims · 24 wordsbecause of some backroom deals, people crossed the floor and the government built itself a majority. Once it had a majority, consultation was over. Positioning · 6 wordsThe government talks a good game.Positioning Claims · 40 wordsThey say that they will continue to work in the common interest and listen to opposition parties, and so on.Partly on point In fact, the reality is that we get bills like C‑31, for which we did some serious work early on.Unearned certainty Positioning · 11 wordsThat is probably the most insulting part of all of this.Positioning Claims · 44 wordsIt is not as though we did not bother to work or as though we just spouted some populist rhetoric and said that the government is bad or rotten. We analyzed the situation. We have a team of researchers and a team of MPs. Positioning · 6 wordsWe are serious. We are dedicated.Positioning Claims · 85 wordsWe came up with real proposals. I get the feeling that the government did not even bother to read them. Of course, we fully expected that some of our proposals would be rejected, such as the idea to reimburse Quebeckers for the money that was stolen from us and used to buy Liberal votes in the last election. We included that out of principle, to make sure no one forgets. We honestly do not understand why this is not generating more reaction in the media.Partly on point Reasoning · 17 wordsThat said, it seems to me that the government should have considered some of the other proposals. Claims · 25 wordsAfter all, it claims to be reasonable. Bill C-31 is a major, complex bill that is several hundred pages long and that contains numerous amendments.² Procedure · 2 wordsOnce again, ProcedureClaims · 67 wordsand this sums up the essence of my speech this morning, the Bloc leader’s office requested, in good faith and in a constructive way, a briefing session on the subtleties and specific features of the bill.³ We waited more than three weeks before that briefing was held. It took place this week. At the same time, we are expected to pass this bill as soon as possible. Promise · 7 wordsThe answer is going to be no. Reasoning · 28 wordsWe cannot hand over a blank cheque for such important, large-scale measures while the government continues to expand its subsidies to the oil and gas industry, for example. Procedure · 3 wordsEnough is enough.Procedure The ask · 7 wordsLet us be serious and work together. Claims · 38 wordsThis government has three years left, if it manages to hold on to its majority.Partly on point People may get fed up, like the former environment minister, the member for Laurier—Sainte-Marie, who announced this week that he is leaving politics.⁹ Positioning · 33 wordsNow that is really something, forcing someone like him to leave politics.Off point That means that the Liberals have pushed things too far when it comes to the highly polluting oil from the west.Positioning Procedure · 7 wordsThat is also part of the issue.Procedure Claims · 28 wordsReturning to today’s topic, the bill proposes to once again expand oil and gas industry subsidies.⁴ We requested a briefing to ensure that we properly understood the bill, Positioning · 80 wordsbut since the Liberals won a majority, the government seems to scorn us. They seem to have no need for a group of MPs that want Quebec to become independent. They seem no longer interested in even talking to us, now that they can vote as a majority and pass bills as fast as they please. Is that democracy? Has the government now decided to administer things at lightning speed? Let us just say that we do not like it.PositioningPartly on point Claims · 43 wordsFurthermore, based on our initial interpretation, considering the limited time we were given and the information we received, Bill C-31 opens the door to increased government powers and less transparency. We also see that the system for processing air traveller complaints has changed.⁵ Positioning · 20 wordsThe government appears to be trying to sweep that issue under the rug. We are deeply concerned about travellers’ rights.Positioning Claims · 26 wordsThe government says it wants to take a different approach by having these complaints handled not by the Canadian Transportation Agency, ⁶but by a private firm. Procedure · 2 wordsOnce again, ProcedureClaims · 60 wordsand I will repeat this several times in my speech to make sure that the government hears me, we were not given a proper explanation and we were not given the opportunity to carefully examine the provisions of this bill. As we understand it, we could end up with private companies working for the airlines to quickly resolve passengers’ complaints. Positioning · 13 wordsNow passengers can be treated with contempt by those companies too. Why not?Positioning Claims · 9 wordsThat is already the way things have been going. Positioning · 3 wordsIt is unfortunate, PositioningPartly on pointPromise · 18 wordsbut for all of these reasons, I have to announce that we will be voting against this bill.¹ Procedure · 19 wordsBefore I close, I want to mention a few of the constructive proposals put forward by the Bloc Québécois.Procedure The ask · 10 wordsFor one, the government needs to stop subsidizing big oil. Claims · 6 wordsOil companies are making exorbitant profits. Reasoning · 20 wordsWhen the government makes the mistake of removing a tax, it does not take long for the benefits to disappear. Claims · 14 wordsWe saw this with the suspension of the excise tax and the 10¢ rebate. Positioning · 12 wordsHow many years has the Bloc Québécois been repeating the same message?Positioning Reasoning · 22 wordsIf the government removes a tax, then this greedy sector will fill that void and put the money in its own pockets. Claims · 4 wordsThat is what happened. Reasoning · 12 wordsIf the government removes another tax, then the same thing will happen. Claims · 34 wordsThe oil companies will wait a few weeks and then they will do it subtly on some pretext about what is happening abroad. At the end of the day, they will pocket the money. The ask · 4 wordsEnough with the subsidies. Reasoning · 13 wordsThere are other things we could be doing with those billions of dollars. Claims · 71 wordsTake SME wage subsidy programs, for example. They play a vital and important role in maintaining the economic fabric of our regions. However, they are not being used. As for the EI reform, it makes no sense for an EI system to cover only about 60% of its contributors.⁸ It means that 40% of people contributing to the plan are throwing money out the window and will never qualify for benefits. Positioning · 9 wordsWe cannot accept that. It constitutes a serious injustice.Positioning Claims · 11 wordsWe could talk about the spring gap that seasonal workers face. Procedure · 9 wordsThere are lots of things we could talk about.Procedure The ask · 30 wordsWe need meaningful measures for our media, the reinstatement of the digital services tax and the reinstatement of labour tax credits. The federal government must listen to the opposition parties. Positioning · 24 wordsWe are not here to block everything. We are here to contribute our opinion, to share Quebec’s take on situations and to work constructively.PositioningPartly on point Procedure · 7 wordsI am sending the government a message.Procedure Promise · 22 wordsIf it wants us to vote in favour of a future bill, it will have to get serious and respect opposition MPs, Reasoning · 9 wordsbecause just like Liberal MPs, they too were elected.Partly on point