Andréanne Larouche

Claims · 42 wordsThis is the third time I have talked about this bill, though I am not a member of the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights.¹ This bill ended up being extensively discussed by the Standing Committee on the Status of Women.² Procedure · 8 wordsI have already talked about it a lot.Procedure Promise · 36 wordsI may come back to Bill C‑16, but I also want to use my speech to talk about the fact that protecting women also requires better housing and local services. I will come back to that. Claims · 38 wordsThe Bloc Québécois obviously supports the principle of Bill C‑16, which contains a number of important improvements for better protecting victims of violence. In particular, it recognizes coercive control.³ It strengthens certain victims’ rights and modernizes criminal law. Procedure · 5 wordsHowever, one fundamental question remains: ProcedurePositioning · 15 wordsCan a woman be truly safe if she has nowhere to go after escaping violence?Positioning Reasoning · 3 wordsJustice is essential, Claims · 14 wordsbut our committee also heard over and over that justice alone is not enough. Procedure · 34 wordsI will begin by talking about the housing issue. I will then move on to the improvements that Bill C‑16 contains. I will close by talking about what makes Quebec different in this domain.Procedure Claims · 176 wordsA woman fleeing violence first needs a place to live. Behind every criminal record and every case file is a woman who has made the extremely difficult decision to leave her abuser. This decision often means giving up her home, leaving her job, uprooting her children and losing her financial security. Without a housing solution, many women remain trapped in their situations. What we heard at committee from survivors is that shelters are more than just places of refuge. The evidence we heard at the Standing Committee on the Status of Women served as a reminder of this. Shelters are true places of recovery. They provide shelter, psychosocial support, legal assistance, financial aid, support for children and assistance in building autonomy. For many women, it is the first night in a long time that they can sleep without fearing for their lives or those of their loved ones. Housing is also a public safety issue. A woman who leaves an abusive partner often has to choose between returning to her abuser or living in precarious conditions. Positioning · 4 wordsIt is absolutely terrible.Positioning Claims · 8 wordsShe has to wait months for affordable housing. Reasoning · 15 wordsAs long as this reality persists, no reform of the Criminal Code will be enough. Procedure · 5 wordsI have some telling statistics.Procedure Claims · 114 wordsIn 2024-25, Canada had approximately 561 residential shelters for victims of violence.⁴ Despite this, officials still identify the lack of affordable housing as one of the main obstacles to a sustainable escape from violence. Research shows that women who have access to second-stage housing are much more likely to rebuild their lives and avoid returning to their abuser. Sexual violence remains vastly under-reported. In fact, nearly nine out of 10 sexual assaults are never reported to the police.⁵ In 2024, 81 women were killed by an intimate partner in Canada, including 25 in Quebec.⁶ There have already been 10 femicides in 2026.⁷ One of the first occurred in Rougemont, in the riding of Shefford.⁸ Procedure · 31 wordsI also mentioned coercive control. I would like to talk about some of the progress this bill will achieve after first discussing the importance of offering abused women more extensive help.Procedure Claims · 19 wordsTackling coercive control is an important step forward. The Bloc Québécois welcomes the creation of a coercive control offence. Reasoning · 4 wordsThis recognition is essential. Claims · 80 wordsIt follows on a study that the Standing Committee on the Status of Women did on my suggestion following a request by the Quebec National Assembly and members who had worked on a report on rebuilding trust.⁹ However, Ottawa did not budge. Late last year, after a number of years went by, the Standing Committee on the Status of Women held a press conference pointing out that one of the main recommendations in my report was to criminalize coercive control.¹⁰ Reasoning · 4 wordsThis recognition is essential. Claims · 48 wordsViolence does not always leave visible wounds. The wounds can also be psychological, economic, social, digital or emotional. Financial dependence is often an integral part of this type of control. Even under the best laws, a woman who cannot afford housing or food for her children remains vulnerable. The ask · 9 wordsWe absolutely need to work toward women’s economic empowerment, Reasoning · 27 wordsbecause we cannot break the cycle of domestic violence if a woman, even after years of trying, cannot accumulate the financial resources needed to escape that violence. Positioning · 10 wordsShe remains trapped in a cycle, in an endless spiral, PositioningClaims · 20 wordswhere the man, to meet his own needs and expectations and to control his victim, exerts financial control over her. The ask · 20 wordsWe must also consider women’s economic empowerment and ways to ensure women can fully take control of their financial lives. Claims · 71 wordsAnother point that came up during the testimonies before the Standing Committee on the Status of Women is that we cannot overlook older women. Coercive control also affects older adults. What is concerning is that some women endure violence perpetrated by a spouse, a caregiver, or even an adult child. Data also show that there has been a significant increase in cases of domestic violence against older adults in recent years. The ask · 10 wordsThe system must be able to recognize these specific realities. Procedure · 14 wordsI also want to talk about the importance of respecting Quebec’s areas of jurisdiction, ProcedureClaims · 11 wordsbecause social services, shelters and housing fall primarily under Quebec’s jurisdiction. Procedure · 5 wordsLet us not forget that.Procedure The ask · 13 wordsThe federal government must financially support these networks without imposing its own conditions. Claims · 15 wordsQuebec organizations are familiar with the realities on the ground and already meeting victims’ needs. Reasoning · 19 wordsIt is therefore important to look at what is being transferred to help the organizations that work with victims. Claims · 3 wordsStaff are exhausted, The ask · 15 wordsand they need resources and means to care for these victims and care for survivors. Claims · 167 wordsBill C‑16 is not perfect, so the Bloc Québécois had moved some amendments, particularly regarding section 810 of the Criminal Code, ¹¹which is still far too subjective. At the Standing Committee on the Status of Women, I moved, in collaboration with my Conservative colleagues, that we conduct a study of section 810 of the Criminal Code.¹² The Bloc Québécois wanted to take that aspect out of Bill C‑16, because it has been proven that section 810 conditions can give victims a false sense of security. We moved amendments, and there are some amendments that could have been made to Bill C‑16. However, our chief concern is that the Criminal Code be strengthened and that new offences be created. The Criminal Code is a federal law, however, whereas the application and administration of justice are the responsibility of Quebec and the provinces. I said that to the Minister of Women and Gender Equality yesterday, ¹³and I asked her to discuss it with her colleague, the Minister of Justice. Reasoning · 48 wordsIf the government does not arrange for money to be transferred to Quebec for the administration of justice, in acknowledgement of the fact that a much bigger burden is going to be placed on Quebec’s justice system, it is going to be passing laws that cannot be enforced. Claims · 31 wordsThere will not be enough resources to take care of victims and survivors properly. In conclusion, the Bloc Québécois will support Bill C‑16. It is a real step forward for victims. Reasoning · 22 wordsHowever, we must guard against believing that the Criminal Code can fix everything and that it is some kind of magic wand. Claims · 18 wordsA woman needs effective justice, safe housing, a bed in a shelter, adequate income and quality psychosocial support. Promise · 32 wordsAs I told the minister yesterday, the Bloc Québécois will be here to make sure nobody forgets the amendments our party put forward at the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights.¹⁴Vague promise Reasoning · 40 wordsThe best way to protect women is not only to punish abusers, but also to give victims the practical means to get away and rebuild their lives with dignity. We owe them that because there must be no more victims.