Analysis · Floor speech · beta

Gord Johns

598 words · 37 sentences · 43 clauses

Statement grade
A+
Average 97 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Anecdote 2%Claims 70%Positioning 3%Procedure 2%Reasoning 20%The ask 4%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. Speaker, Anecdote · 11 wordshere I am again, tonight, at the hour of 12:14 a.m.Anecdote Claims · 26 wordsFair ferry funding is a critical issue to Vancouver Islanders and to coastal British Columbians. It is such a serious issue that it cannot go unanswered. Positioning · 18 wordsI am sure that the Liberals were hoping I would not show up tonight, but here I am.Positioning Claims · 107 wordsI am here because ferry affordability, economic competitiveness and transportation equity matter to the nearly one million people who call Vancouver Island home and to the coastal communities that depend on BC Ferries every day. For many of my constituents, BC Ferries is not just a convenience; it is a necessity. It is a critical transportation link connecting people to work, health care, education, family and economic opportunity. The Liberal government recognizes ferries as essential transportation infrastructure in Atlantic Canada, but it continues to treat British Columbia differently. Last July, the Prime Minister announced a 50% reduction in fares on federally supported ferry routes in Atlantic Canada.1 Procedure · 6 wordsThat decision recognized an important reality.Procedure Reasoning · 18 wordsFerry affordability matters because ferry transportation is essential infrastructure when we have the longest coastline in the world.2 Claims · 5 wordsI agree with that funding. Reasoning · 13 wordsThe question is why the same principle does not apply to British Columbia. Claims · 156 wordsThe people of B.C. pay the same federal taxes as Canadians living in Atlantic Canada, yet when it comes to ferry funding, we receive dramatically different levels of support. BC Ferries is one of the largest ferry systems in the world.3 It operates 25 routes, serves approximately 1,600 kilometres of coastline, maintains 47 terminals, operates a fleet of 37 vessels and carries more than 22 million passengers a year.4 According to the Library of Parliament, federal operational funding accounts for approximately 3% of BC Ferries’ operating revenues.5 By comparison, federal funding covers approximately 43% of operating costs for federally supported ferry services in Atlantic Canada.6 This disparity is also evident on a per capita basis. British Columbians receive approximately five to six dollars per person in federal operational ferry support, 7while Atlantic Canadians receive approximately $125 per person.8 These numbers reveal a significant imbalance in how the federal government supports essential transportation infrastructure across the country. Procedure · 4 wordsLet me be clear.Procedure Reasoning · 19 wordsThis is not an argument against supporting Atlantic Canada. I support those investments. This is an argument for fairness. Claims · 127 wordsB.C. is currently in the midst of a ferry fare review.9 It is around their services. BC Ferries has warned that without additional funding, customers could face fare increases of more than 30% over the coming years.10 Reductions in services could also happen, or both. At a time when Canadians are struggling with the cost of living, that prospect should concern every member in the House, especially coastal MPs from B.C. The current funding framework is rooted in historical arrangements developed decades ago, when Vancouver Island had roughly half its current population.11 Today, Vancouver Island is approaching a million residents and is comparable to the size of New Zealand’s South Island.12 It is home to a major regional economy that depends on reliable and affordable ferry transportation. Reasoning · 67 wordsIf the current model no longer reflects the realities of modern Canada, then it is time for a review and a modification to fix this agreement. Vancouver Islanders and coastal people in B.C. should not have to become a province to qualify for fair federal support for essential transportation infrastructure from the federal government. If ferry affordability matters in Atlantic Canada, it should matter in British Columbia. The ask · 21 wordsI am calling for a real response tonight from the federal government. We need to see action for coastal British Columbians.

Analysed on