This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Mr. Speaker, Thanks · 32 wordsbefore I begin, allow me to acknowledge the work of the firefighters from Lac-Mégantic, Nantes, Lac-Drolet and Audet, who yesterday fought a fire that devastated an apartment block near Lac-Mégantic town centre.1Thanks Claims · 35 wordsSeveral residents were impacted and lost their homes, and the Red Cross is there to support them. Fortunately, no one was injured thanks to the support and assistance of everyone living in the surrounding area. Thanks · 9 wordsOnce again, I would like to thank the firefighters.Thanks Reasoning · 45 wordsCanadians do not judge a government by the number of announcements or programs it creates. They judge it by what is left in their pockets, by their ability to put food on the table and to look to the future with a little more confidence. Claims · 13 wordsToday, too many families are telling us that life is becoming increasingly difficult. Promise · 38 wordsIt is time to save Canadian families money. It is time to protect Canadians’ jobs. It is time to ensure their safety. It is time to fix our immigration system. It is time to put Canada first again. The ask · 20 wordsThis is exactly the Conservative plan we are proposing to Canadians and that we are asking the government to support. Claims · 157 wordsIn the House this week, I talked about Jessy, who lives in Notre-Dame-de-Lourdes. Not very long ago, she was spending about $120 a week on groceries. Now they cost her about $170 a week. That amounts to $50 more a week, every week. Jessy does not measure the Canadian economy based on numbers, statistics or how many programs the government announces, and certainly not based on the number of press conferences, symposia or speeches that the Prime Minister delivers in foreign countries. She measures it by how much she has when she gets to the grocery store checkout, and how much is left to pay for everything else. Obviously, she is not alone. We also spoke in the House this week about Olesya, who has to use her credit card to pay rent and feed her family. We talked about Chantal, a single mother in Saint‑Georges who works full-time but still needs to use a food bank. Reasoning · 149 wordsThat reality, their reality, is what should guide us here, in the House, with every decision we make.Off point That is why Bill C-39, before us today, deserves our serious consideration. I hear the government members asking what the connection is between Bill C-39 and Jessy’s grocery bill, since Bill C-39 deals with environmental assessments, major projects, permits and federal regulations. However, there is a very simple and very real connection. An economy that can attract investment, carry out major projects and create good jobs provides more opportunities for families and workers. On the other hand, when a project remains stalled for years in a process where no one knows when a decision will be made, the uncertainty ends up costing everyone: the businesses that are waiting for the decision, the workers who are waiting for jobs and the regions who are waiting for the economic benefits of those projects. Claims · 33 wordsWe have heard this song from the government before, when it told us that it wanted to fast-track major projects. Eighteen months ago, we were asked to pass Bill C-5 in a rush.2 Reasoning · 5 wordsWhat was the bill’s purpose? Claims · 44 wordsIt was meant to decide exactly which major projects could be fast-tracked, because the Prime Minister had said when he was elected that the government was going to move faster than ever before. Acting in good faith, the Conservatives supported the Liberals’ Bill C‑5.3 Positioning · 31 wordsActing in good faith, we figured that, considering the circumstances and the tariff war with the United States, we should do our part, set partisanship aside, collaborate and put Canada first.Positioning Claims · 20 wordsWe believed that the Liberals really wanted to move fast, do better and, above all, get major projects going again. Positioning · 11 wordsWe are a little disappointed, very disappointed even, with the outcome.Positioning Claims · 48 wordsEighteen months on, there are no new major projects and no new shovels in the ground to get them built. We have not seen any new projects to ensure our independence from the U.S. We are therefore a little skeptical. Today, the government is focusing on Bill C‑39. Reasoning · 5 wordsWhat does this bill add? Claims · 29 wordsIt adds a new word to the title. It also adds a few hundred pages to show how badly the government dropped the ball when it introduced Bill C‑5.4 Procedure · 4 wordsThat is the reality.ProcedureUnearned certainty Claims · 109 wordsBill C‑5 did not do what it was supposed to do, so here we are, 18 months later, with Bill C‑39. The purpose of the bill is to speed up projects and make everything faster. For example, the government wants each project to have a single assessment and it wants projects to be carried out within one year.5 The bill also amends certain laws, including the Canada Labour Code.6 Over the past 18 months, we have seen announcement after announcement. Some projects have been announced. There have been lists of projects, but none of them have been fully completed. Most of the announcements have been about new government structures. Reasoning · 56 wordsAnnouncing a project or a bill and actually setting it in motion or implementing it are two different things. A company planning to invest millions or billions of dollars in Canada needs to know what rules it will be subject to, who will make the decision and, above all, how long it will have to wait. Claims · 9 wordsAccording to Bill C-39, it will take a year. Reasoning · 30 wordsA year from when? Does a year mean 12 consecutive months without a single day’s break, or is it a year with breaks to allow the government to catch up? Positioning · 10 wordsThe private sector moves quickly. The Liberal government is slow.Positioning Claims · 49 wordsThrough Bill C-39, the government has given itself the option to pause the clock during the one year in which everything is supposed to take place.7 According to Bill C-39, the clock starts ticking once the company has completed all the studies required for the submission of its project.8 Reasoning · 60 wordsCarrying out the studies required for the project’s submission means carrying out the studies that the government will ask it to carry out. If the government asks questions and demands study after study to avoid having to start the clock for a year, it is the company that will end up taking all that time to carry out the project. The ask · 14 wordsIt is important that we get more explanations and more information about Bill C-39. Positioning · 39 wordsThe devil is in the details when it comes to figuring out whether the government is serious or whether it is merely posturing or grandstanding, claiming that it is taking care of business when nothing is actually getting done.Positioning Promise · 30 wordsWe want to get everything in place as quickly as possible. We want projects. We want to make Canada more independent and more self-reliant. We want to get projects built. Claims · 47 wordsThere are over 500 projects in the queue that could be built right now.9 Unfortunately, the government has wasted 18 months since Bill C-5 passed, and these projects are still just ideas in the minds of business leaders. We will be lucky if they are still around, Reasoning · 14 wordsbecause the crisis is getting worse and investors may be less keen to invest. Claims · 39 wordsA company in my riding had to adopt job sharing as of yesterday.10 Because of the tariff war and the countertariffs, this company has to pay between $500,000 and $1 million a week in cash just to stay afloat. Reasoning · 21 wordsI do not think this is the time to be asking it to use its cash reserves to invest in Canada. Claims · 13 wordsThat is the result of 18 months of inaction by the Liberal government.Partly on point Promise · 49 wordsWe are going to closely monitor the committee’s study of Bill C-39. We will see if jobs are being created and if businesses are investing. Above all, we will see if Jessy will have more money in her pocket to pay for groceries at the end of the month. Reasoning · 76 wordsWhat matters most is that women like Jessy, from Notre-Dame-de-Lourdes, or Chantal, from Beauce, have more money and are able to make ends meet. They want hope, hope that they will be able to keep living the life Canada once promised, that is, a life where they can live on a safe street with enough money to pay their bills at the end of the month. Canadians do not want more announcements. Canadians want real results.Off point
Analysed on