Analysis · Debate question · beta

Eric St-Pierre

44 words · 2 sentences · 2 clauses

Following a speech by Patrick Bonin (Bloc Québécois)
“Mr. Speaker, I have taken a close look at the budget, and today I want to demonstrate that, despite the Liberals’ claims, this is anything but a green budget. Essentially, we are hearing a lot about the electrification of transportation. We support that, of course. We are also hearing about electrification more broadly, and we support that as well. However, in reality, the much-touted $50 billion that the government claims to be investing in electrification amounts to just $2.4 billion by 2030. A closer look shows that this $2.4 billion will be used to expand gas production in Canada and generate more electricity from that gas. The government has said so itself. Mega data centres are popping up everywhere and they represent an opportunity for the government to sell more gas. In fact, it is an opportunity for businesses, as private companies stand to benefit from those revenues. The government is handing out billions of dollars in subsidies to these companies, so the electricity it keeps talking about may be anything but clean. There will also be money to help companies that use natural gas to generate electricity capture and sequester their energy. That is not all. The government also plans to invest nearly $6 billion in fuel cell development. What are fuel cells? Essentially, energy is generated using natural gas and stored in batteries or the like. Here again, the government is directly subsidizing natural gas and electricity that is hardly clean. In contrast, I would remind the House that Quebec has developed its own renewable electricity sector over the years without a penny from the federal government. Let us not forget that the money being invested in electricity also includes funding for nuclear power. The budget actually allocates $3 billion to support nuclear exports, much of which, as we know, has been publicly funded and, I would remind the House, is causing problems, particularly with respect to waste. The government has chosen to store this waste on the banks of the Ottawa River, even though more than 100 municipalities in Quebec and the Kebaowek First Nation oppose this project. It poses a significant risk of spillage into the Ottawa River, which supplies nearly three million Quebeckers, including many in and around Montreal. The government talks about electrification, yet its budget includes some $22 million for watering down the clean electricity regulations. This means that in addition to investing time and money in advance to develop green electricity regulations, it is spending even more to weaken its own regulations in order to produce more electricity with gas and place fewer restrictions on businesses. Worse still, the government is even going to let these businesses offset their emissions. We are not entirely sure how, but the government is going to change the regulations to place fewer demands on them. Of course, the government will say that we still have heat pumps. Heat pumps are a good thing, but let us not lose perspective. First of all, this is a federal program funded with federal dollars, whereas Hydro-Québec already has programs. Instead, that money should be handed over to Hydro-Québec to be used as it sees fit to manage and improve energy efficiency, building performance and electrification performance. The federal government has no business saying that it is going to create a program on top of Hydro-Québec’s program, that people will have two programs and that it is investing $2 billion in that. Let us put that $2 billion into perspective. This is indeed welcome money that should go to Quebec, but let us compare that to the $43 billion the government is going to spend on a pipeline using Canadians’ and Quebeckers’ money. I think comparing that $2 billion to $43 billion puts into perspective the importance this government attaches to oil and gas compared to the fight against climate change. Of course, the government will also point out that it is investing in the electrification of transportation. Yes, the electrification of transportation is the best way, both economically and environmentally, to move away from oil, especially in Quebec, where we import nearly 13 billion dollars’ worth of oil and send it elsewhere, much of it to Alberta. However, let us look at what it is proposing for the electrification of transportation, specifically roughly $587 million for charging stations. Of these charging stations, 16% will go to Quebec. Quebec will get only 16% of these charging stations, even though about 50% of Canada’s electric vehicles have been sold there. Why? It is because we in Quebec have already made an effort to electrify our transportation. We have already installed charging stations across our nation. We need to keep doing that, but this government is not recognizing the efforts we have already made. It says it wants to electrify transportation, but in reality, aside from adding charging stations, that is not what the government is doing. It recently repealed the zero-emissions vehicle mandate. That mandate required manufacturers to produce and sell more electric vehicles. It gave people access to more vehicles, including cheaper, smaller ones that consume less electricity and cost less. Now, the government has decided to completely eliminate this zero-emissions mandate. It is going to install charging stations, but people are struggling to find vehicles, especially affordable ones. Why is that? It is because Canadian automakers are pretty much the worst in the world when it comes to electrification. In terms of electric vehicle production, they are so far behind Europe and China that they are putting up barriers and blocking electrification. The automakers asked the government to remove these barriers because they were impeding their growth. Obviously, they are just about the worst on the planet. Canada’s vehicle fleet is the worst in the world in terms of size and efficiency. To change that, we need to put pressure on manufacturers, but the government is doing exactly the opposite. On the one hand, it says it wants to electrify transportation, but on the other, it is scrapping its zero-emissions mandate. It gets worse. There were also regulations on greenhouse gas emissions standards for light-duty vehicles that forced manufacturers to develop more fuel-efficient vehicles. What did the government do? It said it was going to freeze those standards. This means that Canadian manufacturers and their lobby have once again managed to get the government to make concessions, which means that no additional effort is being required from manufacturers until 2030. They will not be required to improve the fuel efficiency of their vehicles until 2030. This means that, once again, it will cost taxpayers and Quebeckers more, since they will have to fill up at the pump with vehicles that use more gas. They will have no other choice, because the government has backed down on the issue of EVs. Worse still, the government is blocking the entry of European EVs into Canada and Quebec. In Europe, there are small and inexpensive EVs, but the government is blocking them for safety and other reasons, even though these vehicles can be driven in Europe, Mexico and other places. Why do we not have access to these vehicles? The government should answer that question, but it is clear that the budget has nothing to say on this matter. I talked about the $43 billion in public funds, if not more, for a pipeline. Public funds are being used because the companies involved, those poor little oil companies, do not want to invest in it themselves. Who are the principal owners of Canada’s oil and gas companies? Americans, for the most part. American shareholders are the ones who will benefit from this subsidy. We are talking about an investment of at least $43 billion in public money. In its budget, the government confirmed that it intends to scale back the industrial carbon tax. Apparently a carbon price of 25¢ per barrel of oil is too much for these corporations. This is what the government is calling a green budget: a mega deduction for liquefied natural gas projects to further accelerate the production and export of natural gas. There is no money for adaptation measures, for example. We are paying the cost of climate change, but there is no money to help the provinces or municipalities. There is no more money for public transit. In fact, the government cut $5 billion in the last budget. However, there is money for oil and gas exploration in the Arctic. It is taking advantage of the melting ice pack and climate change to say that it is going to extract even more fossil fuels. It is indecent. In closing, I want to say that the commissioner of the environment and sustainable development was very clear: Canada will not meet the Paris Agreement targets. The government claims that its budget is going to help, but that is not true. The government has been criticized on the world stage by two former ministers, who have accused it of saying the opposite of the truth. I will say it very clearly. It is obvious that this government is engaging in greenwashing with this budget, as it has been doing since it came to power.”
Statement grade
–
Not graded
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Claims 41%The question 59%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. Speaker, Claims · 18 wordsmy colleague, the member for Repentigny, mentioned our subsidies for electric cars or charging stations for electric cars. The question · 26 wordsCould my colleague tell me whether the residents of his riding of Repentigny would be in favour of or against additional charging stations for electric cars?

Analysed on