Analysis · Floor speech · beta

Mel Arnold

457 words · 20 sentences · 26 clauses

Statement grade
A
Average 93 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Claims 68%Reasoning 5%Positioning 16%Procedure 1%The question 9%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. Speaker, Claims · 77 wordson October 30 I asked the Liberal government to adopt our Conservative plan to lower grocery store costs by scrapping all federal taxes on diesel sales until at least Canada Day 2027.1 I emphasized that Food Banks Canada reported 2.3 million food bank visits in March of this year alone, 2and Liberal inflation has only made things worse since that report was released. In Salmon Arm, my hometown, the food bank now serves 500 clients per month.3 Reasoning · 25 wordsBecause many of these are families, 7% to 10% of our small city could be relying on the food bank to meet basic dietary needs.4 Claims · 38 wordsOther small towns and cities, like Golden, B.C., have seen up to a 500% increase in food bank reliance.5 Working families are visiting food banks in increasing numbers because wages have not kept up to rising Liberal inflation. Positioning · 16 wordsThis is a failure of the government to rein in inflation-causing, wasteful government spending and deficits.Positioning Claims · 110 wordsThe minister’s response that day in October suggested that Canadians should be grateful for the government programs that return the same tax money the government took from them in the first place. Fuel costs are also crippling small businesses. Last week, I spoke to a young couple who run a small logging company, employing five people.6 They are unsure how much longer they can continue with fuel costs the way they are. Their fuel costs have almost tripled over the last five years and are now reaching $33,000 per month for a small operation with five people.7 The government is reaping huge benefits from increased fuel costs and the taxes, Positioning · 43 wordsbut instead of providing immediate relief to small businesses and consumers, the Liberals keep the fuel taxes in place, run the profits through the bureaucracy, and buy votes with cheques to the very people they took the money from in the first place.Positioning Claims · 19 wordsSince October 30, the government has introduced a new budget that would add a record-smashing $765 billion in deficit.8 Procedure · 6 wordsThat is billion, with a B.Procedure Claims · 31 wordsThis Liberal plan will make an average family of four pay almost $6,000 in federal debt interest costs alone this year, 9while driving up the cost of food, fuel and housing. Positioning · 12 wordsThe clearest warning sign is the growing cost of servicing this debt.Positioning Claims · 37 wordsJust a few years ago, debt interest consumed five or six cents of every tax dollar.10 Today, it consumes 11¢, roughly $60 billion annually, 11and more than the federal government transfers to provinces for health care transfers.12 The question · 43 wordsAt the fuel pumps, where Liberal taxes are driving up the cost of everything, why will the government not give Canadians a break where it would make the biggest difference, by eliminating federal taxes on diesel sales until at least Canada Day 2027?13

Analysed on