Analysis · Floor speech · beta

Heather McPherson

494 words · 25 sentences · 33 clauses

Statement grade
A–
Average 87 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Procedure 8%Reasoning 9%Positioning 24%Claims 53%The ask 3%Aside 1%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. Speaker, Procedure · 28 wordsI am standing today to talk about airport privatization. It was a question I brought up in the House earlier and is something that I and, I think, ProcedureReasoning · 10 wordsso many Canadians across this country are deeply concerned about. Positioning · 8 wordsThe airports in this country belong to Canadians.Positioning Claims · 8 wordsThey are our assets, purchased with Canadian dollars, Positioning · 23 wordsand the benefits of those airports should be to Canadian communities and Canadians who travel and use those airports, not to private investors.Positioning Claims · 25 wordsHowever, we are seeing a desire by the Liberal government to sell those assets off and give them to private investors to make that income. Positioning · 14 wordsThere is only one way for private investors to make money off our airports.Positioning Procedure · 13 wordsThere are two things that can be done: reduce costs or increase revenue.Procedure Reasoning · 26 wordsBoth of those things are to the detriment of Canadians. The first thing we know about privatization of airports is that it will cost Canadians more. Claims · 110 wordsThe Canadian Labour Congress report “Public Runways, Private Profits” examined privatization in Australia, New Zealand, Portugal, the U.K. and the United States.1 That report estimates that airports would need to generate 15% to 20% more revenue to provide competitive returns to private investors.2 At Perth Airport, after privatization, the cost per passenger went up 60% over a decade.3 CUPE and Unifor have warned the government that there is a risk of increased airport improvement fees, landing fees, parking fees, even charges for dropping off family members.4 The Minister of Transport tells Canadians there would be no unjustifiable increases to the cost of travel for Canadians.5 He says, no unjustifiable costs. The ask · 16 wordsI would really like to hear from the minister as to what a justifiable cost is. Aside · 7 wordsA perfect example would be Heathrow Airport.Aside Claims · 91 wordsIt is an example I know the government has used to justify the privatization of four of our biggest airports: 6the airport in Montreal, Toronto Pearson and the airports in Calgary and Vancouver. These four airports, by the way, make $525 million a year in revenue for the federal government, money that is then used to support smaller airports around this country.7 The example the government gave in its budget was Heathrow Airport.8 Heathrow, we have heard, costs up to 10 times as much as a public airport in Alberta does.9 Positioning · 11 wordsCanadians have a right to be very concerned that air travel, PositioningReasoning · 10 wordswhich is necessary in a country as big as Canada, Claims · 21 wordsand the cost of which is already very prohibitive for many Canadians, is going to get worse with this privatization scheme. Positioning · 56 wordsAside from making things more expensive for Canadians who want to use airports, the second way these private investors and companies can make money is by cutting jobs and cutting corners. I am worried about the safety and the sovereignty of our airports, but I am also deeply concerned about the jobs that will be lost.Positioning Claims · 8 wordsThere are good union jobs in these airports, Positioning · 9 wordsand the government is giving up on those workers.Positioning

Analysed on