Analysis · Debate question · beta

Heather McPherson

167 words · 7 sentences · 11 clauses

Following a speech by Leslie Church (Liberal)
“Mr. Speaker, let me address the member’s original question. As a Toronto member of Parliament, I have heard directly from hundreds of residents in my riding of Toronto—St. Paul’s about Billy Bishop. Their concerns about noise, about health and about the future of our waterfront always deserve a clear response. Our government is not supporting the proposed expansion. Following the consultation that closed on July 24, the Minister of Transport was clear: We will not pursue plans that encroach on Little Norway Park or Hanlan’s Point Beach, that increase noise, that cause significant environmental harm or that hinder Toronto’s ability to build housing. I share that position. I do not support losing green space or community amenities on the waterfront or the islands. The waterfront matters to people across our city. It is where families come to spend time together and enjoy the lake. The decisions we make now will shape that shared space for years to come. We are investing in new homes, better transit and public spaces along the waterfront. The airport’s future must respect the communities around it and the city we are building together. Toronto’s municipal government has a vital role in those decisions. Ontario’s move to acquire city lands makes transparent engagement with residents and the city all that much more important. Billy Bishop serves travellers, supports jobs and connects communities. Our immediate priority is completing the runway safety improvements already approved. That work does not authorize Ontario’s proposed expansion. For Canada’s major airports, the proposed model for investment would require operators to follow clear, strict rules on fees, service standards, worker protections and safety. Airport lands and assets would remain federally owned. The purpose is to improve the infrastructure Canadians rely on, with clear oversight to protect the public interest. As Toronto grows, as Canada grows, we need to build housing and transit, and improve transportation infrastructure while protecting the places people cherish. I will continue to insist that Torontonians have a meaningful say in the future of our waterfront in a city that we love.”
Statement grade
A–
85 / 100, held down by Signal
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Positioning 37%Claims 30%Reasoning 34%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. Speaker, Positioning · 40 wordsI certainly think the member’s government is also interested in protecting the Toronto waterfront because we keep hearing from the Toronto MPs that they have some interest in this, but then the government does not listen to Canadians, as usual.Positioning Claims · 35 wordsMembers should listen as $7.3 billion of rent has been paid to the federal government by airports under the existing model, money that Canadians have earned, 1which the government has with the asset it has. Reasoning · 56 wordsThe member talks about the fact that Canadians will still own the land, but when the government has given away the running of those airports for 50 years to potentially foreign investors, what difference does it make if the land is still there because the profits have been given away?2 The rights have been given away. Claims · 15 wordsThere are 435,800 jobs in this sector and all of those jobs are at risk.3 Positioning · 21 wordsThis is shocking. It is a joke to have them talk about this as if this will be better for Canadians.Positioning

Analysed on