Analysis · beta

Shelby Kramp-Neuman

Replying to Pat Kelly (Conservative)
“Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for drawing a straight line from the Rivard affair of the Pearson era through to present Liberal corruption and the culture within that party. However, I do want to focus in my question on the Alto rail project. The member said that the PBO says it will cost probably $113 billion. I am just doing a quick bit of math. I know the project even said $90 billion. I am sure it will be much more than that, but even $90 billion at 4% interest, divided by 12 million passengers, is $300 per ticket. That is from a study from the University of Montreal. If the interest alone is $300 one way, without operating costs and without recouping capital, how could this program ever make any sense whatsoever, when it is so clearly and obviously going to be a financial boondoggle?”

Not analysed yet

A requested analysis is usually ready within half an hour; come back to this page or reload it.

Mr. Speaker, the government 100% cannot afford it. Canadians at large do not want the Alto project. Ambition without discipline is not a national strategy, and it is an expensive promise. This Alto nonsense is an expensive promise. Canadians cannot afford a mega project built on optimistic projections with uncertain costs and completely questionable priorities. Before this government continues to bankroll the idea of Alto, I think it needs to explain to Canadians, in real dollars, about affordability, what it costs to fill one’s tank and what it costs to go to the grocery store. Alto is a non-stop, full-stop as far as I am concerned.