Discussion · Government Orders
Shelby Kramp-Neuman Conservative
“I oppose this budget. People in my rural riding are struggling to afford fuel and groceries, and they do not want the government adding billions to the debt. I also want real consultation on the Alto high-speed rail project, which threatens farmland and costs too much. This government has a long history of hiding facts from the public, and it must justify every single dollar it borrows.”
“Mr. Speaker, Hastings—Lennox and Addington—Tyendinaga is home to some of Ontario’s most productive farmland, much of it worked by families for generations. It is home to small businesses that support our local economies and sustain our towns and villages. It is home to the Mohawks of the Bay of Quinte, whose history and perspectives I continue to learn from. The people I represent understand the importance of hard work and of responsible decisions. They expect the same from their government. They expect respect for their hard-earned tax dollars, a willingness to listen and accountability for the decisions that affect their lives. These are not unreasonable expectations, yet across my riding, families are struggling to make ends meet. Seniors on fixed incomes are watching their purchasing power shrink. Food banks are seeing working Canadians who never imagined they would need assistance. In rural Canada, affordability comes with challenges that, too often, Ottawa overlooks. For my constituents, driving is not a luxury. It is a necessity. It is how people get to work, attend doctor’s appointments and buy groceries. It is how farmers operate equipment and get their products to market. When fuel costs rise, those costs ripple through our economy, affecting transportation, agriculture, small businesses and ultimately the price Canadians pay for everyday necessities. When Canadians are already stretching every dollar, every additional cost matters. Those dollars matter just as much when the government decides how to spend them. Among the many concerns surrounding the government’s priorities is the Alto high-speed rail project. Residents fear losing land held by their families for generations, farmers worry about divided farmland and rural communities face disrupted access routes and lasting impacts. These are people’s homes, livelihoods and legacies. Who is listening to the people expected to make the greatest sacrifices? For the communities I represent, the Alto initiative will take rather than give. Major infrastructure projects may often offer economic opportunities but those opportunities do not excuse a government from thorough consultation, fiscal accountability or respecting the communities directly affected. The Parliamentary Budget Officer has estimated Alto’s construction costs at between $75 billion and $113 billion-plus. That is an extraordinary financial commitment, deserving extraordinary scrutiny. This brings us to the federal budget. Budget 2026 projects a $62.3-billion deficit, with federal debt approaching $1.37 trillion and $60.2 billion in annual debt-servicing costs. That is more than $60 billion going toward interest on the debt rather than directly delivering new services to Canadians. Those annual debt charges are projected to climb to $85.5 billion by 2030–31. The families, farmers and small businesses I know and represent understand that borrowing sometimes has its place, but they also understand that every borrowed dollar must be justified. As we examine budget 2026, I believe the House must answer one crucial question. Are we making decisions that strengthen the lives of Canadians or are we asking them to carry an ever-growing financial burden without demonstrating the value they receive in return? That is the standard the people of Hastings—Lennox and Addington—Tyendinaga and all Canadians deserve. Next, I would like to turn to what I consider, beyond the extraordinary spending increases, the most historically significant issue in the budget, which is transparency. The manner in which the government is doing things leaves much to be desired. Only after sustained criticism did questions surrounding the Prime Minister’s relationship with Telesat receive greater scrutiny. Only after months of demands did the government disclose the companies lending employees to its Major Projects Office. Transparency should be standard operating procedure, not a crisis management strategy. Canadians are all too familiar with the government’s history on transparency, such as with WE Charity, ArriveCAN and SNC-Lavalin, names familiar to anyone who has followed politics. SNC-Lavalin was extremely troubling. The former prime minister and senior officials were found to have improperly pressured the attorney general over a prosecutorial decision, raising fundamental questions about the independence of that office and the Shawcross principle. This was hardly the first time a Liberal government faced questions about the administration of justice. In 1965, Justice Minister Guy Favreau left that portfolio following the Rivard affair after an inquiry criticized his handling of allegations involving attempted bribery and political interference. Favreau’s departure was followed by Lester B. Pearson’s recruitment of three prominent Quebec candidates, the “three wise men”: Gérard Pelletier, Jean Marchand and Pierre Elliott Trudeau. Interestingly, Favreau represented Montreal’s Papineau, a riding later represented by Pierre Trudeau’s son, Justin Trudeau, some 41 years later. Other names in Liberal Party history must not be forgotten. Groupaction Marketing, Coffin Communications, Lafleur Communication Marketing, Groupe Everest and Cockfield, Brown are names unfamiliar to newer members, perhaps, but not to those who remember the sponsorship scandal and the Gomery commission. I am sure my colleague from Bécancour—Nicolet—Saurel—Alnôbak remembers extremely well, and the member for Vancouver Centre probably wishes that she could forget. The sponsorship scandal remains one of the most consequential failures of public accountability in modern Canadian political history. In a remarkable coincidence, the Gomery hearings were held in Montreal’s Complexe Guy-Favreau. The Gomery commission’s report contained salient points that remain relevant today, which is why I am going to read a small portion of it to the House. It reads: One message has been continually emphasized in the consultations conducted by the Commission: there is a need to rebalance the relationship between Parliament and the Government. The capacity of Parliament to hold the Government to account needs to be restored and strengthened.... If the present Report succeeds in launching a public debate that leads to a rebalancing between Parliament and Government, the Commission, for that reason alone, may be considered a success. A reinforcement of the traditional role of parliamentarians would tend to restore public trust and the confidence that Canadians should have in their political and administrative institutions. That confidence is currently at a low ebb. It would contribute to a renewal of the self-esteem and sense of worth that should be felt by Members of Parliament. It would also restore the public’s respect for them. The commission’s recommendations helped shape the Federal Accountability Act introduced by the nascent Conservative government as its first piece of legislation. This legislation was not perfect, nor was the government that introduced it. As that government approached the end of its mandate, it too faced criticism over accountability and failures of communication. The institutional rot, intentional or not, is colour-blind. That is a lesson every member of the House should remember. Anyone who has walked through these halls over the past 25 years should understand the dangers that fester behind closed doors. As legislators, if we are not comfortable explaining our decisions to the Canadians we serve, we should question whether those decisions ought to be made at all. When legitimate criticism is dismissed, when accountability is avoided and when governments stop listening, the result is predictable: a culture of complacency, indifference and arrogance every single time. Ultimately, the people who pay the price are not the politicians, political staff or public servants involved. It is the taxpayer. We must never forget that everything we do in the House, every decision we make, every budget we pass and every dollar that we ultimately spend must be for them, the taxpayer, not for ourselves”
-
A repeated line
“People are struggling to make ends meet.”
Said 14 times by 11 members since April 27.
Every time it was said
Mr. Speaker, Hastings—Lennox and Addington—Tyendinaga is home to some of Ontario’s most productive farmland, much of it worked by families for generations. It is home to small businesses that support our local economies and sustain our towns and villages. It is home to the Mohawks of the Bay of Quinte, whose history and perspectives I continue to learn from. The people I represent understand the importance of hard work and of responsible decisions. They expect the same from their government. They expect respect for their hard-earned tax dollars, a willingness to listen and accountability for the decisions that affect their lives. These are not unreasonable expectations, yet across my riding, families are struggling to make ends meet. Seniors on fixed incomes are watching their purchasing power shrink. Food banks are seeing working Canadians who never imagined they would need assistance. In rural Canada, affordability comes with challenges that, too often, Ottawa overlooks. For my constituents, driving is not a luxury. It is a necessity. It is how people get to work, attend doctor’s appointments and buy groceries. It is how farmers operate equipment and get their products to market. When fuel costs rise, those costs ripple through our economy, affecting transportation, agriculture, small businesses and ultimately the price Canadians pay for everyday necessities. When Canadians are already stretching every dollar, every additional cost matters. Those dollars matter just as much when the government decides how to spend them. Among the many concerns surrounding the government’s priorities is the Alto high-speed rail project. Residents fear losing land held by their families for generations, farmers worry about divided farmland and rural communities face disrupted access routes and lasting impacts. These are people’s homes, livelihoods and legacies. Who is listening to the people expected to make the greatest sacrifices? For the communities I represent, the Alto initiative will take rather than give. Major infrastructure projects may often offer economic opportunities but those opportunities do not excuse a government from thorough consultation, fiscal accountability or respecting the communities directly affected. The Parliamentary Budget Officer has estimated Alto’s construction costs at between $75 billion and $113 billion-plus. That is an extraordinary financial commitment, deserving extraordinary scrutiny. This brings us to the federal budget. Budget 2026 projects a $62.3-billion deficit, with federal debt approaching $1.37 trillion and $60.2 billion in annual debt-servicing costs. That is more than $60 billion going toward interest on the debt rather than directly delivering new services to Canadians. Those annual debt charges are projected to climb to $85.5 billion by 2030–31. The families, farmers and small businesses I know and represent understand that borrowing sometimes has its place, but they also understand that every borrowed dollar must be justified. As we examine budget 2026, I believe the House must answer one crucial question. Are we making decisions that strengthen the lives of Canadians or are we asking them to carry an ever-growing financial burden without demonstrating the value they receive in return? That is the standard the people of Hastings—Lennox and Addington—Tyendinaga and all Canadians deserve. Next, I would like to turn to what I consider, beyond the extraordinary spending increases, the most historically significant issue in the budget, which is transparency. The manner in which the government is doing things leaves much to be desired. Only after sustained criticism did questions surrounding the Prime Minister’s relationship with Telesat receive greater scrutiny. Only after months of demands did the government disclose the companies lending employees to its Major Projects Office. Transparency should be standard operating procedure, not a crisis management strategy. Canadians are all too familiar with the government’s history on transparency, such as with WE Charity, ArriveCAN and SNC-Lavalin, names familiar to anyone who has followed politics. SNC-Lavalin was extremely troubling. The former prime minister and senior officials were found to have improperly pressured the attorney general over a prosecutorial decision, raising fundamental questions about the independence of that office and the Shawcross principle. This was hardly the first time a Liberal government faced questions about the administration of justice. In 1965, Justice Minister Guy Favreau left that portfolio following the Rivard affair after an inquiry criticized his handling of allegations involving attempted bribery and political interference. Favreau’s departure was followed by Lester B. Pearson’s recruitment of three prominent Quebec candidates, the “three wise men”: Gérard Pelletier, Jean Marchand and Pierre Elliott Trudeau. Interestingly, Favreau represented Montreal’s Papineau, a riding later represented by Pierre Trudeau’s son, Justin Trudeau, some 41 years later. Other names in Liberal Party history must not be forgotten. Groupaction Marketing, Coffin Communications, Lafleur Communication Marketing, Groupe Everest and Cockfield, Brown are names unfamiliar to newer members, perhaps, but not to those who remember the sponsorship scandal and the Gomery commission. I am sure my colleague from Bécancour—Nicolet—Saurel—Alnôbak remembers extremely well, and the member for Vancouver Centre probably wishes that she could forget. The sponsorship scandal remains one of the most consequential failures of public accountability in modern Canadian political history. In a remarkable coincidence, the Gomery hearings were held in Montreal’s Complexe Guy-Favreau. The Gomery commission’s report contained salient points that remain relevant today, which is why I am going to read a small portion of it to the House. It reads: One message has been continually emphasized in the consultations conducted by the Commission: there is a need to rebalance the relationship between Parliament and the Government. The capacity of Parliament to hold the Government to account needs to be restored and strengthened.... If the present Report succeeds in launching a public debate that leads to a rebalancing between Parliament and Government, the Commission, for that reason alone, may be considered a success. A reinforcement of the traditional role of parliamentarians would tend to restore public trust and the confidence that Canadians should have in their political and administrative institutions. That confidence is currently at a low ebb. It would contribute to a renewal of the self-esteem and sense of worth that should be felt by Members of Parliament. It would also restore the public’s respect for them. The commission’s recommendations helped shape the Federal Accountability Act introduced by the nascent Conservative government as its first piece of legislation. This legislation was not perfect, nor was the government that introduced it. As that government approached the end of its mandate, it too faced criticism over accountability and failures of communication. The institutional rot, intentional or not, is colour-blind. That is a lesson every member of the House should remember. Anyone who has walked through these halls over the past 25 years should understand the dangers that fester behind closed doors. As legislators, if we are not comfortable explaining our decisions to the Canadians we serve, we should question whether those decisions ought to be made at all. When legitimate criticism is dismissed, when accountability is avoided and when governments stop listening, the result is predictable: a culture of complacency, indifference and arrogance every single time. Ultimately, the people who pay the price are not the politicians, political staff or public servants involved. It is the taxpayer. We must never forget that everything we do in the House, every decision we make, every budget we pass and every dollar that we ultimately spend must be for them, the taxpayer, not for ourselves