Discussion · Private Members' Business
Doug Eyolfson Liberal
“I oppose this bill. Our self-defence laws already protect people who use reasonable force to defend themselves. Changing the law could justify violence against people who wander into the wrong home by mistake or who pose no threat.”
“Mr. Speaker, I am pleased today to rise to speak to this private member’s bill, Bill C-270, an act to amend the Criminal Code in relation to defence of person. Bill C-270 was introduced by the member for Newmarket—Aurora, and it proposes to reform Canada’s self-defence law. The intended objective of the bill, as I understand it, is to prevent victims of home invasions who act in defence of themselves, their family and their property from being criminally charged. While I believe this is a well-intentioned attempt to strengthen protection for victims of home invasions, which are terrifying crimes that can have long-lasting and profound effects on victims, I cannot support the bill. Criminal law is made up of offences and defences. Offences are prohibited acts, done with the required mental state, that carry criminal consequences, including jail time. These include, among many others, assault, manslaughter and murder. Defences, on the other hand, are legal justifications that can block criminal liability for the commission of an offence. This includes self-defence. Our existing self-defence law shields people who use reasonable defensive force, including lethal force, from criminal liability. More specifically, it permits people to use force if they had a reasonable belief in a threat of harm, they responded defensively and their response was reasonable considering all the circumstances. In assessing whether the use of force was reasonable, the courts will consider a wide range of factors, including the nature and imminence of the threat, whether weapons were involved, the relative physical capabilities of the people involved, and any prior relationship or communication between the parties. Importantly, the current law favours accused persons in self-defence cases. This is because the prosecutor must not only prove beyond a reasonable doubt that a criminal offence was committed but must also disprove self-defence beyond a reasonable doubt. Put differently, in order to secure a conviction, the prosecutor must prove not only that the person committed an offence but also that they did not do so in self-defence. The burden on the prosecution to secure a conviction is, rightly, very high. Canada’s self-defence law is, in my view, operating effectively and as intended. I am not aware of any case where someone has been convicted of an offence when acting in self-defence. The issue of charging practices is an important but separate issue from the Criminal Code laws that apply to self-defence. Take, for example, the 2025 home invasion in Lindsay, Ontario, that resulted in a violent altercation between the tenant, Jeremy McDonald, and the intruder, Michael Kyle Breen. Mr. McDonald used a knife to defend himself and left Mr. Breen with serious, life-threatening injuries. While Mr. McDonald was initially charged with aggravated assault and assault with a weapon, the prosecutors ultimately withdrew the charges against him after reviewing all the evidence. The charges against Mr. Breen, including for breaking and entering, were not dropped, and in April 2026 he pleaded guilty. There was also the 2019 home invasion in Collingwood, Ontario, in which the homeowner, Cameron Gardiner, killed Dean Copkov and Donovan Bass, two masked and armed intruders who broke into his house. This was the result of a struggle between Mr. Gardiner and one of the intruders over a shotgun. While Mr. Gardiner was originally charged with two counts of manslaughter, the charges against him were eventually withdrawn. In Canada, police lay charges when they have reasonable and probable grounds to believe that a criminal offence has been committed. Defences, such as self-defence, are legal justifications that must be disproved by prosecutors in court. Thorough prosecutorial screening prior to charges being laid reduces the likelihood of charges being improperly laid in self-defence cases, rather than having them withdrawn after the fact and after the damage is done. Being charged with an offence, especially a serious offence such as aggravated assault or manslaughter, can have devastating impacts on a person. In the context of violent home invasions, this can also be retraumatizing for the victims. Some provinces and territories already require prosecutors to evaluate police evidence to, among other things, determine before criminal charges are laid whether there is a substantial likelihood of conviction. These practices are in constant evolution by law enforcement at the provincial and territorial level. Bill C-270 proposes to change the existing self-defence law by creating a presumption that the mere fact that a person unlawfully entered house is proof that they intended to use force against someone in that house, and that force used against that person was used in self-defence. This would make it more difficult to hold those who do not act in self-defence criminally liable for violence committed against a person who unlawfully enters their home. This would capture a broad set of circumstances that would not be limited to violent home invasions, like the ones I just discussed. Take, for example, a situation where a senior accidentally enters the wrong apartment after getting off the elevator on the wrong floor and is assaulted by the resident, or, in the intimate partner violence context, a situation where a woman goes to her boyfriend’s house, an argument breaks out, and he assaults or, worse, kills her but claims that she was there unlawfully since he did not invite her over and she does not live there. These are two examples of situations where the “intruder” did not pose any threat of harm, yet under Bill C-270, the proposed self-defence law, the violence committed against them would be presumed to be legally justified. Surely this is not the sponsor’s intent. I would like to remind hon. members that the existing self-defence law came to be in 2013, following Parliament’s enactment of Bill C-26, an act to amend the Criminal Code, citizen’s arrest and the defences of property and persons. This bill was introduced by the Conservative government at the time. As I stated at the outset of my remarks, a person will, under the current law, be shielded from criminal liability if they acted in self-defence, meaning that they had a reasonable belief in a threat of harm, they responded defensively and their response was reasonable considering all of the circumstances. I strongly believe that the existing self-defence law strikes the right balance between recognizing that people need to defend themselves in dangerous situations, while ensuring that appropriate limits are placed on the use of force, and particularly on the use of lethal force. Our self-defence law does not, and should not, permit violence to be committed against someone merely because they trespass. This is why I oppose this bill.”
Mr. Speaker, I am pleased today to rise to speak to this private member’s bill, Bill C-270, an act to amend the Criminal Code in relation to defence of person. Bill C-270 was introduced by the member for Newmarket—Aurora, and it proposes to reform Canada’s self-defence law. The intended objective of the bill, as I understand it, is to prevent victims of home invasions who act in defence of themselves, their family and their property from being criminally charged. While I believe this is a well-intentioned attempt to strengthen protection for victims of home invasions, which are terrifying crimes that can have long-lasting and profound effects on victims, I cannot support the bill. Criminal law is made up of offences and defences. Offences are prohibited acts, done with the required mental state, that carry criminal consequences, including jail time. These include, among many others, assault, manslaughter and murder. Defences, on the other hand, are legal justifications that can block criminal liability for the commission of an offence. This includes self-defence. Our existing self-defence law shields people who use reasonable defensive force, including lethal force, from criminal liability. More specifically, it permits people to use force if they had a reasonable belief in a threat of harm, they responded defensively and their response was reasonable considering all the circumstances. In assessing whether the use of force was reasonable, the courts will consider a wide range of factors, including the nature and imminence of the threat, whether weapons were involved, the relative physical capabilities of the people involved, and any prior relationship or communication between the parties. Importantly, the current law favours accused persons in self-defence cases. This is because the prosecutor must not only prove beyond a reasonable doubt that a criminal offence was committed but must also disprove self-defence beyond a reasonable doubt. Put differently, in order to secure a conviction, the prosecutor must prove not only that the person committed an offence but also that they did not do so in self-defence. The burden on the prosecution to secure a conviction is, rightly, very high. Canada’s self-defence law is, in my view, operating effectively and as intended. I am not aware of any case where someone has been convicted of an offence when acting in self-defence. The issue of charging practices is an important but separate issue from the Criminal Code laws that apply to self-defence. Take, for example, the 2025 home invasion in Lindsay, Ontario, that resulted in a violent altercation between the tenant, Jeremy McDonald, and the intruder, Michael Kyle Breen. Mr. McDonald used a knife to defend himself and left Mr. Breen with serious, life-threatening injuries. While Mr. McDonald was initially charged with aggravated assault and assault with a weapon, the prosecutors ultimately withdrew the charges against him after reviewing all the evidence. The charges against Mr. Breen, including for breaking and entering, were not dropped, and in April 2026 he pleaded guilty. There was also the 2019 home invasion in Collingwood, Ontario, in which the homeowner, Cameron Gardiner, killed Dean Copkov and Donovan Bass, two masked and armed intruders who broke into his house. This was the result of a struggle between Mr. Gardiner and one of the intruders over a shotgun. While Mr. Gardiner was originally charged with two counts of manslaughter, the charges against him were eventually withdrawn. In Canada, police lay charges when they have reasonable and probable grounds to believe that a criminal offence has been committed. Defences, such as self-defence, are legal justifications that must be disproved by prosecutors in court. Thorough prosecutorial screening prior to charges being laid reduces the likelihood of charges being improperly laid in self-defence cases, rather than having them withdrawn after the fact and after the damage is done. Being charged with an offence, especially a serious offence such as aggravated assault or manslaughter, can have devastating impacts on a person. In the context of violent home invasions, this can also be retraumatizing for the victims. Some provinces and territories already require prosecutors to evaluate police evidence to, among other things, determine before criminal charges are laid whether there is a substantial likelihood of conviction. These practices are in constant evolution by law enforcement at the provincial and territorial level. Bill C-270 proposes to change the existing self-defence law by creating a presumption that the mere fact that a person unlawfully entered house is proof that they intended to use force against someone in that house, and that force used against that person was used in self-defence. This would make it more difficult to hold those who do not act in self-defence criminally liable for violence committed against a person who unlawfully enters their home. This would capture a broad set of circumstances that would not be limited to violent home invasions, like the ones I just discussed. Take, for example, a situation where a senior accidentally enters the wrong apartment after getting off the elevator on the wrong floor and is assaulted by the resident, or, in the intimate partner violence context, a situation where a woman goes to her boyfriend’s house, an argument breaks out, and he assaults or, worse, kills her but claims that she was there unlawfully since he did not invite her over and she does not live there. These are two examples of situations where the “intruder” did not pose any threat of harm, yet under Bill C-270, the proposed self-defence law, the violence committed against them would be presumed to be legally justified. Surely this is not the sponsor’s intent. I would like to remind hon. members that the existing self-defence law came to be in 2013, following Parliament’s enactment of Bill C-26, an act to amend the Criminal Code, citizen’s arrest and the defences of property and persons. This bill was introduced by the Conservative government at the time. As I stated at the outset of my remarks, a person will, under the current law, be shielded from criminal liability if they acted in self-defence, meaning that they had a reasonable belief in a threat of harm, they responded defensively and their response was reasonable considering all of the circumstances. I strongly believe that the existing self-defence law strikes the right balance between recognizing that people need to defend themselves in dangerous situations, while ensuring that appropriate limits are placed on the use of force, and particularly on the use of lethal force. Our self-defence law does not, and should not, permit violence to be committed against someone merely because they trespass. This is why I oppose this bill.