Fair Representation Act

Bill C-259, Fair Representation Act · Second reading · now at committee in the House Where it stands

What Bill C-259 would do

The bill would amend the Canada Labour Code to clarify what actions count as an employer, or someone acting for them, dominating or influencing a trade union. Any trade union that is dominated or influenced by an employer would lose its official certification. The bill would also establish penalties for employers who dominate or influence trade unions.

Official text (opens in a new tab)

3 statements

Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe, Lac-Saint-Jean

Bloc Québécois
“I support this bill. It stops bosses from setting up or controlling fake unions to weaken real ones. Current federal laws are too vague, but this bill adds clear rules and fines to punish employers who try to control their workers' unions.”
  • A repeated line

    “I rise this evening to speak to Bill C‑259.”

    Said 4 times by 2 members since May 27.

    Every time it was said
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I would like to start by taking a moment to acknowledge the work of my colleague and friend, the member for Edmonton Strathcona. I know this bill is a reflection of her desire to improve things for the people we represent, and I thank her for that. I rise this evening to speak to Bill C‑259, an act to amend the Canada Labour Code with regard to fair representation. My Bloc Québécois colleague and friend, the member for Shefford, has already explained our position. I think it is clear that the Bloc Québécois will support the bill in principle. This legislation strengthens protections for federally regulated workers from any form of company union that is controlled or dominated by the employer. Everyone knows that protecting workers’ rights has been a long-standing priority for the Bloc Québécois. This evening, we are debating one of our society’s fundamental principles: the right of workers to organize freely. These days, we are seeing repeated attempts to circumvent this right, which we feel is well established. Employers are not the only ones attempting this; the federal government is too. Before continuing, I have to digress for a moment to make a side comment on Bill C‑39. Bill C‑39 is an abomination. It represents a brutal step backwards on the environment, workers’ rights and democracy. I see that not many people on the other side are listening. That bill directly weakens workers’ rights and limits the right to strike. The simple truth is that that bill is one of the worst attacks on workers’ rights in history, yet the Liberals are patting themselves on the back over it. This is unheard of. Fortunately, the bill that we are debating this evening proposes the opposite. It essentially focuses on company unions. Put simply, these are unions that are dominated, controlled or influenced by the employer and that basically became an extension of management rather than a defender of the workers’ interests. Historically, this practice was used to circumvent workers’ true right to organize. The employer would set up a sham union, negotiate with it and then claim that it was respecting union rights. Behind this facade, workers were being denied what was most essential: union autonomy and real bargaining power. It is important to remember that many of the protections we now take for granted were won through the efforts of trade unions. I know this personally: My father was a trade unionist, and I was active in the labour movement myself. The right to paid vacation, parental leave, workplace pensions, safe working conditions and fair wages were secured over time by workers who organized and presented a united front. This contribution is not merely a part of our history. Trade unions continue to act as a counterbalance in today’s workplace. They empower employees to defend their interests, negotiate fairer terms and assert their rights. Union representation is also associated with higher wages, lower gender pay gaps and stronger protections against workplace accidents and occupational hazards. Although the Canada Labour Code already prohibits employers from dominating or interfering with the formation or administration of a trade union, the current provisions are general in nature and rely much more heavily on the interpretation of case law. Bill C‑259 is a continuation of this framework, clarifying the concept of employer domination and influence and clearly linking it to the consequences of such a strategy. That is not all. The bill also strengthens enforcement mechanisms. It provides for substantial fines, introduces the possibility of imposing administrative monetary penalties and expands the powers of the Canada Industrial Relations Board. These are important measures, because a prohibition is only meaningful if it comes with real consequences for non-compliance. The objective is to discourage employers who may be tempted to indirectly control or influence unions at the expense of workers’ freedom and independence. When it comes to an issue like this, it is hard for me not to make a connection with my riding, Lac-Saint-Jean, and the people who work there and who are the lifeblood of our region. My thoughts go out to the thousands of workers who help keep our economy running day after day, whether they work in the industrial, forestry or manufacturing sectors, in the service industry, or in local businesses. For them, as for all workers in Quebec and Canada, it is essential to be able to count on union representation that truly belongs to them, that defends their interests, and that acts with complete independence. Quebec has a long tradition of upholding labour rights and protecting workers. This tradition is not a recent development. Long before the federal government modernized its own labour relations system, Quebec had already begun to structure and legally recognize union activity. A pivotal moment in this history came in 1944 with the passage of the Labour Relations Act. This law paved the way for a more formal framework governing relations between employers and unions. It was followed, 20 years later, by the passage of the Quebec Labour Code in 1964. This evolution was the result of decades of activism by Quebec’s labour movement. From Catholic unions to today’s major labour federations, workers have fought to secure recognition of their rights and to establish a more balanced power dynamic with their employers. Quebec has developed an approach where freedom of association must not simply be recognized on paper. It must be protected by rules and mechanisms that allow workers to organize, engage in collective bargaining and defend their interests. That is one of the reasons why Quebec continues to be recognized for having one of the highest unionization rates in North America. This is a testament to our tradition of working together and recognizing the role that unions play in our society. For all of these reasons and out of respect for all of the workers who get up every morning and make Quebec what it is today, the Bloc Québécois supports the principle of the bill introduced by my colleague from Edmonton Strathcona. I will close with an anecdote. I helped create a documentary with absolutely no money. Back in 2004, I went to Colombia with a group of friends. We did not have a penny to spend, nor did we have a permit to film there. We went to meet with trade unions representing female workers in the flower greenhouses in the Bogota Valley. The trade unions were fighting against the company unions. I saw it first-hand. It happens elsewhere in the world. In Colombia in 2004, union rights were not exactly robust, shall we say. I saw first-hand what that meant. It meant higher union dues to belong to trade unions not controlled by the employer, but it also meant additional perks even in the factory canteen or in the flower greenhouses for workers who belonged to the company union. That is how it used to be. We have seen how that turns out. We do not want that here in Quebec or in Canada.

Dominique O'Rourke, Guelph

Liberal
“I support this bill moving forward. Workers need unions that are truly independent from their employers. Our labour laws already ban bosses from controlling unions, but we should study this bill to see if workers need stronger protections.”
  • A repeated line

    “The best agreements are reached at the bargaining table.”

    Said 5 times by 5 members since May 27.

    Every time it was said
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, it is always a privilege to stand and to represent the wonderful people of the city of Guelph. I would like to thank the member for Edmonton Strathcona for bringing this bill forward and for advocating tirelessly on behalf of workers. The government recognizes the spirit and intent of Bill C-259. Workers deserve unions that are truly their own and represent their best interests. Fairness for Canadian workers has been and will always be a top priority for our government. I met today with members of the Canadian Labour Congress. We talked about this bill, and we agree it is an important time for us to affirm and reaffirm our commitment to protecting workers’ rights and the integrity of collective bargaining. This is why it is my privilege to stand up and speak in support of this bill. Canada is deep in the throes of an illegal and unjustified trade war. It is an attack on our economy and on our sovereignty, but Canadians are determined and so is the government. We have all heard the Prime Minister say that we are focused on what we can control. The way forward is to invest in ourselves, to build fast, to build big and to build Canada strong. We cannot build a strong economy without respecting the workers who keep it running every day. When we talk about building Canada strong, we know it is our people who will do it, our Canadian workers. I had a great conversation with one of our steelworkers just this morning. This belief in our people, in our workers, is one of the reasons we are investing $6 billion in Red Seal trades through team Canada strong. We are working with our unions to make sure those apprenticeships are seen all the way through, including a completion bonus. We know our workers are the foundation of Canada’s economic strength and they expect us to have their backs. We do. We certainly saw that at Stelco last week. It is our job to make sure Canada’s labour framework continues to protect federally regulated workers and to support well-paid jobs with strong collective agreements. More than one million workers and over 22,000 employers keep our ports, railways, airlines and telecommunications running every day. Labour relations in these sectors shape wages, productivity and economic stability not only for these folks, but also for broader society. When these workplaces are constructive, healthy and more stable, supply chains are more reliable and our economy is stronger. Our country is the better for it. Collective bargaining works only when workers trust their union and employers trust the process, and both depend on union independence. A union that is dominated or influenced by an employer undermines that balance. It weakens workers’ voices at the table and erodes trust in the whole system. This is why protecting the credibility, independence and democratic operation of unions is not a peripheral issue. It is a long-standing principle in the Canada Labour Code. The code already reflects this. Part I prohibits employer interference in the administration and representation activities of trade unions. The Canada Industrial Relations Board has interpreted these protections broadly in past decisions. Bill C-259 raises a fair question: Are those existing tools sufficient to ensure workers are represented by organizations that are genuinely independent and accountable to their members and not to the employer? That question deserves careful examination with workers, with employers and with parliamentarians in the House. I would also like to highlight our broader approach to supporting federally regulated workplaces and the collective bargaining process that is protected by law. Our federal labour relations framework works well. Our federal mediation and conciliation service supports parties in reaching new collective agreements together that work for both sides. This is why 95% of all collective bargaining is resolved at the table. It makes for stronger agreements, better workplaces and better communities, but we are always on the lookout for ways to build greater trust in the system, to strengthen labour-management relationships and to provide parties with the tools they need to resolve issues before they become entrenched. This is why this year, we consulted unions, employers, employer representatives, indigenous partners and labour organizations about whether the federal labour relations framework still meets their needs. We heard a range of perspectives from all sides, but one was made clear by all: The best collective agreements are achieved through good-faith negotiations between employers and unions themselves at the bargaining table. That feedback informed Bill C-39, the building Canada strong act. The central objective of these reforms is very straightforward: to support workers and employers in negotiating good, durable agreements and to strengthen collective bargaining, because collective bargaining is not an obstacle to economic growth, but its foundation. Bill C-39 would do this in several concrete ways. First, it would support earlier engagement in higher-risk bargaining situations so issues could be addressed before positions become entrenched. Second, it would help rebuild labour management relationships following a particularly difficult dispute, through postdispute remediation facilitated by the federal mediation and conciliation service. Third, it would provide additional support for first collective agreement negotiations. Workers who have recently chosen union representation deserve a fair opportunity to secure a first agreement. Under Bill C-39, they would be provided earlier assistance and access to binding arbitration where negotiations remain unsuccessful after nine months. Fourth, the bill would also provide more time for parties to work through their differences by extending the conciliation period and creating additional opportunities to reach negotiated settlements. Fifth, it would lay the groundwork for expedited grievance arbitration in certain sectors. It would also lay the groundwork for an administrative monetary penalty regime to address bad-faith bargaining, including complaints that are vexatious, frivolous or not made in good faith. We would also invest in the capacity of the federal mediation and conciliation service and the Canada Industrial Relations Board so the board could address growing caseloads and backlogs, and complaints would be decided in a timely and effective way, which is good for workers. Every one of these measures has the same purpose: to help parties reach agreements themselves at the bargaining table, strengthen good-faith bargaining and support productive labour management relationships over the long term. I mention Bill C-39 because Bill C-259 shares the same goal: healthy, good-faith bargaining relationships built on trust and legitimacy. Bill C-39 focuses on the bargaining process. Bill C-259 focuses on who sits at the table on behalf of workers. Both matter, because a strong process does not mean a thing if workers cannot trust the people who are speaking for them. Collective bargaining functions best when workers have confidence that their union represents their interests independently and when employers have confidence in a fair and balanced process. The government remains firmly committed to protecting workers’ rights to fair worker representation, supporting meaningful collective bargaining and maintaining public confidence in Canada’s labour relations institutions. That is precisely why we introduced Bill C-39. Its measures would strengthen the collective bargaining process by giving parties better tools to resolve disputes earlier, build stronger labour management relationships and reach durable agreements through negotiation. We look forward to continuing to work with the member for Edmonton Strathcona, with committee members and with stakeholders on all sides as this discussion moves forward. I would once again like to thank the member for bringing the bill forward and for her advocacy on behalf of Canadian workers.

Colin Reynolds, Elmwood—Transcona

Conservative
“I support this bill. It stops bosses from controlling or interfering with unions. Unions must work for workers, not employers.”
  • Speech on a bill

    Signal 41 of 100

    Much of this statement went to praise, blame, greetings, routine procedure or general stories rather than reasons, requests or specific points.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, it is with great honour that I rise in the House today to speak on behalf of the people of Elmwood—Transcona regarding Bill C-259. The bill proposes amendments to the Canada Labour Code on the topic of employer influence and dominance of trade unions. Before I was elected as a member of Parliament, I spent 20 years working as a construction electrician, working in the trades alongside the men and women who help build and maintain our communities. My last day on a ladder was only a few days before I was elected to the House. As I get a chance to speak here now, I am proud to say that I continue to serve as the sitting vice-president of the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Local 2085. As I speak in the House, I am able to bring the perspective of someone who has experience living as a construction worker. I have spent decades working alongside Canadians who depend on meaningful representation and the ability to have their voices heard. At its core, Bill C-259 aims to amend the Canada Labour Code to help address situations where employers dominate or interfere with the independence of trade unions. Workers should have the freedom to organize and to choose their own independent representatives who genuinely advocate for their interests without interference or control from their employers. The purpose of a union is to represent its members. The responsibility of a union is meant to be the workers, not the employer. An employer’s having control over a union can be damaging—

Discussion

No comments yet

See the full discussion

Comment rules

More from sitting 166

  1. Government Orders The Budget 87 statements
  2. Oral Questions Housing 8 statements
  3. Oral Questions Finance 4 statements
  4. Oral Questions The Economy 6 statements
  5. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 11 statements
  6. Oral Questions The Budget 4 statements
  7. Oral Questions International Trade 13 statements
  8. Oral Questions The Economy 2 statements
  9. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 11 statements
  10. Oral Questions Housing 2 statements
  11. Oral Questions Rail Transportation 6 statements
  12. Oral Questions The Budget 2 statements
  13. Oral Questions Rail Transportation 2 statements
  14. Oral Questions Telecommunications 2 statements
  15. Oral Questions Forestry Industry 4 statements
  16. Oral Questions Housing 2 statements
  17. Government Orders The Budget 46 statements
  18. Oral Questions Justice 4 statements
  19. Oral Questions Employment 4 statements
  20. Private Members' Business Fair Representation Act 3 statements
  21. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  22. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  23. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  24. Private Members' Business Fair Representation Act 2 statements