National Immigration Month Act

Bill S-215, National Immigration Month Act · Second reading · now at second reading in the House Where it stands

What Bill S-215 would do

The bill would designate the month of November as National Immigration Month. The published material gives no further detail.

Official text (opens in a new tab)

9 statements

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba, Mont-Saint-Bruno—L'Acadie

Liberal
“I want the House to pass this bill to make November National Immigration Month. Immigrants have helped build Canada for centuries, and this bill honours their contributions. It does not change any immigration rules or laws.”
Official Hansard

moved that Bill S-215, An Act respecting National Immigration Month, be read the second time and referred to a committee. He said: Mr. Speaker, I rise to speak to Bill S-215, which proposes to designate November as national immigration month. At first glance, some might think this is just about adding yet another acknowledgement on our calendar. However, this bill represents much more than that. It calls on everyone to recognize a fundamental reality, specifically that immigration is part of our history. It has helped build our country and continues to shape its future. When we talk about immigration, we often think of the people arriving in Canada today. However, immigration did not begin with the current generation. It has been part of our history for centuries. In Quebec and across Canada, successive waves of immigration have shaped our cities, our neighbourhoods, our economy and our culture. Members of the Irish, Italian, Greek, Portuguese, African, Haitian and Vietnamese communities, among many others, have helped build the society we know today. They have started businesses, enriched our culture and contributed to the development of our communities. I am reminded in particular of the words of the renowned Irish poet William Butler Yeats: “There are no strangers here; only friends you haven’t yet met”. Those words invite us to look beyond origins and differences. They remind us that every person who arrives here deserves to be welcomed, respected and regarded as a full member of society. The date on which our families arrived should never determine the place we hold in our society. I am living proof of that. For some families, this story stretches back several generations. For others, it is only just beginning. However, everyone must be able to contribute fully to our shared future. Still, it is important to bear in mind an important distinction: First nations, Inuit and Métis are not immigrants. They are the first peoples of this land. Recognizing their history means recognizing that they have been here since time immemorial. Behind every migration journey is a human story. There are parents who leave their country to provide better opportunities for their children. There are students who come here to go to school. There are workers who put their skills to work for our businesses and organizations. There are entrepreneurs who take risks, create jobs and contribute to the growth of our economy. There are also people who are fleeing conflict and persecution and find in Canada a place where they can life in safety an dignity. These stories are different, but they often have one thing in common: the hope of building a better future. Today, immigrants contribute to virtually every sector of our society. They work in our hospitals, schools, businesses and public services. They participate in research, innovation and regional development. However, their contribution cannot be measured in economic figures alone. It is also measured by the families these people raise, the bonds they form and the communities they participate in. Immigration is a source of human wealth. I want to emphasize how important immigration is for our municipalities and the regions. We often talk about big cities, but newcomers also contribute to the vitality of our many small and medium-sized communities. In many municipalities, their presence helps meet labour needs, support local businesses, maintain services and keep our schools open. Integration does not just happen in large institutions. It happens in our schools, our libraries, our sports associations and our workplaces. It also happens when a child makes new friends at school or around town, when an entrepreneur opens a first business, or when a neighbour welcomes a new family to the neighbourhood. It is through these simple acts that a sense of belonging is built. This responsibility does not rest solely with governments. It concerns all of us: municipalities, schools, businesses and community organizations. We must also recognize the cultural and linguistic richness that immigration brings to our country. In Quebec, that richness must go hand in hand with the fundamental place of the French language. Welcoming newcomers is an opportunity to keep our language vibrant, to pass it on and to strengthen its use in every sphere of our society. Learning French enables people to participate fully in community life, find employment and build lasting connections. However, integration also requires efforts on our part. We must create opportunities for people to meet, support organizations that assist families, and improve access to education and employment. We can be proud of our languages, our history and our Quebec and Canadian identity while at the same time recognizing the richness of the diverse origins that make up our country. These realities are not in conflict. They can reinforce one another. I know that immigration is currently the subject of much debate. We are talking about immigration thresholds, housing, integration capacity, public services and labour needs. These are legitimate questions. We need to take them seriously and address them responsibly. Recognizing the contributions of immigrants does not mean ignoring the challenges. However, we also should not reduce immigration to mere numbers and statistics. Behind every number is a person. Behind every application is a journey. Behind every family is hope, hard work and sometimes great sacrifice. I am living proof of this. I have only been living in Canada for 16 years. Who would have thought that, 16 years later, I would be standing here speaking as an elected representative of Canadians? This bill does not seek to change any immigration policies or eligibility criteria. It proposes something different, specifically taking some time every year to recognize the contributions that immigrants make to our society. That is an important distinction. The month of November was also chosen for a reason. As the bill reminds us, Canada already celebrates National Francophone Immigration Week during that month. In addition, the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act received royal assent on November 1, 2001. November is a great opportunity to bring together these initiatives, share inspiring journeys and highlight the work of organizations that support newcomers. I believe one of the most important aspects of this bill concerns future generations. We have a responsibility to teach our young people that Canada was built through millions of individual human journeys. We must teach them to recognize the contributions of others, to be open-minded and to understand realities different from their own. For young people from immigrant backgrounds, that recognition carries particular significance. It reminds them that they can take pride in their origins, their family history and their heritage while being fully Canadian. For young people whose families have lived here for generations, it is also an opportunity to gain a better understanding of their own country’s history. A strong society is one in which everyone can find their place, participate fully and feel supported and recognized. Ultimately, the bill asks us to recognize the simple fact that immigration has helped shape Canada and will continue to play a role in its development. We have to debate immigration policies rigorously, while recognizing the value of the people who chose to make Canada their home. We can acknowledge the challenges involved in integration but celebrate success stories too. We can be proud of our Quebec and Canadian identity but still welcome the different histories that enrich our society. I will close with this thought. Whether our families arrived here generations ago or whether we were the first to cross the border into Canada, we all have a history that connects us to this country, except the indigenous peoples, of course, whose presence in this land stretches back to time immemorial. Immigration is part of our collective history. Passing this bill is about recognizing that history, celebrating the contributions of the people who helped build our country, and sending everyone who chose Canada a clear message that their journey matters, their contribution matters and they are an integral part of our collective future. For all of these reasons, I ask my colleagues in the House of Commons to support this bill and make November a truly national occasion for acknowledgement, dialogue and celebration.

Michelle Rempel Garner, Calgary Nose Hill

Conservative
“My colleague came to Canada as an immigrant, which shows what this country can offer. But he voted for record immigration levels when we do not have enough affordable homes, health care, or fair wages to support people. I want him to support an amendment to this bill that admits these problems so we can fix them.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I think it is remarkable, and I want to acknowledge something my colleague said. To be an immigrant, like he is, to come to Canada and participate in this place, I think shows the promise of Canada that is available to people who want to come here and build a better life. My colleague said something to the effect that recognizing the contributions of immigrants does not mean ignoring the problems, but that is exactly what he just did. He voted for a budget that had the highest levels of permanent immigration in Canadian history when we do not have the social infrastructure that keeps the promise that Canadians make to immigrants, which is if they come here, they should be able to build a better life with an affordable house, have access to health care and not have suppressed wages, which is what has happened in the Liberal government. Would he support an amendment to his bill that would acknowledge that there are challenges that need to be fixed? I would like to see that amendment put in here to keep the promise to immigrants to Canada.

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba, Mont-Saint-Bruno—L'Acadie

Liberal

Linked statement

“Many immigrants and their families have lived here for years, and their children go to our schools. Our budget aims to give them legal status so they have full rights. My commitment to immigration remains strong.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 46 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, there are immigrants in Canada, and particularly in Quebec, who have settled here with their families. Their children attend our schools and day cares. They have been living here for years. Our budget is primarily aimed at recognizing those who are already in Canada. We want to regularize their status at every level and enable them to fully enjoy their rights in Canada. The member has contributed to the debate in Canada, but her question should not be seen as being at odds with my commitment to immigration in Canada.

Alexis Deschênes, Gaspésie—Les Îles-de-la-Madeleine—Listuguj

Bloc Québécois
“Immigration is good for us, but it can also divide people. The government was confusing and dishonest when it announced its new immigration plans in the budget. I want the member to agree that the government should share the facts clearly and honestly, so we can have a real debate instead of rushing things through.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, the Bloc Québécois agrees that immigration is an asset. That said, it can also be deeply divisive. In the latest budget, the way things were announced was, to put it politely, convoluted. It was intellectually dishonest. Does my colleague not agree that, on an issue as important as immigration, the facts should be presented honestly and transparently so that we can have a genuine debate and so that the public does not get the impression that we are trying to rush things through?

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba, Mont-Saint-Bruno—L'Acadie

Liberal
“I followed the rules when I moved to Canada 16 years ago. The government is not hiding anything in the budget. It is public, and we vote on it every day. We should all support the budget to keep immigration strong.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I have been in Canada for 16 years, and I do not think that I took any shortcuts. I followed the path that brought me here to Canada. We presented our budget to all Canadians. We are not trying to hide anything from them. This is a public budget that is available for all Canadians to read. We vote here in the House every day on its implementation. I think that, since my colleague and I share the same values when it comes to immigration and the benefits that it brings to Canada, we should support the budget to continue making immigration a source of strength for Canada.

Guillaume Deschênes-Thériault, Madawaska—Restigouche

Liberal
“Immigrants help build Canada through their work, culture, and communities. I want the member to say more about why we should publicly recognize all of these contributions, not just the economic ones.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, in his excellent speech, my colleague pointed out just how much immigrants have helped to shape our country and make Canada what it is today. He mentioned not only the economic contribution of immigrants but also their social contributions and contributions to the cultural vitality of our communities. Before becoming an MP, I worked in the area of francophone immigration for about 10 years. I was working mainly to increase francophone immigration, but also to ensure that these people had access to high-quality settlement services. I would like to give the member an opportunity to talk more about the importance of publicly recognizing all of the contributions that immigrants make to our communities, not just from an economic perspective but from a social and cultural perspective as well.

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba, Mont-Saint-Bruno—L'Acadie

Liberal
“I support this bill. Immigration helps shape Canada, helps our economy grow, and builds strong communities outside big cities. Canada is a welcoming place for people who choose to come here.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, that is a good question. I would also like to acknowledge my colleague’s commitment to the francophonie in Quebec and beyond. He is an outstanding leader on these issues. Canada is one of the few countries that encourages its elected officials to take pride in their heritage. I can say here loud and clear, with pride, that immigration truly helps shape our country. Ever since I was elected and have been travelling around the country, I have seen in the regions, throughout Quebec, and across Canada, how immigration drives our economy and helps build communities outside the country’s major urban centres. Our immigration system today sets Canada apart and makes it a welcoming country for everyone who aspires to come here. In closing, I would just like to say that an immigrant is someone who chose to come here. Canada offers us a welcoming home. There is not just the American dream. There is also the Canadian dream.

Michelle Rempel Garner, Calgary Nose Hill

Conservative
“Immigrants helped build Canada, but November is already for remembering our veterans. We can discuss that in committee. More importantly, the government is bringing in too many people too fast. There is not enough housing or health care to keep up, and newcomers are being pushed into low wages and bad living conditions. The sponsor of this bill must push the Prime Minister to fix the immigration system to match what our country can handle.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, we have in front of us today a bill that would create a national immigration month in the month of November. The bill would recognize the contributions of immigration to Canada. There is absolutely no argument that immigrants have contributed to Canada and built this country. I have a concern that my colleague has chosen November, which is typically prioritized for veterans’ remembrance month. That is something we can discuss in committee, but I want to pick up on a few comments that he made during debate today. First of all, the member said that integration requires effort, interaction facilitated across education and employment and we should be proud of our national identity. The problem with that statement is that the last Liberal prime minister, Justin Trudeau, said there is no mainstream or national identity and then the current Prime Minister said that being Canadian is not being American. Without talking more about what Canadian identity is and what the responsibility of immigration into the country looks like, it is difficult for a Liberal to make that statement. I wish he had pushed back on that a little more. Why is that important? It is important when we are talking about the contributions of immigrants to Canada because Canada makes a promise to immigrants when they come here. The promise is that if they come here, work hard and respect the law, then they will have access to an affordable house to raise a family in. They will have access to good-paying jobs with wages that increase. They will have access to quality and timely health care, and more. That is the promise that Canada made to immigrants in the past and it is how so many immigrants who have come to Canada have enriched our country and become so successful, like the member of Parliament. He said something else in response to a question. He said this bill mainly supports people who are here already. That is a problem, because the promise that Canada makes to immigrants is being broken day after day right now. That is because he and his caucus colleagues are voting to set immigration levels so high that the social infrastructure needed to integrate into Canada’s national identity, and I do believe there is a national identity in Canada, is not there. The underlying principle, that social infrastructure needed for integration, is lacking. For example, there is not enough housing for everybody in Canada from an affordability perspective, certainly. The government’s own department wrote that the levels are being set too high for housing to keep up. Who is profiting off that decision? Who is getting richer? Who is that promise being made to? It is being made to wealthy corporate landlords who become rich when rents go up because levels have been set too high for housing to keep up. The other thing is health care. We know there are not enough CT scanners, doctors, hospital beds, surgeries, emergency rooms or emergency room staff to keep up with the pace of levels of immigration that the government has set. That is not fair to a newcomer who we have made a promise to. When my colleague stands up and says this bill mainly talks about people who are already here, we have to deal with the fact that the government is breaking its promise to every newcomer who comes to this country. One of the things I am most concerned about regarding the failures of immigration policy under the Liberal government and the Prime Minister is the fact that we are resigning many immigrants to become low-wage, indentured workers to corporate lobbyists who depress their wages so they can send increased profits to shareholders in Brazil and the United States. The promise of Canada is not coming to Canada to be an indentured labourer in a coffee shop with no path toward self-determination in building a better life, yet that is exactly what the government is enabling. For immigration and integration to be successful, we need to have the right amount of social infrastructure and the right processes to enable people coming to Canada to be successful, as so many of them before have been. My colleague is right. Immigration has built this country, and we have so much to be grateful for and proud of because of that. The very difficult issue that this bill glosses over is that there is social tension in this country right now because scarcity has been created by the Liberal government in setting immigration levels to benefit wealthy corporate lobbyists instead of the newcomers who are coming here, and the Canadians who are already here, and to get that enrichment component that he talked about. Without talking about these things, we are being dishonest to everybody, including people who have come to Canada and built a better life and are also experiencing that scarcity right now. I am very uncomfortable talking about this bill with its sponsor not talking about these issues. The loss of the consensus for immigration in Canada happened under the current Prime Minister, under the current Liberal government, and the fact that the Liberals are just trying to gloss over that and not fix it is a broken promise to every immigrant who has come here or who wants to come here in the future. It is a broken promise to every Canadian who has supported immigration. This was not an issue under the previous Conservative government. It did not come up in question period. It was not a top ballot issue, because we set immigration levels in accordance with Canada’s capacity to successfully integrate people into Canada’s social and economic fabric. I think everybody on the other side actually knows this is a problem. They will try to spin it and try to do whatever, but this is probably the biggest social policy challenge of our time. It has been created solely because the Liberals are setting levels too fast for housing, health care and jobs to keep up. It is too many too fast. Again, it is not to help somebody who wants to come to Canada. It is to help people who are getting rich off of depressed wages. I am deeply uncomfortable about the fact that the Liberals are just trying to gloss over this. We should be able to have uncomfortable, difficult conversations in this place that result in better public policy. It is why Conservatives have been relentless over the last year in putting forward concrete system reforms to make sure that there is, for example, less fraud in the temporary foreign worker program. The amount of abuse that was uncovered by the United Nations, to the point where the UN called it a form of modern-day slavery, should make people uncomfortable. The government should be accepting reforms. Instead, what we hear today is an attempt to gloss over this issue. My colleague’s response to that question just struck my heart. This is mainly about people who are already here? Well, the promise is being broken to people who are already here and to people who want to come to Canada. We have to have compassion for those students who just paid their families’ life savings to come to school in this country and have been forced into a scam college, their life savings stolen, and are then resigned to live 10 deep in a basement suite in Brampton. That is not what the promise of immigration used to mean in this country. It has been broken. It is disappointing that my colleague did not spend more time talking about these issues and talking about the need to reform the system. We can disagree on system reforms, or how to get there, but to just ignore that this is happening is actually breaking that promise to immigrants. It is doing a disservice and a dishonour to every immigrant who has come to Canada under the terms of that promise that used to exist across political stripes. I would ask my colleague this. He needs to make sure when he is advancing this bill that he is pushing his caucus and the Prime Minister to reform the system, to keep that promise to immigrants, to set levels so hospitals and schools can be built; so people can go to class, learn the language and get jobs; and so wages are not depressed. That is how we restore the consensus for immigration, and that is how we honour immigrants’ contributions to Canada, not by allowing corporate lobbyists to take advantage of newcomers. Immigrants are not sterile units of profit. They are contributors to this country and they should be treated that way.

Alexis Deschênes, Gaspésie—Les Îles-de-la-Madeleine—Listuguj

Bloc Québécois
“The new budget shows Canada will actually welcome 662,000 new permanent residents this year, not just 380,000. Most of them will settle outside Quebec. I want to know what the member thinks this means and why the government is doing it.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for her inspired speech. I would like to hear her reaction when she, like me, combed through the latest budget and discovered, on page 216, what appears to be a target of 380,000 permanent resident admissions, unchanged from before. However, as one reads further, it becomes clear that an additional 200,000 temporary residents will be counted and added to that target. Then we learn that there will be another 80,000 people on top of that, meaning that, in the end, Canada will welcome 662,000 new permanent residents this year. Most of those newcomers will settle outside Quebec. What does my colleague think that means? Why is the government doing this?

Discussion

No comments yet

See the full discussion

Comment rules

More from sitting 167

  1. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 6 statements
  2. Oral Questions Ethics 6 statements
  3. Oral Questions The Budget 8 statements
  4. Oral Questions Housing 2 statements
  5. Oral Questions The Environment 4 statements
  6. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 10 statements
  7. Oral Questions The Budget 2 statements
  8. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 9 statements
  9. Oral Questions Public Services and Procurement 6 statements
  10. Oral Questions Health 8 statements
  11. Oral Questions The Economy 7 statements
  12. Oral Questions Housing 2 statements
  13. Oral Questions The Economy 2 statements
  14. Oral Questions Telecommunications 2 statements
  15. Government Orders The Budget 51 statements
  16. Oral Questions Finance 4 statements
  17. Oral Questions Forestry Industry 5 statements
  18. Private Members' Business National Immigration Month Act 9 statements
  19. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  20. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  21. Private Members' Business National Immigration Month Act 3 statements
  22. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  23. Private Members' Business National Immigration Month Act 2 statements