Stand on Guard Act

Bill C-270, Stand on Guard Act · Second reading · now at second reading in the House Where it stands

What Bill C-270 would do

The bill would amend the Criminal Code to add legal presumptions related to the defence of a person. The published material gives no further detail.

Official text (opens in a new tab)

2 statements

Alexis Deschênes, Gaspésie—Les Îles-de-la-Madeleine—Listuguj

Bloc Québécois
“Our laws already allow people to defend themselves and their homes. An Ontario person recently shot an intruder and was found not guilty. Laws like this one in Florida led to more gun deaths. Has the member looked into the real impact of this bill?”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for her contribution to the debate. In her speech, she mentioned the case in Ontario. An individual is the victim of a home invasion, grabs a gun, shoots the intruder, and seriously injures them. That person pleads self-defence and is acquitted. This example demonstrates that the Criminal Code currently provides people with the necessary certainty and security to defend their property. Has my colleague looked into the impact of what she is proposing? This type of law was implemented in Florida, and it was found to have increased the rate of gun-related homicides, because the argument is that as soon as someone enters without permission, the homeowner can shoot them in the head and be cleared of any wrongdoing.

Alexis Deschênes, Gaspésie—Les Îles-de-la-Madeleine—Listuguj

Bloc Québécois
“I am voting against this bill. The law already lets people protect themselves and their homes if they act reasonably. This bill assumes that anyone who enters a home uninvited plans to use force. That could let people legally kill a harmless intruder by mistake. Similar laws in the United States led to more gun deaths. We do not need this change.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I am going to tell two fictional stories. They will help everyone better understand what is being proposed in Bill C-270. Here is the first scenario. I am at home, and someone opens the door and enters uninvited. He is armed and approaches me. He appears threatening and, to protect myself, I punch him. He falls and dies. I could be charged, but I think I have a good chance of being acquitted under the current concept of self-defence in the Criminal Code. The conditions set out in section 34 of the Criminal Code must be met. First, I believed on reasonable grounds that a threat of force was being made against me. Second, I acted to defend or protect myself, not to get revenge. Third, I acted reasonably in the circumstances, that is, I threw a punch to overcome the threat. I think I would be acquitted. Now for the second scenario. I am incredibly fortunate to have three extraordinary, wonderful boys. They are great kids and have lots of friends. In my village of Carleton-sur-Mer, my house is always full because my sons are constantly inviting their friends over to eat, study or spend the night. When there is a party somewhere in the village, it always ends up at our house. There is a steady stream of people coming and going. Let us say that one of my sons’ friends forgets his shoes and decides to come back and get them at 9:30 p.m. Since he is used to stopping in, he opens the door without knocking and comes in to get his shoes. It just so happens that I have a gun and I shoot him, because this young man entered my home knowingly and without having the legal right to do so. If Bill C-270 is passed, I think I would be acquitted. What Bill C-270 states is that, when someone knowingly enters a house without being entitled by law to do so, it can be presumed that the person entered with intent to use force against me. The presumption referred to in Bill C-270 is what will allow me to use lethal force against anyone who, without having the legal right to do so, has entered a residential property in which I am lawfully present. Is that what we want? Of course not. Basically, Bill C-270 gives people permission to kill anyone who enters their home uninvited. It is a bit like the wild west. As I said in the beginning, people have the right to defend themselves under the self-defence provisions of the Criminal Code. However, I think that it is worrisome to go so far as to presume that there is an intent to use force and justifying the use of lethal force without taking into account the context. That is not going to solve any real problems and will mainly lead to tragic mistakes or deaths, which is not what we want. The purpose of criminal law is to keep people safe. Telling people that they can use lethal force against anyone who enters their home uninvited will not make our society safer. It will do the opposite. Other countries, including the United States, have tried this approach. If we do a little research, we find that the only state where this is still legal is Texas. Florida tried implementing this type of legislation and found that it led to a significant increase in the rate of firearm-related homicides. In 57% of cases, there was clear evidence that the person claiming self-defence could have retreated to safety without attacking. What is dangerous about this bill is that it opens the door to homicides. If we look at the law as it currently stands, a contextual analysis is already carried out. That is why I do not think this bill solves anything. Currently, there is the defence of the person, but there is also the defence of property. This defence is also allowed in the Criminal Code. If we think that someone is going to damage our property, we can also use force to stop the threat. However, the Criminal Code provides certain safeguards. My colleague spoke about the uncertainty surrounding all this, but I would not call it uncertainty. On the contrary, the objective is simply to ensure that people are not permitted to go too far and seek revenge by using disproportionate force. The purpose of self-defence or the defence of property is to stop the threat, to stop the use of force. The Criminal Code provides for a way to determine self-defence. As I said, there are three criteria: the person must believe that force will be used against them or that there is a threat; the person must act for the purpose of defending or protecting themselves; and the act committed is reasonable. For a determination of whether a person acted reasonably, the Criminal Code already sets out a number of factors that can be used to contextualize the behaviour. For example, the person’s gender can be taken into consideration. Certain subjective criteria can be used for contextualization purposes. If a person experiences fear when someone else might not, the nature of the force or threat would be examined, along with the extent to which the use of force was imminent. The judge would also consider the history of any relationship between the parties to the incident to determine whether the use of force was reasonable. For example, if the person reacted very quickly but there was a history of violence or intimidation, the reaction could be considered reasonable in the circumstances. The judge will also examine any history of interaction, as well as the nature and proportionality of the person’s response, along with whether the person was acting in response to a use or threat of force that they knew was lawful. If so, that complicates the matter. Nothing is perfect, but the Criminal Code does currently allow someone who is the victim of a home invasion, which is the type of case our colleague mentioned, to defend themselves if they have a reasonable fear, and to put a stop to that threat. What more could we want? I think that the status quo is fine, but when we look at Bill C-270, there really is a presumption of intent that changes the legal analysis and sends a message that, in my view, should not exist. That is why the Bloc Québécois is voting against this bill.

Discussion

No comments yet

See the full discussion

Comment rules

More from sitting 168

  1. Government Orders The Budget 116 statements
  2. Oral Questions Housing 5 statements
  3. Oral Questions Finance 6 statements
  4. Oral Questions The Environment 6 statements
  5. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 7 statements
  6. Oral Questions The Economy 4 statements
  7. Oral Questions Agriculture and Agri-Food 10 statements
  8. Oral Questions Steel and Aluminum Industry 2 statements
  9. Oral Questions Public Safety 2 statements
  10. Oral Questions Public Services and Procurement 2 statements
  11. Oral Questions Government Priorities 2 statements
  12. Oral Questions Infrastructure 2 statements
  13. Oral Questions Government Priorities 5 statements
  14. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 2 statements
  15. Oral Questions Finance 2 statements
  16. Oral Questions Climate Change 2 statements
  17. Oral Questions Industry 3 statements
  18. Oral Questions Business of the House 2 statements
  19. Government Orders The Budget 16 statements
  20. Oral Questions The Environment 2 statements
  21. Oral Questions Steel and Aluminum Industry 2 statements
  22. Government Orders The Budget 8 statements
  23. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 2 statements
  24. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 10 statements
  25. Oral Questions Public Safety 9 statements
  26. Government Orders The Budget 15 statements
  27. Government Orders The Budget 26 statements
  28. Private Members' Business Stand on Guard Act 12 statements
  29. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  30. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  31. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements