The Budget

The House debated the government’s Budget 2026, which members described as covering cost-of-living help, affordable housing, local infrastructure, investments in Canadian technology, immigration measures for worker shortages, and national defence. Liberal members argued the budget helps people with everyday costs, makes the caregiver tax credit fully refundable, targets low- and middle-income households through tax cuts, and builds long-term economic growth. Conservative members said the government’s spending plan is not working, pointing to about $85 billion in interest payments over five years, and called for lower taxes and tighter control of spending. The Bloc Québécois argued the budget falls short on health care transfers to Quebec and the provinces, and raised concerns about free park admission for foreign visitors while park jobs are cut. The NDP raised a funding gap between East Coast and West Coast ferry services, and members also exchanged views on the Alto high-speed rail project and its effect on farmland.Written by AI from the debate. Updated .

Official text (opens in a new tab)

48 statements

Pat Kelly, Calgary Crowfoot

Conservative
“This budget adds 765 billion dollars to the national debt and has a 60-billion-dollar deficit. The government is using accounting tricks to hide where the borrowed money goes. I want the member to explain this.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, in the member’s speech I did not hear anything about the shifting accounting trickery that is going on with this budget, which has been observed by everyone from the Parliamentary Budget Officer to the IMF and other observers. They note that the deficit itself, which is at $60 billion, is double the deficit that was enough to provoke the resignation of the previous minister of finance at this time two years ago. The borrowing requirement in this budget for this year alone is two and a half times the nominal deficit in this budget of $60 billion. Can she comment on the $765 billion in debt that this budget will add and on the shifting deliberate accounting trickery that makes it so difficult to follow even how and where the borrowed money is going?

Rhonda Kirkland, Oshawa

Conservative
“Our job in the opposition is to ask hard questions and hold the government accountable. That is not obstruction. It is part of working together in Parliament. I want the member to agree.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I appreciated this speech more than others I have heard from this member, including different walks in the forest I have seen, which are lovely, but they do this one thing. I do not know if the member realizes that we have a Westminster system. The job of our opposition is to look very closely at things, to inspect them, to question them and to hold the government to account, and it feels as though every time we try to do that in the House, the member puts out a response that says, essentially, “How dare they not support us? They need to collaborate and stop obstructing.” Would he agree, then, that our questioning and our concerns about this budget are indeed collaboration in our government system and not obstruction?

Rhonda Kirkland, Oshawa

Conservative
“I oppose this budget. It spends too much, adds billions to the debt, and does not make life more affordable for families. We should cut wasteful spending, lower taxes like the gas tax, and protect auto jobs instead.”
  • A repeated line

    “Canadians have held up their end of the bargain.”

    Said 3 times by 3 members since November 17.

    Every time it was said
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, it is always an honour to rise on behalf of Oshawa, my neighbours and friends. Today, I rise to speak, of course, about the government’s 2026 federal budget and what it means to Canadians who work hard, pay their taxes and hope to build a better future for their families. When Canadians look at budget 2026, they want to know where their hard-earned tax dollars are going and whether the government’s decisions will indeed make their lives more affordable. Unfortunately for families in Oshawa and across Canada, the answer is becoming harder to find, and that is why I am here to represent Oshawa’s interests. Groceries cost more. Filling up the family vehicle costs more. Housing remains out of reach for far too many Canadians, and small businesses continue to face rising expenses. Canadians have held up their end of the bargain. They have worked hard and followed the rules; they pay their taxes and contribute to their communities. They deserve a government that respects that hard work. Instead, the Prime Minister has delivered yet another costly budget that would increase spending, add drastically to our national debt and leave future generations with the bill. I want to talk about what these rising costs actually mean for Canadian families. Let us bring it right down to where it matters most. It means a parent standing in the grocery aisle, adding up the cost of everything in their cart and deciding what they can afford and what they are going to have to put back. It means seniors on a fixed income, watching their savings disappear just to cover everyday expenses. It means families who work hard all week long, only to find that there is barely anything left after paying the mortgage, buying the groceries and filling up their car. Conservatives propose removing all federal taxes, for instance, on gasoline, with estimated savings of approximately 20¢ per litre and up to $1,200 per family. The Liberals, of course, chose not to provide that relief. Instead, Canadians face the prospect of yet another increase in fuel costs next year. Conservatives have called for cutting wasteful spending so Canadians could keep more of their own money, yet the government chose to spend more. Hard work should mean financial security, not a constant struggle to make ends meet. I am also concerned about the government’s continued lack of fiscal responsibility. The Prime Minister came into the office with what Canadians thought was an impressive financial résumé. He promised Canadians a different approach to managing money from the one we had in the 10 years prior to him under Justin Trudeau, yet here we are with another budget that would add billions in debt while Canadian families are already stretched to their limits. It is worse, far worse, than Justin Trudeau’s spending. That is the shocker here. Conservatives are standing up in the House asking this current government to be as good as Justin Trudeau and spend a little less. Shockingly, that is where we are right now with budget 26. The government’s own projections show federal debt charges rising approximately $85.5 billion annually by 2031. If we think about that, it is billions of dollars every year, not to build homes or improve infrastructure but simply to pay interest on money the government has already borrowed. Instead of addressing the problem, Liberals have introduced a new way of dividing operating spending and capital investment. The Parliamentary Budget Officer has raised concerns about the government’s definition of capital investment, and they are legitimate concerns. Is this an attempt to cook the books? I think so, and Canadians deserve a clear explanation of how the government accounts for their money, because no matter how the Liberals choose to classify their spending, the debt still has to be paid by our children and our grandchildren. What a shame. The Liberals borrow, but our children pay and Canadians pay. Families across Oshawa have been forced to stretch every dollar and make sacrifices to live within their means. It is about time this federal government learned to live within its means. In Oshawa, we know the value of a good-paying job. Our city was built by generations of hard-working men and women in the automotive sector, manufacturing and local businesses that depend on those industries. When an auto worker loses his job, it is not just one paycheque that disappears. There are three to seven more along the supply chain. It affects each entire family that depends on that income, the small business down the street and the future of our community. Canadian businesses need competitive taxes, reliable energy and fewer unnecessary regulations in order to thrive. They deserve a government that encourages investment, supports expansion and creates the conditions for good-paying jobs here at home. Oshawa’s auto workers have helped build this country’s economy for generations. They deserve a government that will stand up for their jobs, not simply try to manage the decline in our auto sector. In fact, the member for Whitby very recently said in this House that all these so-called jobs that were becoming available in the Durham region would help those coming out of auto jobs, implying the Liberals were planning for people to lose their jobs in the auto sector. They are not fighting for Oshawa or any Canadian auto jobs, from my perspective. Housing is another issue I hear about regularly from residents in Oshawa. Young people are getting an education, working hard and saving whatever they can, yet the dream of owning a home continues to slip further away. Renters are spending enormous portions of their income simply to keep a roof over their heads, leaving little for groceries and transportation, and they can forget about savings. Imagine someone working full-time and still worrying about whether they can afford next month’s rent. Building more homes, speeding up construction and removing unnecessary barriers to development must be priorities, but housing and immigration policies cannot be treated as separate issues. Canada deserves an immigration system, for instance, that is fair, compassionate and sustainable. Newcomers have contributed enormously to our country, but the government must ensure that communities have the housing, infrastructure and essential services necessary to support a growing population. That means enough housing, hospitals, schools, transportation and essential services. The government must be transparent about its immigration targets and ensure that population growth reflects the capacity of our communities. When hospitals and schools are already under pressure, we must plan carefully to ensure that families and newcomers can access the services they desperately need. A responsible immigration system must work for Canadians and it must work for newcomers. We must address the growing food insecurity facing Canadian families as well. According to Food Banks Canada’s report, there were more than 2.3 million visits to food banks across Canada in March this year alone. That is the highest number ever recorded. Food banks across the country, including in Oshawa at Simcoe Hall Settlement House, are running out of food and having to turn people away. Food banks do not have enough food to feed people in need. We must remember that every visit to a food bank is a Canadian facing difficult choices just to afford the necessities of life. In a country as wealthy and resourceful as Canada, it is deeply troubling that so many people must rely on food banks just to get through a single month. It is not enough for the government to announce billions of dollars in new band-aid funding and expect Canadians to be satisfied. People deserve to know where that money is going, what it is accomplishing and whether their lives are actually improving. As the member of Parliament for Oshawa, I hear from residents always about affordability, housing, manufacturing jobs and the future of their families. At the end of the day, I keep coming back to one question when I look at this budget. Are Canadians better off? I recently asked Oshawa residents if their lives reflect the Prime Minister’s claim last spring that affordability is the best it has been in a decade, and so far, nobody has agreed. When I think about the people of Oshawa, I think about our auto workers, small business owners, hard-working parents and seniors who have contributed so much to our community. They deserve a government that understands the pressures they face and takes their concerns seriously. Conservatives will continue to call for lower taxes, responsible spending, affordable housing and policies that support Canadian workers and businesses. As the member of Parliament for Oshawa, I will continue to stand up for our workers, our families, our seniors and our young people. I will continue to advocate for the industries that have supported generations of families in Oshawa. I will continue to hold the government accountable for how it spends Canadians’ hard-earned tax dollars while remaining accountable to the people who have entrusted me to represent them. Oshawa families have done their part. It is time the government did its part.

Rhonda Kirkland, Oshawa

Conservative
“I reject the claim of hypocrisy. The government takes most of people's money and gives back very little. The Liberals blame global issues for high costs, but their own policies caused these problems. Canadians are noticing.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I take exception to the word “hypocrisy” for a very clear reason. We have a government that is telling Canadians, “Everything is fine. We’re taking care of you. We’re taking most of your money, but we’re giving you a smidgen back, and that’s us looking after you.” The Liberals keep turning to global issues as the reason Canadians are struggling here at home, but we know it is the policies of the Liberal government that have put Canadians in this place in the first place, and I can promise members that Canadians are starting to pay attention.

Rhonda Kirkland, Oshawa

Conservative
“I want the government to reverse the decision affecting the cadets program. Cadets teaches young people to be good citizens, and it helps bring strong members into our military.”
Official Hansard

Yes, Madam Speaker, I agree 110%. The truth is this. Cadets is an amazing program throughout this country for the army, air and navy. My son was a member of the 151 Chadburn Squadron in Oshawa, and I promise members this: He is a better adult because of the time he spent in our cadet program. I have seen that time and time again. This decision needs to be reversed. We are not training soldiers in our cadet program. That is not really the purpose of it. The purpose is to create good citizens who contribute to our society. However, the member is correct. A lot of times it is an entryway for many of our most solid members who serve in our Canadian Armed Forces.

Helena Konanz, Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay

Conservative
“People in my riding cannot afford fresh food or meat, and some are using food banks. I want my colleague to explain how adding more debt in this budget helps everyday people buy food.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, there are so many parts of my colleague’s impassioned speech that really hit home. The cost of groceries is what I am hearing about in Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay. People going to grocery stores are having to stay in the middle aisles. In other words, they cannot buy anything fresh, or meat. That is for sure. Some are even having to avoid the grocery store and are starting to go to food banks. It sounds like it is the same in Oshawa. How does my colleague think the massive, growing debt in this budget is going to help everyday Canadians when all they want to do is put food on the table?

Rhonda Kirkland, Oshawa

Conservative
“People in my community are struggling to afford what they need, including healthy food. The ministers who wrote this budget need to talk to Canadians and see that life is not affordable right now.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 45 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I appreciate the question and the heart with which that question comes. The truth is, as members of Parliament, we speak to people in our communities every day, and in Oshawa, it is the same. People are struggling. People are suffering. I have asked them, “Is affordability for you the best it’s been in a decade?” I can promise members that it is not. The ministers in the government who created this budget need to have more one-on-one conversations with Canadians in our communities to really understand that sadness of having to shop in the inside aisles and not around the edges where they can get the healthy food. Our country is suffering, and our people are becoming unhealthy because they cannot afford what they need.

Clifford Small, Coast of Bays—Central—Notre Dame

Conservative
“I will not vote for this budget. It spends too much money and adds billions to our debt. It spends money on ocean funds that hurt fishing and shipping, and sends money to Brazil while cutting funds for our youth cadet programs. I also want the Prime Minister's wife to answer questions at committee about her role in the new ocean fund. Our country has rich natural resources, so we should not have a deficit that drives up costs for families.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, it is an honour and a privilege to stand here today to speak on behalf of the people of Coast of Bays—Central—Notre Dame and the people of Newfoundland and Labrador. This budget is going to have a $62-billion deficit and new spending of $151.5 billion in the next fiscal year. It is going to add $765 billion of new debt over the next five years for this country, representing $44,000 of extra expenses for each household in this country, but it is no wonder. We just heard the announcement of a $1.2-billion spend on the new oceans protection fund. Industries like fishing, aquaculture, tourism, goods transportation, and oil and gas will be placed under attack. Every industry that depends on the ocean to earn its livelihood will be under attack. It is totally unnecessary. Canada has the most protected oceans in the world. Is the Oceans Act not enough? Who is going to receive all this funding? Will it be the ENGOs that are already working feverishly to shut down our fishing industry, our aquaculture industry and our oil and gas and to severely restrict cruise ships, which many of our coastal communities depend on for tourism? Conservatives have been trying to get Canada’s ocean envoy, the Prime Minister’s wife, Madame Fox Carney, to come to the fisheries committee and to every other relevant standing committee here in Parliament to explain her role with the $1.2-billion fund the Prime Minister just announced to be administered by none other than his wife. Again today, Liberals voted for the fourth time to shut down debate on the motion we put forward to have Ms. Fox Carney appear at the fisheries committee. I do not know what the cover-up is. We cannot even debate the motion. They could have simply voted it down and said she is not coming, but they do not want to talk about it. What is the big deal? We just heard talk of nearly half a billion dollars committed by the Prime Minister to the forests of Brazil, which his very own companies helped to destroy. That money can buy 10 brand new water bombers to protect the forests of Canada. Are the forests of Canada not worth protecting? In spite of all this rampant spending, the Liberals have cut funding to Canada’s military cadet and junior rangers programs. We have been hearing concerns from parents. In fact, one parent who was to bring her child to Ottawa this weekend as a part of his cadet program was in touch with our office today. She told us it was cancelled because the funding is not there. The leaders of the cadet program are extremely disappointed. They care about these youth, and they care about what the cadet program means for our next generation, our younger generation. Nine communities in Coast of Bays—Central—Notre Dame have cadet programs: Bishop’s Falls, Botwood, Gander, Grand Falls-Windsor, Lewisporte, Springdale, Summerford and Triton. The Summerford program supports Twillingate, New World Island and the surrounding areas. The impact is massive. In a cost of living crisis, when parents are struggling to find affordable activities to enrol their kids in, the most affordable program and most meaningful program in Canada that is basically free for parents is being slashed while enrolment is at a record level. Cadet programs have increased their enrolment over the last year, year over year, by 10,000. It is a program that teaches our youth responsibility, respect, discipline and courage. It introduces them to volunteering in an age where volunteerism is dying. That shows the priorities of the Liberal government. The cadet program is so important because cadets are 10 times more likely to serve in the armed forces than non-cadets are. It is nearly 100% guaranteed that they are going to get through boot camp, their basic training. Of all the new entrants into the armed forces, the ones the Liberals bragged about last year, nearly 90% of them failed out of basic training, and they had to bump them up. Our cadets want to serve, and they will do well in training. At a time when the Liberals have promised 5% of Canada’s GDP to the military, they are cutting the legs out from underneath the very basis, the foundation, that brings people into our military to serve and protect our country. It is very disheartening that there is all this spending but a program like the cadets is being axed when its enrolment is at an all-time high. During a cost of living crisis, a valuable program for parents and families is being pulled out from under their feet. It is just not good enough. Everyone knows we are in a cost of living crisis. It is caused by a few things, mostly by fiscal mismanagement and a Prime Minister who came with a big promise a year and a half ago but has not delivered. Our Canadian dollar is less than or equal to where it was when he was elected. If he is a fiscal guru who is running our economy but our dollar is in the toilet, and everything we import, even gas at the pumps, is costing about 80¢ or 90¢ a litre more than it should because of the weak Canadian dollar, then the government needs to do better. We need Canada to prosper. We have the third-highest amount of natural resources in the world. We should not have deficits. We should be giving out cheques to everybody. Education should be free here. However, the government squashed it. We have a revenue problem and an even more terrible spending problem. It is not good enough, and I will not support this budget.

Clifford Small, Coast of Bays—Central—Notre Dame

Conservative
“The government's dental program is not caring. A senior in my riding was kicked off the program after their income changed and was billed $10,000 for their dentures.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 100 of 100

    Of this reply, 100% addressed the question or point raised.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I am so thankful that the member for Winnipeg North asked me that question. Just a couple of weeks ago, a senior came into our office in Gander. They had been hit with a bill for $10,000. Their eligibility criteria had shifted in a year for some reason or other. Maybe they drew from an RIF or an RRSP, received more pension, or whatever. Their eligibility changed, and they were eliminated from the program. They were handed the bill and told that if they wanted their dentures, they had to bring back the $10,000. Does that sound like a caring program?

Clifford Small, Coast of Bays—Central—Notre Dame

Conservative
“Quebec and other provinces need more money. Quebec has a lot of oil and gas. The government needs to lift the ban on developing these resources so Quebec can make that money.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, obviously it is concerning when provinces are losing out on transfers. However, I mentioned that we have a revenue problem. Quebec needs that money. It has a slight revenue problem. Newfoundland and Labrador has a revenue problem. However, Quebec has lots of oil and gas. It needs the government to lift the ban on developing it, in order to get the revenue flowing in. Then Quebec would be fine.

Clifford Small, Coast of Bays—Central—Notre Dame

Conservative
“I agree that cuts to the cadet program are devastating. Cadets help people join the Canadian Armed Forces. Businesses also know that former cadets make very good workers.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I agree with my colleague 100% on how devastating this is for that key entry point into the Canadian Armed Forces. I will just touch on something else, which was not in my speech. When businesses are hiring youth, they go through their résumés, and when they see that an applicant was a cadet, they know they are getting a really good worker coming into their business.

Grant Jackson, Brandon—Souris

Conservative
“I agree that our immigration system needs to be managed well. Since the member pointed out problems with the system, I want him to say who is responsible for them.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, the member mentioned the need for Canada to have a well-managed immigration system. Conservatives could not agree more. I wonder if that member, after highlighting a number of challenges that exist within Canada’s immigration system, is willing to put on the record today just who is responsible for the flawed immigration system we have in existence in this country right now?

Harb Gill, Windsor West

Conservative
“The Prime Minister called the Stellantis sale a betrayal. But Liberal MPs and officials met with the company months before that announcement. I want the government to give a clear answer: does it oppose this deal, or was it involved in it?”
  • Question or comment in debate

    Relevance 0 of 100

    None of this question addressed the preceding speech or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
  • Question or comment in debate

    Signal 8 of 100

    Much of this statement went to praise, blame, greetings, routine procedure or general stories rather than reasons, requests or specific points.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I know we are debating the budget. However, since the member brought up the credentials of the Prime Minister, people in Windsor are wondering how he can stand in front of Canadians and call the Stellantis sale a “betrayal”. They have also heard that four Liberal MPs toured the plant with Roshel in July, and government officials were meeting with the company months before the announcement. People are wondering if the government is genuinely opposed to the deal or involved in discussions behind closed doors while performing outrage in front of the cameras? Frankly, Canadians are tired of this drama. Can we get some clear answers from the government?

Tamara Kronis, Nanaimo—Ladysmith

Conservative
“The government promised money to expand cadet programs, but it has not delivered it. Cadet activities are being cancelled in my community because of these cuts. The government needs to explain this, and I want the member to work with me right away to restore this funding for our kids.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I want to ask the member a question about the difference between announcements and delivery. In the spring economic update, the government said it was going to provide $195 million over five years, plus $45 million ongoing, to expand cadet programs, yet this week we are seeing the cancellation of many cadet activities in communities like mine because of the government’s failure to provide that funding. It needs to explain why it is making cuts instead of delivering on that promise. I would like to know if the member would commit to working with me immediately, on a short-term basis, to figure out how to get this money back to our kids.

Sukhman Gill, Abbotsford—South Langley

Conservative
“The government is spending too much money and adding hundreds of billions of dollars to the debt. Families now have to pay high interest costs while food and fuel get more expensive. At the same time, the government spent billions on consultants, failed to fix local flood defences in my area, and blocked Canadian oil from reaching global markets. I want the government to remove all federal taxes on diesel until July 2027 to lower costs for truckers, farmers, and families.”
  • A repeated line

    “The Prime Minister promised to spend less.”

    Said 9 times by 8 members since April 28.

    Every time it was said
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, it is always an honour to rise on behalf of the good people of Abbotsford—South Langley. Today, we are talking about one of the most important topics. It is the federal budget that the government is presenting for Canadians. The Prime Minister promised to spend less. Instead, he has ended up spending more on consultants, borrowing more money and making life more expensive for Canadians. His budget should be called “Masters of debt”. The first priority of his budget should have been to save Canadians more money during these hard times, but what did the Prime Minister end up doing? He ended up adding $765 billion to a new debt, a record-smashing sum over the next five years. The Prime Minister will continue to inflate costs, fuel, food and homes. The budget is going to cost the households in Abbotsford—South Langley and nationwide $1.85 billion. Yes, that is billion with a B. This is just the borrowing amount, and it does not include the interest payments on the new debt. In fact, seniors, single moms and small businesses will now have to spend $60 billion each year on interest to bankers and bondholders. Every hard-working family of four in my riding of Abbotsford—South Langley will spend $6,000 a year on interest alone, an amount that rises to $8,100 annually by the year 2030-31. The Liberals are living in a completely different reality from what they are presenting and what they are displaying in front of us. Canadians are forced to cut back at grocery stores, and the Liberals are spending at speeds never seen before. Just last year, they spent over $19 billion on consultants alone, not doctors, not nurses and not hard-working families. They spent $19 billion on consultants. They spent $19 billion on Liberal insiders as well. How much more out of touch can the government possibly be? I want to break this down even further. I want to break it down and highlight how expensive these interest payments truly are. An average family of four in Abbotsford—South Langley, my riding, is spending $1,500 a month on groceries. The amount they will have to pay toward interest in the first year alone is equivalent to a third of their monthly grocery bill. The federal government and the B.C. provincial government signed a deal to expand Roberts Bank terminal two to increase trade and increase container capacity. It is a great plan and a great idea, but if the federal government is looking to increase development, it must also emphasize local infrastructure. We have said this again and again. My colleagues on the Conservative side, including my colleague from Abbotsford, have been advocating this for years now. We have had devastating floods over numerous years, and we have been advocating for our communities to make sure that local infrastructure is up to par. Just this summer, an MOU was signed to create a parallel line alongside the existing energy corridor in the Sumas Prairie region. With investment into our energy sector, it is great news, but without investment into our local infrastructure, our local highways and land development, the new development will leave the local area and the residents vulnerable to floods again. This year marks the five-year anniversary of the tragic floods that happened in the Sumas Valley area. When the floods happened, the residents on the Lower Mainland were told that the floods were due to a once-in-a-century type of storm. In 2025, floods happened again. Thankfully, because the community came together and made sure we were able to pull through in 2021, we had experience, but we are on the verge of another flood. We know winter is around the corner. We know rainfall has started again, and we know we are vulnerable. This is why we advocate to the government. While it allocates new plans for these terminal increases, which are great, we need to make sure our local infrastructure is up to par. This speaks to the larger question of whether or not our local infrastructure will be up to par. The Lower Mainland is gearing up for another season of rain. I have heard from many residents across the Fraser Valley who feel that another flood is bound to happen, not because there is going to be another storm of the century, but rather because local infrastructure has not been maintained. When speaking about the catastrophic flooding in Abbotsford five years ago, poultry farmer Dave Martens told the news, “Any time we hear of rain, there’s always anxiousness.” This is not how our residents should be living. The insecurity Dave and other residents feel increases year after year when the flood prevention mechanisms are not up to par or properly maintained. Energy sector growth is essential and necessary. Development of local infrastructure must be kept up to par so families living around the area do not bear the negative consequences of this growth. However, given the rhetoric and announcements around expansion in B.C., it is not hard to notice the reality on the ground. Just last month, Liberal MPs voted against Bill C-264, which would have repealed the west coast oil tanker ban. Strathcona Resources proposed exporting up to 250,000 barrels of Canadian crude oil daily through Prince Rupert using existing rail infrastructure and a new marine export terminal. The company says it could reach international markets under two years without any government subsidies, which would help Canada diversify energy exports, reduce dependency on the United States and attract private investment. Instead, the tanker ban remains in place, which is limiting our opportunities to bring Canadian oil to the market. The Liberals say they want to make Canada an energy superpower, yet they continue to maintain barriers preventing Canadian energy from reaching these markets. While we are talking about spending money and affordability, it is important to speak about rising food prices as well. The Prime Minister told Canadians to judge him based on the price at the grocery store. If Canadians were to grade the government’s performance, they would definitely give it an F. Food bank usage has hit a record high, with 2.35 million Canadians visiting food banks. It is up 117% since 2019. Archway Abbotsford Food Bank is serving more people than ever before, with a record number of people visiting the food bank. In 2024, the number was only 5,000 people per month. While Canadians are standing in line at the food bank, the Prime Minister fronted a bill of $524,000 for inflight catering. Canadians are told to cut back while the leader of the country is spending luxuriously. Liberals are living in a completely different reality, and it is time to call them out. They are out of touch. Conservatives have been fighting for relief for Canadians, and we will continue to call on the government to eliminate all federal taxes on diesel until at least Canada Day of 2027. The impact of high gas prices goes well beyond the families that are filling up at local gas stations. I think about the farmers, the truckers, the contractors and the small businesses. Fuel is not an option for these Canadians. It is their day-to-day cost of doing business. A trucker cannot deliver goods without diesel, a farmer cannot operate its equipment and machinery without diesel, and a contractor cannot take lumber and tools to a job site on public transit. For millions of Canadians, driving is not a luxury; it is a necessity. It is the way they earn a living, and fuel is built into the cost of living for everything. During a time that Canadians need money in their pockets more than ever, the Liberals have proposed a budget that would increase borrowing and interest costs. The strategy of the Prime Minister went from building at speeds not seen in generations to borrowing at speeds not seen in generations. Canadians deserve real, tangible results. They do not deserve this rhetoric again and again.

Sukhman Gill, Abbotsford—South Langley

Conservative
“The Liberals claim life is more affordable than ever after ten years in power. If that is true, I want to know why food bank lines are longer than ever and why people are struggling to buy food.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 47 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, it is quite funny, because it has been a decade under the Liberal government’s leadership, and its members talk about affordability as being the best it has ever been. I would like to question my hon. member. Why are wait lineups at food banks longer than ever before? Why are Canadians now struggling more than ever just to put food on their tables, if affordability is the best it has ever been?

Tamara Kronis, Nanaimo—Ladysmith

Conservative
“I want the budget to include money to add British Columbia's data into national flood and drought programs. This work saves lives, and weather creates major travel problems in our province.”
  • Question or comment in debate

    Signal 43 of 100

    Much of this statement went to praise, blame, greetings, routine procedure or general stories rather than reasons, requests or specific points.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I want to thank my colleague for focusing on the very real ways that weather impacts our life in British Columbia. We often say that our colleagues here have planes, trains and automobiles, but we add seaplanes, helicopters and ferries, and that missing the ferry is, in fact, an excuse to miss just about everything, up to and including one’s own wedding. I would like the member to expand a little, if he could, on the fact that the national programs on flood and drought do not incorporate British Columbia data, and how important it is to make sure that there is spending in this budget in order to do that integration and that work, which is life-saving.

Sukhman Gill, Abbotsford—South Langley

Conservative
“The government needs to spend money maintaining our trade corridors in British Columbia, including flood protection in the Sumas Prairie. Pipelines, railways, and highways all run through this area. We need this infrastructure in good shape to grow international trade.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 45 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I want to thank the hon. member for Nanaimo—Ladysmith for her great work. She has been a great advocate for her community, and she has always been on top, delivering results. When we talk about food affordability, and droughts as well, and maintaining our B.C. corridor, a great example I gave during the speech is the terminal announcement from the government. Announcements are being made, but we know that it is crucial for infrastructure to be maintained, including flood infrastructure in the Lower Mainland, in the Sumas Prairie region, where everything runs through. We have pipelines, railways and highways that run through it If we want to make sure we can expand B.C.’s portfolio for international trade, that is a main corridor that will impact everything. That is why it is very crucial that we maintain and keep up these corridors. As we are investing in our country, we want to make sure we invest into these corridors.

Sukhman Gill, Abbotsford—South Langley

Conservative
“The government's spending plan is failing, and Canadians are struggling. We need to spend money better, cut taxes, and help Canadians.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I think there are many better ways that money can be spent for Canadians and this country. Right now, the way the government is laying out its plan is failing. Canadians are struggling all over. Our first priority is to make sure we can benefit Canadians, cut back on taxes and deliver results. That is what we are going to be working toward.

Sandra Cobena, Newmarket—Aurora

Conservative
“I oppose this budget. It has no real plan to pay back the money the government borrows, and interest payments now cost more than health care. The government changed accounting words to make the budget look balanced when it is still in deficit, and it hides billions more in debt through Crown corporations. This plan does not help small businesses grow or solve our economic problems. We need to cut spending, lower taxes for small businesses, and remove barriers to investment.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, before I came to Parliament, I worked in commercial banking for 15 years. When someone came in for a loan, we started with two simple questions: How much money is needed, and how is it going to be repaid? I thought all bankers asked the same questions. Then I read the government’s budget and realized that the Prime Minister is a banker who only asks the first question: How much money is needed? I guess that is the difference between a banker who spends his career printing money and one who does not. The reality is that there is no credible plan to repay the debt in this budget. There is only a plan to borrow more, more in five years than Justin Trudeau’s government borrowed in 10, and that includes during COVID. The Prime Minister will be taking on more debt in five years than all prime ministers before 2015 combined. People think that the cover of the budget shows hydro wires. They are, in fact, wrong. The cover shows mountains, and it is a metaphor for the rolling mountains of debt that our children will inherit. Equally scary is how the government has redefined $136 billion in expenses and relabelled them as investments to trick Canadians into believing that it has magically balanced the budget. The Prime Minister has not, in fact, balanced the budget. He has invented an accounting scheme to make the numbers look better, and then, magically, the operating budget is balanced. Under the original definitions, that same budget remains in deficit for at least five more years. The finance minister was asked this very question in the finance committee, and he responded by saying he is doing this for transparency purposes. These are invented definitions used nowhere else in the world that are applied inconsistently and cannot be independently replicated with public information for transparency, and that was not enough. The government then turned to Crown corporations to hide more debt, $262 billion to be exact. There are hundreds of billions of dollars of debt set out in a single sentence in the budget, billions of dollars with one sentence of information without adequate breakdowns, identifying individual corporations, financing purposes or expected financial returns. As it is Crown corporations taking on debt, Canadians do not see it in the deficit numbers, but the obligation to pay is still there. In the upcoming year, the new debt taken on will be $169 billion. That is nearly $10,000 in additional federal borrowing for every Canadian household in just one year. The government focuses Canadians’ attention on the smaller number, the $62-billion deficit number, not on that $169 billion of debt. Interest costs are the fastest-growing expense and cost more than health care. Interest is more than all the GST collected in this country. Canadians deserve straight answers from their government and real solutions. Canada has a productivity problem. Productivity is what allows businesses to pay higher wages, families to enjoy a better standard of living, and governments to afford the services they depend on. When productivity grows, Canadians can earn more without everything having to cost more. When it stagnates, families work harder but struggle to get ahead. After a decade of economic stagnation, Canadians were promised something different. They were promised a prime minister who would spend less and invest more. Instead, they got a Prime Minister who spends more, borrows more and hides more. The Liberals promised houses built at speeds not seen in generations, a single national economy and fiscal prudence, but we got massive amounts of debt. Canada cannot borrow its way to productivity and it cannot spend its way to prosperity. Quite frankly, governments generally have a horrible track record with predicting markets and making sound investments. Let us think about the $50 billion spent on the EV industry, which has now closed down in many respects. We need an economy that rewards hard work, not a government that hand-picks the winners and losers. With the holidays coming up, a survey just found that 62% of Canadians are worried about their finances. For too many families, that worry starts at the grocery store. Last month, Food Banks Canada reported nearly 2.4 million food bank visits in a single month, and a third of those visits were from children. That requires confronting the real obstacles holding back our economy. Canada has an investment problem. Businesses invest in new equipment, technology and facilities when they have confidence in the future. They need affordable energy, predictable regulations, competitive taxes and access to markets, but after years of uncertainty and rising costs, too many Canadian businesses are choosing not to expand. The government points to its productivity mega deduction, and encouraging businesses to invest in new equipment is a positive step, but a tax deduction is of little use to a business that cannot afford to make the investment in the first place. A business cannot write off a machine it cannot afford to buy or reduce the tax burden on profits that do not exist, not to mention that most funds spent purchasing equipment leave Canada, as most equipment is purchased outside of Canada. The C.D. Howe Institute has warned that the government’s productivity measures are far from sufficient. Why? It is because tax incentives alone cannot overcome the broader barriers preventing businesses from investing in Canada. We need to remove those barriers, not simply offer businesses other government incentives to work around them. Canada has a small business problem. In Newmarket—Aurora, I regularly meet with entrepreneurs who have invested their entire life savings into building their businesses. They create jobs, train our young people and support our communities. They are not asking the government to build their businesses for them. They are asking for the opportunity to succeed, yet the government seems far more interested in foreign companies than addressing the daily challenges faced by small and medium-sized businesses that are at the heart of our economy. At the Canadian Federation of Independent Business, they called this budget “mega disappointing”. They asked the government to lower the federal small business tax rate from 9% to 6%. They asked for meaningful regulatory relief and better access to tariff support. Instead, entrepreneurs continue to face high costs and burdens that make it harder to expand. Small businesses do not need another government announcement. They need room to grow from a small business to a medium business to a large business. What does that look like? It means a barrier-free national economy, so businesses can grow nationally. It means less government intervention in the markets, so they do not become dependent on government handouts. It means access to talent. It means a government that moves fast on export loans, projects, permits and infrastructure. Today, we still have only announcements. We do not measure prosperity by how much the government spends. Canadians measure it by whether their wages are rising, whether their businesses can grow, whether their children can have better opportunities than they did, and whether a young family working hard and doing everything right can afford to build a home and a future. That is the real test of this budget. Canada is a country of extraordinary potential. We have natural resources, talented people, remarkable entrepreneurs and every reason to succeed. What we need is a government that trusts Canadians to build that prosperity, that removes obstacles instead of creating new programs, that rewards investment instead of depending on subsidies, and that measures success by results instead of announcements. Prosperity is not something a government can announce into existence. It is something Canadians create through their hard work, ingenuity and determination. It is time we had a budget that helped them do exactly that.

Discussion

No comments yet

See the full discussion

Comment rules

More from sitting 168

  1. Government Orders The Budget 116 statements
  2. Oral Questions Housing 5 statements
  3. Oral Questions Finance 6 statements
  4. Oral Questions The Environment 6 statements
  5. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 7 statements
  6. Oral Questions The Economy 4 statements
  7. Oral Questions Agriculture and Agri-Food 10 statements
  8. Oral Questions Steel and Aluminum Industry 2 statements
  9. Oral Questions Public Safety 2 statements
  10. Oral Questions Public Services and Procurement 2 statements
  11. Oral Questions Government Priorities 2 statements
  12. Oral Questions Infrastructure 2 statements
  13. Oral Questions Government Priorities 5 statements
  14. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 2 statements
  15. Oral Questions Finance 2 statements
  16. Oral Questions Climate Change 2 statements
  17. Oral Questions Industry 3 statements
  18. Oral Questions Business of the House 2 statements
  19. Government Orders The Budget 16 statements
  20. Oral Questions The Environment 2 statements
  21. Oral Questions Steel and Aluminum Industry 2 statements
  22. Government Orders The Budget 8 statements
  23. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 2 statements
  24. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 10 statements
  25. Oral Questions Public Safety 9 statements
  26. Government Orders The Budget 15 statements
  27. Government Orders The Budget 26 statements
  28. Private Members' Business Stand on Guard Act 12 statements
  29. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  30. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  31. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements