“The Liberals are rushing this bill through Parliament. It weakens environmental rules and hurts the rights of workers and Indigenous peoples. The government is rejecting all proposed changes and forcing committee meetings until midnight to wear us down. I want the Liberals to stop rushing and act democratically.”
“Mr. Speaker, anyone wondering what a Liberal majority looks like need only look at the government’s outrageous handling of Bill C-39 and their interference, because that is what this is. The Liberals are trying to ram a bill down Parliament’s throat that weakens environmental laws and undermines the rights of workers and indigenous peoples. They are voting down all of the amendments proposed by civil society by forcing the committee responsible for Bill C-39 to sit until midnight every night in the hopes that the Bloc Québécois will get tired of standing up for citizens. That will not happen. Will the Liberals stop this shift toward authoritarianism and behave like democrats?”
Official Hansard
Mr. Speaker, anyone wondering what a Liberal majority looks like need only look at the government’s outrageous handling of Bill C-39 and their interference, because that is what this is. The Liberals are trying to ram a bill down Parliament’s throat that weakens environmental laws and undermines the rights of workers and indigenous peoples. They are voting down all of the amendments proposed by civil society by forcing the committee responsible for Bill C-39 to sit until midnight every night in the hopes that the Bloc Québécois will get tired of standing up for citizens. That will not happen. Will the Liberals stop this shift toward authoritarianism and behave like democrats?
Loses points more than most for Mockery×2.8Off point×2.2Partly on point×1.7Loses points less than most for AnecdoteAside
Joël Lightbound, Minister of Government Transformation, Public Works and Procurement and Quebec Lieutenant
LiberalLib
“We need to pass this bill because Canadians want us to build things. Reviews will still be strict, but they will take only one year. The bill protects workers and the environment while helping big projects move forward.”
“Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for his question. Under Bill C-39, projects assessments will be just as rigorous, but they will be carried out based on a simple formula: one project, one year, one review. We think it is time to build. That is the mandate we were given by Quebeckers and Canadians. That is exactly what we are doing. We are striking a balance. We want to protect workers’ rights and the environment, because that is essential, while also providing certainty, so that major projects can move forward in Canada.”
Official Hansard
Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for his question. Under Bill C-39, projects assessments will be just as rigorous, but they will be carried out based on a simple formula: one project, one year, one review. We think it is time to build. That is the mandate we were given by Quebeckers and Canadians. That is exactly what we are doing. We are striking a balance. We want to protect workers’ rights and the environment, because that is essential, while also providing certainty, so that major projects can move forward in Canada.
“The Liberals are rushing this bill through the House. It removes environmental checks for pipelines and nuclear projects, skips consultations, bypasses species protection laws, and stops workers from striking. I want to know if the government is rushing because they fear the public will find out what they are doing.”
“Mr. Speaker, the Liberals are holding members and House of Commons staff hostage to rush through Bill C‑39. They want to get rid of impact assessments for pipelines and nuclear projects, despite what was just said. They want to pre-approve projects without waiting for environmental assessments or consultations. They want to get around the Environmental Protection Act and the Species at Risk Act. They want to suspend workers’ right to strike, and they want to start doing all of that as quickly as possible. Are they afraid that the public will find out what they are doing?”
Official Hansard
Mr. Speaker, the Liberals are holding members and House of Commons staff hostage to rush through Bill C‑39. They want to get rid of impact assessments for pipelines and nuclear projects, despite what was just said. They want to pre-approve projects without waiting for environmental assessments or consultations. They want to get around the Environmental Protection Act and the Species at Risk Act. They want to suspend workers’ right to strike, and they want to start doing all of that as quickly as possible. Are they afraid that the public will find out what they are doing?
Loses points more than most for Mockery×2.8Off point×2.2Partly on point×1.7Loses points less than most for AnecdoteAside
Joël Lightbound, Minister of Government Transformation, Public Works and Procurement and Quebec Lieutenant
LiberalLib
“This bill limits project reviews to one year and one review. We can review projects faster without lowering our standards for the environment and workers' rights. Canadians want us to build major projects.”
“Mr. Speaker, I think I explained the principle well: one project, one review, one year, while obviously respecting workers’ rights and the environment. Going faster does not mean we are doing things less rigorously. That is the principle behind Bill C‑39. I would point out to my colleague that many Quebeckers and many Canadians want Canada to build, to diversify our markets and to build major projects. That is indeed the government’s agenda.”
Official Hansard
Mr. Speaker, I think I explained the principle well: one project, one review, one year, while obviously respecting workers’ rights and the environment. Going faster does not mean we are doing things less rigorously. That is the principle behind Bill C‑39. I would point out to my colleague that many Quebeckers and many Canadians want Canada to build, to diversify our markets and to build major projects. That is indeed the government’s agenda.