Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act

Bill C-41, Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act · Second reading · now at committee in the House Where it stands

What Bill C-41 would do

The bill would allow doctors and nurse practitioners to provide medical assistance in dying to a person who has lost the capacity to consent, if the person made an advance request while they still had capacity. To qualify, the person must have been diagnosed beforehand with a serious and incurable condition expected to cause an irreversible loss of capacity, and their province must have a legislative system to store and manage those requests. The bill would also keep the exclusion in place that prevents a person from receiving assisted dying solely for a mental illness.

Official text (opens in a new tab)

17 statements

Marie-Hélène Gaudreau, Laurentides—Labelle

Bloc Québécois
“This debate is about life and death and personal choice. People in unbearable pain should have the right to decide how they face the end of their lives. We are ignoring their wishes and dignity because of fear and religion instead of focusing on care.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I appreciate my colleague’s honest remarks, but I have several questions. I get the impression that we are losing sight of the fundamental issue, which is, at its core, life and death. It is about how we take that final step in our lives, how we embrace it. I am being told that individuals do not have the right to make their own choices, though they may be experiencing unbearable physical suffering, and I am being told that, when the time comes, they are not in a position to decide for themselves how they want to cope with their suffering. I get the impression that people are receiving aggressive treatment in the name of certain religions, when, ultimately, this is about providing care. I think that individuals’ wishes and dignity have been set aside because of the fear of death.

Claude DeBellefeuille, Vallée-du-Haut-Saint-Laurent

Bloc Québécois
“I support letting people ask for medical assistance in dying in advance. But this bill creates confusion with Quebec's law. It makes it unclear if written requests will actually be respected, because it leaves the final choice to doctors. What does my colleague think of this rule?”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I appreciated the speech given by my colleague from Bourassa. I can attest that I, too, have had a great deal of experience with people with dementia, both in my personal life and in my profession as a social worker back in the day. I believe that if these people had had the choice, they would have taken advantage of advance requests. On page 3 of the bill, the eligibility criteria for advance requests are set out. This is where I think there is a problem. There is the following clarification under proposed subsection 4: For the purposes of [the act], the medical practitioner or nurse practitioner must base their opinion that a person is experiencing enduring and intolerable physical or psychological suffering that cannot be relieved through reasonable means on their observations of the person’s current medical state and the information that is available to them, and not solely on the person exhibiting on a recurring basis the clinical manifestations that the person described in their advance request. In my view, this creates confusion regarding the Quebec law. Advance requests must be put in writing, but this paragraph specifies that it is not certain that they will be authorized. It will depend on what clinical practitioners say, and it is not clear whether advance requests will be respected. What does my colleague think of that provision?

Marie-Hélène Gaudreau, Laurentides—Labelle

Bloc Québécois
“This bill is about life and death. It has good rules to protect people and respect their choices when they ask for medical assistance in dying. Quebec has already led the way on this. I want my colleague to stop asking for delays and respect what Quebec has done so we can move forward.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, this bill talks about life and death. With all due respect to my colleague, I would say that the very foundation of this is knowing our safeguards and ensuring that we respect the individual and their dignity in the event of such a request, whether it is an advance directive or a request for medical assistance in dying to avoid palliative care and sedation. As we all know, Quebec has taken the lead, and this bill contains some very good provisions. Does my colleague agree that, even if he wants to take more time, it might be a good idea to respect what Quebec has done so that it can move forward?

Claude DeBellefeuille, Vallée-du-Haut-Saint-Laurent

Bloc Québécois
“Quebec has allowed advance requests for medical assistance in dying for almost two years. The Quebec government asked Ottawa to change the Criminal Code so doctors can carry them out legally. I want to know if the member is completely opposed to Quebec's request.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I do not know whether my colleague is aware, but advance requests have been permitted in Quebec for nearly two years. The Government of Quebec has asked Ottawa to amend the Criminal Code so that it is no longer a criminal offence to act on an advance request made while the patient was competent and capable of providing free and informed consent. Is my colleague saying that he is completely opposed to Quebec’s request, namely that the Criminal Code be amended with respect to advance requests?

Claude DeBellefeuille, Vallée-du-Haut-Saint-Laurent

Bloc Québécois
“I want us to vote for this bill now so a committee can study it and we can pass it. It lets people ask for medical assistance in dying in advance, which Quebec already allows and doctors need legal protection for. Nobody is forced into this. A person chooses it for themselves while they can still make their own choices, and we must respect their wishes even if they seem happy after getting dementia. But I disagree with the part of the bill that permanently bans medical assistance in dying for mental illness. That is unfair to people who suffer for years, and we should keep studying it instead of closing the door.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I am very pleased to rise on behalf of the Bloc Québécois to participate in the debate on Bill C‑41. This bill is particularly important to me because, like anyone who is growing older, I feel personally concerned by the issue it addresses. As members can see from my white hair, I am getting older, and I do think about how I would want my life to end if I were ever diagnosed with dementia. That is why I believe Bill C‑41 is prompting vigorous debates in the House. As a quick reminder, Bill C‑41 has three main objectives. First, it would permanently exclude mental illness as the sole underlying medical condition for medical assistance in dying. I must say that I do not support the idea of imposing a permanent exclusion. In Quebec, we were not ready to provide MAID in such cases, but neither were we prepared to permanently close the door on the possibility. That makes me sad because I used to work in Quebec’s health care system, and I watched people with mental illness suffer for years. I am not talking about depression here. I am talking, for example, about people with schizophrenia, who tried medication and who ended up living on the streets, rejected by many of their loved ones, after exhausting all the resources of the health care system and their family caregivers. Perhaps if they had had the right to end their life with dignity, they might have died in a much more dignified manner. I have been thinking a lot about these people as we prepare to vote on this permanent exclusion. I am sad because I think it is discriminatory, as though people with mental illness do not fully exist as people or do not have the same rights as others. I think that is unacceptable, and I believe that my colleague from Montcalm agrees with me. I expressed this opinion at the Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying. I think medical professionals may not have been ready to administer this type of care, but I believe that we should have continued to study this issue. The reality is that people with mental illness will once again be forced to turn to the Supreme Court to defend their rights. In a few years, they may well succeed. However, it seems profoundly unfair that individuals who are already vulnerable and fragile should bear the burden of fighting for their rights. The bill also establishes a comprehensive framework for advance requests, including eligibility criteria. In doing so, it responds in part to a request made by Quebec, where MAID has been available since 2024 to patients who have made an advance request. As members know, Quebec is currently the only province that allows advance requests for MAID. This framework addresses a very real need. At present, some physicians provide MAID to patients who have made advance requests, yet they continue to face criminal and civil legal uncertainty because the Criminal Code has not been amended. Bill C-41 therefore responds to Quebec’s request. It provides protection for medical practitioners and gives eligible individuals the right to make an advance request for MAID. Advance requests for MAID are based on principles that have been the subject of extensive public debate in Quebec in all sorts of circumstances. Our thinking has evolved considerably. As we know, self-determination is a principle, indeed a value, that is very important in Quebec. People have the right to decide. They have the right to make their own choices, whether that means receiving MAID, opting for palliative care or making an advance request. In response to my Conservative colleagues, advance requests are imposed on no one. It is the individual who makes the request, while still capable of making decisions for themselves, in anticipation of a time when they may feel they are no longer the person they once were. No one is required to have an advance request imposed on them. A person must choose to make such a request, and even then, the fact that a request has been made does not mean it will be carried out when the person or their loved ones ask for it. Self-determination, the right to dignity, and free and informed consent are important. These three principles guide Quebec’s Act Respecting End-of-Life Care. We have made significant progress on this. As for advance requests, some of the provisions in the bill give me pause and cause me concern. That is why we in the Bloc Québécois will give the bill our support in principle so that we can discuss it in greater depth in committee and hear from experts on certain aspects of the bill that, in my view, could call into question people’s true intentions when they draft an advance request. I often provide an example, because people talk about advance requests as though they were something done on a whim, without much thought. I believe, rather, that those who have done so gave it careful consideration. First of all, to have access to care under an advance request, the person has to receive a diagnosis. It is not like they write it into their will, forget about it, and then receive MAID when the will is executed. I sometimes hear the Conservatives say things that give me the impression their perspective is rather simplistic. The request is made when the person is capable of making decisions, has received a diagnosis, and is making decisions about the stage reached. For example, this could be when the person no longer recognizes their husband, wife, children or grandchildren. At this stage, some people prefer that their life end with dignity, rather than die as a different person. In its eligibility criteria clarifications, the bill implies that the request and the criteria set by the person may not always be fully met. This leads us to the whole issue of “happy” dementia. I do not know whether my colleagues have heard of it before. I am a former social worker. I worked in special care units at a local community services and long-term care facility for persons with dementia. To be honest, happy dementia advances the idealized image of a person who wanders a little, causes little bother, smiles, sings, watches television practically all day long, who might knit a little, never makes much of a fuss, no longer recognizes their family members, but can still laugh. It is the person who does not upset the system, but who is a completely different person than they once were. The advance request states that, if that were to happen and I am no longer the same person, I would like to leave with dignity, even if I seem happy. This reminds me of a story. It is not a very pleasant one, but it illustrates my point. When I was a social worker in the special care unit of a long-term care facility, there was a woman who was very attracted to the men in the unit. She was looking for physical intimacy. She would take off all of her clothes. She had lost all her inhibitions. However, we looked into her life story and found out that this woman had devoted her life to Jesus Christ. She was a nun, a member of a religious community. This woman, who had chosen to be celibate and to suppress her sexual desires her entire life, had happy dementia. She was very friendly. However, if she had had the opportunity to make an advance request, would this nun, who had devoted her entire life to Jesus Christ, have wanted to end her days naked and looking for intimacy in the special care unit of a long-term care facility? I do not think that I am wrong in saying that no, she would not have wanted to live out her final days like that. Of course, for the care workers and staff, this behaviour was disturbing but ultimately not that big of a deal. In any case, she was very happy. I would therefore caution against idealizing dementia. We must always take into account the person’s wishes, their free and informed choice when they receive such a diagnosis and make a decision. I encourage my colleagues to adopt the principle of the bill so that we can hear from experts in committee and pass Bill C-41.

Claude DeBellefeuille, Vallée-du-Haut-Saint-Laurent

Bloc Québécois
“I support this bill. Quebec had this debate years ago and moved ahead. This bill lets people ask for medical help to die in advance, but it does not force other provinces to do it. Each province can make its own choice.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 100 of 100

    Of this reply, 100% addressed the question or point raised.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, my colleague is right. We had this societal debate several years ago, and perhaps we moved more quickly than the other provinces. What is interesting about Bill C‑41 is that it does not require other provinces to incorporate advance requests into their practice. It is a matter of choice. If Saskatchewan or other provinces still have questions, so much the better. If they want to draw inspiration from Quebec, hold a public debate and hopefully give people the freedom to choose a dignified death, so much the better.

Claude DeBellefeuille, Vallée-du-Haut-Saint-Laurent

Bloc Québécois
“I support advance requests for medically assisted dying. People should be able to make this choice for themselves while they are still able to make decisions. Nobody is forced into it, and we should respect each person's own wishes.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I appreciate my colleague’s remarks, and I can see that he is giving the issue some thought. That said, I do not think he fully understands the principle behind advance requests. Advance requests exist precisely so that a person who is capable can consent to care, provided the necessary criteria are met. Once a person develops dementia and is declared incapable, that person can no longer make decisions. Advance requests cannot be made once a person is ill or living with dementia. That is not really the issue before us in Bill C‑41. I understand that medical assistance in dying can give rise to ideological debates that are rooted in religious values. I respect my colleague’s perspective, even though I do not share it. The beauty of this is that nothing is mandatory and nothing is imposed. What matters is the individual’s own wishes. Personally, I strongly believe in people’s right to self-determination.

Marie-Hélène Gaudreau, Laurentides—Labelle

Bloc Québécois
“Death is a part of life. If a person made a clear advance request for medical assistance in dying, family members should not overturn it just because dementia changed their personality. People also need to understand that mental suffering hurts just as much as physical suffering.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, my colleague put it very well, but I would go even further for all those who have a hard time accepting that death is a part of life. That is what we are talking about. When a person makes decisions for themselves, who are we as a third party, as a sibling or spouse, to decide whether a personality change caused by dementia alters the situation, especially when the advance request was originally very clear? I would really like people to understand the difference between mental health issues and physical health issues. It is invisible, but it hurts just as much.

Claude DeBellefeuille, Vallée-du-Haut-Saint-Laurent

Bloc Québécois
“I support this bill, and I want the committee to improve and clarify it. If I get dementia, I want to be able to ask for medical assistance in dying in advance, before I stop recognizing the people I love.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Signal 24 of 100

    Much of this statement went to praise, blame, greetings, routine procedure or general stories rather than reasons, requests or specific points.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, if tomorrow I am diagnosed with frontotemporal dementia, Alzheimer’s, vascular dementia, or Korsakoff’s syndrome, I will definitely draw up an advance request. I want to recognize my husband. I am a happy, cheerful, and lively person, and I do not want to end my life not recognizing the people I love and spent my life with. I do not want that. I am grateful that we are able to hold a debate on this issue, and I respect everyone who does not share my opinion. I support the bill and hope that it can be improved and further clarified in committee.

Mario Beaulieu, La Pointe-de-l'Île

Bloc Québécois
“Quebec has allowed advance requests for medical assistance in dying for two years without problems. The rules are clear, and people make these choices while they can still think clearly. My colleague wants to ban advance requests. That ignores years of debate in Quebec. We must not make this practice a crime.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, as my colleague mentioned earlier, advance requests for MAID have been in place in Quebec for the past two years. They have not caused any problems and the rules are very clear. I have experienced this personally with my parents. An advance request may, for example, specify that MAID should be provided when a person no longer recognizes their loved ones, can no longer have meaningful or enjoyable interactions with others, or has become incontinent and is no longer able to care for themselves. These are very specific criteria, and they must be established while the person still has the capacity to make such decisions. It is as though my colleague is suggesting that, once a person has lost that capacity or their memory, they might feel differently. However, that would be completely contradictory. As I understand it, my colleague opposes advance requests altogether. In Quebec, advance requests already exist, and we do not want the practice to be criminalized. My colleague appears to believe that the debate that took place in Quebec over many years is not valid and that advance requests should be rejected.

Sébastien Lemire, Abitibi—Témiscamingue

Bloc Québécois
“The right to life includes the right to die. Medically assisted dying protects people's dignity and lets them choose how and when they die, without unnecessary suffering. Is that not a good reason to support this bill?”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, section 1 of the Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms grants every human being the right to life and to personal security, inviolability and freedom. Quebec society believes that the right to life implies the right to die. In this context, medical assistance in dying must be established as a right that gives individuals the opportunity to avoid terminal suffering and medical paternalism, thereby ensuring their dignity. Allowing MAID means allowing people to choose how, when and where they wish to die, giving them the right to dignity. I would like to hear my colleague’s thoughts on that. Is that not a reason to support the bill?

Marie-Hélène Gaudreau, Laurentides—Labelle

Bloc Québécois
“This bill does not force anyone with dementia to choose medical assistance in dying. Advance requests are a choice, with rules to protect people from being forced. That choice belongs to the person, not to family members who are afraid of losing them.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I want to revisit some of the mechanisms at play. I get the sense that having more choices about our own life has led some people here to conclude that a dementia diagnosis automatically means that the person must request MAID, even when the person does not want to die, as if they are being told that this is how it is and that they have to die. However, that is not the case. Does a person have the right to make an advance request if they wish? There are mechanisms and requirements in place to make sure that nobody is being forced. We want the choice to be made by the person themselves, not by those who are left behind. Nobody wants their loved one to die, that is for sure. I hope that we will be able to make a distinction between the wishes of the individual and the fears of those who will be losing a loved one.

Marie-Hélène Gaudreau, Laurentides—Labelle

Bloc Québécois
“I want this bill to pass. Provinces that are ready to move forward on medically assisted dying should be allowed to do so without waiting for the rest of the country.”
  • Question or comment in debate

    Clarity 26 of 100

    Much of this statement used imprecise wording, lacked details on timing or responsibility, or made broad claims without support.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, members of the Bloc Québécois are often told that they love arguing for the sake of arguing. Seriously, though, I think that some of us enjoy worthwhile debates. I am proposing that provinces that are ahead of the curve and that need to apply what they have studied and implemented be allowed to move forward while the arguing in this place carries on. Eventually, the other provinces and territories will get their turn.

Mario Beaulieu, La Pointe-de-l'Île

Bloc Québécois
“I support this bill. We have debated advance requests for medical assistance in dying for a long time, and they already work well in Quebec. People should have the right to decide when to stop their own suffering, including people with Alzheimer's disease. This bill protects that choice under strict rules in provinces that allow it, and the member is trying to stop that.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I do not know whether my colleague is aware, but we have been debating medical assistance in dying and advance requests for quite some time now. This has been debated here in Parliament for a very long time, and it has been debated in Quebec for a very long time. Quebeckers can already make advance requests for MAID, and this is not a problem. We believe that people should have the freedom to decide when they want to stop suffering. There are very specific conditions and guidelines for advance requests. The same applies to people with Alzheimer’s disease and other such conditions. Basically, the bill simply decriminalizes MAID or advance requests in provinces that already have an existing regime and where the possibility of it being criminalized might cause problems. My colleague wants to prevent that.

Sébastien Lemire, Abitibi—Témiscamingue

Bloc Québécois
“I am worried about this bill permanently banning medically assisted dying for people whose only illness is mental illness. This debate is not finished, and this ban could discriminate against them. I want to know if the member thinks we can improve the bill in committee.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, as we know, this bill does three main things, one of which is to permanently exclude mental illness as the sole underlying condition for MAID. Obviously, we are concerned about the government’s plan to permanently exclude mental illness as the sole underlying condition. We consider the debate unfinished and believe that such an exclusion could discriminate against people with a mental illness. Does my colleague think that the bill could be further improved upon in committee? Does he intend to contribute to the effort?

Marie-Hélène Gaudreau, Laurentides—Labelle

Bloc Québécois
“We need criminal laws to punish people who try to end human lives outside the rules. Quebec has already shown this works to fill any gaps. Does the member agree?”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, my colleague is concerned about edge cases, as am I, of course. That being said, when the government wants to enact legislation and add laws to the Criminal Code, is it not specifically to make sure, for those charlatans or so-called fanatics who want to do away with human life, that it would be a crime? It is clear from all the evidence, as well as what has already been done proactively in Quebec, that if there are any gaps, that is where the Criminal Code comes in. Does my colleague not agree with me?

Marie-Hélène Gaudreau, Laurentides—Labelle

Bloc Québécois
“People want to live, but suffering is hard to deal with. We need to separate legal rules from human suffering. I want us to focus our debate on how hard it is for people to cope with their pain.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, my colleague mentioned Sue Rodriguez. Yes, we know this was back in the 1990s, but it affected my family in 2017. In 2015, my father took part in all the studies examining medical assistance in dying. The first thing he told me was that I should not worry, that he was eligible, but that there would not be a big lineup of people wanting to die, because human beings want to live. I would like us to make a clear distinction between what falls under the Criminal Code, that is, the legal aspect, and human suffering. Does my colleague agree that we need to get back to the substance of the issue, namely how difficult it is for a human being to cope with their suffering?

Discussion

No comments yet

See the full discussion

Comment rules

More from sitting 165

  1. Private Members' Business Youth Criminal Justice Act 5 statements
  2. Government Orders Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act 37 statements
  3. Government Orders Government Orders 23 statements
  4. Statements by Members Ordre National du Mérite Agricole 2 statements
  5. Oral Questions The Economy 6 statements
  6. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 2 statements
  7. Oral Questions The Environment 6 statements
  8. Oral Questions The Budget 4 statements
  9. Oral Questions The Economy 4 statements
  10. Oral Questions Public Services and Procurement 2 statements
  11. Oral Questions Government Priorities 4 statements
  12. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 4 statements
  13. Oral Questions The Economy 10 statements
  14. Oral Questions Housing 2 statements
  15. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 19 statements
  16. Oral Questions Labour 2 statements
  17. Oral Questions Public Services and Procurement 6 statements
  18. Oral Questions Taxation 2 statements
  19. Oral Questions Committees of the House 2 statements
  20. Oral Questions Parks Canada 2 statements
  21. Government Orders Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act 95 statements
  22. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 4 statements
  23. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  24. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  25. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements