The Budget

The House debated the government’s Budget 2026, which members described as covering cost-of-living help, affordable housing, local infrastructure, investments in Canadian technology, immigration measures for worker shortages, and national defence. Liberal members argued the budget helps people with everyday costs, makes the caregiver tax credit fully refundable, targets low- and middle-income households through tax cuts, and builds long-term economic growth. Conservative members said the government’s spending plan is not working, pointing to about $85 billion in interest payments over five years, and called for lower taxes and tighter control of spending. The Bloc Québécois argued the budget falls short on health care transfers to Quebec and the provinces, and raised concerns about free park admission for foreign visitors while park jobs are cut. The NDP raised a funding gap between East Coast and West Coast ferry services, and members also exchanged views on the Alto high-speed rail project and its effect on farmland.Written by AI from the debate. Updated .

Official text (opens in a new tab)

116 statements

Jason Groleau, Beauce

Conservative
“Any good plan needs discipline. The government needs discipline with its budget, and it does not have any.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 48 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for her excellent question. She said that a plan is needed in both sports and business. However, the most important plan is discipline. In your case, we are talking about budgetary discipline, and you do not have any.

Jasraj Hallan, Calgary East

Conservative
“I will vote against this budget. It spends and borrows too much, and the national debt will soon reach $1.6 trillion. That debt interest will cost more than what we transfer for health care. Life is getting more expensive, food bank use has doubled, and fewer homes are being built. Instead of helping Canadians or cutting fuel taxes, this budget wastes money on foreign projects and benefits rich bankers.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, the Liberal Prime Minister will do the impossible. Believe it or not, he will outspend Justin Trudeau. What Justin Trudeau spent in 10 years, the Prime Minister took as a challenge, saying, “Hold my champagne. I’ll do that in half the time.” That is exactly what is happening with this costly credit card budget. It might be funny to some, but it is not funny to struggling Canadians. In fact, food bank usage has doubled since 2019 and is only going up. The 2.35 million Canadians who visit a food bank every single month because of bad Liberal policies are not seeing anything that will help them inside this budget, as usual. This is coming from the Prime Minister who said he would spend less. That was his promise. What did he do right after that? He doubled Justin Trudeau’s deficit, which was, we thought, the most impossible thing that could have happened. This, again, is just another costly credit card budget. It is not Canadians who are going to benefit from this. We all know it is the Prime Minister’s banker, bondholder and Brookfield buddies who are very happy about this budget because they will benefit the most. The PBO confirmed this. She has a scathing report that came out just days ago to prove, in her own words, that this budget is more spending, more debt and more borrowing, with fewer results. Let us start off with that first, the debt and deficit that are going up exponentially with this budget. By 2030-31, the budget itself projects, there will be a total federal debt of almost $1.6 trillion. That is an increase in the federal debt by $287 billion over the next five years. Now, a lot of people may not understand or be able to put that into terms, so let us shorten that down to what it means for Canadians. It means that over the next five years with this continued spending, which we know is a minimum for the government because it always blows through its own targets, in 2030, every single Canadian will have to pay $2,000 more just in debt interest costs. That means money is being taken out of struggling Canadians’ pockets and is being sent to the Prime Minister’s banker and bondholder buddies sitting on Bay Street. Bay Street is getting the benefits, while Main Street gets the bill. Canadians will have to foot the bill for these expensive experiments that the Prime Minister always runs. By then, and every year from now until then, believe it or not, there is going to be more money going toward interest on the debt than what goes to health care transfers to the provinces. Again, it is more money to the Prime Minister’s banker, bondholder and Brookfield buddies and less money to nurses and doctors and the health care system, which has already been made worse. This does not translate well for the government, as usual. Under the Liberal government, an average family already pays more in Liberal taxes than they do for food, shelter and clothing combined. That is why insolvencies are up. That is why food bank usage is up. Every Canadian we talk to tells us about their struggles. Things are getting more expensive because the more government spends, the more things get expensive. We do not have to go further than the grocery store to see what bad Liberal policies do to the price of groceries, and yet the government decided it would spend more and make things worse for Canadians. Another big issue in this country is housing. I will just start off by quoting the PBO again. She proved that the government is spending more on housing with worse results, and that is backed up by the government’s own housing agencies. The Liberals are going to quadruple the spending on housing since 2015, yet housing starts will go down. Any youth we talk to in this country will tell us one thing: that the dream of home ownership is dead under the Liberals. Unless someone has the bank of mom and dad, there is no way they can save up for a down payment on a house today. The youth are the ones suffering the most. Not only have the Liberals driven out jobs and good wages to the U.S. with their bad policies, but they have made housing and home ownership basically impossible. This is the same government, the same Prime Minister who promised two things in the election. He said, number one, that we were going to build at speeds not seen since the Second World War. The second promise was that the government would build 500,000 new homes every single year. The number one thing I noticed that was missing in the entire hundreds of pages of this budget was both of those promises. The Liberals tried to sneakily and quietly get rid of both those promises, which is proven by their own housing agencies. The housing minister is a failed mayor of Vancouver. In fact, when he was the mayor of Vancouver, Vancouver’s housing affordability was the second-worst in the entire world. He promised in 2008 that he would end homelessness by 2015. The Liberals made the former mayor the housing minister. Just yesterday, when he was pushed on this by reporters, he blamed it on Canadians. He said that he can’t “force Canadians to build”. Why then did the Liberals make the promise in the first place? It is their failed policies that are over and over again leading to young people’s not being able to get into new homes. On top of that, new homes are not being built, because of the amount of red tape. The government is well known for shovelling billions of dollars into new bureaucracies and municipalities that just create more bureaucracies, but it does not tie it to anything, and that is why housing starts are going down in this country. Again, it is always the youth who have to suffer for bad Liberal policies. With all this spending the government is doing, I do not think Canadians would mind if we were sending money overseas to help our allies or using it for something that would actually benefit Canadians. However, that is not what Canadians are seeing. What they are seeing is really troubling, woke funding going into foreign funding. For example, the government is well known for sending millions of dollars’ worth of taxpayer money to Vietnam for something called gender-just rice, which is something I do not think many Canadians have heard of. In fact, I have been asked about it, and people are saying they did not know rice had a gender, yet the government, in all of its woke policies, is sending millions of taxpayer dollars out of this country to support gender-just rice. Another example is that the government is sending tens of millions of dollars to Congo for a woke project of bean farming. The government is attacking our farmers with higher taxes and putting in policies that would help reduce the amount of fertilizer that can be used. It is making it more expensive to farm here, but woke farming projects abroad are okay with the Liberals. Just recently, unknown to Canadians because the Liberals did not tell them in the first place, they are going to be sending half a billion dollars to Brazil for its rainforest. They want Canadians to pay so Brazil does not destroy its own rainforest. Maybe we should use that money here for Canadians or give that money back to Canadians so we can lower their costs. That is exactly what Conservatives asked for and exactly what we would do. Conservatives would cut the wasteful spending, stop the borrowing and make sure that money stays in Canadians’ pockets. We would lower the cost of fuel in this country by removing the industrial carbon tax and the Liberals’ clean fuel standard, which is just another carbon tax, and we would remove the GST from that. Not only would that make farming and trucking less expensive, but at the pump, Canadians would also feel the relief immediately. Those were the demands from Conservatives. That is what we are going to continue pushing for. Since those demands were not met, as usual, and Canadians will not have more in their pocket, Conservatives will vote against this budget.

Kevin Lamoureux, Parliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Liberal
“I want to know if the Conservatives support our new tax deduction for businesses. It lasts for one year and helps businesses of all sizes modernize and grow. It will help the economy, so everyone should support it.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I would love to hear a Conservative say that they very clearly support the productivity mega deduction. I would argue that is money everyone should be supporting. It supports small businesses, medium-sized businesses and large businesses in terms of technological changes or modernization but also to expand. We are bringing in the deduction for a one-year period. I would think the Conservatives would support that initiative. After all, it is going to create more growth in our economy. Can the member give a clear indication of whether or not the Conservative Party will endorse the productivity mega deduction?

Jasraj Hallan, Calgary East

Conservative
“The member talks a lot but says nothing. Canadian businesses need the Liberal government to cut taxes, red tape, and spending. Because of Liberal policies, $1 trillion in Canadian investment has left for the U.S. over the last 10 years, taking our jobs with it. Young people are suffering because the government keeps raising taxes and borrowing money instead of helping businesses.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 45 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, what Canadians would want is a mega deduction in the number of words the member collects in the House. He says a lot, but he says nothing at the same time. What Canadians and businesses really need is for the Liberal government to get out of the way, lower taxes and create a better business environment. It has piled on red tape, more bureaucracy and more spending. That is why, over the last 10 years, $1 trillion of Canadian investment has fled to the U.S., because it easier to invest, and that is where all our jobs are going. Youth is suffering because of bad policies by the Liberal government, which does not understand that we cannot make money by raising taxes and raising the amount of money it borrows. It needs to do the exact opposite so we have a better business environment.

Steven Bonk, Souris—Moose Mountain

Conservative
“Too many rules are hurting Canadian farmers, yet the government wants to open our market to South American competitors. The government is also sending $560 million to Brazil. The Prime Minister used to help run a company that cleared thousands of hectares of Brazilian rainforest. I am asking my colleague if this money is just the Prime Minister trying to make up for his bad environmental record.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague has such a great grasp of finances and how this country should be run. He mentioned agriculture a lot in his speech. He mentioned the over-regulation of our Canadian agriculture sector. Canadian farmers are facing real pains right now, yet the Liberal government is considering opening up our market to the Mercosur countries, for example. To make it even worse, he mentioned the money that is going to Brazil, to the rainforest. Our Prime Minister was the vice-chair of a company called Brookfield, which levelled 9,000 hectares of rainforest in Brazil. Does my hon. colleague think the $560 million that is going to Brazil is maybe a way for the Prime Minister to make amends for the disastrous ecological record he has?

Jasraj Hallan, Calgary East

Conservative
“The Prime Minister makes decisions that help his wealthy friends and companies like Brookfield. The government's extra borrowing and spending benefits his banker friends, who make money off interest paid by Canadians. One of his close friends got money through Telesat, and now the Prime Minister is trying to block any investigation into it.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Respect 81 of 100

    This statement targeted a person rather than their actions or views: “Any decision that is made by the Prime Minister always makes people think about how Brookfield will benefit from that…”.

    See full analysis
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 100 of 100

    Of this reply, 100% addressed the question or point raised.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my great friend from Souris—Moose Mountain for his advocacy for farmers and for struggling Canadians across Canada. He is absolutely right. Any decision that is made by the Prime Minister always makes people think about how Brookfield will benefit from that decision. It happens all the time. Just recently, Telesat was another example of this. It is always his buddies who end up benefiting. I highlighted how when they increase borrowing and spending, that benefits the Prime Minister’s banker and bondholder buddies because they get interest payments on the backs of Canadians. Just now with Telesat, it was our team, our Conservatives, who called out that it was one of his close friends who is going to get that funding. Now all of a sudden, after the fact, he puts a screen on himself so he cannot be investigated further. There are more and more examples of what makes people think about who is benefiting when the Prime Minister makes a decision, and it is always Brookfield.

Marilyn Gladu, Sarnia—Lambton—Bkejwanong

Liberal
“We are running deficits to invest in Canada during hard economic times. Prime Minister Stephen Harper did the exact same thing in 2008. Does the member think Harper was wrong to do that then?”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, the member opposite was talking about deficits. Certainly, we are investing in Canada to help it get through a turbulent economic time. In 2008, it was then prime minister Stephen Harper who was working with our current Prime Minister and Jim Flaherty to run deficits to invest in Canada’s economy. Does the member think Prime Minister Harper was wrong to do that at the time?

Jasraj Hallan, Calgary East

Conservative
“The member showed poor character by crossing the floor to join this corrupt government. Conservative decisions got Canada through the 2008 recession. This Liberal government does not know how to manage the economy. It drove jobs away, raised costs, and made Canadians poorer.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Respect 76 of 100

    This statement targeted a person rather than their actions or views: “a time when the member actually spoke with some common sense and actually cared for Canadians”.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I remember a time when the member actually spoke with some common sense and actually cared for Canadians. Now all she has done is cross the floor to one of the most expensive and corrupt governments, but it just shows more of what her character is like. In fact, it was former prime minister Stephen Harper who said it was not the Prime Minister who helped throughout that time, but it was the decisions made by the common-sense Conservative government that got Canadians out of a bad time during a world recession. Compare that to the current government, which went through the same, but all it did was increase costs for Canadians and made our economy worse. It drove jobs out of this country, and it made Canadians poorer. There is a stark difference between a common-sense Conservative government and a Liberal government that clearly does not know how to manage the economy, with the Prime Minister, the so-called banker, who has done nothing but run this economy into the ground.

Giovanna Mingarelli, Prescott—Russell—Cumberland

Liberal
“I support Budget 2026. It helps rural communities like mine with the cost of living, housing, and farming. It gives billions of dollars to build homes, support farmers dealing with tariffs, promote Francophone culture, and improve rural internet and recreation.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my time with the member for Vaughan—Woodbridge. I rise today to speak to budget 2026, “Masters of our destiny”, and what it means for the people of Prescott—Russell—Cumberland. I meet regularly with farmers, families, seniors and business owners who are grappling with the challenges of our time. Although their circumstances may differ, they often express concerns about the same things, namely affordability, housing, economic prospects and whether the next generation will be able to stay in our communities and thrive there. I am proud to say that budget 2026 addresses those priorities by strengthening our rural communities, supporting our families and creating new opportunities for the future. Agriculture is part of Prescott—Russell—Cumberland’s history, identity and pride and has been for generations. It shapes our economy and brings generations together through shared expertise. At a time when tariffs and global market uncertainty continue to create challenges for our farmers, budget 2026 provides for practical support for the agricultural industry. For example, the modernization of the Canadian Agricultural Loans Act will improve access to capital and support intergenerational farm transfers. Since 2025, the federal government has announced nearly $44 billion in support for workers and businesses impacted by tariffs, including $20.6 billion to help key sectors like agriculture adapt, modernize and access new markets. For our local farmers and agri-food businesses, the budget provides support through investments in Canada’s scientific research and experimental development tax incentive program, the productivity superdeduction and the continuation of the implementation of Canada’s $3.2-billion national food security strategy, helping them grow, innovate and expand into new markets. For agricultural businesses such as Wilson Farms in Vankleek Hill, these investments create new opportunities for growth and resilience. The people of Prescott—Russell—Cumberland are proud Franco-Ontarians. It is the only majority francophone riding in our predominantly English-speaking province. This reality shapes our institutions, our culture and our daily lives, and it is a precious heritage that must be preserved. The budget includes $134 million over four years to support local media across the country, as well as $20 million over four years to help Canadian creators tell our stories. It also supports the promotion of Canada’s francophone community in the lead-up to the 2028 Francophonie summit. For our region, this means more support for the organizations, festivals and community spaces keeping our Franco-Ontarian heritage alive, from Le Chenail to the Richelieu clubs in Hawkesbury and Embrun. It also means help for local newspapers such as Le Reflet, The Review and Vision. The budget also allocates more than $390 billion to support the arrangements required to host the 2028 Francophonie summit in the national capital region. For Prescott—Russell—Cumberland, this summit represents a unique opportunity to showcase the Canadian francophonie and the Franco-Ontarian community to the 90 member states coming from all over the world. Together, these measures help to build vibrant communities that are proud of their roots and confident in their future. Too many young families tell me that they want to stay in the community where they grew up. We are fortunate to live in a region where it is possible to raise a family, build a career and contribute to the community, yet many are wondering whether they will still be able to afford to live here. That is why budget 2026 includes $44.7 billion over 11 years to support housing construction. With these investments, we are building stronger communities, including those in Prescott—Russell—Cumberland. The budget also provides $2 billion to renovate up to one million homes across Canada. For families in our region, this could mean housing that better meets their needs and remains affordable over the long term. Ultimately, these investments will help young people build their future close to home, help families find affordable housing and help seniors remain in the communities they helped build. In a riding as vast as Prescott—Russell—Cumberland, connectivity is essential. The investments in rural telecommunications will give more residents access to better Internet and cell coverage and provide more choice and more affordable services. These measures will strengthen participation in the modern economy no matter where a person lives. Budget 2026 invests $1.5 billion in sports and recreation infrastructure, including arenas and skating rinks, which play a vital role in community life. By the way, it was a pleasure to host the Hon. Gregor Robertson and the Hon. Adam van Koeverden in Embrun last week—

Giovanna Mingarelli, Prescott—Russell—Cumberland

Liberal
“I support this budget. It helps my riding by supporting small businesses, funding ten-dollar-a-day child care, and giving more tax help to family caregivers.”
Official Hansard

I apologize, Mr. Speaker. They were there to make a post-budget announcement highlighting the practical benefits of these investments for families in our region. Small and medium-sized businesses are at the heart of the economy of Prescott—Russell—Cumberland. The last few years have not been easy and I regularly speak with entrepreneurs across our region who continue to face significant challenges and uncertainty. This summer, I had the pleasure of visiting businesses such as Robinson Greenhouses in Clarence-Rockland, Gibbs Honey in Vankleek Hill, the Fromagerie in St-Albert, La Binerie in Plantagenet, Sunrise Bites in Navan, and the Black Walnut Bakery in Cumberland. They all contribute greatly to our regional economy. Budget 2026 includes measures such as the regional tariff response initiative to support business innovation, productivity and growth, helping our entrepreneurs invest, adapt and remain competitive. Supporting small businesses means protecting local jobs, preserving services close to home and strengthening our regional economy. With these tools, we are empowering our communities to become masters of their own destiny. Budget 2026 also continues to support families through the early learning and child care agreements. In growing communities like ours, access to affordable child care creates new opportunities for families. The investments in $10-a-day child care and the creation of new spaces will allow more parents to participate in the workforce while supporting children’s development. The budget also recognizes the vital role played by family caregivers. In Canada’s many communities, thousands of caregivers support loved ones every day. In a rural region like mine, caregivers play an irreplaceable role. The enhancements to the Canada caregiver credit will provide additional support and recognize the immense contribution that caregivers make to our communities. A budget is about much more than a series of numbers. It is a reflection of our priorities, our values and the country we want to build together. For Prescott—Russell—Cumberland, this budget is an investment in people. It recognizes the contributions of our families, workers, farmers, businesses and community organizations, while creating new opportunities for future generations. I am proud to support measures that will help Prescott—Russell—Cumberland be strong and resilient and make it a place where people choose to live, work, raise their families and build their futures.

John Barlow, Foothills

Conservative
“This budget speeds up the Alto train project, which will ruin good farm land in Ontario and Quebec. Farmers and business owners in the member's riding are upset that she is not listening to them. I want to know if she supports speeding up this project.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I appreciate my colleague’s speech and the fact that she said she visited many businesses over the summer. This budget fast-tracks the construction of the Alto high-speed rail project, which would devastate tens of thousands of acres of prime agriculture land across Ontario and Quebec, including in her riding. I heard first-hand from dozens of farmers and business owners in her riding who are very frustrated by the fact that their Liberal member of Parliament is not listening to their concerns. Does my colleague support fast-tracking the Alto high-speed rail project in this budget? Does she support that project and the impact it would have on the farmers and businesses in her own riding?

Giovanna Mingarelli, Prescott—Russell—Cumberland

Liberal
“I have met with dozens of farmers and business owners in my riding about this rail project. I know their concerns and I send them regular updates.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 47 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I have also met with dozens of farmers and business owners across Prescott—Russell—Cumberland throughout the year. I have hosted three separate round tables in the riding and have been in an active conversation with all of the constituents. I am deeply compassionate about their concerns. I am well-versed in all of the concerns of the riding, and I do issue regular updates to our community with updates on the project. I would like to thank you for your questions and also for your compassion for my constituents.

Linda Lapointe, Rivière-des-Mille-Îles

Liberal
“I want the member to say more about how handing down family farms affects people in her rural riding. She also spoke about tax credits for caregivers.”
  • Question or comment in debate

    Relevance 0 of 100

    None of this question addressed the preceding speech or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
  • Question or comment in debate

    Signal 26 of 100

    Much of this statement went to praise, blame, greetings, routine procedure or general stories rather than reasons, requests or specific points.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I thank my hon. colleague, whom I hold in very high regard. She does excellent work for her riding and represents it very well. Her speech touched on several positive things, including the Canada caregiver credit. She also spoke about intergenerational transfers of family farms. I would like her to elaborate on that, given that this issue affects her riding, which has a large rural population. She is also a proud Franco-Ontarian, and I support her wholeheartedly.

Giovanna Mingarelli, Prescott—Russell—Cumberland

Liberal
“I support our budget. It helps local farmers, supports workers and natural resources, and gives new money to our local economy.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I am very proud that our budget includes support for farmers in Prescott—Russell—Cumberland. This year’s budget focuses on workers and natural resources, while providing new funding to support the local economy and all of our communities.

Grant Jackson, Brandon—Souris

Conservative
“The member did not say if she supports fast-tracking the Alto project. The budget spends a lot of money on Alto while cutting the cadets program in two provinces. She should not support a budget that funds this project instead of kids in cadets.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, previously the member had been asked about Alto. She did not answer the question about whether she actually supports the fast-tracking of Alto. We also know that there is a huge amount budgeted for it in the government’s expenditures, yet the Liberals would be cutting the cadets program in two provinces in this country. How can that member possibly support this as a good budget, when the budget would be financing Liberal vanity projects like Alto on the backs of kids in our cadets program?

Giovanna Mingarelli, Prescott—Russell—Cumberland

Liberal

Linked statement

“The high-speed rail project will help many Canadians. It strongly affects my riding, and I am talking with my constituents about it, especially farmers. I will stay closely involved.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Clarity 48 of 100

    Much of this statement used imprecise wording, lacked details on timing or responsibility, or made broad claims without support.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, the Alto high-speed rail project is a generational project that that would support a very large portion of the Canadian population through its revenues. It is a project that my riding is deeply affected by, and I am continuing to be in active conversation with constituents, especially with the farming community. It is something that I will continue to be very deeply involved with in the near future.

Marianne Dandurand, Compton—Stanstead

Liberal
“The budget supports local news by making a journalism program permanent and expanding a tax credit to more private news broadcasters. I want my colleague to tell me how important local media is in her region and who is doing good work there.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, it is safe to say that I will be talking about local media. There are two important initiatives in the budget. First, there is the local journalism initiative, which will be made permanent. Second, there is the 35% the Canadian journalism labour tax credit, will be expanded to include private audio and audiovisual news organizations. I would like my colleague to tell me about the importance of local media in her region. Who is doing good work there?

Giovanna Mingarelli, Prescott—Russell—Cumberland

Liberal
“Local news outlets are vital to our communities. They cover local issues and support French-speaking people, who make up most of my riding. This new money will help our communities and support both official languages.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 47 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for that great question. Local media outlets are the lifeblood of Prescott—Russell—Cumberland and communities across Canada. Crucially, they draw attention to local issues and support the francophonie, especially in Prescott—Russell—Cumberland, where nearly 60% of the population is Franco-Ontarian. My riding is predominantly francophone. I believe that this new funding will help support both official languages and enable local communities to thrive.

Michael Guglielmin, Vaughan—Woodbridge

Conservative
“I do not support this budget. The government claims to balance parts of it, but it uses fake accounting to hide billions in deficits and new debt. It spent almost all the extra money from high oil prices instead of lowering the deficit. Interest on our debt is rising fast and will soon cost more than our health-care transfers. The government needs to be honest about its real borrowing numbers and its spending on projects and housing.”
  • A repeated line

    “A former governor of the Bank of Canada.”

    Said 8 times by 8 members since April 28.

    Every time it was said
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise and speak on the budget in the House of Commons today. Before I do, I would like to begin by giving a shout-out. I would first like to recognize the 10th anniversary of the Newman Global Initiative, founded a decade ago by Matthew Newman when he was just nine years old. This grassroots effort has grown from our community in Vaughan—Woodbridge into a dedicated network for young leaders. Over the past 10 years, the initiative has contributed over half a million dollars in community support and more than 5,700 hours of community service. From supporting educational and shelter projects internationally in India, Italy and Peru to local food security and youth programs here in Vaughan—Woodbridge, their work addresses real communities’ needs through direct action. This milestone is a tribute to our student volunteers, sponsors and supporters. I invite my colleagues to join me in congratulating the Newman Global Initiative on 10 years of service. The Liberals have titled this budget “Masters of our destiny”, but Canadians are not sold on this picture painting by the Liberal government. After reviewing the numbers and seeing what is inside this budget, I think the title masters of fiscal illusion might be a little more appropriate. Repeatedly we have heard from the Liberals that they are going to spend less and invest more, yet they committed almost all of their new fiscal room. They claim to balance operations using a definition that excludes $135 billion that would not qualify as capital investment in any internationally recognized accounting standards. Behind the headline, deficits sit at nearly $765 billion in new borrowing over the next five years. Members do not have to take my word for it. The Parliamentary Budget Officer delivered her verdict already earlier this week. She said, “This budget spends more, invests more and borrows more.” Canadians will pay real interest on this fiscal illusion. On Tuesday, the Parliamentary Budget Officer released a damning report on the fiscal track and sustainability of the Liberal budget. The PBO identified over $158 billion in new fiscal room that was largely granted to them due to an increase in oil prices over the recent months as a consequence of the war, which gave the Liberals an opportunity to demonstrate that they were actually prudent fiscal managers of our fiscal position. However, instead, what did they do? They went ahead and spent 96% of that newly found revenue on government programs. This, despite many economists urging the government to be cautious, saying that “those revenue increases should not be expected to continue.” According to the PBO, without the Liberals’ reckless spending measures, this year’s deficit could have fallen to around $43 billion, and in five years, it could have then fallen to $20 billion. They could have actually demonstrated here that we were on some sort of path to deficit recovery, but instead, they chose a path that leaves the deficit at $53 billion five years from now. Oxford economists labelled the Liberals’ budget as a “missed opportunity to lower the deficit and save” the future for the people of this country. This has not come as a surprise to Canadians at this point. We have become so accustomed over the past number of years to successive Liberal governments pushing the absolute limits of the public purse. The last few years have marked the worst fiscal stretch in Canadian history, with seven of the eight highest being the last seven consecutive years. The Liberals keep redefining their own fiscal anchors to fit their illusion to the Canadian taxpayer. Let us take, for example, that the Liberals dropped the declining debt-to-GDP ratio as their fiscal anchor before proceeding to take on historic levels of debt. The obscene federal debt is now projected to rise to $1.6 trillion in five years. Even the International Monetary Fund has recommended that the Liberal government restore its debt-to-GDP ratio as a primary fiscal anchor for Canada, saying that it would “strengthen discipline, transparency, and credibility” for future borrowing and the finances of this country. The PBO added, “Sustainability is commonly assessed by whether the debt-to-GDP ratio is stable or declining over the long term.” Those are her words. The Liberals instead point to their promise of balancing the operating budget, a term we are becoming more and more accustomed to hearing. That promise depends on what it calls “capital investments”. We hear them over and over again say that they are not spending, that they are making capital investments. That is why I use the phrase “fiscal illusion”, because that term, capital investment, and the way they are categorizing all of this really does reveal the real illusion that is at play with the budget. The PBO commented at the finance committee earlier this week that the Liberals list over $135 billion as so-called capital investments that would not qualify as capital investment under internationally recognized standards. If the $135 billion was appropriately treated as operating spending, the operating budget would remain in a deficit every single year for the next five-year forecast, despite the Liberal government’s claiming that it has met its fiscal anchor. That is the problem with the government’s marking its own homework. Its apparent success depends on a definition that it itself has chosen. I challenge the finance minister to table both calculations, so that Canadians can see exactly how much of this claimed balance comes from the government’s own made-up classifications. Canadians also deserve the full picture of federal borrowing. Over five years, the budget projects deficits totalling $289 billion. Its borrowing requirements total $765 billion. That is a gap of $476 billion. Neither of the government’s fiscal anchors places a ceiling on the cash borrowing requirements. When it comes to major projects like the Alto project, I had the transport minister at the finance committee. He seemed to suggest there was no ceiling to how much this project could cost. We hear the PBO say it could reach as high as $260 billion or more. It is a total waste of taxpayer dollars. Parliament should know who receives money, what return is expected and what happens if repayments fall short. Calling something an investment creates an obligation to demonstrate its value to taxpayers. Public debt charges are the fastest-growing expense for the government. This year, debt charges will cost $60.2 billion, reaching $85.5 billion in five years, consuming almost 14¢ of every dollar in federal revenue. If we remember, a previous governor of the Bank of Canada, David Dodge, came up with what is known as the “David Dodge Rule”, saying that governments should keep debt servicing costs below 10% of government revenues as a fiscal benchmark. This year, debt charges already exceed the Canada health transfer, the largest federal transfer to the provinces and territories. Every dollar committed to servicing debt is a dollar unavailable for another priority without additional taxes or even more borrowing. We are noticing a theme here. We see record levels of spending from the COVID era. One could make the case that during a time of crisis we needed elevated spending. None of that spending has been reduced. We see more and more layers added on, debt climbing higher and higher and debt-servicing costs growing even larger. The Prime Minister recently announced a loan of half a billion dollars to a Brazilian-run fund that provides compensation to governments that do not develop their rainforests. Why on earth would the Prime Minister believe that this is a good idea? Every dollar of that is a dollar that could have been used to help our own people, who are facing an ever-increasing need for help from the government. The government cannot demand fiscal discipline from Canadian families while treating scrutiny of its own decisions as a mere inconvenience. Housing is another primary indication of where we can judge the gap between promises and results. With housing starts declining, the government must explain how its plan to massively increase permanent residence will help the young Canadians I hear from every single day, who are struggling to afford homes and find a place to live. The government throws billions of dollars at housing while making the situation worse. Canadians deserve straight answers.

Marilyn Gladu, Sarnia—Lambton—Bkejwanong

Liberal
“Our economy is struggling, but heavy spending on infrastructure helped Canada in the past under Stephen Harper. I want the member to tell us if she thinks what Stephen Harper did was wrong.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, there has been a lot of talk about deficits. I know that we are going through very troubled economic times here in Canada. When Stephen Harper was the prime minister, he, the current Prime Minister and Jim Flaherty decided they would spend heavily on infrastructure to try to keep the economy going, and it worked. Does the member think what Stephen Harper did was wrong?

Discussion

No comments yet

See the full discussion

Comment rules

More from sitting 168

  1. Government Orders The Budget 116 statements
  2. Oral Questions Housing 5 statements
  3. Oral Questions Finance 6 statements
  4. Oral Questions The Environment 6 statements
  5. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 7 statements
  6. Oral Questions The Economy 4 statements
  7. Oral Questions Agriculture and Agri-Food 10 statements
  8. Oral Questions Steel and Aluminum Industry 2 statements
  9. Oral Questions Public Safety 2 statements
  10. Oral Questions Public Services and Procurement 2 statements
  11. Oral Questions Government Priorities 2 statements
  12. Oral Questions Infrastructure 2 statements
  13. Oral Questions Government Priorities 5 statements
  14. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 2 statements
  15. Oral Questions Finance 2 statements
  16. Oral Questions Climate Change 2 statements
  17. Oral Questions Industry 3 statements
  18. Oral Questions Business of the House 2 statements
  19. Government Orders The Budget 16 statements
  20. Oral Questions The Environment 2 statements
  21. Oral Questions Steel and Aluminum Industry 2 statements
  22. Government Orders The Budget 8 statements
  23. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 2 statements
  24. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 10 statements
  25. Oral Questions Public Safety 9 statements
  26. Government Orders The Budget 15 statements
  27. Government Orders The Budget 26 statements
  28. Private Members' Business Stand on Guard Act 12 statements
  29. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  30. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  31. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements