Clean Coasts Act

Bill C-244, Clean Coasts Act · Report stage · now at third reading in the House Where it stands

What Bill C-244 would do

The bill would increase legal liability for damage caused to marine areas under federal environmental protection and vessel laws. The published material gives no further detail.

Official text (opens in a new tab)

4 statements

Tamara Kronis, Nanaimo—Ladysmith

Conservative
“I want to know how this bill will work in real life. If someone sells a broken boat for one dollar and it sinks later, did they break the law? What would officials have to prove to punish them? Why does this bill not require people to report these sales to the government?”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, suppose an owner sells a deteriorating boat for one dollar. The buyer signs a declaration saying they have the resources and intention to maintain it. Six months later, the boat sinks. I would like the member to comment on whether the seller has, in fact, complied with the law and what exactly Transport Canada would have to prove to establish a violation. I would particularly like to know why the member did not include a requirement to report these transfers to Transport Canada in his bill. While I commend him for bringing this forward, as well as all the efforts that have been made, I am wondering what practical impact this would have.

Tamara Kronis, Nanaimo—Ladysmith

Conservative
“How will this bill actually be enforced when the owners who abandon these boats have no money to pay the fines?”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, what would this bill do practically for enforcement when we are dealing, as we are in most cases with derelict boats, with judgment-proof abandonment?

Tamara Kronis, Nanaimo—Ladysmith

Conservative
“Abandoned boats are a big problem on our coast, and I support this bill. But new laws will not fix the issue if the government does not enforce the rules we already have. Current laws already allow the government to remove these boats and fine the owners. We need the government to use its existing powers, give workers the tools they need, and clean up these wrecks.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I represent Nanaimo—Ladysmith, where abandoned and derelict boats are a constant problem. They sit in our harbours, sink in our bays, threaten navigation and damage marine habitats. Like my predecessors, I have spent an extraordinary amount of time dealing with these vessels. Because those who came before me sought legislative change, I too initially thought what was required here was more legislation. However, the more I consulted, the more I came to understand that what we really need is enforcement. More laws will not fix the federal government’s failure to clean up the derelict boats on our coast. Enforcement will do that. On the derelict vessels file, the claim that we need more legislation has become an all-too-convenient excuse for not doing what the law already allows. I supported sending this bill to committee. I agree that we have a problem with people transferring deteriorating vessels to buyers who cannot afford to maintain them. What has come back from committee? The bill would now require the seller to provide written information about the boat’s condition and obtain a written statement from the buyer saying that they have the resources and intention to maintain and eventually dispose of it responsibly. That is it. There would be no requirement for a marine survey, no independent verification of the buyer’s resources, no proof that the buyer can actually afford disposal and no requirement to file the required declarations with Transport Canada. The bill claims it would stop people from transferring worthless boats to people who cannot maintain them by asking them to sign a piece of paper saying they can. I am sure the people who abandon boats are terrified. Here is what actually troubles me. Section 130 of the existing Wrecked, Abandoned or Hazardous Vessels Act already gives the federal government authority to make regulations establishing conditions for selling or acquiring vessels. The government could have regulated the sale and acquisition conditions. No law is required. Section 32 of the existing law makes abandoning a vessel illegal and provides for a process by which it can be designated, abandoned and removed. Section 33 of the existing law prohibits owners from allowing their vessel to become wrecks through inadequate maintenance. Section 30 of the existing law restricts stranding a dilapidated vessel in one location for more than 60 days without consent. The act already authorizes federal authorities to direct owners to act, move or remove vessels, dismantle and dispose of wrecks, impose penalties and recover costs in many cases. These powers have existed since 2019. When I see an uninhabited, derelict or dangerous vessel sitting in my riding, my first question is not whether Parliament needs to pass another law. It is why the federal government has not used the law we already have to remove it. I can tell the House from experience that asking that question repeatedly works. I particularly want to thank the good people of Ladysmith, Gabriola Island and the other coastal communities in my riding, as well as the organizations, many of which were named by the hon. member in his remarks, for the photographs, locations, histories of vessels and evidence of deterioration they have sent me. They have made calls, written emails, followed up with authorities and joined me in refusing to accept that these boats are somebody else’s problem. They have kept after me, and I have kept after Transport Canada and the minister’s office. We have pressed for removal timelines, challenged decisions and insisted on follow through. The boats are starting to move. Transport Canada has arranged for the removal of a number of vessels in Degnen Bay and Silva Bay, and has started enforcement proceedings against several others. At least three left after receiving notices and at least 14 abandoned or dilapidated vessels were removed. Unauthorized floating rafts were also cleared. This was all done under the laws we already have. I was out last weekend surveying the progress so far. I was delighted to see an unprecedented number of unoccupied moorings. That is what enforcement looks like. We have also seen what happens when enforcement fails. Near Ladysmith’s Transfer Beach, residents documented a vessel that sank and an apparent fuel sheen on the water. Advocacy with Transport Canada saw the vessel moved, but only to the Dogpatch, where it promptly started to sink again. That is not a solution. However, at the time of this speech, I am waiting for a list from Transport Canada of vessels to be removed from the Dogpatch. I was supposed to get that list yesterday and have been in touch with an official from the Minister of Transport’s office who knows that I am making this speech today. To his credit, he got back to me immediately, and I take him at his word that I will have the list early next week. The work is far from finished. There is important work to be done, with compassion and with help from the province and other agencies, with those living aboard derelict boats that are not theirs. Still, in these past 18 months, with careful file management, persistence, community advocacy and a good deal of elbow grease, we have accomplished more in parts of my riding than years of legislative proposals have done. Fines do not remove derelict boats; people do. I want to thank the Transport Canada and Coast Guard employees who are doing their jobs. I want them to have the resources to do more of it, and I am working directly with Transport Canada officials to get it. A member of Parliament should not have to chase individual boats through a maze of federal departments before somebody acts, but if that is what is necessary, that is what we will do. Bill C-244 would not build the ship-wrecking and ship-breaking facility we need on the west coast, provide new cleanup funding, establish removal deadlines or give local organizations a clear, user-friendly path to report and remove abandoned and derelict vessels. I would add that removing derelict vessels must not create more pollution in the process. These boats often contain diesel, oil and other contaminants that can escape during salvage. North Vancouver’s Aqua-Guard won a national competition with Canadian-made technology capable of recovering oil sheens previously considered impossible to collect. The technology is now commercially available, but Transport Canada has yet to adopt it. Surely, we should be requiring coastal authorities to have appropriate spill-recovery equipment on hand wherever they operate in Canada. The fisheries committee recommended vessel turn-in programs, better owner identification, disposal and recycling incentives and fewer barriers for people willing to remove and remediate derelict boats. Where are those measures in the bill? I am not opposed to improving the law. I support it, but what I am opposed to is pretending that every enforcement failure can be fixed by passing another law. The people of Nanaimo—Ladysmith do not want another legislative promise to protect their coastline. They want the wrecks removed in a way that deals compassionately with those living aboard dilapidated or abandoned vessels they do not have the right to be on. In Nanaimo—Ladysmith, we have shown that when people organize, when government is pressed to act and when someone actually manages the file, boats get removed. I have no objections to Bill C-244, but new laws are no substitute for enforcing the ones we already have. I thank everyone who has been assisting in this very important project. We will continue until all the boats that are supposed to be gone are gone.

Branden Leslie, Portage—Lisgar

Conservative
“Abandoned boats are a real problem, but this bill will not fix it. The government changed the bill so sellers and buyers only have to trade pieces of paper. The buyer does not have to prove they have the money to look after the boat, and the rules are not clear on what people must write or how long to keep the papers. Yet people could still face huge fines. I want real rules that hold boat owners responsible, not useless paperwork.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I appreciate that we have a couple of Manitobans as the final folks up for debate. I will say my riding does touch the bottom of Lake Manitoba. I am closer to the port of Churchill and, further west, to the ocean. I have a lot more to say, but most importantly, I was at the environment committee as the process of amendments to this bill was undertaken. I heard the sponsor suggest that the government amendments would strengthen the bill in some way. I am sure if the ministry of truth was involved it must have issued corrections, because the bill in fact came out weaker. For those who were not glued to the environment committee meetings on TV, let me explain what happened, because it really is quite something. First, I should say abandoned boats are a very real problem. When someone dumps a rotting boat and simply walks away, taxpayers are left with the mess and the cleanup bill and communities are left facing the environmental damage. It is irresponsible, and we ought to put a stop to it. That should have been straightforward: Hold people abandoning boats accountable for abandoning boats. The Liberals set out to stop shady people from dumping old boats, which is an admirable objective. Their solution was to make those same people sign a piece of paper promising not to do it. Having said all that, let me explain the situation in reality. Imagine a guy puts a boat up for sale for one dollar. Someone sees a steal of a deal and agrees to buy it for one dollar. Before shaking hands, the buyer notices the guy selling the boat has a big old grin on his face, because he is a happy fellow right now. The reason he is happy is that his deteriorating 20-metre boat would cost thousands of dollars to properly dispose of. He just wants the boat gone, and now it is somebody else’s problem. The buyer might have a loonie to buy that boat, but he does not have a nickel to repair it or look after it. Six months later, the boat is half underwater, leaking oil and nobody wants to claim it. He got himself a one-dollar boat. The taxpayers get themselves a cleanup bill worth thousands. That is the real problem here, and it does deserve a serious response. At the committee, Transport Canada officials told us the department had already removed almost 900 wrecked, abandoned and dilapidated boats since 2016. Unfortunately, there are many more remaining. Nobody at the committee was suggesting we should simply leave them there. The Liberal MP bringing forward this bill wants to address this problem and, I believe, very sincerely. I respect that objective, but agreeing with an objective is just the beginning of our work as legislators. We must ask whether the law would actually achieve it and whether Canadians would understand what they would be required to do if we bring a law into force. Before the Liberals changed the bill, it would have stopped someone from selling a boat if they knew or deliberately ignored the risk that the buyer could not afford to look after it or simply had no intention of doing so. It seems reasonable enough. However, officials warned us that assessing somebody else’s resources and intentions could involve information that an ordinary seller could not readily obtain. This is very reasonable and fair enough, as those words could be interpreted differently and certainly cause disputes. We would think the government would come up with a better way to solve this issue, but we would be wrong. Allow me to tell the House what it did instead. With its amendment, before transferring ownership of the boat, now the seller would have to give the buyer written information about the boat’s condition. It sounds good at first glance, but the seller could simply write that the boat is not great or is in rough shape, or could provide a detailed three-page analysis of exactly everything that is wrong with the boat. That is the problem. The amendment never actually says how much detail would be enough. Apparently, telling Canadians to put something in writing was easier than telling them what they are supposed to write. There would be no requirement for a marine survey, which is the technical term for an inspection assessing a boat’s condition and structural integrity. The seller would now also obtain written confirmation that the buyer has the resources and intent to maintain, operate and eventually dispose of it without letting it become abandoned. That sounds like a great idea, until we realize the piece of paper or even, and I asked this, the napkin that it could be written on, is completely worthless. The seller would not be legally required to ask for proof. They exchange their papers and complete the sale. Has the seller complied with the law? The government officials told us that under this Liberal amendment, the seller would not need to ask for any evidence to comply with the law. Responsibility for that boat being abandoned would now rest with the new owner. That helps clarify the responsibility, but it also brings us back to the purpose of this bill. If all it takes is exchanging two pieces of paper, how does that stop boats from being abandoned? The buyer could still be flat broke, with absolutely no intention of fixing the boat or paying to get rid of it properly, but at least we would have his promise in writing. I am sure that would be great comfort to whoever gets stuck with the cleanup bill. However, what if the seller has a good reason to believe that the buyer is lying? Can he simply just take his word for it or is he supposed to investigate? The Liberal amendment would not require bank statements, credit checks or any other proof that a buyer can afford to look after a boat they are purchasing, so where does that leave the seller? Honest people need to know exactly what the law expects of them, especially when there are very hefty fines involved. That brings me to one word in the Liberal amendment that nobody seems to be able to properly explain, and that word is “resources”. We all have a general idea of what that means, but when writing laws that could cost someone thousands of dollars, a general idea is not exactly good enough. Does that mean money in the bank? Does that mean financing capacity? Does that mean access to storage? Does that mean skills and money to repair the vessel? The wording in the Liberal amendment does not define it. The buyer should know exactly what they are promising when they sign and the seller should know exactly what that promise means. The requirement to disclose the boat’s condition also needs to be clearer so that sellers know exactly what information they must provide in order to comply with the law. Officials told us sellers would not have to disclose problems they did not know about. Fair enough, but nobody could clearly explain how much information sellers have to provide about the problems they do know about. These are not minor details. If we get it wrong, an individual could face a fine of up to $50,000, while a company could face one of up to $250,000. I think it is reasonable to say that if Parliament can spell out exactly how much someone could be fined, surely we can spell out exactly what they need to do to avoid that fine. Let us go back to our fictitious but very real example of a boat sale. The seller is an honest broker and tells the buyer everything that he knows to be wrong with the boat. The buyer signs a piece of paper promising that he has the money and every intention to look after it. They shake hands, exchange their paperwork and go their separate ways. A year later, the boat is sinking, the buyer is nowhere to be found and somebody is left with a very expensive mess to clean up. Officials told us that the new owner would be responsible, but here is the interesting part. This amendment in this bill would not create a new specific offence for lying on that declaration. Other laws may obviously still apply, although much more difficult to enforce, but if somebody never intended to look after the boat in the first place, I am not convinced that asking someone to sign a piece of paper, even a napkin, is going to change their mind. Then there is the question of what happens with all of this paperwork. The government wants sellers to exchange these documents, but has not said how long they need to keep them. Imagine Transport Canada asking to see the declaration two years later. The seller thought the deal was finished and it is long gone. He threw away the piece of paper or the napkin. Was he supposed to keep it for five years, 10 years, 15 years or in perpetuity? Nobody should have to guess how long to do something like that in order to avoid hefty fines. My Conservative colleague from Kamloops—Shuswap—Central Rockies, who spent decades working in the boating industry, offered another common-sense approach. His amendment would have required sellers to notify the government within 14 days of selling a boat, providing the new owner’s name and the contact information. Until they did, they would still be considered the owner under that part of the law. That proposal was defeated. At least people would have understood what was expected of them had it not been defeated. It was a shame that the Liberals voted it down. Someone sells their boat, tells the government who bought it and makes sure there is a record of who is responsible. That makes sense. I realize that debating paperwork for boat sales is not exactly the sort of thing that gets Canadians glued to their television screens on a Friday afternoon, but these are details that can cause real headaches for ordinary people. That is what really bothers me about this legislation. At the end of the day, our job is not to make people fill out paperwork. It is to stop irresponsible boat owners from leaving taxpayers with their mess. Coastal communities deserve better.

Discussion

No comments yet

See the full discussion

Comment rules

More from sitting 169

  1. Government Orders Grocery and Housing Affordability Act 26 statements
  2. Oral Questions The Budget 12 statements
  3. Oral Questions The Economy 4 statements
  4. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 2 statements
  5. Oral Questions National Defence 14 statements
  6. Oral Questions Justice 8 statements
  7. Oral Questions National Defence 2 statements
  8. Oral Questions International Trade 2 statements
  9. Oral Questions Natural Resources 4 statements
  10. Oral Questions The Economy 4 statements
  11. Oral Questions Finance 4 statements
  12. Oral Questions Justice 2 statements
  13. Oral Questions Digital Services 4 statements
  14. Oral Questions National Defence 2 statements
  15. Oral Questions Veterans Affairs 2 statements
  16. Oral Questions Air Transportation 2 statements
  17. Oral Questions Foreign Affairs 2 statements
  18. Private Members' Business Clean Coasts Act 11 statements
  19. Oral Questions Taxation 2 statements
  20. Oral Questions Parks Canada 2 statements
  21. Oral Questions Steel and Aluminum Industry 2 statements
  22. Oral Questions Official Languages 2 statements
  23. Oral Questions The Economy 4 statements