Oral Questions
The Environment
“Look at our record. We have plans! An electricity strategy. A Hydro-Quebec strategy. A nature strategy to protect water. Oh and we give money for electric cars. See, we're fighting climate change so well.”
MEMBER OF PARLIAMENT
Dabrusin dodges questions by listing environmental programs, rarely giving specifics on their impact or admitting any shortcomings. She paints the Liberals as climate leaders no matter the context, and frequently tries to change the subject to minor positive news rather than addressing criticism directly.
Oral Questions
“Look at our record. We have plans! An electricity strategy. A Hydro-Quebec strategy. A nature strategy to protect water. Oh and we give money for electric cars. See, we're fighting climate change so well.”
Oral Questions
“You should feel good. I say nice words about how the government is trying to stop a bug and fires in parks.”
Oral Questions
“I'm filling time with kind words and saying nothing anyone could pin down later. We're leading but don't look at the details.”
Oral Questions
“I want to talk about cooperation instead of answering the question. I want to make a list of spending that makes us look good. I say we are already succeeding so taxpayers should not worry about spending more.”
Oral Questions
“I will list big numbers to make our climate policies sound good.”
Oral Questions
“I want to cheer for a thing we did. It's very big. We did it with other governments. It will create jobs and do some environment things.”
“I don't know our emissions numbers either. But I can list many things we are doing! We're doing many things! Electric cars, international talks, methane rules... We do a lot to fight climate change. I won't give you this year's impact but trust that it's a lot.”
“I want to talk about good things my government has done. I don't want to talk about backtracking. I named one program; that should be enough.”
Private Members' Business
“I want to tweak a bill about EI benefits. This is the complex legal wording I have to use to do that.”
Oral Questions
“I don't want to talk about our departing environment ministers. Let me attack you instead. You used to support drilling. We still want to take climate action.”
Oral Questions
“I promise our government is doing lots to stop climate change. Just trust us.”
Oral Questions
“I want to cheer for my team. We are on the good side. We will spend money to fight climate change. We really care about the environment.”
“Don't look at our failing environmental promises. You once did a bad oil thing too! Your whole party agreed with it, right?”
Oral Questions
“I want people to think we are doing a lot for climate change.”
“I'll say everyone on my team agrees with me no matter what. I want taxpayers to spend money on electricity. I need to make everyone think we're doing something on climate.”
“I am right and you are wrong. I know your past position. I want to talk about how much we are helping nature instead. We have many plans and strategies. I do not want to admit to any mistakes.”
“We are full of people ready to keep spending on climate programs. We already spent a lot on many things. We will keep spending. We're a team.”
Oral Questions
“The other speaker said some things I don't want to talk about. Instead I will talk about a nice thing my government did. We protected a big area of water in British Columbia with some First Nations. It's very big. This is good for the environment. We work well with people.”
“I want to look good by talking about my electricity strategy. I hope naming Hydro-Québec asking for a tax credit will make that strategy sound important. I'm saying that my strategy will strengthen the electricity grid. I also say it will help Alberta connect to other provinces, because I want to sound like I'm doing a lot.”
Oral Questions
“I want to look engaged on climate change. Liberals had some minor involvement around a conference we mostly skipped. I won't admit we're missing targets or expanding fossil fuels.”