Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act

Bill C-41, Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act · Second reading · now at committee in the House Where it stands

What Bill C-41 would do

The bill would allow doctors and nurse practitioners to provide medical assistance in dying to a person who has lost the capacity to consent, if the person made an advance request while they still had capacity. To qualify, the person must have been diagnosed beforehand with a serious and incurable condition expected to cause an irreversible loss of capacity, and their province must have a legislative system to store and manage those requests. The bill would also keep the exclusion in place that prevents a person from receiving assisted dying solely for a mental illness.

Official text (opens in a new tab)

95 statements

Kevin Lamoureux, Parliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Liberal
“A joint committee, Quebec, and Saskatchewan all want people to be able to make advance requests for medical assistance in dying. This bill includes that, and it must stay in the bill. Conservatives oppose this bill because they are against advance requests. I want to know if the member thinks we should listen to Saskatchewan and allow advance requests.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the comments from my colleague across the way. What I would emphasize is that the special joint committee of the House of Commons and Senate provided that recommendation. If we then follow through on that, we have Quebec and Saskatchewan, most recently, which have both indicated that they want to move forward on advance requests. This is incorporated in the legislation and is absolutely essential to keep as part of the legislation. The Conservative Party members have already made the decision, based on their principled position of not supporting the need for advance requests, to oppose the legislation. I am wondering if my colleague could provide his thoughts on Saskatchewan’s most recent request. Should we—

Adam Chambers, Simcoe North

Conservative
“It is not true that Conservatives have already decided how to vote on this bill. Our members can vote how they choose. This bill covers two different issues, so it should be split into two. The system cannot handle the current rules for medical assistance in dying, so we should not expand it without testing the system first.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I just do not think it is true that the Conservative Party and individual members of the House, who have a free vote, have already decided on a matter of principle that this bill should not go forward. We are allowing our members to vote individually. I think the bill should be split because there are two very separate issues at stake in this bill. Even if the parliamentary secretary is correct, why are we shortchanging the process? Why are we making an expansion without the ability to test the system that would be charged with implementing the safeguards, when it has proven that it cannot even implement the safeguards today?

Marie-Hélène Gaudreau, Laurentides—Labelle

Bloc Québécois
“We need criminal laws to punish people who try to end human lives outside the rules. Quebec has already shown this works to fill any gaps. Does the member agree?”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, my colleague is concerned about edge cases, as am I, of course. That being said, when the government wants to enact legislation and add laws to the Criminal Code, is it not specifically to make sure, for those charlatans or so-called fanatics who want to do away with human life, that it would be a crime? It is clear from all the evidence, as well as what has already been done proactively in Quebec, that if there are any gaps, that is where the Criminal Code comes in. Does my colleague not agree with me?

Adam Chambers, Simcoe North

Conservative
“Our system is already struggling to enforce the safety rules for medical assistance in dying. This is a major law. We should not rush it. We need to take the time to get it right.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 100 of 100

    Of this reply, 100% addressed the question or point raised.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I have worked with the colleague at committee, and she is incredibly thoughtful. I agree. The point I am making is that the system currently is not dealing with the charlatans. The system currently is unable and it is struggling to actually enforce the safeguards today. What I am asking is for the House to consider why we are shortchanging the process. We should take the time to get it right. This is an incredibly monumental law that is going to be made in a very short period of time, and we should be wanting to take the time to get it right.

Michael Cooper, St. Albert—Sturgeon River

Conservative
“We should not rush this bill. Advance requests for medically assisted death need more study and debate. An expert panel warned that people could be given this procedure who no longer want it. Health Canada numbers show that up to one in five people who change their minds do so right before it happens.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, the parliamentary secretary referred to the special joint committee. I sat on that special joint committee, and the study on advance requests was cursory at best. There were a handful of meetings and there was far from unanimity on that question. The member spoke about patients who might withdraw their consent or change their mind. The Council of Canadian Academies’ study, the expert panel appointed by the government in 2018 that recommended against advance requests, noted that the biggest risk involving advance requests is that it would be administered on patients who do not consent and would have otherwise changed their mind. That is underscored by Health Canada data that shows that in cases of withdrawal of MAID requests, between 10% and 20% of them occur at the moment before MAID is administered. Does this not underscore, on something as complex as advance directives, why meaningful study and meaningful debate are so necessary and what a shame it is that the government is instead shutting it down?

Adam Chambers, Simcoe North

Conservative
“I want the House to take time to think carefully about this bill. People who try to end their lives often regret it right away. Letting people ask for assisted death in advance takes away their chance to change their minds.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 100 of 100

    Of this reply, 100% addressed the question or point raised.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I do agree, and I would like to thank my colleague for his very extensive work on this subject. I agree with his point completely. I will add one more data point for the House to consider: Almost all of the people who jump off the Golden Gate Bridge wanting to commit suicide who are later tracked down say that they regret jumping the moment they jump. I think that is what we are trying to discuss here: that moment to change one’s mind. If we take that away from somebody or if we give that consent to another person, we should take the time to thoroughly consider what those implications are, not just in the short term, but for many years to come.

Elizabeth May, Saanich—Gulf Islands

Green
“People of sound mind have the right to choose how they die through advance requests, especially before diseases like dementia take away their ability to consent. I support letting people make these requests early. I also agree that we should not allow assisted dying for mental illness alone. We must provide help for living, like a basic income, before we make it easier to die. I want the government to slow down this bill so we can fix it. We need one clear federal rule for advance requests instead of different rules in each province.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to rise at this hour. I have to explain, because maybe constituents and people in another room in the parliamentary precinct, like Wellington room 415, will be watching. I have amendments before the committee studying Bill C-39. Because of the way committee processes have been, I think, quite scandalously skewed so that members of non-recognized parties cannot present amendments as we have a right to do in this place at report stage, I am literally supposed to be in two places at the same time. I have placed the priority on Bill C-41, an act to amend the Criminal Code and allow for related amendments to other acts, as it is a very critical bill. I cannot split myself in two, so inevitably, I will miss the opportunity to defend some of my amendments to the monstrous omnibus bill, Bill C-39, which is happening at the same time. This is something I have complained about for years, and unfortunately, the larger parties continue to adopt a motion in committee at the beginning of every committee session, with the effect of reducing the rights that members of non-recognized parties would otherwise have. I will close there because this is so critical. We have heard many people in the House today refer to people who want to change their mind at the last moment. The mind and the ability to form mens rea is something we talk about not only in medical circles, but of course, in legal circles. Mens rea is a legal term for the ability to be of sound mind, to make decisions, for instance, before one swears out a will. The people who are witnessing are witnessing that they are of sound mind and able to make a testament, able to bequeath their belongings at a moment when death is maybe not imminent. One hopes people draw up their wills with a great deal of forethought and well ahead. Being of sound mind is a legal concept. This is where this bill is so critical. It is not a problem of changing one’s mind and the right to change one’s mind; it is the right, when one is of sound mind, to determine the circumstances of their own death, to protect death with dignity. I have a number of conflicts in my own mind as I approach Bill C-41, because I think it needs work. I wish that it was not being sped through this place. In many ways, I may echo some of the comments made by members of the official opposition. However, fundamentally, I do not think we have empirical evidence from anywhere that people who have asked for these advance directives to be put in place, such as people from organizations like Death with Dignity and people concerned about the law, that ever since the Carter decision in 2015, we have known that within our charter rights, one has the right to be able to say they do not need to die early, that they want to have the right to die with dignity when death is reasonably foreseeable. We have been struggling with these concepts in the House since 2015, particularly 2016 and again in 2020, in passing different iterations of allowing a civilized society, as Canada is, to create conditions with protections in law that allow a person to choose if they know the time of their passing is due to an existing and diagnosable condition. I know a lot of the cases are for people looking at what happens with cases of dementia or what happens in cases of ALS. There is a point when they are no longer able to be seen as of sound mind to ask for MAID, and that is why they need an advance directive. When they are of sound mind, and that can be ascertained and confirmed by their doctors, we will have health practitioners who are not to be prosecuted under the Criminal Code for providing a death with dignity. I live in and represent Saanich—Gulf Islands, which, in many ways, is ground zero for death with dignity. The Canadian who struggled the most, who suffered the most, if we had to pick one person, would be Sue Rodriguez. Sue Rodriguez went to the Supreme Court of Canada. She was in what we would now call “irremediable suffering”. She took her case to the Supreme Court of Canada. Of course, the Supreme Court of Canada changed its mind at the time of the Carter decision. Sue Rodriguez, who was a resident of North Saanich before I was elected, so in other words she would have been my constituent, asked for the law to allow her a death with dignity and to end the suffering, in her own home, at a time of her own choosing. A very brave MP was with her at that point and sat with her. A former member of Parliament, Svend Robinson, stayed with her, at her request. A doctor was involved, and no one knows who, because they could still be prosecuted. I think it is unlikely that they would be prosecuted now that we have finally changed the law, but I wondered at the time, when I first became aware, when I was becoming an MP. I thought it was interesting that there were two different chapters of death with dignity within Saanich—Gulf Islands, one on the Saanich Peninsula and another one on Salt Spring Island. I realized this, of course, because Sue Rodriguez’s passing was well before I became the person who would have been her member of Parliament. This has never been an easy issue, but I think most Canadians overwhelmingly agree on this: that just as one would not let a loved one in one’s family, and in this case I would refer to a family dog, because all of us know how much we can love our pets and still recognize that a human life has value above those of other animals, suffer needlessly when there is a remedy. That remedy could be to let them go from this earthly plane, because there is nothing doctors can do. In any case, we have struggled with this a long time, and I was gratified to know two things that the government was going to say were going to at least buy some time with the court decision that is hanging over us, that we must extend medical assistance in dying to people where the only underlying condition is a mental health issue. I do not think we should allow that death. It is a horrible thing to say, because people are struggling with mental health conditions, and they desperately want to have medical assistance in dying, and I believe they probably have a charter right to it. As a lawyer, I am very conflicted. However, I will say, until we provide social assistance in living for people who are dealing with chronic poverty, cannot pay the rent, have crushing depression, and of course if one has crushing depression it is very hard to hold down a job and pay the rent, and have a number of conditions that spiral out of economic disadvantage, we must never be a society that makes it easier for someone to get medical assistance in dying than social assistance in living, a guaranteed livable income and wraparound supports, the things that people struggling with mental health issues really need. Although this is not a complete solution, and we need to return to this, I am gratified that there is a decision that has been made. Friends of mine and advocates in the disabilities community have been very concerned for quite a while now that medical assistance in dying is on a slippery slope. What I do want to put on the record, and I will approach the committee, and I hope the government will be open to amendments, is that I do not think this bill should be rushed through. On advance directives, I think it is a very big mistake to abdicate the federal role here and allow a patchwork of laws across the country. I should not generalize, but Canadians across the country, within every province and within every constituency, say this, and I know members of Parliament across party lines have heard from constituents who say, “Please, let us be able to choose while we are in our right minds and while we do have the right to form sound decisions.” That is the time. If people change their mind when they are in a situation where they have their mind, they can, of course, change their mind, but the notion that they must be allowed to do that at the very last minute is counterfactual. They have made a decision when they were of sound mind on what they want the doctors to do at that moment and what they hope their family will understand. In the six seconds I have left, I can say only that this bill is well intentioned. It still needs work. Please listen to Death with Dignity and the Canadian Civil Liberties Association. Let us try to get this right.

Kevin Lamoureux, Parliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Liberal

Linked statement

“I want to know what the Green Party leader thinks about the role of the provinces on advance requests for medically assisted dying. Quebec already allows them, and Saskatchewan wants to. The provinces have a critical role to play.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, even though I do not always agree with the leader of the Green Party, I appreciate the effort and thought she puts into presenting and making her case. I am very curious about the leader’s perspective on the provincial governments’ role in this. We already know how advanced the Province of Quebec is on this issue. Now the Province of Saskatchewan has indicated that it too would like to be able to have advance requests. I appreciated her comments with regard to hospice care, home care and personal care facilities. There are all sorts of other dynamics at play, but I am curious as to what she feels about the role of the provinces. After all, their role is absolutely critical—

Elizabeth May, Saanich—Gulf Islands

Green
“I want the federal government to set the rules for advance requests for medical assistance in dying, not the provinces. Leaving this to each province would slow down care and treat Canadians unequally.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 100 of 100

    Of this reply, 100% addressed the question or point raised.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I have been struggling with this, and I will only correct my hon. colleague slightly. As of Saturday night, I am now the former leader of the Green Party of Canada, but he does me a great honour by remembering my former role. I am the parliamentary leader for the Greens in the House, and the vast number have allowed me to continue as their parliamentary leader. The role of the provinces is critical, but I cannot, for the life of me, think it is a good way forward to have a patchwork of laws across the country. We did not have a patchwork when we brought in Bill C-7. We did not have a patchwork when we first brought in medical assistance in dying. Surely there is a way to ensure that Health Canada can be a repository for advance directives. Surely it does not have to be separate provincial jurisdictional decision-making. It would slow down access and create unequal situations for Canadians across this country who face a difficult and painful death.

Garnett Genuis, Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan

Conservative
“I want to ask the member to clarify her view. I believe a person should be told when their life is being ended, even if they signed a request earlier. She seems to be saying that someone who agreed earlier can still be killed after they lose the ability to consent, even if they changed their mind. Is that really her position?”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the former and future leader of the Green Party for her comments. I certainly wish Mike Morrice well in his caucus management efforts. This is a serious question for my colleague. In a way, she answered a question I had asked more honestly and more directly than the justice minister had. I tried to ask the justice minister if a person should be told at the moment their life is being ended if they had signed an advance directive. I think what she said, which was direct though also horrifying to me, is that a person who provides consent and then loses capacity should be killed regardless of what their future self who is affected by that illness thinks, based on an advance directive. In other words, the person can, at full capacity, bind their future self. At the point at which they lose capacity, they also lose the right to not want to proceed with a death that had been decided for them previously. Is that really what she thinks?

Elizabeth May, Saanich—Gulf Islands

Green
“When a person makes a clear decision about their own death while they are still able to, that choice should be honoured.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I am certain of one thing, and that is that I am not the future leader of the Green Party of Canada, but I appreciate the member’s humour as always. The thing about this is, to make it way too personal, perhaps, when my husband’s younger brother was dying with cancer and asked for medical assistance in dying, my husband was in the room with his little brother. The doctors looked to him, and of course, there was no question of mental capacity. He had terminal cancer and was in a lot of pain. The doctors just said to him, “Can you sign this? Can you confirm that you want the procedure, medical assistance in dying?” My husband said his brother looked up with a big grin and a thumbs-up. He no longer had the capacity to sign, but he had the capacity to know that he could not stand the suffering and he was going to be dying soon. Now, as to the question about medical and mental capacity to make the decision, if someone else had made some kind of decision about another’s future, it would be unpardonable to imagine that they would not have the ability to say, “I don’t want that.” However, when a person makes a decision for their own self, in their right mind with full capacity, that should be honoured.

Marie-Hélène Gaudreau, Laurentides—Labelle

Bloc Québécois
“People want to live, but suffering is hard to deal with. We need to separate legal rules from human suffering. I want us to focus our debate on how hard it is for people to cope with their pain.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, my colleague mentioned Sue Rodriguez. Yes, we know this was back in the 1990s, but it affected my family in 2017. In 2015, my father took part in all the studies examining medical assistance in dying. The first thing he told me was that I should not worry, that he was eligible, but that there would not be a big lineup of people wanting to die, because human beings want to live. I would like us to make a clear distinction between what falls under the Criminal Code, that is, the legal aspect, and human suffering. Does my colleague agree that we need to get back to the substance of the issue, namely how difficult it is for a human being to cope with their suffering?

Elizabeth May, Saanich—Gulf Islands

Green
“I agree with my colleague. Quebec is ahead of the rest of the country on this issue, and I strongly support these efforts.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I thank my esteemed colleague from the Bloc Québécois. It is true that la belle province, Quebec, is always ahead of the curve, both on this issue and on many others. There was also a private member’s bill introduced by a former member. I am strongly supportive of these efforts. I do agree.

Harb Gill, Windsor West

Conservative
“I want the House to take a closer look at allowing people to ask for medically assisted dying in advance. People change their minds over time, and someone who cannot speak anymore cannot tell us what they want today. I also want better home care and support for families so nobody chooses death just because they cannot get help.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, it is always an honour to rise on behalf of the people of Windsor West. I want to speak about this bill from the perspective of someone who has spent 30 years in policing. During those years, I attended calls that one does not simply forget when one goes home at the end of one’s shift. I have responded to calls involving people threatening to take their own lives. I have walked into homes where a husband or a wife was desperate for help because someone they loved had reached a breaking point. We see the fear in their faces when we hear someone’s spouse ask us to do something because they do not know what else to do. Then we have to find a way to connect with the person in crisis. Sometimes they are angry. Sometimes they do not want to talk. Sometimes they tell us that they do not want to live anymore. As a police officer, we do not walk away and accept that as the end of the story. We try to calm things down. We listen. We get them help. We protect their life, because we know that the way someone feels in the middle of a crisis is not necessarily how they would feel tomorrow. I have also attended family disputes where children are caught in the middle. Let us think about a little boy or girl sitting in their bedroom, hearing their parents screaming at each other, watching police officers come through the door and possibly seeing an ambulance pull up outside. That child does not understand the legal issues or the problems between their parents. They just know they are frightened. They do not know whether their family is going to be okay. They are very afraid. Those experiences also stay with us as a police officer. They stay with the families. They remind us just how vulnerable people can be when their lives are falling apart. I am not suggesting that every MAID situation is the same as a suicide call or a family crisis. They are not. However, my years in policing taught me that we should never assume that what a person is experiencing today is all they will ever experience for the rest of their lives. That brings me to the advance request provisions in this bill. I understand why someone might take an advance request. They may have watched their parents suffer through dementia. They may be frightened about losing their independence or their ability to recognize their family. Those fears are real, but what happens years later? Let us imagine a woman who made an advance request when she was healthy and fully capable. She was terrified of developing dementia. Now she has dementia. She can no longer express herself or talk clearly, but her husband takes care of her every day. Sometimes she recognizes him. Sometimes she smiles when he walks in the room. She enjoys a visit from her grandchildren. Her family knows she is not the same person she once was. They also see that she still has moments of happiness. Now let us imagine the family having to deal with the decision to carry out the request she made years ago. One child says that it is what she wanted and they have to respect it. Another asks if they are sure because she still has good moments where she enjoys being with them. Sadly, the person whose life is at stake may no longer be able to answer that question. That is the difficulty. We are relying on a decision made years earlier, even while the person’s circumstances, experiences and perhaps even their wishes may have changed. The bill includes safeguards. I recognize that. However, I want Canadians to think about how difficult it can be to determine what someone is communicating when they can no longer speak for themselves. If we misunderstand them, there is no second chance. There is another issue we cannot ignore, which is the pressure people can feel when they become dependent on others. I have seen families struggling to care for loved ones, a husband trying to manage his wife’s illness, children trying to look after an aging parent while raising their own children and working full time. These families are often exhausted. They need help. Too often that help is very difficult to find, if not impossible. Now let us think about the person receiving that care. They see their spouse losing sleep. They see their children missing work. They worry about the cost. They start thinking that, because they are putting everyone through this, maybe they would be better off without them. Nobody has to say those words to them. They may come to that conclusion on their own. That is why access to proper care matters. Home care, respite for caregivers, palliative care, mental health services and disability supports are not extras. They are part of giving people a genuine choice. A person should never feel that death is the only option because the support they need to live is not available. That is an inhumane part of our current medical system, the lack of adequate care. I support permanently excluding mental illness as the sole underlying medical condition for MAID, but I also believe that the advance request provisions need further scrutiny. We have to ask the basic questions. How do we know that the request made years earlier is still what the person wants today? How do we distinguish between the physical response and an expression of refusal from a person who cannot talk anymore? How do we make sure that family pressures, financial worries or the lack of ability to care are not the influencing factors? Who carries the consequences if we get this wrong? In my 30 years as a police officer, we learned to protect people. That is fundamental to what we do, and that should be fundamental to what we do here as parliamentarians. Our obligation to our fellow citizens is to protect their lives, not to squander them and not to waste these moments when we have the ability to do things right and to do right by the people we are here to serve.

Kevin Lamoureux, Parliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Liberal
“I want everyone to agree to end debate early today so we can move to the next part of our business.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I suspect if you were to canvass the House, you would find unanimous consent to call it seven o’clock so we can get to the late show.

Discussion

No comments yet

See the full discussion

Comment rules

More from sitting 165

  1. Private Members' Business Youth Criminal Justice Act 5 statements
  2. Government Orders Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act 37 statements
  3. Government Orders Government Orders 23 statements
  4. Statements by Members Ordre National du Mérite Agricole 2 statements
  5. Oral Questions The Economy 6 statements
  6. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 2 statements
  7. Oral Questions The Environment 6 statements
  8. Oral Questions The Budget 4 statements
  9. Oral Questions The Economy 4 statements
  10. Oral Questions Public Services and Procurement 2 statements
  11. Oral Questions Government Priorities 4 statements
  12. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 4 statements
  13. Oral Questions The Economy 10 statements
  14. Oral Questions Housing 2 statements
  15. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 19 statements
  16. Oral Questions Labour 2 statements
  17. Oral Questions Public Services and Procurement 6 statements
  18. Oral Questions Taxation 2 statements
  19. Oral Questions Committees of the House 2 statements
  20. Oral Questions Parks Canada 2 statements
  21. Government Orders Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act 95 statements
  22. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 4 statements
  23. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  24. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  25. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements