Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act

Bill C-41, Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act · Second reading · now at committee in the House Where it stands

What Bill C-41 would do

The bill would allow doctors and nurse practitioners to provide medical assistance in dying to a person who has lost the capacity to consent, if the person made an advance request while they still had capacity. To qualify, the person must have been diagnosed beforehand with a serious and incurable condition expected to cause an irreversible loss of capacity, and their province must have a legislative system to store and manage those requests. The bill would also keep the exclusion in place that prevents a person from receiving assisted dying solely for a mental illness.

Official text (opens in a new tab)

55 statements

Glen Motz, Medicine Hat—Cardston—Warner

Conservative
“I support stopping assisted dying for people whose only condition is mental illness, but I oppose letting people ask for assisted dying in advance. A person might change their mind later but be unable to say so, and the safeguards in this bill are too weak. I want the government to split this bill into two so we can vote on these issues separately.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I am honoured to rise on behalf of the great people of Medicine Hat—Cardston—Warner to discuss the medical assistance in dying safeguards act. Like many of my constituents, I am puzzled as to why Bill C-41 has gone so far beyond what was necessary. It should have dealt only with preventing the scheduled expansion of MAID to individuals whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness. Instead, the Liberals have used it to introduce an entirely separate and deeply divisive debate over advance requests. The question of MAID for mental illness has already been thoroughly discussed and examined. The Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying heard from dozens of witnesses, including clinicians, psychiatrists, researchers and people with lived experience. Serious concerns were raised about the ability to reliably determine whether a mental disorder is irremediable, warning that allowing MAID for mental illness could undermine suicide prevention efforts. The special joint committee’s final report made one formal recommendation: that the Government of Canada amend the Criminal Code to indefinitely exclude from MAID eligibility individuals whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness, with which I agree. Conservatives twice offered the Liberals a straightforward path to do exactly that. Two private members’ bills in two separate Parliaments sought to prevent this expansion and ensure that mental illness is not treated as a grievous and irremediable condition for the purpose of MAID. The Liberals rejected both and have now needlessly complicated the debate by introducing a bill that raises a separate and deeply consequential question of conscience: whether to legalize advance requests for MAID. Let us examine what the government really is proposing. An individual would be able to make an advance request based on fears about a future condition they have never experienced, yet when that condition develops, they may find that life remains meaningful and fulfilling despite declining cognitive capacity, and they may no longer wish to die. By then, however, they may be incapable of withdrawing or revoking their earlier request. There are serious questions about whether the proposed safeguards in the bill would actually protect someone who is no longer able to express or reconsider their wish for MAID. Under Bill C-41, a person would be able to make an advance request while mentally capable, then receive MAID years or even decades later after losing the ability to consent. There would be no requirement to reaffirm or review that decision in the intervening years. The bill does not adequately account for changing circumstances, advances in medical treatment or, importantly, any changes to a person’s experience of living with their illness. Individuals often continue to find happiness, comfort and meaning in life years after a concerning diagnosis, yet this bill all but ignores that reality. One of the most difficult questions is how practitioners would determine whether someone is experiencing enduring and intolerable suffering if that person can no longer communicate their experiences. Although the legislation would require practitioners to assess the person’s current medical condition and available information, it does not define “intolerable suffering”. Two practitioners would have to agree the criteria are met, but there would be no requirement for independent review or approval before MAID is administered. For one, the bill says nothing about a requirement for practitioners to inform patients that MAID is about to be administered or to explain the procedure in words they understand. In the case of any resistance to the procedure, Bill C-41 is even more unclear. If a practitioner is uncertain whether a person’s words, sounds or gestures constitute resistance, MAID would be able to proceed after a 30-day waiting period without independent review. This flies in the face of a Canadian public opinion poll conducted by Angus Reid that found that 72% of respondents favour reassessment or cancellation of MAID if the patient persists or appears distressed. In the bill, involuntary sounds or gestures in response to contact would be expressly disregarded as refusal or resistance. The bill also would not prohibit sedation. This raises concerns about whether a person could be sedated to reduce resistance to the procedure. In addition, all possible treatment options would not have to be exhausted before an advance request could be carried out. Again, the bill largely ignores the passage of time and the significant advances that may occur in treating or alleviating the suffering. Bill C-41 would present another curious challenge. It would leave important aspects of advance requests to provincial or territorial governments, potentially creating a patchwork of safeguards and different rules depending on where Canadians live. More concerning, it would not expressly prevent someone living in a province that prohibits advance requests from travelling to another jurisdiction where they are permitted, providing that they meet that province’s eligibility. In effect, access to MAID through an advance request could depend not only on an individual’s circumstances but on where they choose to seek it. On an issue involving life and death, this lack of consistency and accountability is unacceptable. Before MAID is administered, minimum safeguards and independent oversight should apply nationwide. These are not minor technical concerns. They go to the heart of consent, personal autonomy and the protection of vulnerable people. When a decision is irreversible, Parliament must be confident that safeguards are not merely well intentioned but are exhaustive and enforceable. I would like my colleagues to consider two recommendations from ARPA, the Association for Reformed Political Action, in its policy report entitled “Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia”. It recommends, “Parliament must not legalize” what the report describes as “nonconsensual homicide through advance requests.” Medical professionals would be asked to rely on instructions made in the past rather than on the wishes of the person currently before them. ARPA also warns that this risks creating “a culture of neglect” for people living with neurocognitive conditions. They deserve care, dignity and meaningful support, not a decision made years earlier determining whether they live or die. Another of the recommendations calls on Parliament to examine “the vagueness and permissiveness” of the existing MAID framework and undertake a comprehensive review of its effects across Canada. The original 2016 legislation required such a review after five years, yet it has never been completed. Before even contemplating an expansion of MAID, Parliament has a responsibility to understand if the existing law’s eligibility criteria are sufficient and clear, if safeguards are being consistently applied and properly enforced, if there is adequate independent oversight and accountability when concerns arise, and if vulnerable Canadians are being offered the treatment, care and support they need rather than being left to see MAID as the only alternative. These are not questions that can be brushed aside before attempting to make the regime even more permissive. While I respect the diversity of views in the House, I am opposed to the use of advance requests within the MAID regime, because, first, greater autonomy in end-of-life decisions must never come at the expense of compassionate, affirming care. Too many Canadians in need of mental health care, disability supports or palliative care are left without adequate resources and offered death instead of the support they need to live well. Expanding MAID in these circumstances risks deepening a culture of neglect. Second, existing proposed safeguards are not sufficient. They must be clear, enforceable and transparent. Serious concerns remain about inconsistent application, inadequate oversight and a lack of accountability. The government should not attempt to expand the MAID regime until these shortcomings have been addressed and fixed. Third, fundamental questions remain about whether the bill would protect consent, guard against coercion, ensure independent oversight, account for changes in a person’s wishes over time and respect federal and provincial responsibilities. For this reason, I urge the government to split this bill, allowing parliamentarians to examine two distinct issues on their own merits: advance requests for MAID and preventing the scheduled expansion of MAID to individuals whose sole underlying medical condition is mental illness. Ultimately, parliamentarians’ responsibility must be to ensure that no Canadian feels that death is their only realistic option because the care, treatment and supports they need are unavailable. We should be making it easier for people to live with dignity, not making it easier for them to die.

Glen Motz, Medicine Hat—Cardston—Warner

Conservative
“The federal government and the provinces must work together on health care. The government should spend money on end-of-life care, mental health, and addiction support instead of spending it on debt interest. That would fix many of our country's problems.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, while I certainly acknowledge the role the provinces play in many jurisdictional issues that are provincial and in which the federal government puts its nose where it does not belong, health care is certainly one where there needs to be a partnership. However, my suggestion would be that if the government took seriously the need for palliative care, mental health assistance, addiction resources and those sorts of things, and provided that money instead of spending what it spends on interest payments on the national debt, we probably would have far fewer issues going on in our country.

Glen Motz, Medicine Hat—Cardston—Warner

Conservative
“I oppose this bill. Canada is starting to value death over the value of life. We should not offer people medically assisted death just because they become a burden to the system. Every life is important.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Signal 26 of 100

    Much of this statement went to praise, blame, greetings, routine procedure or general stories rather than reasons, requests or specific points.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I have a lot of admiration and respect for my colleague. I think it is important to recognize that the decision to choose MAID is deeply personal and can be divisive. However, what I am alarmed about is this: When in Canada did this culture of death become such a huge issue that we value it over the value of life? I have known many people who have had incurable diseases and who did not choose MAID. It was not available to them. They were enjoyed by their family. They enjoyed the family they had, new children and whatever else, and the family loved them dearly. I guess what I am really troubled in my spirit about is the whole idea that when someone becomes a burden to the system we have to offer them a reason to take their life. I am disheartened by the attitude that people’s lives are not as important as they should be. As someone who values life, I respect people with a different opinion, but I just cannot see the need for what is being proposed.

Jonathan Rowe, The Eastern Peninsulas

Conservative
“Medical assistance in dying is a huge issue that affects all of our culture and health care. The Liberals should not be cutting off debate and rushing this bill through.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, medical assistance in dying seems to be a very big topic in Canada. It is going to affect almost every corner of our Canadian culture and medical care systems. I wonder if the member was surprised that the Liberals wanted to stop talking about this big issue, limit the time and rush this bill through.

Glen Motz, Medicine Hat—Cardston—Warner

Conservative
“We need to split this bill. The Liberals are rushing it because of a March deadline. They would not have to rush if they had accepted our bills to vote on medically assisted dying for mental illness separately.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 100 of 100

    Of this reply, 100% addressed the question or point raised.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, it is important to recognize that the Liberals would not have had to rush it through at all had they taken the common-sense suggestion from Conservatives and other Canadians to deal with the mental health issue tied to MAID by putting it forward as a separate vote. Two Conservative private members’ bills already tried to deal with that, which the Liberals rejected. Now we have a deadline of March to try to get this through. What we need to do is split the bill.

Alex Ruff, Bruce—Grey—Owen Sound

Conservative
“We should split this bill into two parts. All parties agree on stopping medically assisted dying for mental illness alone. But asking for it in advance needs more debate so we get it right. I want to know why the member voted to cut off debate on this.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I want to thank the member for Bourassa for sharing the story of his father. I had a very similar conversation with my grandmother a few years ago, and I would like to think that the member for Bourassa and I are likely very much aligned in our personal beliefs on this issue. However, I want to exercise some caution. He quoted the polling in the national surveys that were done. The same government conducted a survey a number of years back on the firearms prohibitions. Over almost 300,000 Canadians participated in that, with approximately 85% saying they do not support a firearms prohibition, and the government chose to ignore that. My question is more about why the government is refusing to split the bill into the two issues. We have agreement among pretty much all the parties in the House to support the exclusion of MAID for mental health only. On the issue of advance directives, we need to get this right. Why is the member opposed, as he voted in favour of the time allocation motion earlier today, to having a fulsome debate to make sure we get this right, so we are not back here in two years redebating this same issue because we did not do it right the first time?

Blaine Calkins, Ponoka—Didsbury

Conservative
“I want the government to split this bill into two parts. We should quickly pass the part that stops medically assisted dying for mental illness. Then we need more time to study the part about advance requests in committee, instead of rushing it through.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise and speak on behalf of the electors and residents of the constituency of Ponoka—Didsbury, a beautiful rural area in central Alberta. The south end ends about 45 minutes north of Calgary. The north end ends about 45 minutes south of Edmonton. I would like to take this opportunity to congratulate the Edmonton Elks on their Grey Cup victory. I do not want to jinx anything, but it’s the city of champions, and I might be cheering for the Edmonton Oilers as well. That is the only levity I think I am going to have in the speech I am about to give. This speech is about Bill C-41. It is a very sobering topic. It is a very serious topic because it deals with life and death. I hear about this quite a bit in the riding of Ponoka—Didsbury. There are certainly a lot of folks with a libertarian streak in the constituency, but there are a lot of people who have a very socially conservative mindset in the constituency as well, who are always interested in protecting the dignity of human life. I am speaking about this bill. For those who are watching at home right now, who may not have tuned in earlier, the House actually had a recorded division, which means a vote, on time allocation, which means the government has now set the parameters. There was no willingness to allow all the members in this place who wanted to speak to the bill enough time to do so. The government has put time allocation in place. It has used its new-found majority to do that. It is basically limiting the debate to the amount of time it feels is appropriate for this very serious topic. I think that is the wrong approach on matters of moral conscience like this, but nonetheless, that is where we are at. I would like to entitle my speech “We told you so”. It seems to be the theme of most of my speeches these days in the House of Commons, talking about the government’s legislative agenda, which seems to be undoing the previous version of the government’s legislative agenda, at least in part. There are two parts to this bill, Bill C-41. One part deals with allowing medical assistance in dying in situations where there is no reasonably foreseeable imminent death for the individual who is involved, which led to questions going back several years in this place on the Truchon decision, about mental illness and depression being a good enough reason for the Liberal government of the day to pass legislation that would allow people who are just depressed to seek medical assistance in dying. It removed numerous safeguards at the time, including getting two medical opinions in order to get that process done. As a result, I do not think there is a single country in all of the western liberal democracies that has had more people access medical assistance in dying. In fact, 5.1% of all deaths in Canada now are from medical assistance in dying. When we compare that with Scandinavian countries and other countries around the world, Canadians are accessing medical assistance in dying at rates far above most other developed nations. Here we are, debating this again. If we go back to Bill C-7, Conservatives at that point in time said it was a very dangerous response by the government. First of all, the government made a terrible, calamitous mistake by not appealing the Truchon decision. That was, basically, a decision made by a single judge in a Quebec court. I believe it was the lowest level of federal court in the province of Quebec. One judge, one person, made that ruling, and the government refused to appeal it, or at least to get an opinion from the Supreme Court of Canada, which was the original court that had brought about the medical assistance in dying regime in the first place, back in the decision of 2015. It let a single judge in one province of this country make a decision for the entire country. I think that was a critical mistake. It reminds me of the mistake the government made when it did not appeal the decision to remove the $1,000 bond for elections, and now we have the longest ballot committee. The government has a history of making terrible decisions, and this is just another one of those. Now we find ourselves in this unfathomable situation where every two years we have to pass a bill in the House to stop a bill that we passed in the House from coming into force. For those at home who do not understand what I just said, Bill C-7 basically says we can allow medical assistance in dying if someone is mentally depressed, but that we are going to put an exemption in place or pass another law stating that that law will not come into force, and it has a sunset clause of every two years. That means every two years, in March of every odd-numbered year, the House has to actually pass a piece of legislation to prevent certain parts of Bill C-7 from coming into force. We warned the government at the time that this is not a good idea. It is a bad idea to pursue this agenda. We do not know enough about it. It is another one of the bad ideas it has had. Just to go through some of these bad ideas, the Liberals right now seem to be, at least in words, flip-flopping on most of the things they have been doing from 2015 to 2025. Many of the Liberal MPs across the way are now giving speeches that say exactly the opposite, 180 degrees opposite, of what those same MPs would have said when they were debating Bill C-7 a number of years ago. It begs the question, how can we take these folks seriously? The bill has two parts. What we, as Conservatives, are saying is that everybody now agrees, because we see what the damage and the carnage has been from not getting the part dealing with mental illness right in the first place. Virtually everybody in this House agrees that that part of Bill C-41 should be passed. We could pass that bill expeditiously through this place. I think it would have very little opposition, and we could get that part of the bill passed. What we, as Conservatives, are saying is that for the part on advance medical directives, which are traditionally used for how to proceed with life-saving practices near the end of life, not for administering MAID, we would have way more time to discuss, debate and refer to committee. We have had this information at committees. The joint committee with the Senate and the House of Commons issued its reports and its findings. We did this just before and during COVID, actually. The committee was meeting on a regular basis. That committee recommended, in earnest, not to proceed with the items that were proceeded with in Bill C-7 under the justice minister at the time. I believe it was David Lametti. Thankfully, he is no longer a member of this place. The damage he did to our justice system is still being repaired to this day by Liberal bills undoing the terrible track record they have had. Here we are, nonetheless, with another “I told you so” moment. The Liberals are backpedalling on virtually everything. We warn the government, and they laugh and jeer at us. They chastise us for our warnings. Now here they are, and we in this chamber are cleaning up their mess. We warned them about inflation. We warned them that if they printed massive amounts of money and ran huge deficits they were going to increase the money supply, which is going to create skyrocketing inflation and deflate our currency. They continue to do this to this day. We told them what would happen. We told them inflation would be high. We told them it would increase the costs of goods and services. We have had some of the highest inflation in the world. As a matter of fact, we had 8% inflation at one point in this country. We warned them about housing. We warned them that if they let millions of people into the country too quickly they were going to put significant demands on the housing market. Now young people in this country are finding it hard to break into the housing market. Many people say they will never own a home, because the government did not listen to Conservatives when we said not to do this too fast, not to be careless when they have the levers of control and power in the Canadian government, not to be careless in what they do because it has consequences. We warned them about their justice legislation, if they got rid of mandatory minimum penalties. We warned them that if they set the wrong tone in Bill C-75 by changing the rules on bail, crime would get out of control. Sure enough, for a while, violent crime surged, and extortions surged, in some cases by over 400% in this country. This is the point of what I am talking about today. There are two parts to this bill, including one part where we have enough experience and where Conservatives warned the government years ago that if it went down this road of mental illness as a reason for MAID, it was going to be problematic, and here we are discussing it again. That part of the bill should be stripped out. It should be its own piece of legislation, and we should be able to deal with it expeditiously. The second part is on advance medical directives. I can assure the House that if the Liberals ram this through, we are going to be back here in two years discussing this, and I am going to stand in this place and say, “I told you so.”

Blaine Calkins, Ponoka—Didsbury

Conservative
“The government is rushing this bill on assisted dying. We have not had enough time to study or debate advance requests, and even some Liberal ministers say it could be dangerous. This is a matter of life and death. We must take our time, so the government should split the bill.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 44 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
  • A repeated line

    “It is a matter of life and death.”

    Said 6 times by 5 members since November 4.

    Every time it was said
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, the issue before the House in Bill C-41 is very clear. The government, again, is rushing the bill forward. It used time allocation in this place this morning to rush forward advance requests when we have not had a chance to fully debate, fully study and fully understand what the consequences of that decision would be. As a matter of fact, there are Liberal MPs who are publicly on the record, including cabinet ministers, stating that this is a potentially dangerous idea, which means we have to get it right. Yes, we have a Parliament to have ongoing conversations all the time, but if we do not get this right, it is a matter of life and death. That is what separates this from, say, fiscal policy. We have to get this right. We have to take our time and do the due diligence. Why does the member not support splitting the bill?

Blaine Calkins, Ponoka—Didsbury

Conservative
“I have serious concerns about letting people request medically assisted dying in advance. Choosing not to receive care is very different from asking someone to end your life. People could twist or misuse these instructions. If we allow this, we must make sure strong rules protect elderly, disabled, and vulnerable people from abuse.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 42 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I understand both sides of the argument very well. As somebody who personally believes strongly in the dignity of life, I have a lot of questions and concerns about the safeguards that would come with advance requests for medical assistance in dying. As somebody who grew up on a farm and is a hunter, I also understand that we want to be as humane as possible in all cases and all circumstances. Most advance requests now are about things like not resuscitating someone if they have a heart attack. This is about how not to provide care. That is a completely different question from how to administer the end of life. If somebody has the ability to do an advance directive on the end of their life, they will have given a set of instructions on how to go about ending their life. That could be used and manipulated in a lot of different ways if we are not careful. We have to be very sure that the guardrails we have in place actually fulfill the directives of the individual in question, if that is how the House chooses to proceed, and make sure that vulnerable people, disabled people and elderly people are not susceptible to abuse. That is the real question that is before this place.

Grant Jackson, Brandon—Souris

Conservative
“Another member suggested we do not need to debate this issue because Parliament discussed it 15 years ago. But many of us are newly elected. I ask my colleague if he agrees that new members still have a right to speak on serious bills.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, in the member for Winnipeg North’s question rejecting everything my colleague has argued today, he suggested that because Parliament had this discussion on a relatively similar type of topic 15 years ago, Parliament should no longer need to debate these issues. While I appreciate my colleague’s longevity in elected office, and I think he has been elected longer than I have been alive, many of us are actually new to this place. In fact, there are quite a few new members on his side as well. Does my colleague from Alberta agree with the member for Winnipeg North that all of us who are newly elected should not bother having a say on serious matters of government legislation, or does he feel differently?

Blaine Calkins, Ponoka—Didsbury

Conservative
“This bill is a very serious matter. Every member who wants to speak for the people they represent should be allowed to speak. The government should be ashamed for stopping debate.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Signal 28 of 100

    Much of this statement went to praise, blame, greetings, routine procedure or general stories rather than reasons, requests or specific points.

    See full analysis
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 100 of 100

    Of this reply, 100% addressed the question or point raised.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I really want to be helpful in responding kindly to my friend from Manitoba’s question, but I think he insinuated somehow that I am old. I have been here a long time, but I will just say this. The answer to my colleague’s question was actually in the question. This is a very serious matter. Everybody who wants to speak to this on behalf of their constituents should be allowed to do so. Shame on the government for taking that away.

Grant Jackson, Brandon—Souris

Conservative
“I want the government to split this bill into two parts. We should immediately ban medically assisted dying for mental illness on its own. We need more time to debate the separate plan to allow advance requests.”
  • A repeated line

    “That is exactly what the government has done.”

    Said 5 times by 4 members since May 5.

    Every time it was said
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I am proud to get up. Unfortunately, the member for Winnipeg North and his government have limited the number of my colleagues who will be able to do likewise. I am very proud to rise today to deliver remarks on the bill on behalf of the great constituents of Brandon—Souris in southwestern Manitoba. The conversation we are having today is an extremely important one, given the sensitive nature of the topic we are discussing. Any changes to medical assistance in dying, or MAID, are important not only to members in the House but also to the thousands of Canadians we represent. We are discussing legislation that deals with some of the most difficult and deeply personal circumstances Canadians and their families can face. That is why we have a responsibility as parliamentarians to give the legislation the time, attention and careful consideration it deserves. I want to draw attention to the vote that took place earlier this morning and its significance. Conservatives have serious concerns about the government’s choice to move time allocation on the bill. We also question how the government can reject Bill C-218, a Conservative bill that sought to permanently exclude individuals whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness from eligibility for MAID, only to later introduce its own legislation proposing that very same exclusion and then demand that there is not enough time to get it done. While that important protection has now been repackaged into Bill C-41, the government has also included additional changes that raise serious questions and undoubtedly require further debate. When we are dealing with legislation of this nature, safeguards cannot simply work on paper. We need to understand how they will work in practice and whether they will actually protect Canadians. We are talking about matters of life and death. While debate on certain aspects of the bill has already taken place, that does not mean that debate on new provisions should be cast aside or steamrolled by the newfound majority Liberal government. Unfortunately, that is exactly what the government has done. The Liberals have used their majority to limit the time members of the House have to debate this important legislation. I voted against that time allocation motion this morning, because it will limit us to just eight hours of debate. My Conservative colleagues did so as well, as did the members of the other opposition parties. I think Canadians would like to see the legislative process focused on the substance of the legislation and not simply the speed with which it progresses through this place. There is a reason why we debate legislation, hear from experts and ask difficult questions. The decisions we make here have real consequences for the people we represent. When we are dealing with changes to Canada’s medical assistance in dying laws, the responsibility is profound. The ironic part is that we do have a deadline. In March 2027, the current exclusion for individuals whose sole underlying medical condition is mental illness is scheduled to expire. Parliament needs to act before that happens. Conservatives were and are prepared to do so. That was why we had a private member’s bill on the topic. There is no equivalent deadline for the other significant changes proposed in Bill C-41, so the question to the government is very simple: Why is it using the deadline for one issue to rush Parliament’s consideration of others? These are separate matters, and they deserve to be treated that way. Unfortunately, the Liberals shut down that critical piece of legislation, Bill C-218, a private member’s bill from my colleague from Cloverdale—Langley City. That bill sought to permanently prevent MAID from expanding to individuals whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness. It was straightforward legislation, addressing an issue that Parliament has already spent considerable time studying. The Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying spent months hearing testimony and examining evidence, and ultimately recommended that this exclusion be made permanent. We agreed, yet the Liberals voted against Bill C-218. It is disappointing to see the political games the Liberals are playing with such an important piece of legislation. At a time when we are only four months away from serious changes potentially taking place, instead of moving our bill along, which was introduced well in advance of theirs, the Liberals killed it, repackaged the part they voted down and combined it with a completely different issue, that of advance requests. They are now pushing it through Parliament with limited debate. It is gross. I want to be clear: There is no question that advance requests are very different from the exclusion for mental illness. Put quite simply, they should be separated and advance requests studied on their own merits to the degree of study that the exclusion for mental illness has already received. Parliament should be able to hear from doctors, legal experts, families, veterans, Canadians living with disabilities, and the provinces and territories that are responsible for implementing these changes. If the Liberals had supported my colleague’s bill, we could have already made progress toward resolving the issue of mental illness as a sole underlying medical condition, while now turning our attention to advance requests. Instead, the Liberals killed that bill and are now trying to move forward with a much broader piece of legislation. Over the last six months alone, I have received hundreds of emails on MAID, as, I am sure, have many of my colleagues. Many opposed expanding MAID, some opposed MAID entirely and, of course, some support it in certain circumstances. I understand these differing perspectives. This is a deeply personal issue, and Canadians have strong opinions shaped by their own experiences and those of the ones they love. It has taken years of study, expert testimony and repeated delays to arrive at the responsible decision that MAID should not be expanded to individuals whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness. That experience should remind the House of the importance of getting these decisions right, which is why I want to return to the issue of safeguards. There is a significant difference between safeguards that appear sufficient in legislation and safeguards that actually work when put into practice. Bill C-41 proposes allowing advance requests for MAID in circumstances where an individual may later lose the capacity to make medical decisions. That raises an important question about consent, capacity and the responsibilities of medical professionals. For example, how do we ensure that a request made at one point in a person’s life continues to reflect their wishes when they can no longer communicate those wishes? What happens when a person’s circumstances change? These are not minor, administrative questions. They go directly to the protection of senior and vulnerable Canadians. We cannot simply assume that because a safeguard is written into legislation, it will operate exactly as Parliament intended. We need to understand who is responsible for enforcing those safeguards, how compliance will be monitored and what accountability exists when proper procedures are not followed. We are prepared to pass the permanent exclusion through all stages in the House today and send it to the Senate without delay. What we are asking is that the government separate that important protection from the additional changes it has chosen to include in Bill C-41. We hope to see the Liberals do that today.

Grant Jackson, Brandon—Souris

Conservative
“Parliament spent months studying whether to ban medically assisted dying for people with only a mental illness. We have not spent that much time studying requests made in advance. I want the government to give a simple yes or no answer: will it allow the same deep study for advance requests?”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I cannot believe the member for Winnipeg North got through that one with a straight face. It is worthwhile to remind him that, during his long tenure here, the issue of excluding mental health as the sole requirement for medical assistance in dying to be provided was the subject of months’ worth of study in a special joint committee, which informed Bill C-218, put forward by my colleague from Langley. That amount of study has not taken place for advance requests. Will the government commit to allowing that same level of comprehensive study to be done for advance requests, yes or no? That is the question that is on the floor today.

Grant Jackson, Brandon—Souris

Conservative
“We should not rush this bill. It affects healthcare across the country, but the government only listened to Quebec. We need to talk to the other nine provinces and their doctors before making such a big change.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I do not believe that is what I said at all, but I would be curious to know what the other provincial health departments are asking for. Perhaps the Quebec provincial government has written to the government asking for something specific. Now the government is bringing in a piece of legislation that would affect all provincial health departments and all provincial health practitioners. We have not yet had the opportunity to hear from doctors from those other provinces, nor requests from the other nine provincial governments. I think, again, before we make such a drastic change on the national level, it is important to have consultations with all provincial governments. That is the work the government should have done before it moved time allocation on this bill.

Garnett Genuis, Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan

Conservative
“We need to study this bill more before we pass it. It allows people to ask for medically assisted death in advance, but it leaves big questions unanswered. For example, it does not say if a person must be told on the day their life is ended. It also does not say what happens if doctors or family members disagree on whether the person's conditions were met. The law needs to be clearer on these real problems.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I want to thank my colleague for his excellent speech. One of the reasons we need further study and debate on advance requests is that there are many practical issues the government is not prepared to address or respond to, concrete questions about how things would work. For instance, I asked this of the justice minister twice this morning, and he would not answer: Should a person be told before their life is ended? Regardless of what they have written in the past, should they be informed on the day when it is happening? The minister could not give a response to that. Another very practical question is this: What happens if you have disagreement among medical staff about how to interpret an advance request? If someone has made an advance request that states that if certain conditions are met they would want to end their life, there might be some doctors who would say that they think the conditions are met and other doctors who would not think the conditions are met. One family member might bring the case to some doctors, and other family members might bring it to other doctors. How do we resolve a situation in which there is legitimate ambiguity or disagreement about whether the conditions of an advance request are met? These are some of the practical challenges. I do not know if the member has thoughts on how we would answer those, but the main point is that these are real problems and the reason this issue needs to be understood in detail. There needs to be more clarity in the legislation at the very least.

Grant Jackson, Brandon—Souris

Conservative
“This bill is not clear enough and could cause real problems. We should have debated it more to fix these issues.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, my colleague raises very real possible examples of situations that might arise due to the ambiguity within the legislation as it is currently written. These are things that could have been solved with further debate. That is what should have been done.

Garnett Genuis, Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan

Conservative
“I oppose letting people ask in advance for assisted dying. Dementia changes who a person is, and people cannot predict how they will feel in the future. A past version of someone should not make life-or-death decisions for who they become later. Consent should only be given in the moment.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I want to pick up on one thing my colleague said. She talked about how, when someone has dementia, they become, in certain respects, a very different person than they were before, which is, in a way, precisely the argument against advance requests, which is that a previous version of a person should not be able to definitively bind a future version of a person, as they may have different preferences and different desires, or they may have a quality of life or an experience of life that is different than what they would have expected. If asked what I would like to happen to me if I had dementia or some other disability, I would find it very hard to predict what my experience would be or what I would feel one way or the other. This is why, generally speaking, we expect contemporaneous consent. That is, we rely on the consent of the person themselves in the moment. It would seem strange to me to go from saying that a person becomes a completely different person to concluding that person one should be able to make life-or-death decisions for person two.

Rachael Thomas, Lethbridge

Conservative
“This bill combines two very different issues. It permanently bans assisted dying for people whose only condition is mental illness. It also lets people ask for assisted dying years in advance, before they lose the ability to make decisions. We support banning assisted dying for mental illness, and we should pass that today. But allowing advance requests is dangerous and raises serious questions about consent. We should split this bill in two so we can pass the mental illness ban now and study the advance requests properly.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I rise today to speak to Bill C-41, the medical assistance in dying safeguards act, brought forward by the Liberals. MAID is an issue that people in my constituency of Lethbridge very much care about. I have certainly read many emails, had many conversations and engaged in many phone calls. I have heard from countless constituents who have serious concerns about what the Liberals are attempting here. This level of public concern is exactly why Parliament must carefully examine legislation of this magnitude. Unfortunately, however, earlier today the Liberals used their majority to shut down debate and move this bill forward at a quick pace. When it comes to an issue literally of life and death, playing political games is extremely cold-hearted and altogether inappropriate. Canadians expect us to listen to experts. They expect us to examine the evidence and consider the consequences before making decisions with irreversible effects. Instead, the government is limiting debate on legislation that raises profound questions about consent, medical safeguards and the protection of vulnerable Canadians. This is not a minor legislative adjustment. It concerns human life, which is something very sacred. Bill C-41 combines two very different issues. First, it proposes to permanently exclude individuals whose sole underlying medical condition is mental illness from accessing medical assistance in dying. This is a positive shift. Second, it would establish a framework for advance requests, allowing someone to request medical assistance in dying today, which would be carried out in the future. This is alarming because there is inadequate research to suggest this would be done effectively or that it would take into account the individual’s capacity at the time of their death. These issues raise very different ethical, medical and legal questions, and they deserve independent study and debate. The current exclusion of mental illness expires March 17, 2027, meaning Parliament must act before that deadline. However, there is no comparable deadline for the advance directives that are being included in this legislation. The government has tied the two together, one urgent and one not, in order to get this through quickly. Conservatives have been clear from the beginning that these issues should be separated. There is no reason to put them together, except, of course, for political gamesmanship. We are prepared to pass the permanent mental illness exclusion through all stages of the House today and send it to the Senate without any further delay. Advance requests, meanwhile, deserve their own thorough parliamentary study, meaningful consultation and thorough debate. Religious organizations, including the Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops, and disability advocates have raised serious concerns. Their voices should not be dismissed from the conversation. Parliament should never operate under artificial political pressure when considering legislation that could result in the loss of human life. Canadians deserve better than having debate limited on an issue this consequential. At the heart of advance requests is a fundamental question: What are the fundamental requirements of consent? Consent is the question. Under this proposal, someone could request MAID while they have decision-making capacity, with that request carried out years later, after they have lost that capacity, but how can someone know with certainty what they will want years into the future, particularly before experiencing the circumstances they are making a decision about? Someone may believe today that they could never want to live with dementia or significant cognitive decline, but imagining that experience and living that experience are two very different things. People adapt. Their perspectives change and their priorities evolve. Someone who once feared a particular condition may still find meaning, comfort and joy in life after developing that said condition. How can we know that a decision made years earlier still reflects what that person truly wants? There are also serious questions about interpreting behaviour when someone can no longer communicate verbally. The legislation would address words, sounds or gestures that may indicate refusal or resistance to MAID, but how does a practitioner distinguish an involuntary reflex or expression of distress from a genuine indication that someone does not wish to proceed? The consequences of getting that wrong, of course, are irreversible. The person will die. Similarly, how can practitioners determine whether someone is experiencing enduring and intolerable suffering when that person can no longer communicate? It is based on the judgment of another. How can they distinguish irremediable suffering from fear, distress or confusion that may be treatable? These clinical judgments deserve much more examination than what this government is currently allowing for by rushing the bill through. There is another concern, which is people feeling pressured to seek medical assistance in dying, because they fear they will become a burden to their families or to society. People with disabilities, seniors and those experiencing serious illness should never feel that their lives are worth less because they have need for assistance. They should never feel that their families or society would be better off without them. I have heard directly from a woman in my riding who lives with a disability. She regularly reaches out to the medical system for help, yet has repeatedly found herself being offered medical assistance in dying rather than the support and services she truly requires. Let us think about that: Someone asks the health care system for help to improve their circumstances and live, and instead they are offered death. That should give the House reason to pause. People with disabilities deserve appropriate care, they deserve a treatment and they deserve support. Death should never be presented as an alternative to the services they cannot access. We must do better. We must not create a society where dependency is seen as a loss of dignity and where people feel they should end their lives before becoming dependent on others. There are also concerns about implementation. Bill C-41 would permit advance requests only in provinces and territories that establish their own regulatory frameworks. This could result in inconsistent oversight and different levels of protection across Canada. Canadians deserve consistent safeguards regardless of where they live. This is concerning and deserves careful consideration, which is not being granted by the government as the bill before us, once again, is being rushed through the House of Commons. Conservatives have been fighting to make the exclusion for mental illness permanent, which is the second component of the bill. We very much support that. My colleague, the member for Cloverdale—Langley City, championed this protection through her private member’s bill, Bill C-218, which would have permanently excluded individuals whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness from MAID. The Liberals voted that bill down, knowing that they were going to play a political game and couple that provision with the advance medical directive. It is absolutely shameful: playing with the lives of people and rushing a piece of legislation of this magnitude through the House of Commons. It is unspeakable. At the end of the day, this debate comes down to a simple principle. Parliament has a responsibility to protect the most vulnerable. That is our job. That is the will of the Canadian people. That is what they have sent us here for, and that means listening to Canadians. It means examining the evidence and carefully considering the consequences of legislation that we pass in this place. I will close by sharing an email I received today from a constituent. It reads, “I am very concerned about how MAID impacts vulnerable Canadians and how it will impact our loved ones with dementia and other capacity-limiting illnesses. Thank you for taking the time to hear my concerns on this.” As members can imagine, there was much more to that email, but the bottom line is that this is just one of dozens of emails, another several dozen phone calls and in-person meetings that I have taken with regards to this issue. It matters to Canadians. We owe it to the Canadian public to take this seriously and give it careful consideration. We must hear from physicians, psychiatrists, legal experts, families, veterans, disability advocates, faith-based organizations and provincial governments. We must examine consent, safeguards and the realities of our health care system. Most importantly, we must ensure that vulnerable Canadians are protected. Conservatives are prepared today to separate the bill into two parts and pass the protection for those with a mental illness while having robust discussions and debates, and hearing from witnesses, with regards to the advance directive piece.

Rachael Thomas, Lethbridge

Conservative
“The Liberals are trying to shut down debate and stop Canadians from having a voice on this bill. They say we cannot rethink rules about advance requests for assisted dying, but they are willing to rethink rules about mental illness. That is hypocritical.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Signal 38 of 100

    Much of this statement went to praise, blame, greetings, routine procedure or general stories rather than reasons, requests or specific points.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, wow, I wish the member opposite was honourable. I would love to be able to use that term, but unfortunately, that was an attack on Canadians. It was an attack on their concerns. It was an attack on their desire to be heard, to have a voice. It is this desire that the Liberal Party has to shut down debate, to prevent any form of discourse from taking place. The members act as if something in the past, pointing to 2023, is somehow ironclad, as if it is done, as if there is no reason to reconsider it. Ironically, the other part of the bill is in fact a reconsideration of mental illness being a sole reason for requesting medical assistance in dying. They are willing to reconsider one part, but they are not willing to reconsider another part. That is the definition of hypocrisy.

Jeremy Patzer, Swift Current—Grasslands—Kindersley

Conservative
“The government should split this bill. Most of us agree that people should not get medically assisted dying just for mental illness. But the government also added rules about advance requests, which our committee did not even study. They should not put these two things together.”
  • Question or comment in debate

    Signal 28 of 100

    Much of this statement went to praise, blame, greetings, routine procedure or general stories rather than reasons, requests or specific points.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, my colleague spoke very well on the issue. I think what is happening here is that we are again seeing that the Liberals want to just wrap multiple things up into one bill. They have a chance to put one thing in a bill that the House, I think, would have unanimous, if not pretty near unanimous, agreement on, which would be to remove mental illness as a sole reason for MAID. I sat on the committee and there was no consensus on irremediability. That became abundantly clear. The issue of advance directives was not actually part of the scope of the study of the committee, so for the Liberals to add that into this bill is ridiculous and, I would say, an overstep in what they should be doing with this bill. They have already screwed up MAID legislation multiple times. Why are they trying to screw it up again?

Discussion

No comments yet

See the full discussion

Comment rules

More from sitting 165

  1. Private Members' Business Youth Criminal Justice Act 5 statements
  2. Government Orders Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act 37 statements
  3. Government Orders Government Orders 23 statements
  4. Statements by Members Ordre National du Mérite Agricole 2 statements
  5. Oral Questions The Economy 6 statements
  6. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 2 statements
  7. Oral Questions The Environment 6 statements
  8. Oral Questions The Budget 4 statements
  9. Oral Questions The Economy 4 statements
  10. Oral Questions Public Services and Procurement 2 statements
  11. Oral Questions Government Priorities 4 statements
  12. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 4 statements
  13. Oral Questions The Economy 10 statements
  14. Oral Questions Housing 2 statements
  15. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 19 statements
  16. Oral Questions Labour 2 statements
  17. Oral Questions Public Services and Procurement 6 statements
  18. Oral Questions Taxation 2 statements
  19. Oral Questions Committees of the House 2 statements
  20. Oral Questions Parks Canada 2 statements
  21. Government Orders Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act 95 statements
  22. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 4 statements
  23. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  24. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  25. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements