Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act

Bill C-41, Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act · Second reading · now at committee in the House Where it stands

What Bill C-41 would do

The bill would allow doctors and nurse practitioners to provide medical assistance in dying to a person who has lost the capacity to consent, if the person made an advance request while they still had capacity. To qualify, the person must have been diagnosed beforehand with a serious and incurable condition expected to cause an irreversible loss of capacity, and their province must have a legislative system to store and manage those requests. The bill would also keep the exclusion in place that prevents a person from receiving assisted dying solely for a mental illness.

Official text (opens in a new tab)

55 statements

Rachael Thomas, Lethbridge

Conservative
“The government is rushing this bill through without listening to experts or having real debate. That is dangerous and unfair to Canadians.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 45 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
  • Reply to a debate question

    Signal 20 of 100

    Much of this statement went to praise, blame, greetings, routine procedure or general stories rather than reasons, requests or specific points.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I cannot put myself into the frame of reference or mindset of a Liberal member. I value the voices of Canadians too much. I understand the need to hear from experts on this issue. I understand the need to have robust discussion, to hold proper meetings, but unfortunately, the government does not. Why the Liberals are sweeping that under the rug and pretending there is nothing to see here and that we can just push this through as if it is some frivolous piece of legislation is beyond my ability to comprehend, but it is incredibly dangerous and it is a massive disservice to the Canadian public.

Rachael Thomas, Lethbridge

Conservative
“This bill does two opposite things. It stops people from getting medical help to die if they only have a mental illness. But it also lets people ask for it ahead of time before they lose the ability to choose. Putting these two things together is wrong for Canadians.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, today the government has presented us with a piece of legislation that is of two minds: one, it would take away medical assistance in dying from those who would request it because of mental illness as their sole reason; and, two, the other part of this legislation would allow for an individual to request medical assistance in dying as an advance directive. To put these two together is a disservice to the Canadian public, because the second component—

Blake Richards, Airdrie—Cochrane

Conservative
“This bill should be split into two. I support the part that stops medically assisted dying for mental illness. We need to pass that now. But allowing people to ask for assisted dying in advance needs much more study. The government is rushing this through and shutting down debate. Veterans who asked the government for help have been offered assisted dying instead of the benefits they earned. That is wrong. People who are suffering need care and support, not death.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I rise today to speak about Bill C-41, the government’s latest piece of legislation related to medical assistance in dying. Now, my Conservative colleagues and I welcome the overdue admission in this bill that expanding MAID to individuals suffering solely from mental illness is a dangerous step. We know that people living with mental illness can experience tremendous suffering, but we also know that recovery is possible, that circumstances can change, and that people deserve access to the treatment and support that can help them rebuild their lives. For years, Conservatives have been arguing that Canadians struggling with mental illness deserve treatment, support and hope, not the government telling them that MAID is the best option for them. The responsibility of government should be to ensure that these options are available, not to create a system where someone who is struggling may come to see MAID as their best or only option. The other part of this piece of legislation is a separate issue altogether, the idea of advance requests. I really struggle to understand why the Liberals feel the need to tie these two issues together. I think I do understand why, but I really struggle to understand why they are doing this, taking two different issues, one where there seems to be pretty broad agreement, and another one where there is certainly a need for more study. Advance requests raise serious questions about consent, safeguards, provincial jurisdiction and a whole host of things that need to be considered. They deserve to have a thorough study, not to just be rushed through in a piece of legislation because they are being tied together with the other concept that there is obviously a need to rush but also where there seems to be a lot more broad consent. I think it is even more important to note that in the context of the government’s track record, in terms of ensuring that there are proper safeguards, ensuring that getting this legislation right when it comes to the topic of medical assistance in dying, the government’s track record is not exactly good. There is no doubt that this piece of legislation needed to be split into two pieces of legislation to be voted on separately, so that one could pass with the speed that is needed, and the other one could be studied properly. Not only did the Liberals ignore our legitimate pleas to split the bill, but now they are shutting down debate, and ramming it through without allowing for that proper study or for that scrutiny to take place that needs to happen. This is literally a matter of life or death. The Liberals are relegating this legislation to limited debate based on, frankly, what seems to be just petty politics. The Liberals have to stop playing games with people’s lives. Let us pass the mental illness provisions, and let us give the advance request the study and scrutiny it is due. I want to speak a little, while I have the floor, about the impact of medical assistance in dying on the veteran community. That is a community that is near and dear to my heart, and one that I spend a lot of time thinking about and working for. It is an issue that I hear about quite consistently when I speak with veterans across Canada. There are far too many heartbreaking stories from veterans out there who were seeking help from the government to access benefits that they are entitled to, but instead of getting that help that they were asking for to live their lives, they were being offered, and in some cases even pressured, to consider medical assistance in dying. Can members imagine the impact that has on someone, when they go to the government looking for help to live their lives and are asked if they would consider death instead? Can members imagine the impact that must have on someone, especially when they may already be in a state of suicidality, PTSD or mental health issues? They are already dealing with sanctuary trauma from the organization that is supposed to help them not being there for them, and then they get that. We need to understand what is happening here. When we are talking about these cases, we are talking about heroes who stepped up and served this country. When those veterans returned to Canada, they did not ask for handouts, but asked for the care they earned through their service. They asked for treatment and assistance in their transition back into civilian life. What did they get from the government? They were met with a mountain of delays and denials. Worst of all, in some cases, they were offered medical assistance in dying. In some cases, they were even pressured to consider it. I really want people to think about that. A veteran calls Veterans Affairs for help and the person on the other end of the line instead offers them death. The system is so overwhelmed and backlogged that, for whatever reason, in some cases, death is being considered a more efficient option than support. If that is the case, that is a deeply broken system. These stories should concern every single Canadian, no matter what their stance on medical assistance in dying is otherwise. Our veterans made a commitment to Canada. They accepted difficult assignments, away from their families. In many cases, they returned home carrying physical or psychological injuries that came from their service. When they came back after fighting those battles, they found themselves fighting another battle, this time with their own government. They are forced to navigate complicated application processes; wait months, and in many cases, even years, for decisions on their benefits; and then are often forced to repeatedly demonstrate that those injuries were sustained while serving. Consider what that means for someone who has already sacrificed so much for Canada. They may be dealing with physical and psychological injuries that affect their daily lives. They are not asking for special treatment. They are just asking for the government to honour the commitments it made to them when they signed up to serve. The government has a responsibility to ensure that every veteran who reaches out for help is treated with dignity and compassion. That means ensuring that VAC employees are well-trained and are ensuring that veterans are connected with the appropriate health care and support services. That brings me to the question of safeguards and accountability. When it comes to medical assistance in dying, the government must be able to demonstrate that medical practitioners are properly trained, that eligibility requirements are being respected and that concerns raised by patients, families and health care professionals are being taken seriously. That means ensuring that individuals are making decisions freely, that they understand the options available to them and that they are not being influenced by outside pressure, by inadequate access to care or a feeling that they have become a burden on their families or society. Bill C-41 must get this right. While we welcome the decision to maintain the exclusion for individuals suffering solely from mental illness, finally, serious questions certainly remain about the safeguards, the oversight and the government’s ability to protect vulnerable Canadians. Canada should be a country where someone struggling with their mental health knows that help is available, where someone living with a disability knows they will be supported and where someone facing a serious illness knows they and their family will not be left to navigate those challenges alone. It should certainly be a country where the men and women who put their lives on the line in service to Canada can return home knowing that their government will stand behind them. We have a responsibility to protect those who are most vulnerable. That responsibility must be reflected in our laws, our policies and, most importantly, the services we deliver to Canadians. The answer here is straightforward. Canadians struggling with a mental illness deserve treatment, individuals living with disabilities deserve support and those facing serious illnesses deserve access to quality care. Our veterans deserve the benefits and assistance they earned through their service to this country. The government must ensure that MAID is never presented as a substitute for the care and treatment that Canadians deserve. When someone reaches out to the government for help, they should be met with compassion and solutions, not the suggestion that death is their best option.

Blake Richards, Airdrie—Cochrane

Conservative
“We should split this bill in two. Almost everyone agrees on one part, but the other part needs more study and better safeguards. The Liberals could have just voted for our bill to solve the first part.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 44 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, there is a saying that when someone is explaining, they are losing. That is exactly what we are hearing over there. The suggestion has been clearly made here that there is a need to split this piece of legislation because one piece has broad agreement. On the other piece, there is a need for further study. Why could that not happen? Why could we not do that? We could split the legislation so we could ensure proper study and the proper safeguards on the one piece. On the other piece, the government has finally come around on that one. Frankly, it could have just voted for the piece of Conservative legislation and that would have been dealt with. This seems to me like one of those examples where if someone is explaining, they are losing. The Liberals are losing.

Blake Richards, Airdrie—Cochrane

Conservative
“I support the part of this bill that stops assisted dying for mental illness. I have concerns about the rest of the bill. I do not trust the Liberals to get the safety rules right, so this bill needs proper study.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Signal 40 of 100

    Much of this statement went to praise, blame, greetings, routine procedure or general stories rather than reasons, requests or specific points.

    See full analysis
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 100 of 100

    Of this reply, 100% addressed the question or point raised.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, let me start by making it quite clear that I support wholeheartedly the portion of the bill dealing with ensuring we have the safeguards in place for those with mental illness. I struggle with the other parts more, mostly because I do not really trust the Liberals to get the safeguards right. They have proven time and time again that they do not seem to be able to do that. That is why the study is needed. Having said that, I recognize there is a range of different opinions out there in terms of what those safeguards should be. It is not a matter of legislation passing or not passing. It is a matter of making sure it gets the proper study and scrutiny that it deserves.

Alex Ruff, Bruce—Grey—Owen Sound

Conservative
“The government is rushing debate on this assisted dying bill. I worry they will also rush the committee study and stop experts from speaking to us.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I want to thank my hon. colleague for his unrelenting advocacy for our veterans over the last number of years, and in particular for shining a light on this issue where, unfortunately, employees of Veterans Affairs Canada were offering MAID to our veterans. That is point one. Point two is the member for Winnipeg North keeps asking if we support this in principle. That is fine, he can ask that question. I actually think there is going to be a split feeling on that, even among all parties in this House. However, I am concerned that, and the ship has sailed, the Liberals have used time allocation on this bill here at second reading. As the member highlighted in his speech, it is so important that we get this right going forward. Does the member share the same concerns I have that the Liberal government is now going to likely use time allocation even during debate at committee and take away the opportunity for all the stakeholders and experts to testify at committee so that we can make sure we get this bill right?

Blake Richards, Airdrie—Cochrane

Conservative
“Veterans are still being offered medical assistance in dying today. The government has repeatedly failed to put proper safeguards in its assisted dying laws. It is rushing this bill through without the study and careful review it needs.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 100 of 100

    Of this reply, 100% addressed the question or point raised.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, on the first part of his question, the only thing that I would disagree with is that member used the past tense when he referred to veterans being offered medical assistance in dying. I have heard many stories and I do not believe it is in the past, unfortunately, though I wish that were the case. I also want to thank the member for his service because that is always something that deserves mentioning. In terms of the second part of his question, the reality here is that the government has repeatedly failed to ensure proper safeguards in the legislation around the topic of medical assistance in dying. I do not have much faith that the government has it right in this instance. It certainly needs that proper scrutiny and study, and it is not receiving that. It is ramming this bill through, and I think it is doing it for a very—

Anna Roberts, King—Vaughan

Conservative
“I do not want medically assisted dying to be allowed for mental illness alone. People should get mental health care instead of being pushed toward death because help takes too long or costs too much. I want the government to bring in a separate bill just to ban this, so we can vote on it on its own.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the residents of King—Vaughan, especially on a topic as important as this one. The Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying heard considerable concerns about safeguards and oversights in the MAID process. There are serious moral and legal considerations when we discuss MAID for Canadians whose sole underlying medical condition is mental illness. We are asking whether it is possible to know with enough certainty to make an irreversible decision that a person’s condition would never improve. After hearing from experts and the people directly affected, it recommended keeping the exclusion in place indefinitely. I support that recommendation. The most important thing we need to keep front and centre in this debate is that MAID must never become a cheaper or easier alternative to providing real and effective support to Canadians who are suffering. We cannot tell Canadians in a vulnerable state that the help they need is many months or even years away and then turn around and tell them that MAID is the option. When someone finally works up the courage to ask for help and is told they will have to wait six months, what are they supposed to do tonight? What are they supposed to do tomorrow? We have a responsibility to make sure that Canadians have access to those supports when they need them most. Bill C-41 would keep the exclusion in place for Canadians whose sole underlying medical condition is mental illness. The government should instead bring forward a separate bill to maintain this exclusion, so that the House can debate and vote on that question on its own. The committee has given Parliament a clear recommendation, and the House should act on it, but questions that were raised when the government first introduced MAID are still being raised today: How do we make sure that consent is freely given when someone feels they have run out of options? What guidance do doctors have when they are uncertain about eligibility? How do we know whether a person has had a genuine opportunity to access the care that might have helped them? Being told that a treatment exists is one thing. Being able to find a doctor who provides it, affording it, getting it and receiving that treatment when one needs it is another. Canadian seniors are concerned about safeguards. They want to know that when they go to the hospital for treatment, they will get the care they came for. A senior recently told me that a family member brought her to the hospital because she had a bad flu. They told me that during that visit, they were offered MAID without asking about it. They are now afraid to go back to the hospital. The next time this senior falls ill and their family tells them they need to go to the hospital, they may hesitate. They may stay home longer than they should. Many seniors in this country are already in a vulnerable situation. They should be able to go to the hospital, tell the doctor exactly what they are going through and feel confident that they will get the care they need. There is one thing I am crystal clear on. Canadians who are suffering from mental illness and who can get better must have the opportunity to get better. They should never feel pushed toward an irreversible decision because they could not get the help they needed. Someone may have already tried several treatments. They may have been referred to a specialist and spent months waiting to be seen. They may be relying on a family member who is doing everything they can to help and has run out of places to call. Those Canadians are asking for something very practical. They need an appointment they can get to, treatment they can afford and someone they can call when things get worse. We are in no position to make MAID available to people whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness. It would also be profoundly unfair to this country’s medical professionals to put them in such a difficult moral and legal position. A doctor may know that another treatment is worth trying and also know that their patient cannot afford it or cannot get an appointment. We need to take seriously what that means for the patients and the doctors as well. We cannot tell veterans who have fought and suffered for this country that the care they need, the treatment they need and the medication they need are months away and then turn around and raise MAID in the meantime. It is an insult to their service, their courage and their love of this great country. A veteran who calls for help should be able to say how difficult things have become and know that the person on the other end of that call will help them get care. They should be able to ask when they will see a specialist, what help is available while they wait, and who they can call if things get worse. After all we have asked of them, they should never have to wonder whether asking for that help was a mistake. We need to see how the existing safeguards work in practice, especially in the most difficult cases. If a patient or a family member raises a concern, who hears it? Who reviews what happens? How does Parliament find out whether the safeguards we put in place are being followed? These questions matter to the Canadians who depend on us right now. The special joint committee has heard serious concerns about the safeguards and oversights. It is up to us as parliamentarians to take those concerns seriously. We need to listen to doctors, nurses and legal experts. We need to hear from veterans and veterans groups, Canadians living with mental illness, Canadians with disabilities, and seniors and their families, who are often the first to see when someone is struggling. They can tell us whether the system worked for them and where they were left trying to find out on their own. When we ask a committee to listen to those Canadians and bring forward recommendations, we have a responsibility to act on what we heard. Conservatives will continue to work in the House to make sure those voices are heard. We will fight to keep the exclusion in place for Canadians whose sole underlying medical condition is mental illness. We will keep pressing for safeguards that work in practice and for Canadians who reach for mental health support to get the help they ask for. When a senior goes to the hospital, when a veteran calls for treatment or when a Canadian who has been struggling for months finally asks for help, they should be able to count on us to make that help available. No Canadian should ever feel that MAID is their only option because the help they asked for never came.

Anna Roberts, King—Vaughan

Conservative
“I do not trust the Liberal government to make decisions about medical assistance in dying for people with mental health issues. These people need help. We should value life instead of expanding this program.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Signal 0 of 100

    Much of this statement went to praise, blame, greetings, routine procedure or general stories rather than reasons, requests or specific points.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I am going to answer that question, because I respect my colleague, and I respect her decision. It is not her decision I am worried about. It is the decision of the Liberal government that I cannot trust. I cannot trust it to make these decisions on behalf of individuals who have issues of mental health and need the help that they wanted. For that individual, my colleague across the way who made those comments, I have sat with seniors on their last dying breath, and they have always hoped that there would be an opportunity to live another day. I think maybe what you should do is look into your heart and soul and start realizing that life is something that we all cherish, and we all want to live it to the fullest extent.

Anna Roberts, King—Vaughan

Conservative
“We need to check if this bill would apply to people who struggle with mental illness after being trafficked. Right now, people wait months or years to see a mental health doctor. Canada should send less money abroad and give that money to the provinces for healthcare instead.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 46 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, my concern here is very simple. I recently spent some time with a mother whose daughter was coerced into human trafficking. She was a young child when she was recruited. After many surgeries, that daughter is now suffering from mental health, and the mother has tried everything within her power to save this child. I will tell members something: The appointments to get her help are months and years away. I think we need to look at this bill, and we need to decipher if it meets the circumstances for that particular individual. I think the other issue we have in this country is that if money was not sent abroad and was sent to the provinces for medical help, so that the doctors are available to help individuals with their mental health, this would solve a lot of the problems.

Ned Kuruc, Hamilton East—Stoney Creek

Conservative
“We should split this bill in two. We agree on the first part and should pass it. We need more time and expert advice to study the second part.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, very quickly, I would like to ask my colleague how important it would be to split this bill, debate the second part and get some more insight into the second part of this bill. We could look at it, talk to more experts, and put more time on the second part. I think the first part is something we can agree on and that it should move forward. I hope the members across the way will see it that way too.

Anna Roberts, King—Vaughan

Conservative
“I agree that we should split this bill and debate it more. We need to listen to experts, veterans, and Canadian families first.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 100 of 100

    Of this reply, 100% addressed the question or point raised.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I think it is important that we do that. I think it is important that we listen to the experts. It is important that we listen to the veterans. It is important that we listen to the Canadian families that are so desperately trying—

Brad Vis, Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford

Conservative
“I am voting against this bill, and I oppose the government cutting off debate. The bill lets people ask in advance for medically assisted death. That is dangerous because they cannot confirm their consent later. Poor health care, poverty, and isolation are already pushing vulnerable people to choose death, and families could pressure seniors for money. Parliament needs to slow down and protect these people instead of rushing this vote.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I will be rising in opposition to Bill C-41 and the use of time allocation for a bill that every Canadian has a legitimate opinion on. There are two provisions in this bill, which are advance requests and excluding mental illness as the sole underlying condition for MAID eligibility. I will ask members to excuse my political cynicism, but the Liberals have voted down two Conservative bills in the last two years, Bill C-314 in the last Parliament and Bill C-218 in this Parliament, which would have permanently excluded mental illness as a condition for MAID eligibility, as is in the legislation today. Now they have used time allocation to force through a bill that deserves serious consideration. They are proposing the same permanent exclusion for mental illness, while tying it to the separate and deeply consequential second issue before the House of advance requests. My remarks will mostly focus on that. For my constituents, in 2016, Parliament passed Bill C-14, which legalized medical assistance in dying. Bill C-14 required that, to qualify for MAID, a person must have a grievous and irremediable medical condition, be experiencing intolerable suffering and have a natural death that was reasonably foreseeable. In 2019, the Quebec Superior Court ruled that the reasonably foreseeable requirement was unconstitutional. This led to the introduction of Bill C-7 by Mr. Lametti, which separated MAID applicants into track 1, those whose natural death is reasonably foreseeable, and track 2, those whose natural death is not reasonably foreseeable. Bill C-7 also introduced the waiver of final consent, wherein a person who had already been assessed and approved for MAID could sign an agreement allowing MAID to proceed if they were to lose capacity before the scheduled procedure. Today, through Bill C-41, the government is seeking to expand that concept into advance requests. An advance request is a written directive made by a person, while they still have decision-making capacity, asking to receive MAID in the future if specified circumstances occur and they are no longer capable of consenting at that time. For example, a 70-year-old diagnosed with Alzheimer’s could say, “If I no longer recognize my spouse or children, cannot communicate meaningful choices and require complete assistance with all daily activities, I want MAID to be provided.” Since the individual will be unable to provide consent in the future, it will be left at the discretion of their medical provider to determine when the criteria are met. Importantly, Bill C-41 does not restrict advance requests to people whose natural death is reasonably foreseeable. Therefore, it would extend to track 2 cases. This means that someone who is not approaching the end of their life could receive MAID just because they have lost certain physical or cognitive abilities, or maybe their life circumstances have changed. That is a key point right there. The Council of Canadian Academies warned the government in 2018 that no combination of safeguards can eliminate every risk of someone receiving an assisted death against their wishes. This is a key point. Can we respect individual autonomy under advance requests? Even Liberal MPs and cabinet ministers have previously acknowledged these key concerns. In 2024, the former minister of health, Mark Holland, said in a discussion about advance requests, it only stands to reason that we should take a few more months to make sure that the system is ready, to hold a conversation and to allow everyone in every family across Canada to participate. The actions of the government today show no such restraint. The Liberals are tying two separate issues together. Also in 2024, the member for Thunder Bay—Rainy River, who served on the MAID committee and who is a physician, raised concerns about the willingness of some MAID practitioners to approve requests. He said, “there are a lot of MAID practitioners who are very zealous about its being all about one’s personal autonomy and saying it is not for them to question someone’s suffering, and who are quick to approve people.” This is too serious of an issue to face time allocation today. Parliament must take the time to unpack and examine the safeguards surrounding another expansion of MAID in Canada. Let us look at some of the dangers of advance requests. Number one is the loss of contemporaneous consent. An advance request cannot fully anticipate a person’s future quality of life. Dementia Justice Canada has raised concerns about the proposed safeguards in Bill C-41 and stated that, “if the practitioner...is uncertain whether the person’s words, sounds, or gestures amount to a refusal, Bill C-41 does not set a limit on the number of times the practitioner can try again.... The practitioner must only wait 30 days each time. Repeated attempts could continue until the person gives up or loses the ability to resist.” Inclusion Canada CEO, Krista Carr, has also warned, “Consent at the time is the most basic protection a person has. Parliament should not take it away.” My second concern is that advance requests could turn failures in health care and social support into reasons for death. People may consider MAID because the support they need is inadequate, inaccessible or delayed. A deteriorating health care system can undermine the meaningfulness of individual choice. For example, a paraplegic who has lost social support could request MAID even if their death was not reasonably foreseeable. Consider the circumstances facing many Canadians with disabilities, such as long waits for medical treatment and specialist care, limited access to mental health services, inaccessible or unaffordable housing, social isolation, or insufficient community support. Failures of our health care and social support systems should not become reasons for someone to pursue medical assistance in dying, but they already are. A running issue in my community is whether we even have health care services. This spring, Mission Memorial Hospital’s ER experienced 51 consecutive days of overnight closure. These are hard questions, and Parliament is not given adequate time to discuss them. My third point is that disabilities may be treated as a source of suffering. The disability advocacy group Living with Dignity has raised concerns about the potential normalization of MAID for people experiencing significant impairments. The organization stated, “What they need is help to live, not medical aid in dying under a veneer of compassion.” My fourth point is with regard to socio-economic status and MAID requests. We must also examine the relationship between poverty, social isolation and requests for MAID. A study examining requests for medically assisted death at London Health Sciences Centre between 2016 and 2019 found that a disproportionate number of requests came from patients of lower socio-economic status. The Ontario chief coroner’s 2024 report identified similar characteristics among track 2 MAID recipients whose natural death were not reasonably foreseeable. A higher portion of these individuals were elderly, lived alone and were more likely to list an extended family member, caseworker, lawyer or health care provider as their next of kin. The report also documented a case involving a woman who “experienced social isolation, which greatly contributed to her suffering and request for MAiD.” Health Canada’s sixth annual report on medical assistance in dying revealed that 61.5% of track 2 respondents self-identified as having a disability. The United Nations Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities has also challenged Canada’s approach, with committee vice-chair Rosemary Kayess questioning whether the situation amounts to “State-sanctioned euthanasia”, and this is before advance requests would even expand MAID even further. The committee warned that the concept of choice creates a false dichotomy, setting up the premise that, if persons with disabilities are suffering, it is valid for the state party to enable their death without providing safeguards that guaranteed the provision of support. The committee recommended that, rather than expanding MAID access to include advance requests, the Government of Canada ensure that Canadians can afford to live and have access to health care, housing and mental health supports. These are matters of life and death. My final point is with regard to financial bias. Advance requests call into question financial bias. Think of a scenario where an elderly person qualifies for MAID under track 2 and is sitting on a piece of land or a sizable amount of money. They may be pressured by a family member to put in place an advance request so that their family members can receive their inheritance earlier. It is hard to say that, but those are the questions we need to have answered in the House. In conclusion, the government’s own members have previously acknowledged that advance requests present significant ethical, medical and practical challenges. The health minister said it would be irresponsible to proceed without robust public debate. We have not done that. In my own community, people point to the abuse of MAID at Fraser Health. We have not addressed that, and we are not addressing that. Parliament is not taking the time to get this right. Time allocation, especially, is not the answer. Canadians deserve careful study and legislation that puts the protection of vulnerable people first. I will be voting against the bill on the procedural tactics of the government alone.

Brad Vis, Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford

Conservative
“The government combined the issue of advance requests with the issue of mental illness in this bill. My biggest concern is that the Minister of Justice cut debate short. This is an important bill. We need more time to debate it so every member of Parliament can speak, not just the member for Winnipeg North.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 34 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, the member for Winnipeg North is referring to the one provision in the bill for mental illness being the sole provision for requesting MAID. That was through two parliamentary bills. What I am cynical about today is how the government coupled advance requests with the mental health issue, which has been debated in this Parliament, but what I am most concerned about is that the Minister of Justice stood up and limited the amount of debate we had on this important piece of legislation, whether we agree with it or not. Parliament, in Canada, has a right. Canada needs to have a better debate on this, and Canadians have a right to hear from every member of Parliament, not simply the member for Winnipeg North, who seems to speak on behalf of the Liberal Party on all important issues.

Brad Vis, Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford

Conservative
“We must respect the rights of provinces and territories to run their own systems. That is not happening here.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, my Bloc Québécois colleague has a good point. We have to respect provincial and territorial jurisdictions when it comes to implementing our existing system. That is not being done here.

Garnett Genuis, Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan

Conservative
“Canada has more than 15 times the rate of medically assisted deaths as California, even though both places made it legal around the same time. Our current system has serious problems, and its safety rules are failing. The government is rushing this bill to limit debate instead of studying these issues. We need to talk more about these failures in the House.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for her excellent speech outlining the problems with the regime as it exists and also with the advance request provision. California legalized MAID, medically facilitated death, around the same time Canada did. We have more than 15 times the number of people here in Canada who are getting MAID. What does that tell us? Does that tell us that Canadians are just more likely to want to die than people in California, or does it say that there are different aspects of the system, the regime, the social context around it and the verification process in these two jurisdictions, and that they are having dramatically different effects? I would like to see more discussion in the House about all of the cases where we see safeguards not working, and where we see people getting rejected and then finding two people who agree. We need more discussion here about the evident problems with the existing system, but that is not the priority of the government. The priority of the government is continuing to try to push the bill forward with as limited a debate as possible without analyzing the serious issues and problems that are underneath it. I wonder if the member has a comment on that.

Brad Vis, Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford

Conservative
“Canada now allows assisted dying more easily than other countries. Our medical system cannot always care for people with dignity, so assisted dying is offered instead. I want Parliament to pass safeguards to protect vulnerable people and people with disabilities.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, it is a very important comparison to make between Canada and state jurisdictions in the United States, or even in countries that Canada saw as very liberal in the application of MAID, such as the Netherlands and Belgium, prior to its legalization in Canada. Canada has now surpassed other regimes in the world that we saw as the most liberal just ten years ago. In fact, many of the debates that took place in this chamber a decade ago were talking about the slippery slope that would allow the social context of the inability of our medical system to treat people with dignity to use MAID as an excuse to be offered in those circumstances. We have gone down that slippery slope now. It is so concerning that, in the name of compassion, we have actually eliminated compassion and reverence for the individual person. Our medical system needs to bring that back and we, as Parliament, need to safeguard the rights of all people, especially for the vulnerable and those with disabilities, that they are recognized as valuable people of society.

Kelly Block, Carlton Trail—Eagle Creek

Conservative
“I support stopping medically assisted dying for mental illness alone, but I oppose letting people ask for it in advance. People change their minds, and doctors cannot know what a patient wants once that patient cannot speak. The government is rushing this bill, and we need to slow down and debate it properly.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, while I am pleased to rise today to speak to Bill C-41, an act to amend the Criminal Code with respect to medical assistance in dying and to make related amendments to other acts, I do so out of deep concern. As many Canadians are aware, Bill C-41 was introduced just one day before the House was scheduled to vote on the member for Cloverdale—Langley City’s private member’s bill, Bill C-218, which was introduced to ensure that the temporary pause in providing MAID for persons whose sole condition is mental illness would be made permanent. The Liberals could have voted for it and dealt with this issue once and for all. Whether it was the minister’s intent to upstage my colleague and perhaps take the credit for finally responding to the concerns of Canadians, including many experts who raised the alarm, or whether he was responding to the recommendation by the AMAD committee to permanently exclude from MAID eligibility persons whose sole medical condition is a mental illness, no one could have imagined the absolute skepticism portrayed by the government with the introduction of Bill C-41. Under the current Criminal Code framework as amended by Bill C-14, Bill C-7, Bill C-39 and Bill C-62, MAID is legal for persons with a grievous and irremediable medical condition, and their natural death need not be reasonably foreseeable. While Bill C-41 would amend the Criminal Code to prevent the scheduled expansion of MAID to individuals whose sole condition is mental illness, it includes a new provision that would allow individuals with an incurable condition that will affect their decision-making capacity to make an advance request for MAID. The country has seen a major expansion of MAID since 2016. In 2024, 16,499 people died as a result of MAID, making up 5.1% of all deaths at that time. The bill before us today seeks to expand the provision of MAID again by virtue of enabling advance directives. The core issue with the advance request provision is that the individual may sign off on their death today, with the potential of being unable to communicate withdrawal of their request later. Changing one’s mind about receiving MAID is not uncommon. According to Health Canada’s sixth report on MAID, 692 individuals withdrew their MAID request, but under the proposed framework in Bill C-41, the practitioner would have to assess their consent retroactively. Additionally, the bill would place extraordinary weight on practitioners to interpret a patient’s prior wishes and decide whether those circumstances envisioned have been met, even though the patient can no longer speak for themselves. Consider a person diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease, for example. In later stages of the disease, they may lose the ability to communicate and may experience cognitive and/or physical decline. However, the person does not exhibit signs of distress such as extreme anger, anxiety or agitation. In this circumstance, how would the practitioner determine whether the individual is in an advanced state of irreversible decline in capability? Would they be deemed to be experiencing enduring and intolerable physical or psychological suffering? Canadians are being asked to get MAID instead of being treated. Although statutory safeguards are present in existing legislation and are proposed in the bill, these safeguards have not prevented ineligible people from receiving or being offered MAID. The leader of the official opposition recently and quite correctly pointed to the case of Kiano Vafaeian, who was diagnosed with diabetes, depression and vision loss. Mr. Vafaeian was eligible for MAID in British Columbia, despite being previously rendered ineligible in Ontario. Mr. Vafaeian’s conditions were treatable, yet he was able to end his life at only 26 years old. The case of Vafaeian speaks to the fragmentation issue within the MAID regime between provinces, and the loose interpretation of eligibility by medical practitioners. The inappropriate recommendation of MAID is a common issue in our health care system, especially toward disabled persons and elderly persons. Recently, the National Post reported on a B.C. physician who offered MAID to an elderly patient whose only symptom was back pain. Veterans Affairs Canada has also launched its own investigations into cases where veterans seeking disability and mental health supports were inappropriately offered MAID by VAC caseworkers. That said, I would like to acknowledge my colleague the member for Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan’s private member’s bill, Bill C-260, the proposed preventing coercion of persons not seeking medical assistance in dying act. It would create a summary offence under the Criminal Code for a Government of Canada employee other than a medical practitioner or nurse to initiate a discussion with a person about the availability of MAID, especially if that employee is in a position of trust or authority. What is most discouraging about the discussion we are having today is that we do not need to be debating this legislation. We could be debating the government’s most recent budget bill, which was tabled earlier this month. As I noted earlier, the government could have saved the justice department a bunch of time and energy by simply supporting my colleague the member for Cloverdale—Langley City’s private member’s bill, Bill C-218. It was a simple and uncontroversial bill that deserved to be supported. As was mentioned in an earlier speech, the government could have supported Bill C-314 in the previous Parliament. However, rather than voting for a Conservative MP’s bill, the government deceived Canadians by telling them that the Liberals would vote against Bill C-218 because they were going to propose their own legislation to do the same thing. What they did not tell Canadians is that their bill would include more than just the issue of MAID expansion to those whose sole underlying condition is mental illness. In closing, I would like to remind every member of the House and Canadians who might be listening that the legalization of MAID and the subsequent changes to the MAID regime in Canada have all necessitated amendments to the Criminal Code of Canada. We are not debating amendments to the Canada Health Act or some bill dealing with health care provisions. We are changing the Criminal Code to allow medical professionals to end someone’s life. This is a matter of life or death. It is my belief that vulnerable Canadians from every part of the country should be provided with hope and help, not simply a pathway to state-facilitated death. Medical assistance in dying is one of the most serious and deeply personal issues that we as parliamentarians can address. The priority must be protecting vulnerable Canadians, respecting individual dignity and ensuring that any changes to the law include strong safeguards and accountability. We must guard against any circumstance in which people feel that MAID is their only realistic option because adequate supports are unavailable. While I welcome the exclusion of mental illness as the sole underlying condition and am willing to support that part of Bill C-41, advance requests raise profound questions about consent, capacity and safeguards. It is my belief that vulnerable Canadians from every part of the country should be provided with hope and help. Parliament must get the answers right before changing the law. To do that, parliamentarians need to have the opportunity to debate this new provision instead of having this piece of legislation rush through Parliament to meet some self-imposed deadline that could have been dealt with long before we got to this place.

Kelly Block, Carlton Trail—Eagle Creek

Conservative
“Private members' bills are always debated for only two hours. It is not fair to claim Conservatives wanted to cut the debate short. Also, Saskatchewan has introduced laws to ban medically assisted dying for children, people with only mental illness, and people who cannot make their own health decisions. The member needs to stop misrepresenting Saskatchewan's position.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I am going to address two things. First, private members’ bills are only ever debated for two hours. Trying to portray that we were willing to debate the bill for only two hours is disingenuous. Second, let me read the press release from the Government of Saskatchewan for the member and encourage him to go back and talk to the Minister of Health: The Government of Saskatchewan has introduced legislation that would establish provincial safeguards for Medical Assistance in Dying (MAID). The Medical Assistance in Dying Additional Safeguards Act would prohibit MAID in Saskatchewan for: Anyone under the age of 18; Anyone whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness; and Individuals who lack the capacity to make their own health care decisions. The member should make sure he is representing the Government of Saskatchewan’s position correctly.

Kelly Block, Carlton Trail—Eagle Creek

Conservative
“I do not want this bill to pass. We should give vulnerable Canadians hope and help, not an easy path to assisted death. We need a deeper debate on advance requests before making this change.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I am not sure how long the member has been a member of Parliament, but I have been one for 18 years and remember the conversation around medical assistance in dying in 2010. I do appreciate the question from the member and acknowledge that Quebec has passed laws in its provincial legislature to address advance directives as they relate to receiving medical assistance in dying. However, it is my belief that vulnerable Canadians from every part of this country should be provided with hope and help, not an easy pathway to state-facilitated death when it may seem like it is their only option. I would say that we need to have a debate around advance directives similar to the one we had when the AMAD committee was struck to study that issue.

Discussion

No comments yet

See the full discussion

Comment rules

More from sitting 165

  1. Private Members' Business Youth Criminal Justice Act 5 statements
  2. Government Orders Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act 37 statements
  3. Government Orders Government Orders 23 statements
  4. Statements by Members Ordre National du Mérite Agricole 2 statements
  5. Oral Questions The Economy 6 statements
  6. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 2 statements
  7. Oral Questions The Environment 6 statements
  8. Oral Questions The Budget 4 statements
  9. Oral Questions The Economy 4 statements
  10. Oral Questions Public Services and Procurement 2 statements
  11. Oral Questions Government Priorities 4 statements
  12. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 4 statements
  13. Oral Questions The Economy 10 statements
  14. Oral Questions Housing 2 statements
  15. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 19 statements
  16. Oral Questions Labour 2 statements
  17. Oral Questions Public Services and Procurement 6 statements
  18. Oral Questions Taxation 2 statements
  19. Oral Questions Committees of the House 2 statements
  20. Oral Questions Parks Canada 2 statements
  21. Government Orders Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act 95 statements
  22. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 4 statements
  23. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  24. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  25. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements