Youth Criminal Justice Act

Bill C-231, For the Friends of David Law · Third reading · now at second reading in the Senate Where it stands

What Bill C-231 would do

The bill would amend the Youth Criminal Justice Act to clarify rules around addiction treatment programs for young persons. It would allow youth justice courts to delay sentencing after a guilty finding so a young person can enter a treatment program, or to order them to attend one. Failing or refusing to comply with a treatment condition could not on its own lead to a custodial sentence.

Official text (opens in a new tab)

3 statements

Brad Vis, Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford

Conservative
“I want the House to pass this bill. It helps police and courts send young offenders to addiction treatment instead of just sending them to jail. Many young people are dying from toxic drugs. This bill holds them accountable for their crimes, but it also gives them a chance to get healthy and turn their lives around.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I rise today in support of Bill C-231, David’s law, which recognizes the serious risks young Canadians face as our country continues to confront a devastating opioid and toxic drug crisis. Bill C-231 would strengthen the ability of police and courts to direct youth toward treatment programs early, before situations escalate. It would expand the use of extrajudicial measures so that intervention could happen outside the courtroom, where appropriate and in a way that prioritizes rehabilitation. Four months ago in the city of Abbotsford, the RCMP issued a statement regarding an investigation of a website that sold drugs. Through this investigation, three individuals were arrested, and numerous packages of drugs were seized. While the existence of these sites is not new, what troubled me most was that the site targeted minors specifically. That should concern every parent in our country. In British Colombia, unregulated drug toxicity was the leading cause of unnatural death among youth from 2019 to 2023, and in 67% of these cases, these youth had a mental health diagnosis or evidence of a mental health disorder. We know that these are not just statistics and numbers. These are young people who were struggling with something long before they encountered the criminal justice system: peer pressure, trauma, escapism, mental health challenges, addiction or, in many cases, a combination of circumstances that can be difficult for a young person to navigate on their own. We cannot ignore the offence. Public safety matters, and there must be accountability for criminal behaviour. With this bill, there would be no automatic amnesty. The young person would remain accountable for their actions, and the courts would retain their decision-making authority. However, accountability must also include asking a difficult question: Why did the young person end up where they are in the first place? We must address more than the crime. We must address the pain behind it. While Bill C-231’s scope focuses on what would happen after a crime occurs, it is not just a path to recovery. It is a promise to our youth that they will not be abandoned because they use drugs and that they will not be written off because they were arrested due to those drugs. What happened in Abbotsford is not an isolated incident. Across British Columbia and Canada at large, the toxic drug crisis continues to claim lives. While British Columbia has taken steps to reverse the disastrous impacts of the NDP’s drug legalization pilot project, the crisis does not appear to be ending any time soon. Just recently, the B.C. Supreme Court ruled that banning the possession of drugs for trafficking purposes is unconstitutional. This ruling comes after the opioid deaths among youth in B.C. tripled between 2017 and 2021. B.C. paramedics responded to nearly 40,000 overdose calls in 2025. In 2026, one in every three drug deaths in B.C. involved someone under the age of 30. One in nine of those involved a child. Dr. Jennifer Charlesworth, British Columbia’s representative for children and youth, noted that young people experiencing brain injuries following non-fatal drug poisonings are often being exploited when seeking or using illicit substances. These heartbreaking trends cannot continue. In the words of my hon. colleague who introduced this bill, we must do “everything we can...to improve the lives of our children” and “show young people in this country that the House [,their House,] cares for them.” Bill C-231 had unanimous support at second reading and has since undergone amendments that would improve the bill’s effectiveness. The committee process strengthened Bill C-231 by proposing expanded access to treatment at every stage of the youth justice process. It clarified that police and prosecutors should consider referring young people to treatment, it would formally add treatment as an option to extrajudicial sanctions, and it would allow courts to delay sentencing so a young person could complete a treatment program with consent. It would also ensure that treatment could be included as a condition of probation and supervision orders, while aligning the bill with related legislation and adding a clear coming-into-force timeline. These are practical tools that would give our justice system greater flexibility. These changes sharpen Bill C-231 and should only encourage the House to pass the legislation with unanimous consent once again. Public trust in our laws is being tested. Canadians need clarity, accountability and confidence that our laws can both protect public safety and address addiction. Instead, years of Liberal mismanagement have produced confusion about how drug laws should be enforced and what tools the justice system has in order to confront this crisis. If a young person can overcome addiction, re-enter their community and avoid reoffending, that is a win for them and a win for society. Conservatives have always maintained that compassion and accountability must go hand in hand. At the same time, we must never lose sight of the fact that other people profit from suffering. Those who traffic dangerous drugs should face meaningful consequences for the harm they cause in our communities. That is why Bill C-231 is so important. It recognizes that addiction is not solved by incarceration alone and that intervention, treatment and rehabilitation must be available to our youth so they can rebuild their lives and avoid a future marked by substance abuse and crime. It is a way forward. It would give young people an opportunity to confront addiction, receive treatment and change the course of their lives before it is too late. This is why I support Bill C-231, and I encourage all my colleagues of the House to support it as well.

Jamil Jivani, Bowmanville—Oshawa North

Conservative
“I want everyone to vote for this bill. It makes it easier for police and the courts to send young people into drug treatment instead of jail. Families need this help because too many young people are dying from overdoses, and waiting lists for care are far too long. The government also needs to put more money for youth treatment into the budget and stop giving out drugs through its safe supply programs.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I rise today in support of Bill C-231. I want to thank all the members who have risen so far this morning in support of this very important legislation and the amendments to the Youth Criminal Justice Act. When our colleague, the member for Mégantic—L’Érable—Lotbinière, first rose to introduce this bill and share his family’s personal story, his experience and his son’s experience, it was one of the most powerful moments in this chamber since I have had the privilege of serving in the House. I commend him for his advocacy work and for all the effort he has put into bringing this change forward. I know that many of my constituents, and many Canadians across the country, believe this is a really important change to the way our system currently works. This bill is called the for the friends of David law. In every community across our country, there are friends of David. There are people who are going through the exact same challenges and are in need of the exact same help and support that David was in need of. I want to share a story about a particular young man from my community of Oshawa, one of our star football players who was picked for team Ontario three times. I will not share his name out of respect for the family, but the family did an interview with Maclean’s magazine where some of these details can be found if anyone would like to read more about it. One of the important parts of their story, as they detailed what it was like as a mother and father to watch their son, a very talented young man who played football in our community, deal with his addiction issues and challenges, is how difficult it was for them to get help. There is a quote from his mother in the Maclean’s magazine article where she said, “All I kept hearing was: ‘Our hands are tied.’” Every time she would go to the police or social services to seek out help for her son, she kept being told their hands were tied and there was nothing they could do about it. It is a very heartbreaking story knowing all the talent that was lost when that young man passed away from an overdose several years ago. The parents spoke of the ups and downs they experienced as hope was presented to them and then hope was lost, as there was the possibility of their son getting help and then that possibility going away. It is a very emotionally, psychologically and spiritually taxing experience. I wish there was a perfect solution for it so we could cure people of the illness they are experiencing with just the stroke of a pen. However, what we can do is make it easier for people to get help when they interact with governmental systems and processes. What this bill would do, and why I think it is so important, is that, just like with the young man in Oshawa, where people could see he needed help and were struggling to match him with the help that he needed, it would give the system an opportunity, when there are young men and young women in that same situation, to give them the help they need. This is especially true for young people when they first interact with the justice system. Many of those young men and young women are in some of the most difficult circumstances that one could imagine. Many of them are looking for help, but until someone puts it right in front of their faces or until someone really pushes them and encourages them to take that help, it can often be an opportunity lost. This bill would make it easier for police and prosecutors to refer youth to treatment. That is a really important step in the process of changing how our system works and making sure that help is more readily available to more people. In Durham region, the part of Ontario where I am from, we have seen a massive increase in opioid addiction in particular, with the number of people who have suffered an opioid overdose death tripling since 2015. ER visits have also gone up more than 100% since 2015. Suspected overdose paramedic calls have also increased over 100%, which is a real demand for our local services. People are constantly, whether they are paramedics, police officers, prosecutors or youth outreach workers, trying to find every opportunity they can to get people help. In Ontario, we have seen opioid deaths for those aged 15 to 24 triple from 2014 to 2021. A very important detail is that this is all while treatment medications have fallen 50%. We have seen a change in how much legal drugs are being given out by the system, but it has not changed the amount of overdoses we are seeing in our communities, which is an important proof point for the availability of illicit drugs to young people. I also want to point out that it is important to create these imperatives in the system for people to be able to say they are entitled to treatment. That is one of the things this legislation is able to do. Because people would know their children can be referred to youth treatment, it would create an opportunity for parents and young people to ask for it themselves. In Ontario, we see massive wait times for people to get access to treatment. The Ontario auditor general found that an average wait for live-in youth treatment is 105 days. That number is from 2024. I am sure it has only gone up since that research was made available. We have heard from parents who have said on the record publicly, and also in some of the reports we have reviewed, that there are hundreds of kids on wait-lists waiting for treatment who have not gotten it yet. There is no withdrawal management services specifically for youth in Ontario either. That means it is up to adult services to accept youth, which is often limited to those who are 16 and older. There is a bottleneck in the system, even if someone is willing to accept treatment, for the system to actually guarantee it is available. This was an important point made by one of the witnesses before the justice committee. I want to read some of the words from this witness because I think they put into perspective that, once we all support this bill, and I hope it will be unanimous, there is a lot more work to do to make sure the young people who are affected by this bill also receive the treatment they need. Angy Riendeau, a criminologist from Quebec who appeared as a witness before the justice committee in May 2026, stated, “The question, then, may not be solely how to compel a youth to undergo treatment, but rather how to ensure that, upon the first offence, a youth has rapid access to specialized assessment, care and appropriate resources.” As we vote on this bill, and as we think about what the next steps would be after this bill becomes law, it is important to go back to the question of the resources available to young people, families and, in particular, parents. There are two opportunities before the government right now to follow through on the sentiment behind this legislation with actual resources. One of those opportunities is a budget that we have yet to vote on in the House. That budget has a very paltry amount of resources dedicated to those of all age groups who are fighting addictions, and very little new spending is being contributed to help solve that problem. Perhaps if it would like to continue on with the sentiment behind this legislation, it may consider adding more funding for addiction services in the budget, particularly for young men and young women, before it goes to a vote. I think that would be a fantastic change to what has been presented in it thus far. Another important opportunity before the government to follow through on the sentiment behind this legislation is in its forthcoming national strategy for men and boys’ health. We have seen a lot of changes in the initial plan for that national strategy. Just over a year ago, the government first announced that it was going to produce that strategy in 2026. We have since learned it has been delayed to 2027, with no specific dates. We were also told the government was going to do detailed and comprehensive consultations as part of its gathering of information about what should be in that national strategy. We saw it release a report that, quite frankly, omits a tremendous amount of feedback that was given by the Canadian people that should have been included. One of the most important points of feedback that I myself submitted, and also hosted town halls on, and I know the government received this feedback from organizations and individuals across the country, was on how to help young men and boys with addiction issues. That was a specific thing that was raised, and it is not adequately addressed in the report the government put forward outlining the feedback it received on its national strategy. One of the most important things missing in there is any acknowledgement of the government’s failed safe supply drug policies, which put taxpayer dollars behind drugs, making it easier, as police departments across this country have reported, for taxpayer-supplied drugs to make their way into the illicit drug market. There are opportunities for the government to do more than just support the bill, but I am very glad to see all parties rise in the House today in support of this legislation. I look forward to voting for it.

Luc Berthold, Mégantic—L'Érable—Lotbinière

Conservative
“I want the House to agree to name this bill 'For the Friends of David Law'. My son David died from drug addiction after the justice system failed to give him the help he needed. This bill gives courts tools to help young people get addiction treatment. I want the Senate to pass it quickly.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, if I may, I would like to say the next few words directly to my son, David. Happy birthday, David. Today, you would have been 30 years old. Your mother Caroline, your sisters Marie‑Soleil and Justine, your children Clovis and Éloi, your partner Audrey, and your grandmother Viviane all want you to know that we love you and wish you a happy birthday. Today, David, the House of Commons is unanimous. Your life, your experiences, your joys, your pain: all that was not in vain. Your life will serve as an example so that other young people will not have to go through all the hardships that you went through. Perhaps young people will be able to make different choices and choose a path that leads to them being alive on their 30th birthday. David, you and I wanted to change things together. When things started going well, we wanted to use your youth, your adolescence, to prevent young people from going down that path. We said we would give talks and make a difference. Unfortunately, because of the reality of substance use and life itself, we were not able to achieve that dream together. I wanted to tell you today that life was still good to us, because we shared some wonderful moments together. When you were young, we had fun. We played together and enjoyed ourselves. We went on outings and trips with your mother, your sisters, our family. We laughed. We did not cry very often, it is true, but we did cry nonetheless. Especially at the end, we cried. We cried a lot. We cried because you left us too soon. Today, we are trying to turn all of that into something meaningful. We are trying to make the inexplicable understandable, make the unacceptable acceptable and bring something good out of what happened. We introduced a bill to help your friends. I am not talking about the friends who were around you, but about all those who, like you, went through some rough times and decided to take a puff or a sniff, only to find themselves dependent on that puff or sniff and unable to break free, leading them into a justice system that was unable to help them because the law did not provide the right tools. Today, we will be creating some tools, but we need you, David. We need you to talk to all these young people, from where you are today, and tell them that they should not hesitate to use the resources offered to them, when it is possible, once everything gets passed, once the friends of David bill comes into force, so that young people will agree to seek treatment. I know that it is not easy for a young person to say that they need help. There are many young people who will not need it. They will take that quick puff and move on with their lives. They will go on to have great careers. However, for others who are struggling with mental health issues, or who may not know that they are suffering from mental health issues, that quick puff can completely change their lives, like it changed yours and the lives of many people around you. David, I want you to see, from where you are today, that the House of Commons, all the members of the House of Commons, want to do something so that David’s story becomes a positive story in the future, so that you will be remembered for something good, for truly making a difference, and for helping young people find a way out. Thank you. We are doing it for your friends, for all those with whom you spent your wonderful childhood and who miss you, for all those you do not know but will be able to help from above. Your mother, your sisters and I are doing this for you, for our little family. We are going to change lives. David, for your birthday gift, today, I am going to ask for the unanimous consent of the House to officially add your name to Bill C-231. Mr. Speaker, if you seek it, I think you will find unanimous consent for the following motion: That, notwithstanding any standing order or usual practice of the House, Bill C-231, An Act to amend the Youth Criminal Justice Act, be amended by adding the following alternate title “For the Friends of David Law”, and that the Law Clerk and Parliamentary Counsel be authorized to make any technical changes or corrections to the bill as may be necessary to give effect to this motion. David, thank you and happy birthday. I want to thank all my colleagues in the House of Commons who made this bill possible. I would invite my colleagues in the other chamber to pass this bill as quickly as possible in order to make it a reality.

Discussion

No comments yet

See the full discussion

Comment rules

More from sitting 165

  1. Private Members' Business Youth Criminal Justice Act 5 statements
  2. Government Orders Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act 37 statements
  3. Government Orders Government Orders 23 statements
  4. Statements by Members Ordre National du Mérite Agricole 2 statements
  5. Oral Questions The Economy 6 statements
  6. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 2 statements
  7. Oral Questions The Environment 6 statements
  8. Oral Questions The Budget 4 statements
  9. Oral Questions The Economy 4 statements
  10. Oral Questions Public Services and Procurement 2 statements
  11. Oral Questions Government Priorities 4 statements
  12. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 4 statements
  13. Oral Questions The Economy 10 statements
  14. Oral Questions Housing 2 statements
  15. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 19 statements
  16. Oral Questions Labour 2 statements
  17. Oral Questions Public Services and Procurement 6 statements
  18. Oral Questions Taxation 2 statements
  19. Oral Questions Committees of the House 2 statements
  20. Oral Questions Parks Canada 2 statements
  21. Government Orders Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act 95 statements
  22. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 4 statements
  23. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  24. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  25. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements