Official Hansard
Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to rise today to talk about the budget that was tabled two weeks ago in this chamber. What we have here is a budget that is using what the Liberals love to use: creative accounting. They are splitting the budget up into three different envelopes. There is the operating budget, the capital budget and the Crown corporations, but when we add it all together, it is $765 billion of new debt over the next five years. I will repeat that. There is $765 billion of new debt that is burdened onto the taxpayers of Canada, which works out to $44,000 for every household in Canada, and that is just on the new debt over the next five years. The interest charges on all of this debt, which is now over $1.5 trillion and going higher, are the fastest-growing budget item in the entire federal budget. It is growing faster than health care transfers. It is actually $17 billion more this year than health care transfers. It is more than we spend on national defence. It is more than we spend on transfers to seniors and families. The interest alone is costing Canadians $6,000 for a family of four per year. This year, that $6,000 of taxes will go to just servicing our national debt. This has to stop, because it just keeps going up. By the end of this budget forecast, which takes us to 2030-31, the debt interest charge is going to be over $8,100 per family. As Conservatives, we have been calling on the government to cut the wasteful spending and keep the election promises that the Prime Minister ran on just over a year ago to get the debt down according to GDP. The Liberals are using creative accounting to fudge the numbers on what the GDP number really is. They actually applied the money in the Canada pension plan against the national debt. That is not the way it works, because the $866 billion in the CPP fund is Canadians’ money. It is there to protect Canadians’ retirement. It is contributions between Canadians and employers, not government money, and the government should never use it as part of its accounting. As I said, the government is using all sorts of sneaky tricks. There are the three different credit cards it is running: the operating budget, the capital budget, and now getting more and more into Crown corporations, including the new Defence Investment Agency, which we are debating at committee right now. All of those Crown corporations are a way to hide more debt that the government continues to take on. The former PBO, former governors of the Bank of Canada and leading economists across this country have all called this out as bad accounting practices. We can pretty much summarize it as accounting malpractice, which is what the Prime Minister and the finance minister are doing with our tax dollars. One thing I did read in great detail was chapter 5, on national defence. I have to say that the Liberals, for some time now, have been using creative accounting, lots of smoke and mirrors, on defence spending, which they have now transferred to how they are doing the overall bookkeeping of our nation and the operations of the Government of Canada. However, we know that the actual expenditures in this budget would not create any new opportunities. Everything that is in there has already been announced and re-announced. There have been very few contracts signed to buy the equipment that the Liberals are saying they are going to buy. To highlight what they have done with creative accounting, there is the Canadian Coast Guard, which used to be under Fisheries and Oceans as it has no defence role. We had the deputy commissioner of the coast guard in the defence committee just yesterday, who said that they do not have a role as an organization within National Defence to make sure that we can defend our country. When the Liberals first started doing creative accounting, they took about $47 million back in 2017-18, which was for things along the lines of border security, and started moving it in and out of the Canadian Coast Guard. They upped that number to $759 million. Well, this budget has the Canadian Coast Guard expenditures at $2.4 billion, and all as national defence. We are talking about icebreaking vessels, research vessels and science vessels, which have nothing to do with actual defence. If we look at all the creative accounting, there is absolutely nothing there that increases our defence capabilities, our kinetic energy, in a military conflict. To add insult to injury, the government also moved Transport Canada’s aviation fleet. Its aviation services are there to track illegal fishing and any illegal migrations in the Great Lakes and across our coastlines. The reality is that it also does not provide any defensive capabilities, but now that budget is being absorbed to get our defence spending up to 2%, which is demanded by NATO. NATO did change the rule to allow national defence expenses to be counted as defence spending. That is why we are seeing things happen with pensions, civilian pensions, veteran pensions, the Coast Guard and Transport Canada. When reading this budget, the only new spending in chapter 5 is for Canadian border services, the RCMP and CSIS. They are not defence organizations, but they now count. I assume they will soon be absorbed in as national defence spending, even though they do not actually increase our defence capabilities as a nation. We have seen creative accounting, more money for consultants and bigger bureaucracies within the department, including the Defence Investment Agency, a new bureaucracy to do what was already being done. There is also a lack of political will to actually invest in the kit that our troops need to defend Canada and work alongside our allies. To add insult to the injury of the fact that there are not any new investments in this budget other than a paper shuffle and more smoke and mirrors, we are actually seeing a 10% budget cut. This year, that budget cut is hitting the Canadian Armed Forces right in the pocketbook. That is $2.9 billion of operational spending that is being reduced. Even Justin Trudeau did not do that. He reduced defence spending by 2.7% over three years, at about $900 million a year, but the Liberals under this Prime Minister are reducing it by 2.9%, and it is really targeted at our reserve force. The first thing the reservists were told for Remembrance Day was that they were not allowed paid leave to attend Remembrance Day services. If they went, and if they had to travel to rural areas, it was out of their own pockets. Reserve units are cancelling training. Class B reservists, who are full-time reservists, working in our armouries and working alongside our troops on different bases, are actually being laid off. We have members in uniform in the primary reserves who are applying for employment insurance as we speak. That, again, is ridiculous. The Liberals talk about wanting to improve retention and recruitment, but who wants to join when they are going to get laid off if they become a reservist? That does not make any sense. It is undermining morale, and it is undermining people’s confidence in the Canadian Armed Forces. Armouries have been telling their members that they are not going to be doing any new training between now and the end of the fiscal year, which is March 31. They are also being told that they are going to be parading less, and that there is going to be less on roll call. If a reserve unit decides it is going to take on any extra training, we have been told that it is going to pull back 20%. The Liberals are actually going to cut the new budget that they were asked for, that has not been previously allocated and cut by 10%. They are going to cut that by 27%. How do we maintain operational readiness when the Liberals are doing this? It is not just the reserves. I just saw a post on Reddit about our cadets. The cadets across this country, the army, air force and sea cadets, have been told that all their activities have been paused until the end of the year. They should not expect any training opportunities between now and March 31. They will not be given any new uniforms. They will not be able to take on any new members, because their budgets are frozen. They will not be able to do anything. In conclusion, we have the Liberals making more cuts, our military is less capable, and the Liberals are undermining morale. It makes Canada less safe every time the Liberals attack our armed forces.