The Budget

Debate on the government’s 2026 budget, titled “Masters of our destiny.” Liberal members supported it, pointing to spending on affordable housing, food banks, caregiver and grocery support, mental health funding, health infrastructure for provinces, electric charging stations, and the Churchill Falls hydro project. Conservative members opposed it, citing the size of the debt and new spending, interest on the debt exceeding health transfers to provinces, cost-of-living pressures on families, fuel costs, and allocations that go disproportionately to Liberal-held ridings. The Bloc Québécois raised the reduction in the growth of health transfers to Quebec and the provinces, and a clause in the bill concerning farmers’ land being taken for the Alto train project. Green member Elizabeth May said she would vote against the budget, citing accounting treatment of business spending, cuts to national parks, and lack of commitment to climate targets, and proposed spending to protect the Amazon rainforest. Some statements touched on members’ own ridings and past statements by members who crossed the floor.Written by AI from the debate. Updated .

Official text (opens in a new tab)

6 statements

Elizabeth May, Saanich—Gulf Islands

Green
“I will vote against this budget. It uses bad accounting rules for business spending that add $36 billion to the deficit, and it helps foreign companies instead of Canadian ones. It also makes deep cuts to national parks, cutting park wardens and rescue dogs while encouraging more people to visit.”
  • Speech in the House

    Signal 44 of 100

    Much of this statement went to praise, blame, greetings, routine procedure or general stories rather than reasons, requests or specific points.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, as many members will know, when one starts a speech, in my case on November 6, and resumes it today, with the passage of time, it gives one a chance to reflect on what was said and what was left out. I concentrated very much in that first effort on a section of this budget that I did not think many members had been talking about. I would now like to concentrate on an aside I made on November 6 and give it more substance today. In my speech on November 6, I agreed with the hon. member for Wellington—Halton Hills North that the Government of Canada seems to be able to insist that other entities live up to generally acceptable accounting practices but apparently does not believe it has to live up to them itself. I would like to expand on that. The productivity mega dividend has evolved from last year’s budget, the productivity superdividend. I do not know what kinds of lessons the PMO comms people are taking from the White House, but we are getting into a trend of it being huge, and now it is even huger. It was the Building Canada Act, and now it is the building Canada strong act. I guess by next year, we will have the “building Canada really strong we did not mean it before” act. It is huge, the biggest act anyone has ever seen. I would like to turn to page 363 of the budget to explain why I said that this budget departs from what would be considered generally acceptable accounting practices. That is in the definition of capital that goes into the 100% immediate writeoffs that are possible under the mega dividend. This is no small matter. It adds to the spending in this budget and the expansion of government debt and deficit. This one measure is $36 billion more than if we were not doing the productivity mega dividend. I would like to expand on this. In this budget, the government has taken extreme liberties with its methods of accounting. Any current expense of any organization outside of the federal government, public or private, domestic or international, of any of those entities with an intention to form capital, is considered a capital expense. It is quite astonishing. I see my friends nodding. I do not usually turn to Google for help with anything, because I rather like to consider my own mind my own Google. However, Google calls these flexible domestic definitions rather than strict international accounting standards. These are indeed flexible. For instance, if a public company or a financial institution, such as a bank in Canada, reported a current expense in such a fashion to be considered a capital expense, I can confidently predict that the management of that company and its auditors would be called on the carpet or fired. It is an extraordinary thing. No organization would dare to try such financial trickery in reporting to any bank in Canada that this is a capital expense. Organizations could classify advertising as such, because it is intended to form capital. It is hard to think of anything that would not fit within the flexibility of this definition. Again, I say this is material, because the way in which one defines capital in order to make it fit within access to the productivity mega dividend has an impact on Canada’s finances. Certainly, the Canadian public is on board with team Canada. They want our Prime Minister to take on aggressors from other countries, whether it is the White House or anyone else who thinks they can harm Canada’s economy or cost us jobs. There is a tremendous degree of public trust and goodwill, and I would urge the Prime Minister not to squander it on such trickery. We want to see support for Canadian businesses. This definition, as I mentioned earlier, would apply for a mega dividend for a company. We heard this earlier in debate the other week on the opposition’s supply day motion, in which they questioned why it was that the Commissionaires were not given a contract to protect the Canada Revenue Agency offices. We said we want Canadian. Is “Canada first” not our policy? In that context, it is important that, in revisiting this definition and revisiting most of the enticements and inducements to invest in Canada, there is nothing that says it has to be a Canadian company. In fact, in debate on that day on the motion of supply, we heard government members explain that the current definition of “Canadian” could be just to have opened an office in Canada, or having a box office somewhere and saying one is going to hire Canadians. Then it is a Canadian company. There are small and medium-sized enterprises across Canada that really need to be able to access capital for investment, and one would hope that a mega dividend of this type would be defined and prescribed in ways that particularly helped them, but it actually would do the opposite. It would particularly help foreign investors, companies that are not Canadian. There is much else in this budget that I did not get a chance to speak to when I first spoke back on November 6. One of these issues was one I raised yesterday in question period, which is this: Why we are slashing Parks Canada? The budget, if we read it without care, says that there is $3.5 billion over a 10-year period for Parks Canada. That could be used in talking points, as I have heard it used by Liberal members, to say that they are protecting our parks and putting in $3.5 billion over 10 years. One has to read it carefully. That is only for actual capital improvements, not the fictitious ones that work for the mega dividend. They actually work only for putting in roads, bridges and specific infrastructure. It is physical investment in parks, like rebuilding Jasper. Those get the $3.5 billion. It is not much money, when we consider that it would be spread out over 10 years, but at the same time, we would save a relatively small amount of money, $145 million, when we consider that the mega dividend is costing $37 billion. Here we have $145 million. The government at this point has told two-thirds of Parks staff that they could be eliminated. Yesterday, in question period, the Minister of the Environment said to me that they could be eliminated, when I told her that four park wardens from the Gulf Islands National Park in my riding had been told their positions were eliminated. The minister’s response was that maybe they had not told her yet what they have done. They have been told within the Gulf Islands National Park that there will be no full-time wardens again in the Gulf Islands National Park, but that they are to rely on a warden from Pacific Rim National Park. Yes, it is in the same province, and yes, it is closer than some other parks, but as the crow flies, it is 130-some kilometres away. We need full-time wardens on the ground. By the way, when I say “as the crow flies”, the only way one would be able to do it in a day is by flying, because it is not reachable by roads. We would be taking ferries. The B.C. ferry system has a schedule, and unless the budget is expanded to include a 24-7 available helicopter service, there is no way to quickly get a park warden on the ground who is needed to put out an illegal campfire or because someone is poaching. The park wardens are significant parts of law enforcement to protect national parks and protect visitors to the parks. They are allowed to carry sidearms. They are allowed to enforce the law, and those four positions, we have been told, are permanently eliminated. It is not that they have received a pink note and maybe will or maybe will not be eliminated. They have told this to the Gulf Islands National Park staff and the residents of the island within my riding that has the most ground as a national park as a proportion of its land mass, Saturna Island, which is about half national park. When they negotiated with the people of Saturna Island, Parks Canada said it absolutely guaranteed them there would always be a full-time resident park warden on Saturna Island, so that promise is broken with this. I love Parks Canada. I had the honour of working in the office of the federal minister of the environment from 1986 to 1988, and in that time we negotiated Pacific Rim National Park, from which they now think a park warden could cover Gulf Islands National Park. We negotiated Gwaii Haanas National Park grasslands. We negotiated parks across this country. I am very proud of being part, in a tangential way, of Parks Canada, as a representative from the minister’s office, to lead those negotiations. However, I am ashamed to think of how the current approach to protecting our national parks is so reckless with ecosystems and the health and safety of the tourists who go to our national parks. That, again, brings me to the part of this budget that most Canadians would be happy to see. I am happy to see the continuation of the Canada strong pass, which allows free access to museums for Canadians. This is great. With respect to reduced rates on Via Rail, we really need to invest more in passenger rail. I am not speaking of Alto, which needs a lot of work. We definitely, as Greens, support high-speed rail across Canada, but we have put out a statement, which I will not go into detail on, of what is needed to repair and reform the approach taken to Alto. We need national parks, and we need Via Rail. They are not getting support in this budget, but we are giving Canadians access to the parks for free. We have done a double whammy to Parks Canada. For more than a year, which is great, we have encouraged Canadians and foreigners to visit our national parks, to experience this national beauty. However, visitors to Banff and Jasper are less safe, because the government just cut the search and rescue program that involved 55 well-trained dogs that could sniff out, rescue and save lives. At the same time, we have encouraged Canadians to visit our national parks without park wardens in places like Saturna Island, the Gulf Islands National Park, and Kejimkujik. Across the country, the park cuts are deep. Canadians should understand that the government is not cutting the fat. With respect to Parks Canada, it is cutting into the bone. I do not know how we fix this. We never really recovered from the 10% budget cuts that occurred to Parks Canada in 2012 under Stephen Harper, but this is more than a double whammy. It is a violation of the statutory obligation of the Government of Canada, under the Canada National Parks Act, to keep our parks healthy and secure for the next generation. I see that I have about 15 seconds left. In that time, I will say that I will not be voting for this budget. I urge the government, at a minimum, to not make our budget a laughing stock for accountants. This is embarrassing.

Elizabeth May, Saanich—Gulf Islands

Green
“I support encouraging investments, but the budget's definition of capital investments is too broad. Companies could treat regular costs, like advertising, as capital expenses. The government must use clearer rules and avoid bad accounting.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I will read for the parliamentary secretary from page 352, because, yes, capital expenditures and ways of increasing investment are great. It states: Capital investments, for the purposes of the framework, are defined broadly as any...capital formation, held directly on the government’s balance sheet or on that of a private sector entity.... There is no real precision to this definition at all. A company could go to the Government of Canada and say that although this is a current expense, they are counting it as a capital expense, because if they invest it in advertising, it will form capital for their company down the road. We need to ensure that the Government of Canada does not practise trickery in accounting that would embarrass the private sector.

Elizabeth May, Saanich—Gulf Islands

Green
“I support spending $560 million to protect the Amazon rainforest. Canada's climate depends on it, and Brazil is an important trading partner. This amount is small compared to the billions we give to big foreign companies.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I thank my honourable friend from York—South Simcoe. He has picked an example, and I hope I do not disappoint him too much. Last year, the Prime Minister broke a promise to the President of Brazil and, I think, embarrassed Brazil on the world stage. The Prime Minister had committed to attending the high-level summit at COP30 that was taking place, the first climate negotiation to take place in the geographical Amazon, in Belém. This money is not a lot when we consider that the Canadian climate and the world’s climate depend on what is sometimes called the lungs of the earth, the Amazon. I think most Canadians would be glad to see us putting $560 million into protecting the Amazon rainforest because it is connected to our atmosphere and it is connected to our climate, but it goes back to why the Prime Minister made a commitment to a foreign government with whom we are, by the way, trying to secure a trade deal. It is one of the BRIC economies. Brazil is a big economy. It is the biggest economy in South America. We could do more business. I know that one of my friend’s colleagues attacked President Lula. He recently won a democratic and free election. It so happens that the former minister of environment is an old friend of mine. Her name is Marina Silva. I am very happy to see funding go to protecting the Amazon, but I think it is paltry compared to the billions of dollars that are going to foreign multinationals.

Elizabeth May, Saanich—Gulf Islands

Green
“My colleague is right. This budget works against real climate action. It does not commit to our climate targets, and it even says we focus on targets too much. Scientists say missing these goals will ruin human civilization and harm our children's future. I will not accept that.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I think my colleague is right. Canadian climate leaders are at the UN conference right now. We have Catherine McKenna and Steven Guilbeault at COP31, and they stand for climate action. This budget does the opposite. As I said when I spoke to the budget on November 6, scandalously, on page 7 of this budget, it not only does not commit to the Paris Agreement targets, but also says that, for too long, we have been driven by targets. The scientific community has advised us that, if we do not meet those targets, we do not have a human civilization, which would have a direct impact on our economy, but it would have a particularly large impact on my granddaughter. That will not happen on my watch.

Elizabeth May, Saanich—Gulf Islands

Green
“Creating jobs matters, and small businesses create the most jobs in Canada. But this budget ignores small businesses. It helps big foreign corporations and foreign governments instead.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Clarity 43 of 100

    Much of this statement used imprecise wording, lacked details on timing or responsibility, or made broad claims without support.

    See full analysis
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 100 of 100

    Of this reply, 100% addressed the question or point raised.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I certainly agree with the parliamentary secretary that job creation is critical, and the single biggest job creator in this country is small businesses. Small businesses are not the target of the benefits in this budget. Large investment capital from foreign governments and foreign corporations are far more likely to benefit from this than small businesses in Canada, which are largely overlooked.

Elizabeth May, Saanich—Gulf Islands

Green
“I agree that we must protect our public health care system. But I am worried that interest on the debt is the biggest spending increase in this budget. Next year, the government will spend more on debt interest than on health care for the provinces. That is a problem.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 47 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I thank my esteemed colleague from the Bloc Québécois for his question. I agree that it is essential that we keep our public health care system secure and sustainable. At the same time, what concerns me is that interest payments on the debt account for the largest increase in government spending in this budget. I believe that, as of next year, the amount needed to pay the interest on the debt will exceed the amount going to public health transfers, and that is a problem.

Discussion

No comments yet

See the full discussion

Comment rules

More from sitting 166

  1. Government Orders The Budget 87 statements
  2. Oral Questions Housing 8 statements
  3. Oral Questions Finance 4 statements
  4. Oral Questions The Economy 6 statements
  5. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 11 statements
  6. Oral Questions The Budget 4 statements
  7. Oral Questions International Trade 13 statements
  8. Oral Questions The Economy 2 statements
  9. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 11 statements
  10. Oral Questions Housing 2 statements
  11. Oral Questions Rail Transportation 6 statements
  12. Oral Questions The Budget 2 statements
  13. Oral Questions Rail Transportation 2 statements
  14. Oral Questions Telecommunications 2 statements
  15. Oral Questions Forestry Industry 4 statements
  16. Oral Questions Housing 2 statements
  17. Government Orders The Budget 46 statements
  18. Oral Questions Justice 4 statements
  19. Oral Questions Employment 4 statements
  20. Private Members' Business Fair Representation Act 3 statements
  21. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  22. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  23. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  24. Private Members' Business Fair Representation Act 2 statements